Structural Change Can Be Detected in Advanced-Glaucoma Eyes.

PurposeTo compare spectral-domain optical coherence tomography (SD-OCT) standard structural measures and a new three-dimensional (3D) volume optic nerve head (ONH) change detection method for detecting change over time in severely advanced-glaucoma (open-angle glaucoma [OAG]) patients.MethodsThirty-five eyes of 35 patients with very advanced glaucoma (defined as a visual field mean deviation < -21 dB) and 46 eyes of 30 healthy subjects to estimate aging changes were included. Circumpapillary retinal fiber layer thickness (cpRNFL), minimum rim width (MRW), and macular retinal ganglion cell-inner plexiform layer (GCIPL) thicknesses were measured using the San Diego Automated Layer Segmentation Algorithm (SALSA). Progression was defined as structural loss faster than 95th percentile of healthy eyes. Three-dimensional volume ONH change was estimated using the Bayesian-kernel detection scheme (BKDS), which does not require extensive retinal layer segmentation.ResultsThe number of progressing glaucoma eyes identified was highest for 3D volume BKDS (13, 37%), followed by GCPIL (11, 31%), cpRNFL (4, 11%), and MRW (2, 6%). In advanced-OAG eyes, only the mean rate of GCIPL change reached statistical significance, -0.18 μm/y (P = 0.02); the mean rates of cpRNFL and MRW change were not statistically different from zero. In healthy eyes, the mean rates of cpRNFL, MRW, and GCIPL change were significantly different from zero. (all P < 0.001).ConclusionsGanglion cell-inner plexiform layer and 3D volume BKDS show promise for identifying change in severely advanced glaucoma. These results suggest that structural change can be detected in very advanced disease. Longer follow-up is needed to determine whether changes identified are false positives or true progression

Automated Glaucoma Detection Using Hybrid Feature Extraction in Retinal Fundus Images

Glaucoma is one of the most common causes of blindness. Robust mass screening may help to extend the symptom-free life for affected patients. To realize mass screening requires a cost-effective glaucoma detection method which integrates well with digital medical and administrative processes. To address these requirements, we propose a novel low cost automated glaucoma diagnosis system based on hybrid feature extraction from digital fundus images. The paper discusses a system for the automated identification of normal and glaucoma classes using higher order spectra (HOS), trace transform (TT), and discrete wavelet transform (DWT) features. The extracted features are fed to a support vector machine (SVM) classifier with linear, polynomial order 1, 2, 3 and radial basis function (RBF) in order to select the best kernel for automated decision making. In this work, the SVM classifier, with a polynomial order 2 kernel function, was able to identify glaucoma and normal images with an accuracy of 91.67%, and sensitivity and specificity of 90% and 93.33%, respectively. Furthermore, we propose a novel integrated index called Glaucoma Risk Index (GRI) which is composed from HOS, TT, and DWT features, to diagnose the unknown class using a single feature. We hope that this GRI will aid clinicians to make a faster glaucoma diagnosis during the mass screening of normal/glaucoma images

Retinal Fundus Image Analysis for Diagnosis of Glaucoma: A Comprehensive Survey

© 2016 IEEE. The rapid development of digital imaging and computer vision has increased the potential of using the image processing technologies in ophthalmology. Image processing systems are used in standard clinical practices with the development of medical diagnostic systems. The retinal images provide vital information about the health of the sensory part of the visual system. Retinal diseases, such as glaucoma, diabetic retinopathy, age-related macular degeneration, Stargardt's disease, and retinopathy of prematurity, can lead to blindness manifest as artifacts in the retinal image. An automated system can be used for offering standardized large-scale screening at a lower cost, which may reduce human errors, provide services to remote areas, as well as free from observer bias and fatigue. Treatment for retinal diseases is available; the challenge lies in finding a cost-effective approach with high sensitivity and specificity that can be applied to large populations in a timely manner to identify those who are at risk at the early stages of the disease. The progress of the glaucoma disease is very often quiet in the early stages. The number of people affected has been increasing and patients are seldom aware of the disease, which can cause delay in the treatment. A review of how computer-aided approaches may be applied in the diagnosis and staging of glaucoma is discussed here. The current status of the computer technology is reviewed, covering localization and segmentation of the optic nerve head, pixel level glaucomatic changes, diagonosis using 3-D data sets, and artificial neural networks for detecting the progression of the glaucoma disease

Clinical Significance of Optic Disc Progression by Topographic Change Analysis Maps in Glaucoma: An 8-Year Follow-Up Study

Aim. To investigate the ability of Heidelberg Retina Tomograph (HRT3) Topographic Change Analysis (TCA) map to predict the subsequent development of clinical change, in patients with glaucoma. Materials. 61 eyes of 61 patients, which, from a retrospective review were defined as stable on optic nerve head (ONH) stereophotographs and visual field (VF), were enrolled in a prospective study. Eyes were classified as TCA-stable or TCA-progressed based on the TCA map. All patients underwent HRT3, VF, and ONH stereophotography at 9–12 months intervals. Clinical glaucoma progression was determined by masked assessment of ONH stereophotographs and VF Guided Progression Analysis. Results. The median (IQR) total HRT follow-up period was 8.1 (7.3, 9.1) years, which included a median retrospective and prospective follow-up time of 3.9 (3.1, 5.0) and 4.0 (3.5, 4.7) years, respectively. In the TCA-stable eyes, VF and/or photographic progression occurred in 5/13 (38.4%) eyes compared to 11/48 (22.9%) of the TCA-progressed eyes. There was no statistically significant association between TCA progression and clinically relevant (photographic and/or VF) progression (hazard ratio, 1.18; P=0.762). The observed median time to clinical progression from enrollment was significantly shorter in the TCA-progressed group compared to the TCA-stable group (P=0.04). Conclusion. Our results indicate that the commercially available TCA progression criteria do not adequately predict subsequent photographic and/or VF progression

Statistical atlas-based descriptor for an early detection of optic disc abnormalities

Optic disc (OD) appearance in fundus images is one of the clinical indicators considered in the assessment of retinal diseases such as glaucoma. The cup-to-disc ratio (CDR) is the most common clinical measurement used to characterize glaucoma. However, the CDR only evaluates the relative sizes of the cup and the OD via their diameters. We propose to construct an atlas-based shape descriptor (ASD) to statistically characterize the geometric deformations of the OD shape and of the blood vessels' configuration inside the OD region. A local representation of the OD region is proposed to construct a well-defined statistical atlas using nonlinear registration and statistical analysis of deformation fields. The shape descriptor is defined as being composed of several statistical measures from the atlas. Analysis of the average model and its principal modes of deformation are performed on a healthy population. The components of the ASD show a significant difference between pathological and healthy ODs. We show that the ASD is able to characterize healthy and glaucomatous OD regions. The deviation map extracted from the atlas can be used to assist clinicians in an early detection of deformation abnormalities in the OD region

Stuctural and functional progression in glaucoma: some aspects

This thesis explored some aspects of the relationship between structural progression of the glaucomatous optic nerve head (ONH) and functional progression of the visual field. Sixty-one individuals with a longitudinal series of ONH images were manually identified from a database of approximately 2800 individuals attending a hospital glaucoma clinic. The ONH images obtained from the various photographic sources were equalized, for each individual, in terms of ONH size. Custom-software was designed to enable the viewing of consecutive and chronologically different ONH image-pairs under monoscopic and stereoscopic conditions, with and without sequential flicker. The efficacy, for the identification of progressive glaucomatous loss, amongst the 61 individuals, of the four viewing techniques was qualitatively evaluated by two ophthalmologists. Stereo-flicker identified the largest number of cases of progression, although little agreement was present between the two ophthalmologists. The digital characteristics of the ONH images from 27 of the 61 individuals enabled quantitative digital stereo-planimetry. A weak positive curvilinear association was present, at baseline, between the reduction in the neuroretinal rim area and the outcomes of perimetry, including residual retinal ganglion cell (RGC) count. However, little agreement was again present between the two ophthalmologists. Little association was present with either ophthalmologist between progressive structural damage and functional damage. A separate manual search of 1000 individuals with glaucoma archived in ‘Open eyes’ identified 112 individuals with a minimum of 5 visual field examinations over a minimum of 5 years. The outcomes at each stimulus location of the differential light sensitivity, expressed in decibels (dB), and of the residual RGC count, against time to follow-up, were compared using univariate linear regression analysis. In general, residual RGC count identified progression, in terms of a greater statistical significance and/ or of more stimulus locations, at an earlier stage of the disease than sensitivity expressed in dB

Retinal vessel segmentation using textons

Segmenting vessels from retinal images, like segmentation in many other medical image domains, is a challenging task, as there is no unified way that can be adopted to extract the vessels accurately. However, it is the most critical stage in automatic assessment of various forms of diseases (e.g. Glaucoma, Age-related macular degeneration, diabetic retinopathy and cardiovascular diseases etc.). Our research aims to investigate retinal image segmentation approaches based on textons as they provide a compact description of texture that can be learnt from a training set. This thesis presents a brief review of those diseases and also includes their current situations, future trends and techniques used for their automatic diagnosis in routine clinical applications. The importance of retinal vessel segmentation is particularly emphasized in such applications. An extensive review of previous work on retinal vessel segmentation and salient texture analysis methods is presented. Five automatic retinal vessel segmentation methods are proposed in this thesis. The first method focuses on addressing the problem of removing pathological anomalies (Drusen, exudates) for retinal vessel segmentation, which have been identified by other researchers as a problem and a common source of error. The results show that the modified method shows some improvement compared to a previously published method. The second novel supervised segmentation method employs textons. We propose a new filter bank (MR11) that includes bar detectors for vascular feature extraction and other kernels to detect edges and photometric variations in the image. The k-means clustering algorithm is adopted for texton generation based on the vessel and non-vessel elements which are identified by ground truth. The third improved supervised method is developed based on the second one, in which textons are generated by k-means clustering and texton maps representing vessels are derived by back projecting pixel clusters onto hand labelled ground truth. A further step is implemented to ensure that the best combinations of textons are represented in the map and subsequently used to identify vessels in the test set. The experimental results on two benchmark datasets show that our proposed method performs well compared to other published work and the results of human experts. A further test of our system on an independent set of optical fundus images verified its consistent performance. The statistical analysis on experimental results also reveals that it is possible to train unified textons for retinal vessel segmentation. In the fourth method a novel scheme using Gabor filter bank for vessel feature extraction is proposed. The ii method is inspired by the human visual system. Machine learning is used to optimize the Gabor filter parameters. The experimental results demonstrate that our method significantly enhances the true positive rate while maintaining a level of specificity that is comparable with other approaches. Finally, we proposed a new unsupervised texton based retinal vessel segmentation method using derivative of SIFT and multi-scale Gabor filers. The lack of sufficient quantities of hand labelled ground truth and the high level of variability in ground truth labels amongst experts provides the motivation for this approach. The evaluation results reveal that our unsupervised segmentation method is comparable with the best other supervised methods and other best state of the art methods

Level set segmentation of retinal structures

This thesis was submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy and awarded by Brunel University London.Changes in retinal structure are related to different eye diseases. Various retinal imaging techniques, such as fundus imaging and optical coherence tomography (OCT) imaging modalities, have been developed for non-intrusive ophthalmology diagnoses according to the vasculature changes. However, it is time consuming or even impossible for ophthalmologists to manually label all the retinal structures from fundus images and OCT images. Therefore, computer aided diagnosis system for retinal imaging plays an important role in the assessment of ophthalmologic diseases and cardiovascular disorders. The aim of this PhD thesis is to develop segmentation methods to extract clinically useful information from these retinal images, which are acquired from different imaging modalities. In other words, we built the segmentation methods to extract important structures from both 2D fundus images and 3D OCT images. In the first part of my PhD project, two novel level set based methods were proposed for detecting the blood vessels and optic discs from fundus images. The first one integrates Chan-Vese's energy minimizing active contour method with the edge constraint term and Gaussian Mixture Model based term for blood vessels segmentation, while the second method combines the edge constraint term, the distance regularisation term and the shape-prior term for locating the optic disc. Both methods include the pre-processing stage, used for removing noise and enhancing the contrast between the object and the background. Three automated layer segmentation methods were built for segmenting intra-retinal layers from 3D OCT macular and optic nerve head images in the second part of my PhD project. The first two methods combine different methods according to the data characteristics. First, eight boundaries of the intra-retinal layers were detected from the 3D OCT macular images and the thickness maps of the seven layers were produced. Second, four boundaries of the intra-retinal layers were located from 3D optic nerve head images and the thickness maps of the Retinal Nerve Fiber Layer (RNFL) were plotted. Finally, the choroidal layer segmentation method based on the Level Set framework was designed, which embedded with the distance regularisation term, edge constraint term and Markov Random Field modelled region term. The thickness map of the choroidal layer was calculated and shown.Department of Computer Science, Brunel University London

Modélisation statistique des structures anatomiques de la rétine à partir d'images de fond d'oeil

L’examen non-invasif du fond d’oeil permet d’identifier sur la rétine les signes de nombreuses pathologies oculaires qui développent de graves symptômes pour le patient pouvant entraîner la cécité. Le réseau vasculaire rétinien peut de surcroît présenter des signes précurseurs de pathologies cardiovasculaires et cérébro-vasculaires. La rétine, où apparaissent ces pathologies, est constituée de plusieurs structures anatomiques dont la variabilité est importante au sein d’une population saine. Pour autant, les évaluations cliniques actuelles ne prennent pas en compte cette variabilité ce qui ne permet pas de détecter précocement ces pathologies. Ces évaluations se basent sur un ensemble restreint de mesures prélevées à partir de structures dont la segmentation manuelle est réalisable par les experts. De plus, elles sont basées sur un seuillage empirique déterminé par les cliniciens et appliqué sur chacune des mesures afin d’établir un diagnostic. Ainsi, les évaluations cliniques actuelles sont affectées par la grande variabilité des structures anatomiques de la rétine au sein de la population et elles n’évaluent pas les anomalies trop difficiles à mesurer manuellement. Dans ce contexte, il convient de proposer de nouvelles mesures cliniques qui tiennent compte de la variabilité normale à l’aide d’une modélisation statistique des structures anatomiques de la rétine. Cette modélisation statistique permet de mieux comprendre et identifier ce qui est normal et comment l’anatomie et ses attributs varient au sein d’une population saine. Cela permet ainsi d’identifier la présence de pathologies à l’aide de nouvelles mesures cliniques construites en tenant compte de la variabilité des attributs de l’anatomie. La modélisation statistique des structures anatomiques de la rétine est cependant difficile étant donné les variations morphologiques et topologiques de ces structures. Les changements morphologiques et topologiques du réseau vasculaire rétinien compliquent son analyse statistique ainsi que les outils de recalage, de segmentation et de représentation sémantique s’y appliquant. Les questions de recherches adressées dans cette thèse sont la production d’outils capables d’analyser la variabilité des structures anatomiques de la rétine et l’élaboration de nouvelles mesures cliniques tenant compte de la variabilité normale de ces structures. Pour répondre à ces questions de recherche, trois objectifs de recherche sont formulés. ----------ABSTRACT: Non-invasive retinal fundus examination allows clinicians to identify signs of many ocular conditions that develop critical symptoms affecting the patient and even leading to blindness. In addition, the retinal vascular network may present early signs of cardiovascular and cerebrovascular diseases. The retina, where these pathologies appear, is composed of several anatomical structures whose variability is considerable within a healthy population. Yet, current clinical evaluations do not take into account this variability, and this does not allow early detection of these pathologies. These evaluations are based on a limited set of measurements taken from structures whose manual segmentation is achievable by the experts. In addition, they are based on empirical thresholding determined by the clinicians and applied to each of the measurements to establish a diagnosis. Thus, current clinical assessments are affected by the large variability of anatomical structures of the retina within a healthy population and do not evaluate abnormalities that are too difficult to measure manually. In this context, it is advisable to propose new clinical measurements that take into account the normal variability using statistical modeling of the anatomical structures of the retina. Such a statistical modeling approach helps us to better understand and identify what is normal and how the anatomy and its attributes vary across a healthy population. This makes it possible to identify the presence of pathologies using new clinical measurements constructed by taking into account the variability of the anatomy’s attributes. Statistical modeling of the anatomical structures of the retina is difficult, however, given the morphological and topological variations of these structures. Morphological and topological changes in the retinal vascular network complicate its statistical analysis as well as the registration methods, segmentation and semantic representation applied to it. The research questions proposed in this thesis pertain to creating tools capable of analyzing the variability of the anatomical structures of the retina and proposing new clinical measures that take into account the normal variability of those structures. To answer these research questions, three research objectives are formulated