Expression-based aliasing for OO-languages

Alias analysis has been an interesting research topic in verification and optimization of programs. The undecidability of determining whether two expressions in a program may reference to the same object is the main source of the challenges raised in alias analysis. In this paper we propose an extension of a previously introduced alias calculus based on program expressions, to the setting of unbounded program executions s.a. infinite loops and recursive calls. Moreover, we devise a corresponding executable specification in the K-framework. An important property of our extension is that, in a non-concurrent setting, the corresponding alias expressions can be over-approximated in terms of a notion of regular expressions. This further enables us to show that the associated K-machinery implements an algorithm that always stops and provides a sound over-approximation of the "may aliasing" information, where soundness stands for the lack of false negatives. As a case study, we analyze the integration and further applications of the alias calculus in SCOOP. The latter is an object-oriented programming model for concurrency, recently formalized in Maude; K-definitions can be compiled into Maude for execution

Alias calculus, change calculus and frame inference

Abstract Alias analysis, which determines whether two expressions in a program may reference to the same object, has many potential applications in program construction and verification. We have developed a theory for alias analysis, the "alias calculus", implemented its application to an object-oriented language, and integrated the result into a modern IDE. The calculus has a higher level of precision than many existing alias analysis techniques. One of the principal applications is to allow automatic change analysis, which leads to inferring "modifies clauses", providing a significant advance towards addressing the Frame Problem. Experiments were able to infer the "modifies" clauses of an existing formally specified library. Other applications, in particular to concurrent programming, also appear possible. The article presents the calculus, the application to frame inference including experimental results, and other projected applications. The ongoing work includes building more efficient model capturing aliasing properties and soundness proof for its essential elements

Generic Combination of Heap and Value Analyses in Abstract Interpretation

Abstract. Abstract interpretation has been widely applied to approx-imate data structures and (usually numerical) value information. One needs to combine them to effectively apply static analysis to real software. Nevertheless, they have been studied mainly as orthogonal problems so far. In this context, we introduce a generic framework that, given a heap and a value analysis, combines them, and we formally prove its soundness. The heap analysis approximates concrete locations with heap identifiers, that can be materialized or merged. Meanwhile, the value analysis tracks information both on variable and heap identifiers, taking into account when heap identifiers are merged or materialized. We show how existing pointer and shape analyses, as well as numerical domains, can be plugged in our framework. As far as we know, this is the first sound generic automatic framework combining heap and value analyses that allows to freely manage heap identifiers.

A Formal C Memory Model for Separation Logic

The core of a formal semantics of an imperative programming language is a memory model that describes the behavior of operations on the memory. Defining a memory model that matches the description of C in the C11 standard is challenging because C allows both high-level (by means of typed expressions) and low-level (by means of bit manipulation) memory accesses. The C11 standard has restricted the interaction between these two levels to make more effective compiler optimizations possible, on the expense of making the memory model complicated. We describe a formal memory model of the (non-concurrent part of the) C11 standard that incorporates these restrictions, and at the same time describes low-level memory operations. This formal memory model includes a rich permission model to make it usable in separation logic and supports reasoning about program transformations. The memory model and essential properties of it have been fully formalized using the Coq proof assistant

Formally verified countermeasures against cache based attacks in virtualization platforms

Cache based attacks are a class of side-channel attacks that are particularly effective in virtualized or cloud-based environments, where they have been used to recover secret keys from cryptographic implementations. One common approach to thwart cache-based attacks is to use constant-time implementations, which do not branch on secrets and do not perform memory accesses that depend on secrets. However, there is no rigorous proof that constant-time implementations are protected against concurrent cache attacks in virtualization platforms; moreover, many prominent implementations are not constant-time. An alternative approach is to rely on system-level mechanisms. One recent such mechanism is stealth memory, which provisions a small amount of private cache for programs to carry potentially leaking computations securely. We weaken the definition of constant-time, introducing a new program classification called S-constant-time, that captures the behavior of programs that correctly use stealth memory. This new definition encompasses some widely used cryptographic implementations. However, there was no rigorous analysis of stealth memory and S-constant-time, and no tool support for checking if applications are S-constant-time. In this thesis, we propose a new information-flow analysis that checks if an x86 application executes in constant-time or S-constant-time. Moreover, we prove that (S-)constant-time programs do not leak confidential information through the cache to other operating systems executing concurrently on virtualization platforms. The soundness proofs are based on new theorems of independent interest, including isolation theorems for virtualization platforms, and proofs that (S-)constant-time implementations are non-interfering with respect to a strict information flow policy which disallows that control flow and memory accesses depend on secrets. We formalize our results using the Coq proof assistant and we demonstrate the effectiveness of our analyses on cryptographic implementations, including PolarSSL AES, DES and RC4, SHA256 and Salsa20.Los ataques basados en el cache son una clase de ataques de canal lateral (side-channel) particularmente efectivos en entornos virtualizados o basados en la nube, donde han sido usados para recuperar claves secretas de implementaciones criptográficas. Un enfoque común para frustrar los ataques basados en cache es usar implementaciones de tiempo constante (constant-time), las cuales no tienen bifurcaciones basadas en secretos, y no realizan accesos a memoria que dependan de secretos. Sin embargo, no existe una prueba rigurosa de que las implementaciones de tiempo constante están protegidas de ataques concurrentes de cache en plataformas de virtualización. Además, muchas implementaciones populares no son de tiempo constante. Un enfoque alternativo es utilizar mecanismos a nivel del sistema. Uno de los más recientes de estos es stealth memory, que provee una pequeña cantidad de cache privado a los programas para que puedan llevar a cabo de manera segura computaciones que potencialmente filtran información. En este trabajo se debilita la definición de tiempo constante, introduciendo una nueva clasificación de programas llamada S-constant-time, que captura el comportamiento de programas que hacen un uso correcto de stealth memory. Esta nueva definición abarca implementaciones criptográficas ampliamente utilizadas. Sin embargo, hasta el momento no había un análisis riguroso de stealth memory y S-constant-time, y ningún soporte de herramientas que permitan verificar si una aplicación es S-constant-time. En esta tesis, proponemos un nuevo análisis de flujo de información que verifica si una aplicación x86 ejecuta en constant-time o S-constant-time. Además, probamos que los programas (S-)constant-time no filtran información confidencial a través del cache a otros sistemas operativos ejecutando concurrentemente en plataformas de virtualización. La pruebas de corrección están basadas en propiedades que incluyen teoremas, de interés en sí mismos, de aislamiento para plataformas de virtualización y pruebas de que las implementaciones (S-)constant-time son no interferentes con respecto a una política estricta de flujo de información que no permite que el control de flujo y los accesos a memoria dependan de secretos. Formalizamos nuestros resultados utilizando el asistente de pruebas Coq, y mostramos la efectividad de nuestros análisis en implementaciones criptográficas que incluyen PolarSSL AES, DES y RC4, SHA256 y Salsa20

Understanding and evolving the Rust programming language

Rust is a young systems programming language that aims to fill the gap between high-level languages—which provide strong static guarantees like memory and thread safety—and low-level languages—which give the programmer fine-grained control over data layout and memory management. This dissertation presents two projects establishing the first formal foundations for Rust, enabling us to better understand and evolve this important language: RustBelt and Stacked Borrows. RustBelt is a formal model of Rust’s type system, together with a soundness proof establishing memory and thread safety. The model is designed to verify the safety of a number of intricate APIs from the Rust standard library, despite the fact that the implementations of these APIs use unsafe language features. Stacked Borrows is a proposed extension of the Rust specification, which enables the compiler to use the strong aliasing information in Rust’s types to better analyze and optimize the code it is compiling. The adequacy of this specification is evaluated not only formally, but also by running real Rust code in an instrumented version of Rust’s Miri interpreter that implements the Stacked Borrows semantics. RustBelt is built on top of Iris, a language-agnostic framework, implemented in the Coq proof assistant, for building higher-order concurrent separation logics. This dissertation begins by giving an introduction to Iris, and explaining how Iris enables the derivation of complex high-level reasoning principles from a few simple ingredients. In RustBelt, this technique is exploited crucially to introduce the lifetime logic, which provides a novel separation-logic account of borrowing, a key distinguishing feature of the Rust type system.Rust ist eine junge systemnahe Programmiersprache, die es sich zum Ziel gesetzt hat, die Lücke zu schließen zwischen Sprachen mit hohem Abstraktionsniveau, die vor Speicher- und Nebenläufigkeitsfehlern schützen, und Sprachen mit niedrigem Abstraktionsniveau, welche dem Programmierer detaillierte Kontrolle über die Repräsentation von Daten und die Verwaltung des Speichers ermöglichen. Diese Dissertation stellt zwei Projekte vor, welche die ersten formalen Grundlagen für Rust zum Zwecke des besseren Verständnisses und der weiteren Entwicklung dieser wichtigen Sprache legen: RustBelt und Stacked Borrows. RustBelt ist ein formales Modell des Typsystems von Rust einschließlich eines Korrektheitsbeweises, welcher die Sicherheit von Speicherzugriffen und Nebenläufigkeit zeigt. Das Modell ist darauf ausgerichtet, einige komplexe Komponenten der Standardbibliothek von Rust zu verifizieren, obwohl die Implementierung dieser Komponenten unsichere Sprachkonstrukte verwendet. Stacked Borrows ist eine Erweiterung der Spezifikation von Rust, die es dem Compiler ermöglicht, den Quelltext mit Hilfe der im Typsystem kodierten Alias-Informationen besser zu analysieren und zu optimieren. Die Tauglichkeit dieser Spezifikation wird nicht nur formal belegt, sondern auch an echten Programmen getestet, und zwar mit Hilfe einer um Stacked Borrows erweiterten Version des Interpreters Miri. RustBelt basiert auf Iris, welches die Konstruktion von Separationslogiken für beliebige Programmiersprachen im Beweisassistenten Coq ermöglicht. Diese Dissertation beginnt mit einer Einführung in Iris und erklärt, wie komplexe Beweismethoden mit Hilfe weniger einfacher Bausteine hergeleitet werden können. In RustBelt wird diese Technik für die Umsetzung der „Lebenszeitlogik“ verwendet, einer Erweiterung der Separationslogik mit dem Konzept von „Leihgaben“ (borrows), welche eine wichtige Rolle im Typsystem von Rust spielen.This research was supported in part by a European Research Council (ERC) Consolidator Grant for the project "RustBelt", funded under the European Union’s Horizon 2020 Framework Programme (grant agreement no. 683289)

Proving Cryptographic C Programs Secure with General-Purpose Verification Tools

Security protocols, such as TLS or Kerberos, and security devices such as the Trusted Platform Module (TPM), Hardware Security Modules (HSMs) or PKCS#11 tokens, are central to many computer interactions. Yet, such security critical components are still often found vulnerable to attack after their deployment, either because the specification is insecure, or because of implementation errors. Techniques exist to construct machine-checked proofs of security properties for abstract specifications. However, this may leave the final executable code, often written in lower level languages such as C, vulnerable both to logical errors, and low-level flaws. Recent work on verifying security properties of C code is often based on soundly extracting, from C programs, protocol models on which security properties can be proved. However, in such methods, any change in the C code, however trivial, may require one to perform a new and complex security proof. Our goal is therefore to develop or identify a framework in which security properties of cryptographic systems can be formally proved, and that can also be used to soundly verify, using existing general-purpose tools, that a C program shares the same security properties. We argue that the current state of general-purpose verification tools for the C language, as well as for functional languages, is sufficient to achieve this goal, and illustrate our argument by developing two verification frameworks around the VCC verifier. In the symbolic model, we illustrate our method by proving authentication and weak secrecy for implementations of several network security protocols. In the computational model, we illustrate our method by proving authentication and strong secrecy properties for an exemplary key management API, inspired by the TPM

A Formally-Verified Alias Analysis

Abstract. This paper reports on the formalization and proof of soundness, using the Coq proof assistant, of an alias analysis: a static analysis that approximates the flow of pointer values. The alias analysis considered is of the points-to kind and is intraprocedural, flow-sensitive, field-sensitive, and untyped. Its soundness proof follows the general style of abstract interpretation. The analysis is designed to fit in the Comp-Cert C verified compiler, supporting future aggressive optimizations over memory accesses.