Statistical analysis of nitrous oxide emission factors from pastoral agriculture field trials conducted in New Zealand

AbstractBetween 11 May 2000 and 31 January 2013, 185 field trials were conducted across New Zealand to measure the direct nitrous oxide (N2O) emission factors (EF) from nitrogen (N) sources applied to pastoral soils. The log(EF) data were analysed statistically using a restricted maximum likelihood (REML) method. To estimate mean EF values for each N source, best linear unbiased predictors (BLUPs) were calculated. For lowland soils, mean EFs for dairy cattle urine and dung, sheep urine and dung and urea fertiliser were 1.16 ± 0.19% and 0.23 ± 0.05%, 0.55 ± 0.19% and 0.08 ± 0.02% and 0.48 ± 0.13%, respectively, each significantly different from one another (p < 0.05), except for sheep urine and urea fertiliser. For soils in terrain with slopes >12°, mean EFs were significantly lower. Thus, urine and dung EFs should be disaggregated for sheep and cattle as well as accounting for terrain

Ammonia and nitrous oxide emission factors for excreta deposited by livestock and land-applied manure

Manure application to land and deposition of urine and dung by grazing animals are major sources of ammonia (NH3) and nitrous oxide (N2O) emissions. Utilizing data on NH3 and N2O emissions following land-applied manures and excreta deposited during grazing, emission factors (EFs) disaggregated by climate zone were developed and effects of mitigation strategies evaluated. The NH3 data represents emissions from cattle and swine manures in temperate wet climates, while the N2O data includes cattle, sheep and swine manure emissions in temperate wet/dry and tropical wet/dry climates. The NH3 EFs for broadcast cattle solid manure and slurry were 0.03 and 0.24 kg NH3-N kg-1 total N (TN), respectively, while broadcast swine slurry was 0.29. Emissions from both cattle and swine slurry were reduced between 46 and 62% with low emissions application methods. Land application of cattle and swine manure in wet climates had EFs of 0.005 and 0.011 kg N2O-N kg-1 TN, respectively, while in dry climates the EF for cattle manure was 0.0031. The N2O EF for cattle urine and dung in wet climates was 0.0095 and 0.002 kg N2O-N kg-1 TN, respectively, which were three times greater than for dry climates. The N2O EFs for sheep urine and dung in wet climates were 0.0043 and 0.0005, respectively. The use of nitrification inhibitors reduced emissions in swine manure, cattle urine/dung and sheep urine by 45 to 63%. These enhanced EFs can improve national inventories; however, more data is needed across multiple livestock species and climates

DataMan: A global dataset of nitrous oxide and ammonia emission factors for excreta deposited by livestock and land-applied manure

Nitrous oxide (N2O), ammonia (NH3) and methane (CH4) emissions from the manure management chain of livestock production systems are important contributors to greenhouse gases (GHG) and NH3 emitted by human activities. Several studies have evaluated manure-related emissions and associated key variables at regional, national or continental scales. However, there have been few studies focusing on these emissions using a global dataset. An international project was created (DataMan) to develop a global database on GHG and NH3 emissions from the manure management chain (housing, storage and field), to identify key variables influencing emissions, and ultimately to refine EFs for future national GHG inventories and NH3 emission reporting. This paper describes the “field” database that focuses on N2O and NH3 EFs from land-applied manure and excreta deposited by grazing livestock. We collated relevant information (EFs, manure characteristics, soil properties and climatic conditions) from published peer-reviewed research, theses, conference papers and existing databases. The database, containing 5,632 observations compiled from 184 studies, was relatively evenly split between N2O and NH3 (56% and 44% of the EF values, respectively). The N2O data were derived from studies conducted in 21 countries on five continents, with New Zealand, the UK, Kenya and Brazil representing 86% of the data. The NH3 data originated from studies conducted in 17 countries on four continents, with the UK, Denmark, Canada and the Netherlands representing 79% of the data. Wet temperate climates represented 90% of the total database. The DataMan field database is available online at http:// dataman.azurewebsites.net

Nutrient losses associated with irrigation, intensification and management of land use: A study of large scale irrigation in North Otago, New Zealand

Irrigation of pasture enables the intensification of land use, but can also result in increased losses of nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P). In 2006 an irrigation scheme was introduced into the Kakanui River and Waiareka Creek catchments in North Otago, New Zealand, which has intensified land use, especially dairying. Supplementation of the Waiareka Creek by direct discharge of 'clean' irrigation water from a nearby River is practiced to raise the minimum flow. This supplementation is hypothesized to dilute N and P losses associated with increased land use intensification and irrigation return flow. Farm losses of N and P before irrigation were then used as a reference to judge in the Kakanui River, and compare against dilution in the Waiareka Creek, the effectiveness of best management practices (BMPs) to improve water quality in 2010 and 2020. Data for N and P fractions from three sites since the mid 1990s were analysed, and flow adjustments for direct discharge to the Waiareka Creek made. Similar concentrations of N and P fractions in Waiareka Creek before and after irrigation began suggest the current minimum flow of 100 L s-1 is insufficient to improve the nutrient status of the Creek, but does dilute recent intensification, which without dilution would have increased concentrations by 30-400%. In the lower Kakanui catchment, direct discharge does not occur and N and P concentrations increased, while little change occurred in the upper Kakanui catchment. Within each catchment, N and P losses from sheep and beef farms and dairy farms (with and without BMPs) were modelled for 2010 and 2020 and compared against that estimated in 2000. This showed that although substantial decreases could be made by adopting BMPs, the predicted increase in N and P losses (up to 200% by 2020) would require either more rigorous use of existing strategies or additional strategies to improve water quality, over and above dilution which is restricted by a need to minimise the risk of flooding.Catchments Nitrogen Overseer Phosphorus Water quality

Evaluation of the wind-tunnel method for measurement of ammonia volatilization from land

A comparison was made of the percentage ammonia recovery from a UK and a French system of small wind-tunnels, commonly used for studying ammonia volatilization losses from grassland. Evaluation of wind-tunnel systems is necessary if data generated by this method are to be used for estimating ammonia losses form field-scale sites and if comparisons are to be drawn between results from different laboratories, organisation and countries. Indoor trials resulted in an average ammonia percentage recovery of 86 and 90% for the UK and French wind tunnel systems, respectively. The difference was probably related to the sampling procedure or to the calculation of the loss rather than to the real process of volatilization from the trays or to the small differences in equipment. Nevertheless, the results suggest that the ammonia trapping efficiency of the wind tunnel system should be evaluated on a regular basis. / Une campagne expérimentale a été conduite à la Station de Recherches de North-Wyke (Royaume-Uni). L'efficacité de deux systèmes de tunnels de ventilation (wind tunnel) a été comparée au cours d'essais de calibration en conditions contrôlées. Trois tunnels construits d'après le modèle de LOCKYER et utilisés régulièrement en France (Cemagref Rennes) ont été testés en regard de six "wind tunnels" développés et utilisés en routine par la station de North Wyke. En moyenne, le pourcentage de recouvrement des tunnels Français s'établit à 90% contre 86% pour les tunnels britanniques. Ces essais ont permis de confirmer que la méthodologie "wind tunnel" permet d'obtenir une mesure par défaut de la volatilisation, mais également que les deux systèmes de tunnels testés, fournissent des résultats comparables et fiables

Costs and effects of measures to reduce ammonia emissions from dairy cattle and pig production: A comparison of country-specific estimations and model calculations

Understanding the costs of emission abatement measures is essential for devising reduction efforts. It allows to identify cost-effective solutions to achieve target values set by international agreements or national policies. This work aims to summarize and discuss the current knowledge on costs and effects associated with selected ammonia (NH3) mitigation measures in livestock production through comparison of country-specific and model-estimated values. Often, large differences appear between the results of individual countries, also in comparison with model results that are generally better harmonized between countries. It seems that different system boundaries in cost assessments, but also different geographic and structural conditions create perceived as well as real cost differences, also caused by the variability of individual situations. Our results are robust with respect to identifying feeding strategies as the most cost-effective, but results for other mitigation options do not show any clear trends, thus making it difficult to distinguish further cost-effective solutions. We point out and discuss some key aspects which may affect estimates of national costs, leading to challenges with the interpretation of final results. Our study concludes that further and more consistent assessments (e.g. standardized protocols) are needed to improve the evaluation base for other individual abatement options, including options that are under development

Improved accuracy and reduced uncertainty in greenhouse gas inventories by refining the IPCC emission factor for direct N2O emissions from nitrogen inputs to managed soils

Most national GHG inventories estimating direct N2O emissions from managed soils rely on a default Tier 1 emission factor (EF1) amounting to 1% of nitrogen inputs. Recent research has, however, demonstrated the potential for refining the EF1 considering variables that are readily available at national scales. Building on existing reviews, we produced a large dataset (n = 848) enriched in dry and low latitude tropical climate observations as compared to former global efforts and disaggregated the EF1 according to most meaningful controlling factors. Using spatially explicit N fertilizer and manure inputs, we also investigated the implications of using the EF1 developed as part of this research and adopted by the 2019 IPCC refinement report. Our results demonstrated that climate is a major driver of emission, with an EF1 three times higher in wet climates (0.014, 95% CI 0.011–0.017) than in dry climates (0.005, 95% CI 0.000–0.011). Likewise, the form of the fertilizer markedly modulated the EF1 in wet climates, where the EF1 for synthetic and mixed forms (0.016, 95% CI 0.013–0.019) was also almost three times larger than the EF1 for organic forms (0.006; 95% CI 0.001–0.011). Other factors such as land cover and soil texture, C content, and pH were also important regulators of the EF1. The uncertainty associated with the disaggregated EF1 was considerably reduced as compared to the range in the 2006 IPCC guidelines. Compared to estimates from the 2006 IPCC EF1, emissions based on the 2019 IPCC EF1 range from 15% to 46% lower in countries dominated by dry climates to 7%–37% higher in countries with wet climates and high synthetic N fertilizer consumption. The adoption of the 2019 IPCC EF1 will allow parties to improve the accuracy of emissions’ inventories and to better target areas for implementing mitigation strategies