Review of Jewish Tradition and the Challenge of Darwinism, Geoffery Cantor and Marc Swetlitz, eds.

This is a book review

Review of Analysis of Phylogenetics and Evolution with R by Emmanuel Paradis

This is a book review

Escherichia coli Lacking RpoS Are Rare in Natural Populations of Non-Pathogens

The alternative sigma factor RpoS controls a large regulon that allows E. coli to respond to a variety of stresses. Mutations in rpoS can increase rates of nutrient acquisition at the cost of a decrease in stress resistance. These kinds of mutations evolve rapidly under certain laboratory conditions where nutrient acquisition is especially challenging. The frequency of strains lacking RpoS in natural populations of E. coli is less clear. Such strains have been found at frequencies over 20% in some collections of wild isolates. However, laboratory handling can select for RpoS-null strains and may have affected some of these strain collections. Other studies have included an unknown diversity of strains or only used a phenotypic proxy as a measure of RpoS levels. We directly measured RpoS levels in a collection of E. coli that includes the full diversity of the species and that was handled in a manner to minimize the potential for laboratory evolution. We found that only 2% of strains produce no functional RpoS. Comparison of these strains in multiple labs shows that these rpoS mutations occurred in the laboratory. Earlier studies reporting much higher levels of RpoS polymorphism may reflect the storage history of the strains in laboratories rather than true frequency of such strains in natural populations

Size Doesn\u27t Matter: Microbial Selection Experiments Address Ecological Phenomena

Experimental evolution is relevant to ecology because it can connect physiology, and in particular metabolism, to questions in ecology. The investigation of the linkage between the environment and the evolution of metabolism is tractable because these experiments manipulate a very simple environment to produce predictable evolutionary outcomes. In doing so, microbial selection experiments can examine the causal elements of natural selection: how specific traits in varying environments will yield different fitnesses. Here, we review the methodology of microbial evolution experiments and address three issues that are relevant to ecologists: genotype-by-environment interactions, ecological diversification due to specialization, and negative frequency-dependent selection. First, we expect that genotype-by-environment interactions will be ubiquitous in biological systems. Second, while antagonistic pleiotropy is implicated in some cases of ecological specialization, other mechanisms also seem to be at work. Third, while negative frequency-dependent selection can maintain ecological diversity in laboratory systems, a mechanistic (biochemical) analysis of these systems suggests that negative frequency dependence may only apply within a narrow range of environments if resources are substitutable. Finally, we conclude that microbial experimental evolution needs to avail itself of molecular techniques that could enable a mechanistic understanding of ecological diversification in these simple systems

The transcriptional response of genes to RpoS concentration in Escherichia coli is not determined by core promoter sequences

The alternative sigma factor RpoS is an important regulatory protein in Escherichia coli, responsible for mediating the general stress response. RpoS levels vary continuously in response to different stresses. Previous work has shown that genes vary in their responsiveness to increasing RpoS concentrations, with some genes being "sensitive," requiring only a low level of RpoS to be relatively highly expressed, while other genes are "insensitive," only being highly expressed in the presence of high levels of RpoS. In other systems, this type of variation is caused by interactions between the regulatory protein and the DNA it binds. To see if this is the case for RpoS, we measured twelve RpoS binding site mutants for their effects on maximal expression and responsiveness to increasing RpoS concentration. While maximal expression varied over an order of magnitude across these twelve constructs, the responsiveness to increasing RpoS concentration was largely unaffected, suggesting that the RpoS binding site alone is not responsible for a genes' sensitivity or insensitivity to RpoS. In addition, we swapped the RpoS binding region between sensitive and insensitive promoters and found no change in the behavior of the promoter. Taken together, these results argue that differences in sensitivity of the RpoS-dependent promoters are not due to interactions between RpoS and the various DNA sites it binds

The transcriptional response of genes to RpoS concentration in Escherichia coli is not determined by core promoter sequences

The alternative sigma factor RpoS is an important regulatory protein in Escherichia coli, responsible for mediating the general stress response. RpoS levels vary continuously in response to different stresses. Previous work has shown that genes vary in their responsiveness to increasing RpoS concentrations, with some genes being "sensitive," requiring only a low level of RpoS to be relatively highly expressed, while other genes are "insensitive," only being highly expressed in the presence of high levels of RpoS. In other systems, this type of variation is caused by interactions between the regulatory protein and the DNA it binds. To see if this is the case for RpoS, we measured twelve RpoS binding site mutants for their effects on maximal expression and responsiveness to increasing RpoS concentration. While maximal expression varied over an order of magnitude across these twelve constructs, the responsiveness to increasing RpoS concentration was largely unaffected, suggesting that the RpoS binding site alone is not responsible for a genes' sensitivity or insensitivity to RpoS. In addition, we swapped the RpoS binding region between sensitive and insensitive promoters and found no change in the behavior of the promoter. Taken together, these results argue that differences in sensitivity of the RpoS-dependent promoters are not due to interactions between RpoS and the various DNA sites it binds

Genome-Wide Transcriptional Response to Varying RpoS Levels in Escherichia coli K-12

The alternative sigma factor RpoS is a central regulator of many stress responses in Escherichia coli. The level of functional RpoS differs depending on the stress. The effect of these differing concentrations of RpoS on global transcriptional responses remains unclear. We investigated the effect of RpoS concentration on the transcriptome during stationary phase in rich media. We found that 23% of genes in the E. coli genome are regulated by RpoS, and we identified many RpoS-transcribed genes and promoters. We observed three distinct classes of response to RpoS by genes in the regulon: genes whose expression changes linearly with increasing RpoS level, genes whose expression changes dramatically with the production of only a little RpoS (“sensitive” genes), and genes whose expression changes very little with the production of a little RpoS (“insensitive”). We show that sequences outside the core promoter region determine whether an RpoS-regulated gene is sensitive or insensitive. Moreover, we show that sensitive and insensitive genes are enriched for specific functional classes and that the sensitivity of a gene to RpoS corresponds to the timing of induction as cells enter stationary phase. Thus, promoter sensitivity to RpoS is a mechanism to coordinate specific cellular processes with growth phase and may also contribute to the diversity of stress responses directed by RpoS

Compensatory Evolution of Gene Regulation in Response to Stress by Escherichia coli Lacking RpoS

The RpoS sigma factor protein of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase is the master transcriptional regulator of physiological responses to a variety of stresses. This stress response comes at the expense of scavenging for scarce resources, causing a trade-off between stress tolerance and nutrient acquisition. This trade-off favors non-functional rpoS alleles in nutrient-poor environments. We used experimental evolution to explore how natural selection modifies the regulatory network of strains lacking RpoS when they evolve in an osmotically stressful environment. We found that strains lacking RpoS adapt less variably, in terms of both fitness increase and changes in patterns of transcription, than strains with functional RpoS. This phenotypic uniformity was caused by the same adaptive mutation in every independent population: the insertion of IS10 into the promoter of the otsBA operon. OtsA and OtsB are required to synthesize the osmoprotectant trehalose, and transcription of otsBA requires RpoS in the wild-type genetic background. The evolved IS10 insertion rewires expression of otsBA from RpoS-dependent to RpoS-independent, allowing for partial restoration of wild-type response to osmotic stress. Our results show that the regulatory networks of bacteria can evolve new structures in ways that are both rapid and repeatable

Lack of Evidence for Horizontal Transfer of the lac Operon into Escherichia coli

The idea that Escherichia coli gained the lac operon via horizontal transfer, allowing it to invade a new niche and form a new species, has become a paradigmatic example of bacterial nonpathogenic adaptation and speciation catalyzed by horizontal transfer. Surprisingly, empirical evidence for this event is essentially nonexistent. To see whether horizontal transfer occurred, I compared a phylogeny of 14 Enterobacteriaceae based on two housekeeping genes to a phylogeny of a part of their lac operon. Although several species in this clade appear to have acquired some or all of the operon via horizontal transfer, there is no evidence of horizontal transfer into E. coli. It is not clear whether the horizontal transfer events for which there is evidence were adaptive because those species which have acquired the operon are not thought to live in high lactose environments. I propose that vertical transmission from the common ancestor of the Enterobacteriaceae, with subsequent loss of these genes in many species can explain much of the patchy distribution of lactose use in this clade. Finally, I argue that we need new, well-supported examples of horizontal transfer spurring niche expansion and speciation, particularly in nonpathogenic cases, before we can accept claims that horizontal transfer is a hallmark of bacterial adaptation