Named Data Networking in Vehicular Ad hoc Networks: State-of-the-Art and Challenges

International audienceInformation-Centric Networking (ICN) has been proposed as one of the future Internet architectures. It is poised to address the challenges faced by today's Internet that include, but not limited to, scalability, addressing, security, and privacy. Furthermore, it also aims at meeting the requirements for new emerging Internet applications. To realize ICN, Named Data Networking (NDN) is one of the recent implementations of ICN that provides a suitable communication approach due to its clean slate design and simple communication model. There are a plethora of applications realized through ICN in different domains where data is the focal point of communication. One such domain is Intelligent Transportation System (ITS) realized through Vehicular Ad hoc NETwork (VANET) where vehicles exchange information and content with each other and with the infrastructure. To date, excellent research results have been yielded in the VANET domain aiming at safe, reliable, and infotainment-rich driving experience. However, due to the dynamic topologies, host-centric model, and ephemeral nature of vehicular communication, various challenges are faced by VANET that hinder the realization of successful vehicular networks and adversely affect the data dissemination, content delivery, and user experiences. To fill these gaps, NDN has been extensively used as underlying communication paradigm for VANET. Inspired by the extensive research results in NDN-based VANET, in this paper, we provide a detailed and systematic review of NDN-driven VANET. More precisely, we investigate the role of NDN in VANET and discuss the feasibility of NDN architecture in VANET environment. Subsequently, we cover in detail, NDN-based naming, routing and forwarding, caching, mobility, and security mechanism for VANET. Furthermore, we discuss the existing standards, solutions, and simulation tools used in NDN-based VANET. Finally, we also identify open challenges and issues faced by NDN-driven VANET and highlight future research directions that should be addressed by the research community

Information-centric communication in mobile and wireless networks

Information-centric networking (ICN) is a new communication paradigm that has been proposed to cope with drawbacks of host-based communication protocols, namely scalability and security. In this thesis, we base our work on Named Data Networking (NDN), which is a popular ICN architecture, and investigate NDN in the context of wireless and mobile ad hoc networks. In a first part, we focus on NDN efficiency (and potential improvements) in wireless environments by investigating NDN in wireless one-hop communication, i.e., without any routing protocols. A basic requirement to initiate informationcentric communication is the knowledge of existing and available content names. Therefore, we develop three opportunistic content discovery algorithms and evaluate them in diverse scenarios for different node densities and content distributions. After content names are known, requesters can retrieve content opportunistically from any neighbor node that provides the content. However, in case of short contact times to content sources, content retrieval may be disrupted. Therefore, we develop a requester application that keeps meta information of disrupted content retrievals and enables resume operations when a new content source has been found. Besides message efficiency, we also evaluate power consumption of information-centric broadcast and unicast communication. Based on our findings, we develop two mechanisms to increase efficiency of information-centric wireless one-hop communication. The first approach called Dynamic Unicast (DU) avoids broadcast communication whenever possible since broadcast transmissions result in more duplicate Data transmissions, lower data rates and higher energy consumption on mobile nodes, which are not interested in overheard Data, compared to unicast communication. Hence, DU uses broadcast communication only until a content source has been found and then retrieves content directly via unicast from the same source. The second approach called RC-NDN targets efficiency of wireless broadcast communication by reducing the number of duplicate Data transmissions. In particular, RC-NDN is a Data encoding scheme for content sources that increases diversity in wireless broadcast transmissions such that multiple concurrent requesters can profit from each others’ (overheard) message transmissions. If requesters and content sources are not in one-hop distance to each other, requests need to be forwarded via multi-hop routing. Therefore, in a second part of this thesis, we investigate information-centric wireless multi-hop communication. First, we consider multi-hop broadcast communication in the context of rather static community networks. We introduce the concept of preferred forwarders, which relay Interest messages slightly faster than non-preferred forwarders to reduce redundant duplicate message transmissions. While this approach works well in static networks, the performance may degrade in mobile networks if preferred forwarders may regularly move away. Thus, to enable routing in mobile ad hoc networks, we extend DU for multi-hop communication. Compared to one-hop communication, multi-hop DU requires efficient path update mechanisms (since multi-hop paths may expire quickly) and new forwarding strategies to maintain NDN benefits (request aggregation and caching) such that only a few messages need to be transmitted over the entire end-to-end path even in case of multiple concurrent requesters. To perform quick retransmission in case of collisions or other transmission errors, we implement and evaluate retransmission timers from related work and compare them to CCNTimer, which is a new algorithm that enables shorter content retrieval times in information-centric wireless multi-hop communication. Yet, in case of intermittent connectivity between requesters and content sources, multi-hop routing protocols may not work because they require continuous end-to-end paths. Therefore, we present agent-based content retrieval (ACR) for delay-tolerant networks. In ACR, requester nodes can delegate content retrieval to mobile agent nodes, which move closer to content sources, can retrieve content and return it to requesters. Thus, ACR exploits the mobility of agent nodes to retrieve content from remote locations. To enable delay-tolerant communication via agents, retrieved content needs to be stored persistently such that requesters can verify its authenticity via original publisher signatures. To achieve this, we develop a persistent caching concept that maintains received popular content in repositories and deletes unpopular content if free space is required. Since our persistent caching concept can complement regular short-term caching in the content store, it can also be used for network caching to store popular delay-tolerant content at edge routers (to reduce network traffic and improve network performance) while real-time traffic can still be maintained and served from the content store

Content, Topology and Cooperation in In-network Caching

In-network caching aims at improving content delivery and alleviating pressures on network bandwidth by leveraging universally networked caches. This thesis studies the design of cooperative in-network caching strategy from three perspectives: content, topology and cooperation, specifically focuses on the mechanisms of content delivery and cooperation policy and their impacts on the performance of cache networks. The main contributions of this thesis are twofold. From measurement perspective, we show that the conventional metric hit rate is not sufficient in evaluating a caching strategy on non-trivial topologies, therefore we introduce footprint reduction and coupling factor, which contain richer information. We show cooperation policy is the key in balancing various tradeoffs in caching strategy design, and further investigate the performance impact from content per se via different chunking schemes. From design perspective, we first show different caching heuristics and smart routing schemes can significantly improve the caching performance and facilitate content delivery. We then incorporate well-defined fairness metric into design and derive the unique optimal caching solution on the Pareto boundary with bargaining game framework. In addition, our study on the functional relationship between cooperation overhead and neighborhood size indicates collaboration should be constrained in a small neighborhood due to its cost growing exponentially on general network topologies.Verkonsisäinen välimuistitallennus pyrkii parantamaan sisällöntoimitusta ja helpottamaan painetta verkon siirtonopeudessa hyödyntämällä universaaleja verkottuneita välimuisteja. Tämä väitöskirja tutkii yhteistoiminnallisen verkonsisäisen välimuistitallennuksen suunnittelua kolmesta näkökulmasta: sisällön, topologian ja yhteistyön kautta, erityisesti keskittyen sisällöntoimituksen mekanismeihin ja yhteistyökäytäntöihin sekä näiden vaikutuksiin välimuistiverkkojen performanssiin. Väitöskirjan suurimmat aikaansaannokset ovat kahdella saralla. Mittaamisen näkökulmasta näytämme, että perinteinen metrinen välimuistin osumatarkkuus ei ole riittävä ei-triviaalin välimuistitallennusstrategian arvioinnissa, joten esittelemme parempaa informaatiota sisältävät jalanjäljen pienentämisen sekä yhdistämistekijän. Näytämme, että yhteistyökäytäntö on avain erilaisten välimuistitallennusstrategian suunnitteluun liittyvien kompromissien tasapainotukseen ja tutkimme lisää sisällön erilaisten lohkomisjärjestelmien kautta aiheuttamaa vaikutusta performanssiin. Suunnittelun näkökulmasta näytämme ensin, kuinka erilaiset välimuistitallennuksen heuristiikat ja viisaan reitityksen järjestelmät parantavat merkittävästi välimuistitallennusperformanssia sekä helpottavat sisällön toimitusta. Sisällytämme sitten suunnitteluun hyvin määritellyn oikeudenmukaisuusmittarin ja johdamme uniikin optimaalin välimuistitallennusratkaisun Pareto-rintamalla neuvottelupelin kehyksissä. Lisäksi tutkimuksemme yhteistyökustannusten ja naapurustokoon funktionaalisesta suhteesta viittaa siihen, että yhteistyö on syytä rajoittaa pieneen naapurustoon sen kustannusten kasvaessa eksponentiaalisesti yleisessä verkkotopologiassa

Recent advances in information-centric networking based internet of things (ICN-IoT)

Information-Centric Networking (ICN) is being realized as a promising approach to accomplish the shortcomings of current IP-address based networking. ICN models are based on naming the content to get rid of address-space scarcity, accessing the content via name-based-routing, caching the content at intermediate nodes to provide reliable, efficient data delivery and self-certifying contents to ensure better security. Obvious benefits of ICN in terms of fast and efficient data delivery and improved reliability raises ICN as highly promising networking model for Internet of Things (IoTs) like environments. IoT aims to connect anyone and/or anything at any time by any path on any place. From last decade, IoTs attracts both industry and research communities. IoTs is an emerging research field and still in its infancy. Thus, this paper presents the potential of ICN for IoTs by providing state-of-the-art literature survey. We discuss briefly the feasibility of ICN features and their models (and architectures) in the context of IoT. Subsequently, we present a comprehensive survey on ICN based caching, naming, security and mobility approaches for IoTs with appropriate classification. Furthermore, we present operating systems (OS) and simulation tools for ICN-IoT. Finally, we provide important research challenges and issues faced by ICN for IoTs

Routin in wireless sensor networks

Internet of Things (IoT) paradigm envisages to expand the current Internet witha huge number of intelligent communicating devices. Wireless Sensor Networks(WSN) deploy the devices running on meagre energy supplies and measuring environmental phenomena (like temperature, radioactivity, or CO 2 ). WSN popularapplications include monitoring, telemetry, and natural disaster prevention. Major WSN challenges are energy efficiency, overcome impairments of wireless medium, and operate in the self-organisation. The WSN integrating IoT will rely on a set of the open standards striving to offer scalability and reliability in a variety of the operating scenarios and conditions. Nevertheless, the current state of the standards have interoperability issues and can benefit from further improvements. The contributions of the thesis work are:We performed an extensive study of Bloom Filters and their use in storing nodetext-based elements in IP address. Different techniques of compression andvariants of filters allowed us to develop an efficient system closing the gapbetween feature-routing and classic approach compatible with IPv6 networks.We propose Featurecast, a routing protocol/naming service for WSN. It allowsto query sensor networks using a set of characteristics while fitting in anIPv6 packet header. We integrate our protocol in RPL and introduce a newmetric, which increase the routing efficiency. We check its performance inboth extensive simulations and experimentations on real sensors in a large-scale Senslab testbed. Large-scale simulations demonstrate the advantagesof our protocol in terms of memory usage, control overhead, packet deliveryrate and energy consumption.We introduce WEAVE - a routing protocol for networks with geolocation. Our so-lution does not use any control message and learn its paths only by observingthe traffic. Several mechanisms are introduce to keep a fixed-size header andbypass both small as well as large obstacles and provide an efficient communication between nodes. We performed simulations on large scale involvingmore than 19000 nodes and real-sensor experimentations on IoT-lab testbed. Our results show that we achieve much better performance especially in large and dynamic networks without introducing any control overhead.Le paradigme d’Internet des objets (IoT) envisage d’élargir Internet actuelle avec un grand nombre de dispositifs intelligents. Réseaux de Capteurs sans Fil (WSN) déploie les dispositifs fonctionnant sur des approvisionnements énergétiques maigres et mesurant de phénomènes environnementaux (comme la température, la radioactivité, ou CO 2). Des applications populaires de WSN comprennent la surveillance, le télémétrie, et la prévention des catastrophes naturelles. Des défis majeurs de WSN sont comment permettre à l’efficacité énergétique, surmonter les déficiences de support sans fil, et d’opérer dans à la manière auto-organisée. L’intégration de WSN dans IoT se posera sur des standards ouvertes efforçant d’offrir évolutivité et de fiabilité dans une variété de scénarios et conditions de fonctionnement. Néanmoins, l’état actuel des standards a les problèmes d’interopérabilité et peuvent bénéficier de certaines améliorations. Les contributions de la thèse sont :Nous avons effectué une étude approfondie des filtres de Bloom et de leur utilisation dans le stockage de caractéristiques de nœud dans l’adresse IP. Différentes techniques de compression et de variantes de filtres nous ont permisde développer un système efficace qui comble l’écart entre le routage de caractéristiques et l’approche classique compatible avec les réseaux IPv6.Nous proposons Featurecast, un protocole de routage / service de nommage pourWSN. Il permet d’interroger les réseaux de capteurs en utilisant un ensemble de caractéristiques tout raccord en entête de paquet IPv6. Nous intégrons notre protocole dans RPL et introduisons une nouvelle mesure, qui augmentent l’efficacité de routage. Nous vérifions sa performance contre dans des simulations approfondies et des test sur des capteurs réels dans un bancd’essai à grande échelle. Simulations approfondies démontrent les avantagesde notre protocole en termes d’utilisation de la mémoire, le surcharge de con-trôle, le taux de livraison de paquets et la consommation d’énergie.Nous introduisons WEAVE - un protocole de routage pour les réseaux avec géolo-calisation. Notre solution n’utilise pas de message de contrôle et apprend sesvoies seulement en observant le trafic. Plusieurs mécanismes sont introduitspour garder un en-tête de taille fixe, contourner à la fois les petits commeles grands obstacles et fournir une communication efficace entre les nœuds.Nous avons effectué des simulations à grande échelle impliquant plus de 19000noeuds et des expériences avec des capteurs réels sur banc d’essai IoT-lab.Nos résultats montrent que nous atteignons bien meilleures performances enparticulier dans les réseaux grands et dynamiques sans introduire de surcharg

Availability, Integrity, and Confidentiality for Content Centric Network internet architectures

The Internet as we know it today, despite being ``the result of a series of accidents of choices'' in Prof. Jon Crowcroft's words, has undoubtedly been an amazing success story. However, it has been constantly challenged by the demands of the overwhelming evolution of data traffic types, non-functional needs of applications and users, and device diversity. The phrase ``future internet architecture'' can be interpreted as referring to a revised set of design principles. As Dr David Clark rightfully suggested, we need to ``allow for the future in the face of the present''. Content Centric Networking (CCN) is one of the candidates for a future internet architecture. Security is one of the most significant considerations while designing a future internet architecture. Availability, Integrity, and Confidentiality (AIC) are considered the three most crucial components of security: 1) availability is the assurance of continuous, reliable, and uninterrupted access to the information by authorized people, 2) integrity is the preservation of information and prevention of any change in it caused via accident or malicious intent, and 3) confidentiality is the ability to keep the information secret from unintended audience, intruders, and adversaries. This thesis discusses AIC related security threats and corresponding remedies for Named Data Networking (NDN) which is a promising example of CCN. It also presents a system dynamics modelling approach to bridge the gap between the technical solutions and business strategy by quantifying some of the qualitative variables salient to technology architects, policymakers, lawmakers, regulators, and internet service providers for the design of a future-proof internet architecture

On the design of efficient caching systems

Content distribution is currently the prevalent Internet use case, accounting for the majority of global Internet traffic and growing exponentially. There is general consensus that the most effective method to deal with the large amount of content demand is through the deployment of massively distributed caching infrastructures as the means to localise content delivery traffic. Solutions based on caching have been already widely deployed through Content Delivery Networks. Ubiquitous caching is also a fundamental aspect of the emerging Information-Centric Networking paradigm which aims to rethink the current Internet architecture for long term evolution. Distributed content caching systems are expected to grow substantially in the future, in terms of both footprint and traffic carried and, as such, will become substantially more complex and costly. This thesis addresses the problem of designing scalable and cost-effective distributed caching systems that will be able to efficiently support the expected massive growth of content traffic and makes three distinct contributions. First, it produces an extensive theoretical characterisation of sharding, which is a widely used technique to allocate data items to resources of a distributed system according to a hash function. Based on the findings unveiled by this analysis, two systems are designed contributing to the abovementioned objective. The first is a framework and related algorithms for enabling efficient load-balanced content caching. This solution provides qualitative advantages over previously proposed solutions, such as ease of modelling and availability of knobs to fine-tune performance, as well as quantitative advantages, such as 2x increase in cache hit ratio and 19-33% reduction in load imbalance while maintaining comparable latency to other approaches. The second is the design and implementation of a caching node enabling 20 Gbps speeds based on inexpensive commodity hardware. We believe these contributions advance significantly the state of the art in distributed caching systems

BloomCasting for publish/subscribe networks

Publish/subscribe has been proposed as a way of addressing information as the primary named entity in the network. In this thesis, we develop and explore a network architecture based on publish/subscribe primitives, based on our work on PSIRP project. Our work is divided into two areas: rendezvous and Bloomcasting, i.e. fast Bloom filter-based forwarding architecture for source-specific multicast. Taken together these are combined as a publish/subscribe architecture, where publisher and subscriber matching is done by the rendezvous and Bloom filter-based forwarding fabric is used for multicasting the published content. Our work on the inter-domain rendezvous shows that a combination of policy routing at edges and an overlay based on hierarchical distributed hash tables can overcome problems related to incremental deployment while keeping the stretch of queries small and that it can solve some policy related problems that arise from using distributed hash tables in inter-domain setting. Bloom filters can cause false positives. We show that false positives can cause network anomalies, when Bloom filters are used for packet forwarding. We found three such anomalies: packet storms, packet loops, and flow duplication. They can severely disrupt the network infrastructure and be used for denial-of-service attacks against the network or target services. These security and reliability problems can be solved by using the combination of three techniques. Cryptographically computed edge pair-labels ensure that an attacker cannot construct Bloom filter-based path identifiers for chosen path. Varying the Bloom filter parameters locally at each router prevents packet storms and using bit permutations on the Bloom filter locally at each router prevent accidental and malicious loops and flow duplications.Yksi Internetin puutteista on se, ettei ole mitään kaikille sovelluksille yhteistä tapaa nimetä informaatiota. Julkaisija/tilaaja-malli on yksi ehdotus, jolla Internet-arkkitehtuuria voisi muuttaa tämän puutteen korvaamiseksi. Väitöskirjassani kehitän julkaisija/tilaaja-malliin pohjautuvan verkkoarkkitehtuurin, joka pohjautuu työlleni PSRIP-projektissa. Arkkitehtuuri koostuu kohtaamisjärjestelmästä, joka yhdistää julkaisijat ja tilaajat, ja Bloom-suodattimiin pohjautuvasta monen vastaanottajan viestintäkanavasta, jolla julkaistu sisältö toimitetaan tilaajille. Internetin kattavalla kohtaamisjärjestelmällä on korkeat vaatimukset. Tutkin kahta erilaista menetelmää: paikallisiin reitityspolitiikoihin pohjautuvaa järjestelmää ja toinen hajautettuihin hajautustauluihin pohjautuvaa järjestelmää. Ensimmäisen haasteena on skaalautuvuus erityisesti silloin, kun kaikki Internetin verkot eivät osallistu järjestelmän ylläpitoon. Jälkimmäinen on ongelmallinen, sillä siihen pohjautuvat järjestelmät eivät voi taata, mitä reittiä julkaisu ja tilaus -viestit kulkevat järjestelmässä. Näin viesti saattaa kulkea myös julkaisijan tai tilaajan kilpailijan verkon kautta. Ehdotan väitöskirjassani menetelmää, joka yhdistää reunoilla politiikkaan pohjautuvan julkaisu/tilaaja reitityksen ja verkon keskellä yhdistää nämä erilliset saarekkeet hierarkista hajautettua hajautustaulua hyödyntäen. Julkaisujen toimittamiseen tilaajille käytän Bloom-suodattimiin pohjautuvaa järjestelmää. Osoitan väitöskirjassani, että Bloom-suodattimien käyttö pakettien reitittämiseen voi aiheuttaa verkossa merkittäviä vikatilanteita, esimerkiksi pakettiräjähdyksen, silmukan, tai samaan vuohon kuuluvien pakettien moninkertaistumisen. Nämä ongelmat aiheuttavat verkolle turvallisuus- ja luotettavuusongelmia, jotka voidaan ratkaista kolmen tekniikan yhdistelmällä. Ensinnäkin, Bloom-suodattimiin laitettavat polun osia merkitsevät nimet lasketaan kryptografiaa hyödyntäen, ettei hyökkääjä kykene laskemaan Bloom-suodatinta haluamalleen polulle ilman verkon apua. Toisekseen, reitittimet määrittävät Bloom suodatinparametrit paikallisesti siten, ettei pakkettiräjähdyksiä tapahdu. Kolmannekseen, kukin reititin uudelleen järjestelee Bloom-suodattimen bitit varmistaen, ettei suodatin ole enää sama, jos paketti kulkee esimerkiksi silmukan läpi ja palaa samalle takaisin samalle reitittimelle.