Learning labelled dependencies in machine translation evaluation

Recently novel MT evaluation metrics have been presented which go beyond pure string matching, and which correlate better than other existing metrics with human judgements. Other research in this area has presented machine learning methods which learn directly from human judgements. In this paper, we present a novel combination of dependency- and machine learning-based approaches to automatic MT evaluation, and demonstrate greater correlations with human judgement than the existing state-of-the-art methods. In addition, we examine the extent to which our novel method can be generalised across different tasks and domains

Detecting grammatical errors with treebank-induced, probabilistic parsers

Today's grammar checkers often use hand-crafted rule systems that define acceptable language. The development of such rule systems is labour-intensive and has to be repeated for each language. At the same time, grammars automatically induced from syntactically annotated corpora (treebanks) are successfully employed in other applications, for example text understanding and machine translation. At first glance, treebank-induced grammars seem to be unsuitable for grammar checking as they massively over-generate and fail to reject ungrammatical input due to their high robustness. We present three new methods for judging the grammaticality of a sentence with probabilistic, treebank-induced grammars, demonstrating that such grammars can be successfully applied to automatically judge the grammaticality of an input string. Our best-performing method exploits the differences between parse results for grammars trained on grammatical and ungrammatical treebanks. The second approach builds an estimator of the probability of the most likely parse using grammatical training data that has previously been parsed and annotated with parse probabilities. If the estimated probability of an input sentence (whose grammaticality is to be judged by the system) is higher by a certain amount than the actual parse probability, the sentence is flagged as ungrammatical. The third approach extracts discriminative parse tree fragments in the form of CFG rules from parsed grammatical and ungrammatical corpora and trains a binary classifier to distinguish grammatical from ungrammatical sentences. The three approaches are evaluated on a large test set of grammatical and ungrammatical sentences. The ungrammatical test set is generated automatically by inserting common grammatical errors into the British National Corpus. The results are compared to two traditional approaches, one that uses a hand-crafted, discriminative grammar, the XLE ParGram English LFG, and one based on part-of-speech n-grams. In addition, the baseline methods and the new methods are combined in a machine learning-based framework, yielding further improvements

Automatic correction of grammatical errors in non-native English text

Thesis (Ph. D.)--Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Dept. of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science, 2009.Cataloged from PDF version of thesis.Includes bibliographical references (p. 99-107).Learning a foreign language requires much practice outside of the classroom. Computer-assisted language learning systems can help fill this need, and one desirable capability of such systems is the automatic correction of grammatical errors in texts written by non-native speakers. This dissertation concerns the correction of non-native grammatical errors in English text, and the closely related task of generating test items for language learning, using a combination of statistical and linguistic methods. We show that syntactic analysis enables extraction of more salient features. We address issues concerning robustness in feature extraction from non-native texts; and also design a framework for simultaneous correction of multiple error types. Our proposed methods are applied on some of the most common usage errors, including prepositions, verb forms, and articles. The methods are evaluated on sentences with synthetic and real errors, and in both restricted and open domains. A secondary theme of this dissertation is that of user customization. We perform a detailed analysis on a non-native corpus, illustrating the utility of an error model based on the mother tongue. We study the benefits of adjusting the correction models based on the quality of the input text; and also present novel methods to generate high-quality multiple-choice items that are tailored to the interests of the user.by John Sie Yuen Lee.Ph.D

Comparative Quality Estimation for Machine Translation. An Application of Artificial Intelligence on Language Technology using Machine Learning of Human Preferences

In this thesis we focus on Comparative Quality Estimation, as the automaticprocess of analysing two or more translations produced by a Machine Translation(MT) system and expressing a judgment about their comparison. We approach theproblem from a supervised machine learning perspective, with the aim to learnfrom human preferences. As a result, we create the ranking mechanism, a pipelinethat includes the necessary tasks for ordering several MT outputs of a givensource sentence in terms of relative quality. Quality Estimation models are trained to statistically associate the judgmentswith some qualitative features. For this purpose, we design a broad set offeatures with a particular focus on the ones with a grammatical background.Through an iterative feature engineering process, we investigate several featuresets, we conclude to the ones that achieve the best performance and we proceedto linguistically intuitive observations about the contribution of individualfeatures. Additionally, we employ several feature selection and machine learning methodsto take advantage of these features. We suggest the usage of binary classifiersafter decomposing the ranking into pairwise decisions. In order to reduce theamount of uncertain decisions (ties) we weight the pairwise decisions with theirclassification probability. Through a set of experiments, we show that the ranking mechanism can learn andreproduce rankings that correlate to the ones given by humans. Most importantly,it can be successfully compared with state-of-the-art reference-aware metricsand other known ranking methods for several language pairs. We also apply thismethod for a hybrid MT system combination and we show that it is able to improvethe overall translation performance. Finally, we examine the correlation between common MT errors and decoding eventsof the phrase-based statistical MT systems. Through evidence from the decodingprocess, we identify some cases where long-distance grammatical phenomena cannotbe captured properly. An additional outcome of this thesis is the open source software Qualitative,which implements the full pipeline of ranking mechanism and the systemcombination task. It integrates a multitude of state-of-the-art natural languageprocessing tools and can support the development of new models. Apart from theusage in experiment pipelines, it can serve as an application back-end for webapplications in real-use scenaria.In dieser Promotionsarbeit konzentrieren wir uns auf die vergleichende Qualitätsschätzung der Maschinellen Übersetzung als ein automatisches Verfahren zur Analyse von zwei oder mehr Übersetzungen, die von Maschinenübersetzungssysteme erzeugt wurden, und zur Beurteilung von deren Vergleich. Wir gehen an das Problem aus der Perspektive des überwachten maschinellen Lernens heran, mit dem Ziel, von menschlichen Präferenzen zu lernen. Als Ergebnis erstellen wir einen Ranking-Mechanismus. Dabei handelt es sich um eine Pipeline, welche die notwendigen Arbeitsschritte für die Anordnung mehrerer Maschinenübersetzungen eines bestimmten Quellsatzes in Bezug auf die relative Qualität umfasst. Qualitätsschätzungsmodelle werden so trainiert, dass Vergleichsurteile mit einigen bestimmten Merkmalen statistisch verknüpft werden. Zu diesem Zweck konzipieren wir eine breite Palette von Merkmalen mit besonderem Fokus auf diejenigen mit einem grammatikalischen Hintergrund. Mit Hilfe eines iterativen Verfahrens der Merkmalskonstruktion untersuchen wir verschiedene Merkmalsreihen, erschließen diejenigen, die die beste Leistung erzielen, und leiten linguistisch motivierte Beobachtungen über die Beiträge der einzelnen Merkmale ab. Zusätzlich setzen wir verschiedene Methoden des maschinellen Lernens und der Merkmalsauswahl ein, um die Vorteile dieser Merkmale zu nutzen. Wir schlagen die Verwendung von binären Klassifikatoren nach Zerlegen des Rankings in paarweise Entscheidungen vor. Um die Anzahl der unklaren Entscheidungen (Unentschieden) zu verringern, gewichten wir die paarweisen Entscheidungen mit deren Klassifikationswahrscheinlichkeit. Mithilfe einer Reihe von Experimenten zeigen wir, dass der Ranking-Mechanismus Rankings lernen und reproduzieren kann, die mit denen von Menschen übereinstimmen. Die wichtigste Erkenntnis ist, dass der Mechanismus erfolgreich mit referenzbasierten Metriken und anderen bekannten Ranking-Methoden auf dem neusten Stand der Technik für verschiedene Sprachpaare verglichen werden kann. Diese Methode verwenden wir ebenfalls für eine hybride Systemkombination maschineller Übersetzer und zeigen, dass sie in der Lage ist, die gesamte Übersetzungsleistung zu verbessern. Abschließend untersuchen wir den Zusammenhang zwischen häufig vorkommenden Fehlern der maschinellen Übersetzung und Vorgängen, die während des internen Dekodierungsverfahrens der phrasenbasierten statistischen Maschinenübersetzungssysteme ablaufen. Durch Beweise aus dem Dekodierungsverfahren können wir einige Fälle identifizieren, in denen grammatikalische Phänomene mit Fernabhängigkeit nicht richtig erfasst werden können. Ein weiteres Ergebnis dieser Arbeit ist die quelloffene Software ``Qualitative'', welche die volle Pipeline des Ranking-Mechanismus und das System für die Kombinationsaufgabe implementiert. Die Software integriert eine Vielzahl modernster Softwaretools für die Verarbeitung natürlicher Sprache und kann die Entwicklung neuer Modelle unterstützen. Sie kann sowohl in Experimentierpipelines als auch als Anwendungs-Backend in realen Nutzungsszenarien verwendet werden

Empirical machine translation and its evaluation

Aquesta tesi estudia l'aplicació de les tecnologies del Processament del Llenguatge Natural disponibles actualment al problema de la Traducció Automàtica basada en Mètodes Empírics i la seva Avaluació.D'una banda, tractem el problema de l'avaluació automàtica. Hem analitzat les principals deficiències dels mètodes d'avaluació actuals, les quals es deuen, al nostre parer, als principis de qualitat superficials en els que es basen. En comptes de limitar-nos al nivell lèxic, proposem una nova direcció cap a avaluacions més heterogènies. El nostre enfocament es basa en el disseny d'un ric conjunt de mesures automàtiques destinades a capturar un ampli ventall d'aspectes de qualitat a diferents nivells lingüístics (lèxic, sintàctic i semàntic). Aquestes mesures lingüístiques han estat avaluades sobre diferents escenaris. El resultat més notable ha estat la constatació de que les mètriques basades en un coneixement lingüístic més profund (sintàctic i semàntic) produeixen avaluacions a nivell de sistema més fiables que les mètriques que es limiten a la dimensió lèxica, especialment quan els sistemes avaluats pertanyen a paradigmes de traducció diferents. Tanmateix, a nivell de frase, el comportament d'algunes d'aquestes mètriques lingüístiques empitjora lleugerament en comparació al comportament de les mètriques lèxiques. Aquest fet és principalment atribuïble als errors comesos pels processadors lingüístics. A fi i efecte de millorar l'avaluació a nivell de frase, a més de recòrrer a la similitud lèxica en absència d'anàlisi lingüística, hem estudiat la possibiliat de combinar les puntuacions atorgades per mètriques a diferents nivells lingüístics en una sola mesura de qualitat. S'han presentat dues estratègies no paramètriques de combinació de mètriques, essent el seu principal avantatge no haver d'ajustar la contribució relativa de cadascuna de les mètriques a la puntuació global. A més, el nostre treball mostra com fer servir el conjunt de mètriques heterogènies per tal d'obtenir detallats informes d'anàlisi d'errors automàticament.D'altra banda, hem estudiat el problema de la selecció lèxica en Traducció Automàtica Estadística. Amb aquesta finalitat, hem construit un sistema de Traducció Automàtica Estadística Castellà-Anglès basat en -phrases', i hem iterat en el seu cicle de desenvolupament, analitzant diferents maneres de millorar la seva qualitat mitjançant la incorporació de coneixement lingüístic. En primer lloc, hem extès el sistema a partir de la combinació de models de traducció basats en anàlisi sintàctica superficial, obtenint una millora significativa. En segon lloc, hem aplicat models de traducció discriminatius basats en tècniques d'Aprenentatge Automàtic. Aquests models permeten una millor representació del contexte de traducció en el que les -phrases' ocorren, efectivament conduint a una millor selecció lèxica. No obstant, a partir d'avaluacions automàtiques heterogènies i avaluacions manuals, hem observat que les millores en selecció lèxica no comporten necessàriament una millor estructura sintàctica o semàntica. Així doncs, la incorporació d'aquest tipus de prediccions en el marc estadístic requereix, per tant, un estudi més profund.Com a qüestió complementària, hem estudiat una de les principals crítiques en contra dels sistemes de traducció basats en mètodes empírics, la seva forta dependència del domini, i com els seus efectes negatius poden ésser mitigats combinant adequadament fonts de coneixement externes. En aquest sentit, hem adaptat amb èxit un sistema de traducció estadística Anglès-Castellà entrenat en el domini polític, al domini de definicions de diccionari.Les dues parts d'aquesta tesi estan íntimament relacionades, donat que el desenvolupament d'un sistema real de Traducció Automàtica ens ha permès viure en primer terme l'important paper dels mètodes d'avaluació en el cicle de desenvolupament dels sistemes de Traducció Automàtica.In this thesis we have exploited current Natural Language Processing technology for Empirical Machine Translation and its Evaluation.On the one side, we have studied the problem of automatic MT evaluation. We have analyzed the main deficiencies of current evaluation methods, which arise, in our opinion, from the shallow quality principles upon which they are based. Instead of relying on the lexical dimension alone, we suggest a novel path towards heterogeneous evaluations. Our approach is based on the design of a rich set of automatic metrics devoted to capture a wide variety of translation quality aspects at different linguistic levels (lexical, syntactic and semantic). Linguistic metrics have been evaluated over different scenarios. The most notable finding is that metrics based on deeper linguistic information (syntactic/semantic) are able to produce more reliable system rankings than metrics which limit their scope to the lexical dimension, specially when the systems under evaluation are different in nature. However, at the sentence level, some of these metrics suffer a significant decrease, which is mainly attributable to parsing errors. In order to improve sentence-level evaluation, apart from backing off to lexical similarity in the absence of parsing, we have also studied the possibility of combining the scores conferred by metrics at different linguistic levels into a single measure of quality. Two valid non-parametric strategies for metric combination have been presented. These offer the important advantage of not having to adjust the relative contribution of each metric to the overall score. As a complementary issue, we show how to use the heterogeneous set of metrics to obtain automatic and detailed linguistic error analysis reports.On the other side, we have studied the problem of lexical selection in Statistical Machine Translation. For that purpose, we have constructed a Spanish-to-English baseline phrase-based Statistical Machine Translation system and iterated across its development cycle, analyzing how to ameliorate its performance through the incorporation of linguistic knowledge. First, we have extended the system by combining shallow-syntactic translation models based on linguistic data views. A significant improvement is reported. This system is further enhanced using dedicated discriminative phrase translation models. These models allow for a better representation of the translation context in which phrases occur, effectively yielding an improved lexical choice. However, based on the proposed heterogeneous evaluation methods and manual evaluations conducted, we have found that improvements in lexical selection do not necessarily imply an improved overall syntactic or semantic structure. The incorporation of dedicated predictions into the statistical framework requires, therefore, further study.As a side question, we have studied one of the main criticisms against empirical MT systems, i.e., their strong domain dependence, and how its negative effects may be mitigated by properly combining outer knowledge sources when porting a system into a new domain. We have successfully ported an English-to-Spanish phrase-based Statistical Machine Translation system trained on the political domain to the domain of dictionary definitions.The two parts of this thesis are tightly connected, since the hands-on development of an actual MT system has allowed us to experience in first person the role of the evaluation methodology in the development cycle of MT systems

Use and Evaluation of Controlled Languages in Industrial Environments and Feasibility Study for the Implementation of Machine Translation

El presente trabajo de investigación se enmarca en los estudios de doctorado en traducción y la sociedad del conocimiento de la Universidad de Valencia y, en concreto, en la línea de investigación en tecnologías de la traducción, terminología y localización. En este sentido, esta disertación surge por la necesidad de establecer una metodología de investigación y ofrecer resultados empíricos sobre el desarrollo, implementación y evaluación de lenguajes controlados en la documentación técnica y su efecto tanto en los textos originales como en las traducciones de estos documentos. Así pues, el objetivo ha sido desarrollar una metodología para evaluar el impacto de los lenguajes controlados en la producción de documentación técnica dentro de contextos industriales y, más en concreto, en la elaboración de documentación técnica para el vehículo. El impacto se ha concretado en la mejora de la traducibilidad automática, un concepto que hemos discutido ampliamente en el capítulo 4, así como de la calidad de los textos meta.This research is part of the doctoral studies program "La traducción y la sociedad del conocimiento" at the University of Valencia. In particular the area of ​​research is translation technology, terminology and localisation. In this sense, this dissertation arises from the need to establish a research methodology and to provide empirical results on the development, implementation and evaluation of controlled languages ​​in the technical documentation and its effect on both original texts and the translations of these documents. Thus, the aim has been to develop a methodology to assess the impact of controlled languages ​​in the production of technical documentation in industrial contexts, and more specifically in the technical documentation for the vehicle. The impact has resulted in improved automatic translatability, a concept we have discussed at length in Chapter 4, as well as in the quality of the target texts