A cost-effective heuristic to schedule local and remote memory in cluster computers

Cluster computers represent a cost-effective alternative solution to supercomputers. In these systems, it is common to constrain the memory address space of a given processor to the local motherboard. Constraining the system in this way is much cheaper than using a full-fledged shared memory implementation among motherboards. However, memory usage among motherboards can be unfairly balanced. On the other hand, remote memory access (RMA) hardware provides fast interconnects among the motherboards of a cluster. RMA devices can be used to access remote RAM memory from a local motherboard. This work focuses on this capability in order to achieve a better global use of the total RAM memory in the system. More precisely, the address space of local applications is extended to remote motherboards and is used to access remote RAM memory. This paper presents an ideal memory scheduling algorithm and proposes a cost-effective heuristic to allocate local and remote memory among local applications. Compared to the devised ideal algorithm, the heuristic obtains the same (or closely resembling) results while largely reducing the computational cost. In addition, we analyze the impact on the performance of stand alone applications varying the memory distribution among regions (local, local to board, and remote). Then, this study is extended to any number of concurrent applications. Experimental results show that a QoS parameter is needed in order to avoid unacceptable performance degradation. © 2011 Springer Science+Business Media, LLC.This work was supported by Spanish CICYT under Grant TIN2009-14475-C04-01 and by Consolider-Ingenio under Grant CSD2006-00046.Serrano Gómez, M.; Sahuquillo Borrás, J.; Petit Martí, SV.; Hassan Mohamed, H.; Duato Marín, JF. (2012). A cost-effective heuristic to schedule local and remote memory in cluster computers. Journal of Supercomputing. 59(3):1533-1551. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11227-011-0566-8S15331551593IBM journal of Research and Development staff (2008) Overview of the IBM blue gene/P project. IBM J Res Dev 52(1/2):199–220Blocksome M, Archer C, Inglett T, McCarthy P, Mundy M, Ratterman J, Sidelnik A, Smith B, Almási G, Castaños J, Lieber D, Moreira J, Krishnamoorthy S, Tipparaju V, Nieplocha J (2006) Design and implementation of a one-sided communication interface for the IBM eServer Blue Gene® supercomputer. In: Proceedings of the 2006 ACM/IEEE conference on supercomputing, SC ’06, Tampa, FL, USA, November 2006, pp 54–54Kumar S, Dózsa G, Almasi G, Heidelberger P, Chen D, Giampapa M, Blocksome M, Faraj A, Parker J, Ratterman J, Smith BE, Archer C (2008) The deep computing messaging framework: generalized scalable message passing on the blue gene/P supercomputer. In: Proceedings of the 22nd annual international conference on supercomputing, Island of Kos, Greece, June 2008, pp 94–103Tipparaju V, Kot A, Nieplocha J, Bruggencate MT, Chrisochoides N (2007) Evaluation of remote memory access communication on the cray XT3. In: Proceedings of the 21th international parallel and distributed processing symposium, Long Beach, California, USA, March 2007, pp 1–7Nussle M, Scherer M, Bruning U (2009) A resource optimized remote-memory-access architecture for low-latency communication. In: International conference on parallel processing, Sept 2009, pp 220–227http://www.hypertransport.org/Serrano M, Sahuquillo J, Hassan H, Petit S, Duato J (2010) A scheduling heuristic to handle local and remote memory in cluster computers. In: Proceedings of the 12th IEEE international conference on high performance computing, Melbourne, Australia, Sept 2010, pp 35–42Keltcher CN, McGrath KJ, Ahmed A, Conway P (2003) The AMD opteron processor for multiprocessor servers. IEEE MICRO 23(2):66–76Duato J, Silla F, Yalamanchili S (2009) Extending hypertransport protocol for improved scalability. In: First international workshop on hypertransport research and applications.Litz H, Fröening H, Nuessle M, Brüening U (2007) A hypertransport network interface controller for ultra-low latency message transfers. HyperTransport Consortium White Paperhttps://www.simics.net/http://www.cs.wisc.edu/gems/http://www.cs.virginia.edu/stream/Woo SC, Ohara M, Torrie E, Singh JP, Gupta A (1995) The SPLASH-2 programs: Characterization and methodological considerations. In: Proceedings of the 22nd annual international symposium on computer architecture, New York, NY, USA, 1995, pp 24–36Levitin A (2003) Introduction to the design and analysis of algorithms. Addison Wesley, ReadingOleszkiewicz J, Xiao L, Liu Y (2004) Parallel network RAM: Effectively utilizing global cluster memory for large data-intensive parallel programs. In: Proceedings of 33rd international conference on parallel processing, Montreal, Quebec, Canada, pp 353–360Liang S, Noronha R, Panda DK (2005) Swapping to remote memory over infiniband: An approach using a high performance network block device. In: Proceedings of the 2005 IEEE international conference on cluster computing, Boston, Massachusetts, USA, pp 1–10Oguchi M, Kitsuregawa M (2000) Using available remote memory dynamically for parallel data mining application on ATM-connected PC cluster. In: Proceedings of the 14th international parallel & distributed processing symposium, Cancun, Mexico, pp 411–420Werstein P, Jia X, Huang Z (2007) A remote memory swapping system for cluster computers. In: Proceedings of the eighth international conference on parallel and distributed computing, applications and technologies, Adelaide, Australia, pp 75–81Midorikawa H, Kurokawa M, Himeno R, Sato M (2008) DLM: A distributed large memory system using remote memory swapping over cluster nodes. In: Proceedings of the 2008 IEEE international conference on cluster computing, Tsukuba, Japan, October 2008, pp 268–27

A cluster computer performance predictor for memory scheduling

Remote Memory Access (RMA) hardware allow a given motherboard in a cluster to directly access the memory installed in a remote motherboard of the same cluster. In recent works, this characteristic has been used to extend the addressable memory space of selected motherboards, which enable a better balance of main memory resources among cluster applications. This way is much more cost-effective than than implementing a full-fledged shared memory system. In this context, the memory scheduler is in charge of finding a suitable distribution of local and remote memory that maximizes the performance and guarantees a minimum QoS among the applications. Note that since changing the memory distribution is a slow process involving several motherboards, the memory scheduler needs to make sure that the target distribution provides better performance than the current one. In this paper, a performance predictor is designed in order to find the best memory distribution for a given set of applications executing in a cluster motherboard. The predictor uses simple hardware counters to estimate the expected impact on performance of the different memory distributions. The hardware counters provide the predictor with the information about the time spent in processor, memory access and network. The performance model used by the predictor has been validated in a detailed microarchitectural simulator using real benchmarks. Results show that the prediction accuracy never deviates more than 5% compared to the real results, being less than 0.5% in most of the cases.This work was supported by Spanish CICYT under Grant TIN2009-14475-C04-01, and by Consolider-Ingenio under Grant CSD2006-00046Serrano Gómez, M.; Sahuquillo Borrás, J.; Hassan Mohamed, H.; Petit Martí, SV.; Duato Marín, JF. (2011). A cluster computer performance predictor for memory scheduling. En Algorithms and Architectures for Parallel Processing. Springer Verlag (Germany). 7017:353-362. doi:10.1007/978-3-642-24669-2_34S3533627017Meuer, H.W.: The top500 project: Looking back over 15 years of supercomputing experience. Informatik-Spektrum 31, 203–222 (2008), doi:10.1007/s00287-008-0240-6Nussle, M., Scherer, M., Bruning, U.: A Resource Optimized Remote-Memory-Access Architecture for Low-latency Communication. In: International Conference on Parallel Processing, pp. 220–227 (September 2009)Blocksome, M., Archer, C., Inglett, T., McCarthy, P., Mundy, M., Ratterman, J., Sidelnik, A., Smith, B., Almási, G., Castaños, J., Lieber, D., Moreira, J., Krishnamoorthy, S., Tipparaju, V., Nieplocha, J.: Design and implementation of a one-sided communication interface for the IBM eServer Blue Gene®supercomputer. In: Proceedings of the 2006 ACM/IEEE Conference on Supercomputing, p. 120. ACM, New York (2006)Kumar, S., Dózsa, G., Almasi, G., Heidelberger, P., Chen, D., Giampapa, M., Blocksome, M., Faraj, A., Parker, J., Ratterman, J., Smith, B.E., Archer, C.: The deep computing messaging framework: generalized scalable message passing on the blue gene/P supercomputer. In: ICS, pp. 94–103 (2008)Tipparaju, V., Kot, A., Nieplocha, J., Bruggencate, M.T., Chrisochoides, N.: Evaluation of Remote Memory Access Communication on the Cray XT3. In: IEEE International Parallel and Distributed Processing Symposium, pp. 1–7 (March 2007)HyperTransport Technology Consortium. HyperTransport I/O Link Specification Revision (October 3, 2008)Serrano, M., Sahuquillo, J., Hassan, H., Petit, S., Duato, J.: A scheduling heuristic to handle local and remote memory in cluster computers. In: High Performance Computing and Communications (2010) (accepted for publication)Serrano, M., Sahuquillo, J., Petit, S., Hassan, H., Duato, J.: A cost-effective heuristic to schedule local and remote memory in cluster computers. The Journal of Supercomputing, 1–19 (2011), doi:10.1007/s11227-011-0566-8Ubal, R., Sahuquillo, J., Petit, S., López, P.: Multi2Sim: A Simulation Framework to Evaluate Multicore-Multithreaded Processors. In: Proceedings of the 19th International Symposium on Computer Architecture and High Performance Computing (2007)Keltcher, C.N., McGrath, K.J., Ahmed, A., Conway, P.: The AMD Opteron Processor for Multiprocessor Servers. IEEE Micro 23(2), 66–76 (2003)Duato, J., Silla, F., Yalamanchili, S.: Extending HyperTransport Protocol for Improved Scalability. In: First International Workshop on HyperTransport Research and Applications (2009)Litz, H., Fröening, H., Nuessle, M., Brüening, U.: A HyperTransport Network Interface Controller for Ultra-low Latency Message Transfers. In: HyperTransport Consortium White Paper (2007)Zhuravlev, S., Blagodurov, S., Fedorova, A.: Addressing shared resource contention in multicore processors via scheduling. In: Proceedings of the 15th International Conference on Architectural Support for Programming Languages and Operating Systems, pp. 129–142 (2010)Xie, Y., Loh, G.H.: Dynamic Classification of Program Memory Behaviors in CMPs. In: 2nd Workshop on Chip Multiprocessor Memory Systems and Interconnects in conjunction with the 35th International Symposium on Computer Architecture (2008)Xu, C., Chen, X., Dick, R.P., Mao, Z.M.: Cache contention and application performance prediction for multi-core systems. In: IEEE International Symposium on Performance Analysis of Systems and Software, pp. 76–86 (2010)Rai, J.K., Negi, A., Wankar, R., Nayak, K.D.: Performance prediction on multi-core processors. In: 2010 International Conference on Computational Intelligence and Communication Networks (CICN), pp. 633–637 (November 2010)Liang, S., Noronha, R., Panda, D.K.: Swapping to Remote Memory over InfiniBand: An Approach using a High Performance Network Block Device. In: CLUSTER, pp. 1–10. IEEE, Los Alamitos (2005)Werstein, P., Jia, X., Huang, Z.: A Remote Memory Swapping System for Cluster Computers. In: Eighth International Conference on Parallel and Distributed Computing, Applications and Technologies, pp. 75–81 (2007)Midorikawa, H., Kurokawa, M., Himeno, R., Sato, M.: DLM: A distributed Large Memory System using remote memory swapping over cluster nodes. In: IEEE International Conference on Cluster Computing, pp. 268–273 (October 2008

Distributed data cache designs for clustered VLIW processors

Wire delays are a major concern for current and forthcoming processors. One approach to deal with this problem is to divide the processor into semi-independent units referred to as clusters. A cluster usually consists of a local register file and a subset of the functional units, while the L1 data cache typically remains centralized in What we call partially distributed architectures. However, as technology evolves, the relative latency of such a centralized cache will increase, leading to an important impact on performance. In this paper, we propose partitioning the L1 data cache among clusters for clustered VLIW processors. We refer to this kind of design as fully distributed processors. In particular; we propose and evaluate three different configurations: a snoop-based cache coherence scheme, a word-interleaved cache, and flexible LO-buffers managed by the compiler. For each alternative, instruction scheduling techniques targeted to cyclic code are developed. Results for the Mediabench suite'show that the performance of such fully distributed architectures is always better than the performance of a partially distributed one with the same amount of resources. In addition, the key aspects of each fully distributed configuration are explored.Peer ReviewedPostprint (published version

A Case for Cooperative and Incentive-Based Coupling of Distributed Clusters

Research interest in Grid computing has grown significantly over the past five years. Management of distributed resources is one of the key issues in Grid computing. Central to management of resources is the effectiveness of resource allocation as it determines the overall utility of the system. The current approaches to superscheduling in a grid environment are non-coordinated since application level schedulers or brokers make scheduling decisions independently of the others in the system. Clearly, this can exacerbate the load sharing and utilization problems of distributed resources due to suboptimal schedules that are likely to occur. To overcome these limitations, we propose a mechanism for coordinated sharing of distributed clusters based on computational economy. The resulting environment, called \emph{Grid-Federation}, allows the transparent use of resources from the federation when local resources are insufficient to meet its users' requirements. The use of computational economy methodology in coordinating resource allocation not only facilitates the QoS based scheduling, but also enhances utility delivered by resources.Comment: 22 pages, extended version of the conference paper published at IEEE Cluster'05, Boston, M

A Tutorial on Clique Problems in Communications and Signal Processing

Since its first use by Euler on the problem of the seven bridges of K\"onigsberg, graph theory has shown excellent abilities in solving and unveiling the properties of multiple discrete optimization problems. The study of the structure of some integer programs reveals equivalence with graph theory problems making a large body of the literature readily available for solving and characterizing the complexity of these problems. This tutorial presents a framework for utilizing a particular graph theory problem, known as the clique problem, for solving communications and signal processing problems. In particular, the paper aims to illustrate the structural properties of integer programs that can be formulated as clique problems through multiple examples in communications and signal processing. To that end, the first part of the tutorial provides various optimal and heuristic solutions for the maximum clique, maximum weight clique, and $k$-clique problems. The tutorial, further, illustrates the use of the clique formulation through numerous contemporary examples in communications and signal processing, mainly in maximum access for non-orthogonal multiple access networks, throughput maximization using index and instantly decodable network coding, collision-free radio frequency identification networks, and resource allocation in cloud-radio access networks. Finally, the tutorial sheds light on the recent advances of such applications, and provides technical insights on ways of dealing with mixed discrete-continuous optimization problems

Dynamic Resource Scheduling in Cloud Data Center

Cloud infrastructure provides a wide range of resources and services to companies and organizations, such as computation, storage, database, platforms, etc. These resources and services are used to power up and scale out tenants' workloads and meet their specified service level agreements (SLA). With the various kinds and characteristics of its workloads, an important problem for cloud provider is how to allocate it resource among the requests. An efficient resource scheduling scheme should be able to benefit both the cloud provider and also the cloud users. For the cloud provider, the goal of the scheduling algorithm is to improve the throughput and the job completion rate of the cloud data center under the stress condition or to use less physical machines to support all incoming jobs under the overprovisioning condition. For the cloud users, the goal of scheduling algorithm is to guarantee the SLAs and satisfy other job specified requirements. Furthermore, since in a cloud data center, jobs would arrive and leave very frequently, hence, it is critical to make the scheduling decision within a reasonable time. To improve the efficiency of the cloud provider, the scheduling algorithm needs to jointly reduce the inter-VM and intra-VM fragments, which means to consider the scheduling problem with regard to both the cloud provider and the users. This thesis address the cloud scheduling problem from both the cloud provider and the user side. Cloud data centers typically require tenants to specify the resource demands for the virtual machines (VMs) they create using a set of pre-defined, fixed configurations, to ease the resource allocation problem. However, this approach could lead to low resource utilization of cloud data centers as tenants are obligated to conservatively predict the maximum resource demand of their applications. In addition to that, users are at an inferior position of estimating the VM demands without knowing the multiplexing techniques of the cloud provider. Cloud provider, on the other hand, has a better knowledge at selecting the VM sets for the submitted applications. The scheduling problem is even severe for the mobile user who wants to use the cloud infrastructure to extend his/her computation and battery capacity, where the response and scheduling time is tight and the transmission channel between mobile users and cloudlet is highly variable. This thesis investigates into the resource scheduling problem for both wired and mobile users in the cloud environment. The proposed resource allocation problem is studied in the methodology of problem modeling, trace analysis, algorithm design and simulation approach. The first aspect this thesis addresses is the VM scheduling problem. Instead of the static VM scheduling, this thesis proposes a finer-grained dynamic resource allocation and scheduling algorithm that can substantially improve the utilization of the data center resources by increasing the number of jobs accommodated and correspondingly, the cloud data center provider's revenue. The second problem this thesis addresses is joint VM set selection and scheduling problem. The basic idea is that there may exist multiple VM sets that can support an application's resource demand, and by elaborately select an appropriate VM set, the utilization of the data center can be improved without violating the application's SLA. The third problem addressed by the thesis is the mobile cloud resource scheduling problem, where the key issue is to find the most energy and time efficient way of allocating components of the target application given the current network condition and cloud resource usage status. The main contribution of this thesis are the followings. For the dynamic real-time scheduling problem, a constraint programming solution is proposed to schedule the long jobs, and simple heuristics are used to quickly, yet quite accurately schedule the short jobs. Trace-driven simulations shows that the overall revenue for the cloud provider can be improved by 30\% over the traditional static VM resource allocation based on the coarse granularity specifications. For the joint VM selection and scheduling problem, this thesis proposes an optimal online VM set selection scheme that satisfies the user resource demand and minimizes the number of activated physical machines. Trace driven simulation shows around 18\% improvement of the overall utility of the provider compared to Bazaar-I approach and more than 25\% compared to best-fit and first-fit. For the mobile cloud scheduling problem, a reservation-based joint code partition and resource scheduling algorithm is proposed by conservatively estimating the minimal resource demand and a polynomial time code partition algorithm is proposed to obtain the corresponding partition

A study in grid simulation and scheduling

Grid computing is emerging as an essential tool for large scale analysis and problem solving in scientific and business domains. Whilst the idea of stealing unused processor cycles is as old as the Internet, we are still far from reaching a position where many distributed resources can be seamlessly utilised on demand. One major issue preventing this vision is deciding how to effectively manage the remote resources and how to schedule the tasks amongst these resources. This thesis describes an investigation into Grid computing, specifically the problem of Grid scheduling. This complex problem has many unique features making it particularly difficult to solve and as a result many current Grid systems employ simplistic, inefficient solutions. This work describes the development of a simulation tool, G-Sim, which can be used to test the effectiveness of potential Grid scheduling algorithms under realistic operating conditions. This tool is used to analyse the effectiveness of a simple, novel scheduling technique in numerous scenarios. The results are positive and show that it could be applied to current procedures to enhance performance and decrease the negative effect of resource failure. Finally a conversion between the Grid scheduling problem and the classic computing problem SAT is provided. Such a conversion allows for the possibility of applying sophisticated SAT solving procedures to Grid scheduling providing potentially effective solutions