10 research outputs found
Sensitivity of L-band vegetation optical depth to carbon stocks in tropical forests: a comparison to higher frequencies and optical indices
Supplementary data to this article can be found online at https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rse.2019.111303.Monitoring vegetation carbon in tropical regions is essential to the global carbon assessment and to evaluate the actions oriented to the reduction of forest degradation. Mainly, satellite optical vegetation indices and LiDAR data have been used to this purpose. These two techniques are limited by cloud cover and are sensitive only to the top of vegetation. In addition, the vegetation attenuation to the soil microwave emission, represented by the vegetation optical depth (VOD), has been applied for biomass estimation using frequencies ranging from 4 to 30¿GHz (C- to K-bands). Atmosphere is transparent to microwaves and their sensitivity to canopy layers depends on the frequency, with lower frequencies having greater penetration depths. In this regard, L-band VOD (1.4¿GHz) is expected to enhance the ability to estimate carbon stocks. This study compares the sensitivity of different VOD products (from L, C, and X-bands) and an optical vegetation index (EVI) to the above-ground carbon density (ACD). It quantifies the contribution of ACD and forest cover proportion to the VOD/EVI signals. The study is conducted in Peru, southern Colombia and Panama, where ACD maps have been derived from airborne LiDAR. Results confirm the enhanced sensitivity of L-band VOD to ACD when compared to higher frequency bands, and show that the sensitivity of all VOD bands decreases in the densest forests. ACD explains 34% and forest cover 30% of L-band VOD variance, and these proportions gradually decrease for EVI, C-, and X-band VOD, respectively. Results are consistent through different categories of altitude and carbon density. This pattern is found in most of the studied regions and in flooded forests. Results also show that C-, X-band VOD and EVI provide complementary information to L-band VOD, especially in flooded forests and in mountains, indicating that synergistic approaches could lead to improved retrievals in these regions. Although the assessment of vegetation carbon in the densest forests requires further research, results from this study support the use of new L-band VOD estimates for mapping the carbon of tropical forests.Peer ReviewedPostprint (author's final draft
Comparing synthetic aperture radar and LiDAR for above-ground biomass estimation in Glen Affric, Scotland
Quantifying above-ground biomass (AGB) and carbon sequestration has been a
significant focus of attention within the UNFCCC and Kyoto Protocol for improvement
of national carbon accounting systems (IPCC, 2007; UNFCCC, 2011). A multitude of
research has been carried out in relatively flat and homogeneous forests (Ranson & Sun,
1994; Beaudoin et al.,1994; Kurvonen et al., 1999; Austin et al., 2003; Dimitris et al.,
2005), yet forests in the highlands, which generally form heterogeneous forest cover and
sparse woodlands with mountainous terrain have been largely neglected in AGB studies
(Cloude et al., 2001; 2008; Lumsdon et al., 2005; 2008; Erxue et al., 2009, Tan et al.,
2010; 2011a; 2011b; 2011c; 2011d). Since mountain forests constitute approximately
28% of the total global forest area (Price and Butt, 2000), a better understanding of the
slope effects is of primary importance in AGB estimation. The main objective of this
research is to estimate AGB in the aforementioned forest in Glen Affric, Scotland using
both SAR and LiDAR data.
Two types of Synthetic Aperture Radar (SAR) data were used in this research:
TerraSAR-X, operating at X-band and ALOS PALSAR, operating at L-band, both are
fully polarimetric. The former data was acquired on 13 April 2010 and of the latter, two
scenes were acquired on 17 April 2007 and 08 June 2009. Airborne LiDAR data were
acquired on 09 June 2007. Two field measurement campaigns were carried out, one of
which was done from winter 2006 to spring 2007 where physical parameters of trees in
170 circular plots were measured by the Forestry Commission team. Another intensive
fieldwork was organised by myself with the help of my fellow colleagues and it
comprised of tree measurement in two transects of 200m x 50m at a relatively flat and
dense plantation forest and 400m x 50m at hilly and sparse semi-natural forest. AGB is
estimated for both the transects to investigate the effectiveness of the proposed method
at plot-level. This thesis evaluates the capability of polarimetric Synthetic Aperture Radar data
for AGB estimation by investigating the relationship between the SAR backscattering
coefficient and AGB and also the relationship between the decomposed scattering
mechanisms and AGB. Due to the terrain and heterogeneous nature of the forests, the
result from the backscatter-AGB analysis show that these forests present a challenge for
simple AGB estimation. As an alternative, polarimetric techniques were applied to the
problem by decomposing the backscattering information into scattering mechanisms
based on the approach by Yamaguchi (2005; 2006), which are then regressed to the field
measured AGB. Of the two data sets, ALOS PALSAR demonstrates a better estimation
capacity for AGB estimation than TerraSAR-X. The AGB estimated results from SAR
data are compared with AGB derived from LiDAR data. Since tree height is often
correlated with AGB (Onge et al., 2008; Gang et al., 2010), the effectiveness of the tree
height retrieval from LiDAR is evaluated as an indicator of AGB. Tree delineation was
performed before AGB of individual trees were calculated allometrically. Results were
validated by comparison to the fieldwork data. The amount of overestimation varies
across the different canopy conditions. These results give some indication of when to
use LiDAR or SAR to retrieve forest AGB. LiDAR is able to estimate AGB with good
accuracy and the R2 value obtained is 0.97 with RMSE of 14.81 ton/ha. The R2 and
RMSE obtained for TerraSAR-X are 0.41 and 28.5 ton/ha, respectively while for ALOS
PALSAR data are 0.70 and 23.6 ton/ha, respectively. While airborne LiDAR data with
very accurate height measurement and consequent three-dimensional (3D) stand profiles
which allows investigation into the relationship between height, number density and
AGB, it's limited to small coverage area, or large areas but at large cost. ALOS
PALSAR, on the other hand, can cover big coverage area but it provide a lower
resolution, hence, lower estimation accuracy
Recommended from our members
The Changing Matrix: Reforestation and Connectivity in a Tropical Habitat Corridor
In the last two decades, export-oriented crops and timber and fruit plantations have joined small-scale cultivation and pasture as important causes of tropical deforestation. Widespread conversion of tropical forest to agriculture threatens to isolate protected areas, which has led to efforts to maintain functional connectivity in landscapes between protected areas. Relatively few "landscape conservation" efforts have been assessed for their effect on deforestation, but advances in remote sensing now permit detailed monitoring of tropical land uses over time, including mapping of tree crops and plantations. This dissertation evaluates the long-term impact of forest conservation and reforestation policies on tropical forests in a habitat corridor. The following chapters test the capability of remote sensing to monitor tropical conservation efforts and assess whether landscape conservation policies can maintain forest cover and connectivity in the face of rapid agricultural expansion. Costa Rica has one of the most comprehensive landscape conservation policies in the tropics: a 1996 Forest Law banned deforestation and expanded payments for environmental services (PES) to protect forests and plant trees, prioritizing designated habitat corridors between protected areas. The long-term effect of the program on land-use transitions is not well known. To take advantage of this regional policy experiment, I used a time-series of five moderate-resolution Landsat images to track land-use change from 1986 to 2011in the oldest habitat corridor, the San Juan-La Selva Biological Corridor (SJLSBC). Forest conservation policies were associated with a 40% decline in deforestation after 1996 despite a doubling in the area of cropland in the last decade. The proportion of cropland derived from mature forest dropped from 16.4% to 1.9% after 1996, while one fifth of pasture expansion continued to be derived from mature forest. These results suggest that forest conservation policies can successfully lower deforestation, and that they can be more effective with large export producers than small-scale cattle producers. Tree plantations are an important component of Costa Rican PES, but knowledge of their distribution and contribution to connectivity in the corridor region is poor. After reviewing the remote sensing literature, I employed a novel integration of hyperspectral images and a Landsat time-series to create the first regional map of tropical tree plantation species. Including multitemporal data significantly improved overall hyperspectral map accuracy to 91%; the six tree plantation species were classified with 83% mean producer's accuracy. Non-native species made up 89% of tree plantations, and they were cleared more rapidly than native tree plantations and secondary forests. I combined existing land cover maps, field behavioral experiments, and a graph connectivity model to estimate whether landscape conservation policies increased connectivity for understory insectivorous birds, a representative forest-dependent group. The field playback experiments indicated both native and exotic tree plantations with a dense shrubby understory were acceptable dispersal habitat for all species, and that birds traveled readily near secondary forest edges but rarely into forested pasture. Graph model parameters were informed by these results. For all of these bird species, functional connectivity declined by 14-21% with only a 4.9% decline in forest area over time, implying that conservation policies have not caused a net increase in functional connectivity in the SJLSBC region. Despite making up 2% of the region, tree plantations had little effect on regional connectivity because of their placement in the landscape; we demonstrate that spatially-targeted reforestation of 0.1% of the region could increase connectivity by 1.8%. Collectively, the results presented in these chapters underline the potential and limitations of landscape conservation policies and corridor plans in the tropics; combining regulations and PES can lower deforestation over the medium-term, but increased enforcement, improved monitoring with remote sensing, and targeted conservation effort is needed to combat illegal deforestation and restore functional connectivity. Given numerous new tropical corridor and PES programs and the qualified successes of landscape conservation policies in Costa Rica and other tropical countries, our approach to the analysis can be applied to monitor and evaluate connectivity across the tropics
A review of commercialisation mechanisms for carbon dioxide removal
The deployment of carbon dioxide removal (CDR) needs to be scaled up to achieve net zero emission pledges. In this paper we survey the policy mechanisms currently in place globally to incentivise CDR, together with an estimate of what different mechanisms are paying per tonne of CDR, and how those costs are currently distributed. Incentive structures are grouped into three structures, market-based, public procurement, and fiscal mechanisms. We find the majority of mechanisms currently in operation are underresourced and pay too little to enable a portfolio of CDR that could support achievement of net zero. The majority of mechanisms are concentrated in market-based and fiscal structures, specifically carbon markets and subsidies. While not primarily motivated by CDR, mechanisms tend to support established afforestation and soil carbon sequestration methods. Mechanisms for geological CDR remain largely underdeveloped relative to the requirements of modelled net zero scenarios. Commercialisation pathways for CDR require suitable policies and markets throughout the projects development cycle. Discussion and investment in CDR has tended to focus on technology development. Our findings suggest that an equal or greater emphasis on policy innovation may be required if future requirements for CDR are to be met. This study can further support research and policy on the identification of incentive gaps and realistic potential for CDR globally