162 research outputs found

    Energy return on investment (EROI) of solar PV: an attempt at reconciliation

    Get PDF
    In a recent Point of View piece, William Pickard made an excellent case for the importance of energy return on investment (EROI) as a useful metric for assessing longterm viability of energy-dependent systems from bands of hunter-gatherers, to modern society and, finally to the specific case of a solar electricity generating project. The author then highlighted a seeming disparity between a number of different research groups 1) Fthenakis group at Brookhaven, 2) Prieto group in Madrid, 3) Weißbach group in Berlin, and 4) Brandt group at Stanford all of whom have recently published values for the EROI (or similar metric) for solar photovoltaic (PV) technologies. Unfortunately, in so doing, the author directly compares results calculated using different system boundaries, methodologies, and assumptions. It is the purpose of this response to (1) adjust the results for the four groups to better compare like systems and (2) outline details of two methodological issues common in the EROI literature. The objective of these two activities is to explain much of the apparent disparity between the different EROI values produced by the different research groups

    Estimation of photovoltaic potential for electricity self-sufficiency: A study case of military facilities in northwest Spain

    Get PDF
    Renewable energies, including photovoltaic energy, are attracting widespread international attention, in reaction to worsening environmental problems and the diminishing long-term sustainability of fossil fuel energies. In this work, the potential benefits of installing photovoltaic panels on several buildings at the Spanish Naval Military School (Escuela Naval Militar, ENM) of Mar ın are considered. The two salient advantages are significant economic savings from the production and the sale of electricity to the Spanish Electricity Network and achieving selfsufficiency in electricity requirements. Consequently, the main objective of this work is to estimate the energy potential of photovoltaic installations on the roofs of the ENM buildings. This is the first time that a project of this nature and size is presented to the Spanish Navy. To that end, a three-dimensional geographic analysis of the buildings is performed using three freeware software: Trimble SketchUp, Skelion, and Photovoltaic Geographical Information System. An economic study is also conducted to determine the feasibility of the installations, by estimating the Net Present Value of the photovoltaic installation and the Internal Rate of Return associated with the project. Subsequently, a sensitivity analysis that considers the most important parameters for the calculation of the amortization period is reported. The results show that the installation could fulfill the ENM electrical demands and could, in addition, generate significant economic benefits. The conclusions end with a recommendation to consider the merits of the proposed solution.Regional Government of Castilla y Le on (Ref. BU034U16), under European Regional Development Fund, and the Spanish Ministry of Economy, Industry and Competitiveness under the IþD þ i state programme Challenges for the Society (Ref. ENE-2014-54601-R). One of the authors, David Gonz alez Pe~na, thanks Junta de Castilla-Le on for economic support (PIRTU Program, ORDEN EDU/301/2015

    China’s rising hydropower demand challenges water sector

    Get PDF
    Demand for hydropower is increasing, yet the water footprints (WFs) of reservoirs and hydropower, and their contributions to water scarcity, are poorly understood. Here, we calculate reservoir WFs (freshwater that evaporates from reservoirs) and hydropower WFs (the WF of hydroelectricity) in China based on data from 875 representative reservoirs (209 with power plants). In 2010, the reservoir WF totaled 27.9 × 109 m3 (Gm3), or 22% of China’s total water consumption. Ignoring the reservoir WF seriously underestimates human water appropriation. The reservoir WF associated with industrial, domestic and agricultural WFs caused water scarcity in 6 of the 10 major Chinese river basins from 2 to 12 months annually. The hydropower WF was 6.6 Gm3 yr−1 or 3.6 m3 of water to produce a GJ (109 J) of electricity. Hydropower is a water intensive energy carrier. As a response to global climate change, the Chinese government has promoted a further increase in hydropower energy by 70% by 2020 compared to 2012. This energy policy imposes pressure on available freshwater resources and increases water scarcity. The water-energy nexus requires strategic and coordinated implementations of hydropower development among geographical regions, as well as trade-off analysis between rising energy demand and water use sustainability
    corecore