Artificial Intelligence Algorithms to Diagnose Glaucoma and Detect Glaucoma Progression: Translation to Clinical Practice

Purpose: This concise review aims to explore the potential for the clinical implementation of artificial intelligence (AI) strategies for detecting glaucoma and monitoring glaucoma progression. / Methods: Nonsystematic literature review using the search combinations "Artificial Intelligence," "Deep Learning," "Machine Learning," "Neural Networks," "Bayesian Networks," "Glaucoma Diagnosis," and "Glaucoma Progression." Information on sensitivity and specificity regarding glaucoma diagnosis and progression analysis as well as methodological details were extracted. / Results: Numerous AI strategies provide promising levels of specificity and sensitivity for structural (e.g. optical coherence tomography [OCT] imaging, fundus photography) and functional (visual field [VF] testing) test modalities used for the detection of glaucoma. Area under receiver operating curve (AROC) values of > 0.90 were achieved with every modality. Combining structural and functional inputs has been shown to even more improve the diagnostic ability. Regarding glaucoma progression, AI strategies can detect progression earlier than conventional methods or potentially from one single VF test. / Conclusions: AI algorithms applied to fundus photographs for screening purposes may provide good results using a simple and widely accessible test. However, for patients who are likely to have glaucoma more sophisticated methods should be used including data from OCT and perimetry. Outputs may serve as an adjunct to assist clinical decision making, whereas also enhancing the efficiency, productivity, and quality of the delivery of glaucoma care. Patients with diagnosed glaucoma may benefit from future algorithms to evaluate their risk of progression. Challenges are yet to be overcome, including the external validity of AI strategies, a move from a "black box" toward "explainable AI," and likely regulatory hurdles. However, it is clear that AI can enhance the role of specialist clinicians and will inevitably shape the future of the delivery of glaucoma care to the next generation. / Translational Relevance: The promising levels of diagnostic accuracy reported by AI strategies across the modalities used in clinical practice for glaucoma detection can pave the way for the development of reliable models appropriate for their translation into clinical practice. Future incorporation of AI into healthcare models may help address the current limitations of access and timely management of patients with glaucoma across the world

An End-to-End Real-Time Lightweight Network for the Joint Segmentation of Optic Disc and Optic Cup on Fundus Images

Glaucoma is the second-most-blinding eye disease in the world and accurate segmentation of the optic disc (OD) and optic cup (OC) is essential for the diagnosis of glaucoma. To solve the problems of poor real-time performance, high algorithm complexity, and large memory consumption of fundus segmentation algorithms, a lightweight segmentation algorithm, GlauNet, based on convolutional neural networks, is proposed. The algorithm designs an efficient feature-extraction network and proposes a multiscale boundary fusion (MBF) module, which greatly improves the segmentation efficiency of the algorithm while ensuring segmentation accuracy. Experiments show that the algorithm achieves Dice scores of 0.9701/0.8959, 0.9650/0.8621, and 0.9594/0.8795 on three publicly available datasets—Drishti-GS, RIM-ONE-r3, and REFUGE-train—for both the optic disc and the optic cup. The number of model parameters is only 0.8 M, and it only takes 13 ms to infer an 800 × 800 fundus image on a GTX 3070 GPU

Machine Learning for Glaucoma Assessment using Fundus Images

[ES] Las imágenes de fondo de ojo son muy utilizadas por los oftalmólogos para la evaluación de la retina y la detección de glaucoma. Esta patología es la segunda causa de ceguera en el mundo, según estudios de la Organización Mundial de la Salud (OMS). En esta tesis doctoral, se estudian algoritmos de aprendizaje automático (machine learning) para la evaluación automática del glaucoma usando imágenes de fondo de ojo. En primer lugar, se proponen dos métodos para la segmentación automática. El primer método utiliza la transformación Watershed Estocástica para segmentar la copa óptica y posteriormente medir características clínicas como la relación Copa/Disco y la regla ISNT. El segundo método es una arquitectura U-Net que se usa específicamente para la segmentación del disco óptico y la copa óptica. A continuación, se presentan sistemas automáticos de evaluación del glaucoma basados en redes neuronales convolucionales (CNN por sus siglas en inglés). En este enfoque se utilizan diferentes modelos entrenados en ImageNet como clasificadores automáticos de glaucoma, usando fine-tuning. Esta nueva técnica permite detectar el glaucoma sin segmentación previa o extracción de características. Además, este enfoque presenta una mejora considerable del rendimiento comparado con otros trabajos del estado del arte. En tercer lugar, dada la dificultad de obtener grandes cantidades de imágenes etiquetadas (glaucoma/no glaucoma), esta tesis también aborda el problema de la síntesis de imágenes de la retina. En concreto se analizaron dos arquitecturas diferentes para la síntesis de imágenes, las arquitecturas Variational Autoencoder (VAE) y la Generative Adversarial Networks (GAN). Con estas arquitecturas se generaron imágenes sintéticas que se analizaron cualitativa y cuantitativamente, obteniendo un rendimiento similar a otros trabajos en la literatura. Finalmente, en esta tesis se plantea la utilización de un tipo de GAN (DCGAN) como alternativa a los sistemas automáticos de evaluación del glaucoma presentados anteriormente. Para alcanzar este objetivo se implementó un algoritmo de aprendizaje semi-supervisado.[CA] Les imatges de fons d'ull són molt utilitzades pels oftalmòlegs per a l'avaluació de la retina i la detecció de glaucoma. Aquesta patologia és la segona causa de ceguesa al món, segons estudis de l'Organització Mundial de la Salut (OMS). En aquesta tesi doctoral, s'estudien algoritmes d'aprenentatge automàtic (machine learning) per a l'avaluació automàtica del glaucoma usant imatges de fons d'ull. En primer lloc, es proposen dos mètodes per a la segmentació automàtica. El primer mètode utilitza la transformació Watershed Estocàstica per segmentar la copa òptica i després mesurar característiques clíniques com la relació Copa / Disc i la regla ISNT. El segon mètode és una arquitectura U-Net que s'usa específicament per a la segmentació del disc òptic i la copa òptica. A continuació, es presenten sistemes automàtics d'avaluació del glaucoma basats en xarxes neuronals convolucionals (CNN per les sigles en anglès). En aquest enfocament s'utilitzen diferents models entrenats en ImageNet com classificadors automàtics de glaucoma, usant fine-tuning. Aquesta nova tècnica permet detectar el glaucoma sense segmentació prèvia o extracció de característiques. A més, aquest enfocament presenta una millora considerable del rendiment comparat amb altres treballs de l'estat de l'art. En tercer lloc, donada la dificultat d'obtenir grans quantitats d'imatges etiquetades (glaucoma / no glaucoma), aquesta tesi també aborda el problema de la síntesi d'imatges de la retina. En concret es van analitzar dues arquitectures diferents per a la síntesi d'imatges, les arquitectures Variational Autoencoder (VAE) i la Generative adversarial Networks (GAN). Amb aquestes arquitectures es van generar imatges sintètiques que es van analitzar qualitativament i quantitativament, obtenint un rendiment similar a altres treballs a la literatura. Finalment, en aquesta tesi es planteja la utilització d'un tipus de GAN (DCGAN) com a alternativa als sistemes automàtics d'avaluació del glaucoma presentats anteriorment. Per assolir aquest objectiu es va implementar un algoritme d'aprenentatge semi-supervisat.[EN] Fundus images are widely used by ophthalmologists to assess the retina and detect glaucoma, which is, according to studies from the World Health Organization (WHO), the second cause of blindness worldwide. In this thesis, machine learning algorithms for automatic glaucoma assessment using fundus images are studied. First, two methods for automatic segmentation are proposed. The first method uses the Stochastic Watershed transformation to segment the optic cup and measures clinical features such as the Cup/Disc ratio and ISNT rule. The second method is a U-Net architecture focused on the optic disc and optic cup segmentation task. Secondly, automated glaucoma assessment systems using convolutional neural networks (CNNs) are presented. In this approach, different ImageNet-trained models are fine-tuned and used as automatic glaucoma classifiers. These new techniques allow detecting glaucoma without previous segmentation or feature extraction. Moreover, it improves the performance of other state-of-art works. Thirdly, given the difficulty of getting large amounts of glaucoma-labelled images, this thesis addresses the problem of retinal image synthesis. Two different architectures for image synthesis, the Variational Autoencoder (VAE) and Generative Adversarial Networks (GAN) architectures, were analysed. Using these models, synthetic images that were qualitative and quantitative analysed, reporting state-of-the-art performance, were generated. Finally, an adversarial model is used to create an alternative automatic glaucoma assessment system. In this part, a semi-supervised learning algorithm was implemented to reach this goal.The research derived from this doctoral thesis has been supported by the Generalitat Valenciana under the scholarship Santiago Grisolía [GRISOLIA/2015/027].Díaz Pinto, AY. (2019). Machine Learning for Glaucoma Assessment using Fundus Images [Tesis doctoral]. Universitat Politècnica de València. https://doi.org/10.4995/Thesis/10251/124351TESI

Deep learning analysis of eye fundus images to support medical diagnosis

Machine learning techniques have been successfully applied to support medical decision making of cancer, heart diseases and degenerative diseases of the brain. In particular, deep learning methods have been used for early detection of abnormalities in the eye that could improve the diagnosis of different ocular diseases, especially in developing countries, where there are major limitations to access to specialized medical treatment. However, the early detection of clinical signs such as blood vessel, optic disc alterations, exudates, hemorrhages, drusen, and microaneurysms presents three main challenges: the ocular images can be affected by noise artifact, the features of the clinical signs depend specifically on the acquisition source, and the combination of local signs and grading disease label is not an easy task. This research approaches the problem of combining local signs and global labels of different acquisition sources of medical information as a valuable tool to support medical decision making in ocular diseases. Different models for different eye diseases were developed. Four models were developed using eye fundus images: for DME, it was designed a two-stages model that uses a shallow model to predict an exudate binary mask. Then, the binary mask is stacked with the raw fundus image into a 4-channel array as an input of a deep convolutional neural network for diabetic macular edema diagnosis; for glaucoma, it was developed three deep learning models. First, it was defined a deep learning model based on three-stages that contains an initial stage for automatically segment two binary masks containing optic disc and physiological cup segmentation, followed by an automatic morphometric features extraction stage from previous segmentations, and a final classification stage that supports the glaucoma diagnosis with intermediate medical information. Two late-data-fusion methods that fused morphometric features from cartesian and polar segmentation of the optic disc and physiological cup with features extracted from raw eye fundus images. On the other hand, two models were defined using optical coherence tomography. First, a customized convolutional neural network termed as OCT-NET to extract features from OCT volumes to classify DME, DR-DME and AMD conditions. In addition, this model generates images with highlighted local information about the clinical signs, and it estimates the number of slides inside a volume with local abnormalities. Finally, a 3D-Deep learning model that uses OCT volumes as an input to estimate the retinal thickness map useful to grade AMD. The methods were systematically evaluated using ten free public datasets. The methods were compared and validated against other state-of-the-art algorithms and the results were also qualitatively evaluated by ophthalmology experts from Fundación Oftalmológica Nacional. In addition, the proposed methods were tested as a diagnosis support tool of diabetic macular edema, glaucoma, diabetic retinopathy and age-related macular degeneration using two different ocular imaging representations. Thus, we consider that this research could be potentially a big step in building telemedicine tools that could support medical personnel for detecting ocular diseases using eye fundus images and optical coherence tomography.Las técnicas de aprendizaje automático se han aplicado con éxito para apoyar la toma de decisiones médicas sobre el cáncer, las enfermedades cardíacas y las enfermedades degenerativas del cerebro. En particular, se han utilizado métodos de aprendizaje profundo para la detección temprana de anormalidades en el ojo que podrían mejorar el diagnóstico de diferentes enfermedades oculares, especialmente en países en desarrollo, donde existen grandes limitaciones para acceder a tratamiento médico especializado. Sin embargo, la detección temprana de signos clínicos como vasos sanguíneos, alteraciones del disco óptico, exudados, hemorragias, drusas y microaneurismas presenta tres desafíos principales: las imágenes oculares pueden verse afectadas por artefactos de ruido, las características de los signos clínicos dependen específicamente de fuente de adquisición, y la combinación de signos locales y clasificación de la enfermedad no es una tarea fácil. Esta investigación aborda el problema de combinar signos locales y etiquetas globales de diferentes fuentes de adquisición de información médica como una herramienta valiosa para apoyar la toma de decisiones médicas en enfermedades oculares. Se desarrollaron diferentes modelos para diferentes enfermedades oculares. Se desarrollaron cuatro modelos utilizando imágenes de fondo de ojo: para DME, se diseñó un modelo de dos etapas que utiliza un modelo superficial para predecir una máscara binaria de exudados. Luego, la máscara binaria se apila con la imagen de fondo de ojo original en una matriz de 4 canales como entrada de una red neuronal convolucional profunda para el diagnóstico de edema macular diabético; para el glaucoma, se desarrollaron tres modelos de aprendizaje profundo. Primero, se definió un modelo de aprendizaje profundo basado en tres etapas que contiene una etapa inicial para segmentar automáticamente dos máscaras binarias que contienen disco óptico y segmentación fisiológica de la copa, seguido de una etapa de extracción de características morfométricas automáticas de segmentaciones anteriores y una etapa de clasificación final que respalda el diagnóstico de glaucoma con información médica intermedia. Dos métodos de fusión de datos tardíos que fusionaron características morfométricas de la segmentación cartesiana y polar del disco óptico y la copa fisiológica con características extraídas de imágenes de fondo de ojo crudo. Por otro lado, se definieron dos modelos mediante tomografía de coherencia óptica. Primero, una red neuronal convolucional personalizada denominada OCT-NET para extraer características de los volúmenes OCT para clasificar las condiciones DME, DR-DME y AMD. Además, este modelo genera imágenes con información local resaltada sobre los signos clínicos, y estima el número de diapositivas dentro de un volumen con anomalías locales. Finalmente, un modelo de aprendizaje 3D-Deep que utiliza volúmenes OCT como entrada para estimar el mapa de espesor retiniano útil para calificar AMD. Los métodos se evaluaron sistemáticamente utilizando diez conjuntos de datos públicos gratuitos. Los métodos se compararon y validaron con otros algoritmos de vanguardia y los resultados también fueron evaluados cualitativamente por expertos en oftalmología de la Fundación Oftalmológica Nacional. Además, los métodos propuestos se probaron como una herramienta de diagnóstico de edema macular diabético, glaucoma, retinopatía diabética y degeneración macular relacionada con la edad utilizando dos representaciones de imágenes oculares diferentes. Por lo tanto, consideramos que esta investigación podría ser potencialmente un gran paso en la construcción de herramientas de telemedicina que podrían ayudar al personal médico a detectar enfermedades oculares utilizando imágenes de fondo de ojo y tomografía de coherencia óptica.Doctorad

Exploring Deep Learning Techniques for Glaucoma Detection: A Comprehensive Review

Glaucoma is one of the primary causes of vision loss around the world, necessitating accurate and efficient detection methods. Traditional manual detection approaches have limitations in terms of cost, time, and subjectivity. Recent developments in deep learning approaches demonstrate potential in automating glaucoma detection by detecting relevant features from retinal fundus images. This article provides a comprehensive overview of cutting-edge deep learning methods used for the segmentation, classification, and detection of glaucoma. By analyzing recent studies, the effectiveness and limitations of these techniques are evaluated, key findings are highlighted, and potential areas for further research are identified. The use of deep learning algorithms may significantly improve the efficacy, usefulness, and accuracy of glaucoma detection. The findings from this research contribute to the ongoing advancements in automated glaucoma detection and have implications for improving patient outcomes and reducing the global burden of glaucoma

Reconstruction-driven Dynamic Refinement based Unsupervised Domain Adaptation for Joint Optic Disc and Cup Segmentation

Glaucoma is one of the leading causes of irreversible blindness. Segmentation of optic disc (OD) and optic cup (OC) on fundus images is a crucial step in glaucoma screening. Although many deep learning models have been constructed for this task, it remains challenging to train an OD/OC segmentation model that could be deployed successfully to different healthcare centers. The difficulties mainly comes from the domain shift issue, i.e., the fundus images collected at these centers usually vary greatly in the tone, contrast, and brightness. To address this issue, in this paper, we propose a novel unsupervised domain adaptation (UDA) method called Reconstruction-driven Dynamic Refinement Network (RDR-Net), where we employ a due-path segmentation backbone for simultaneous edge detection and region prediction and design three modules to alleviate the domain gap. The reconstruction alignment (RA) module uses a variational auto-encoder (VAE) to reconstruct the input image and thus boosts the image representation ability of the network in a self-supervised way. It also uses a style-consistency constraint to force the network to retain more domain-invariant information. The low-level feature refinement (LFR) module employs input-specific dynamic convolutions to suppress the domain-variant information in the obtained low-level features. The prediction-map alignment (PMA) module elaborates the entropy-driven adversarial learning to encourage the network to generate source-like boundaries and regions. We evaluated our RDR-Net against state-of-the-art solutions on four public fundus image datasets. Our results indicate that RDR-Net is superior to competing models in both segmentation performance and generalization abilit