Inégalités sociales de santé : quels impacts sur l’accès aux soins de prévention ?

En abordant la réduction des inégalités sociales et territoriales de santé sous l’angle exclusif de l’amélioration de l’accès aux soins des populations les plus « vulnérables », les politiques et programmes de santé considèrent une seule dimension de ces inégalités, alors qu’elles traversent l’ensemble de la hiérarchie sociale. Or, si les disparités d’accès aux soins préventifs ne constituent pas le déterminant principal des inégalités sociales de santé, dans un modèle de soins français essentiellement curatif, elles ne sont pas négligeables dans leur production. Cependant, les mesures visant à élargir l’accès aux soins de prévention ne sont pas les seules à mettre en oeuvre pour réduire les inégalités sociales de santé, qui traversent l’ensemble de la hiérarchie sociale.Seeking to reduce social and territorial inequalities of health by focusing exclusively on improved access to care for the most “vulnerable” population means that health policies and programmes take only one dimension of such inequalities into account, even though they are found throughout the social hierarchy. While access to preventive care is not the principal determinant of social inequalities of health, it is not a negligible factor in the production of such inequalities in a health care system such as France’s which focuses on cure

Pourquoi refuser de délivrer des soins ?

This article analyses social dynamics of care refusal by private practitioners towards patients covered by public funded complementary health insurance (CMU-C). The data are based on in-depth face-to-face interviews with physicians and dentists conducted between (2015-2016), and are analyzed from a socio-anthropological approach. The results show intertwining between economic logic and non-economic such as the social representations of those patients, the practitioners’ values, their relationship with the government and social insurance institution.Cet article vise à analyser les logiques sociales du refus de soins à l’égard des bénéficiaires de la Couverture maladie universelle complémentaire par des professionnels de santé de ville. Les résultats reposent sur une analyse socioanthropologique de discours d’une cinquantaine de médecins et dentistes, récoltés entre 2015 et 2016. Ils montrent l’intrication entre des logiques économiques et non économiques, telles que les représentations de cette catégorie de patients, les valeurs des praticiens et leur rapport à l’État et à l’assurance maladie

Decisional issues in antibiotic prescribing in French nursing homes: An ethnographic study

Background: Medication prescription is generally the responsibility of doctors. In nursing homes, the nursing staff is often the first to suspect an infection. Today, physicians are more confident with nursing assessment, relying primarily on nursing staff information. Very few studies have investigated the nurses’ influence on decision of medical prescription. This study investigates the role of nurses in antibiotic prescribing for the treatment of suspected infections in nursing home residents. Design and methods: An ethnographic study based on semi-structured interviews and participant observations was conducted. Sixteen nurses and five doctors working in five nursing homes in Paris, France participated between October 2015 and January 2016. Results: Given their proximity to elderly residents, registered nurses at the nursing homes occasionally assisted doctors in their medical diagnostic. However, nurses who are theoretically incompetent have met difficulties in their ability to participate in their decisions to prescribe antibiotics when managing residents’ infections.Conclusion: if proximity and nursing skills reinforce the relevance of the clinical judgment of nurses, the effective and collaborative communication between the nurse and the doctor may help the nurse to enhance their role in the antibiotic prescribing in nursing homes, which would enhance antimicrobial stewardship efficiency

Impact of Home-Based Management of malaria combined with other community-based interventions: what do we learn from Rwanda?

Introduction: This study aimed to evaluate the impact of home-based management of malaria (HBM) strategy on time to treatment and reported presumed malaria morbidity in children aged less than 5 years in Rwanda. Methods: The study was carried out in two malaria-endemic rural districts, one where HBM was applied and the other serving as control. In each district, a sample of mothers was surveyed by questionnaire before (2004) and after (2007) implementation of HBM. Results: After implementation, we observed: i) an increase (P<0.001) in the number of febrile children treated within 24 hours of symptom onset in the experimental district (53.7% in 2007 vs 5% in 2004) compared with the control district (28% vs 7.7%); ii) a decrease in the reported number of febrile children in the experimental district (28.7% vs 44.9%, P<0.01) compared with the control district (45.7% vs 56.5%, P<0.05). Conclusion: HBM contributed to decrease time to treatment and reported presumed malaria morbidity.Pan African Medical Journal 2013; 14:5

Patient-physician interaction in general practice and health inequalities in a multidisciplinary study: design, methods and feasibility in the French INTERMEDE study

<p>Abstract</p> <p>Background</p> <p>The way in which patients and their doctors interact is a potentially important factor in optimal communication during consultations as well as treatment, compliance and follow-up care. The aim of this multidisciplinary study is to use both qualitative and quantitative methods to explore the 'black box' that is the interaction between the two parties during a general practice consultation, and to identify factors therein that may contribute to producing health inequalities. This paper outlines the original multidisciplinary methodology used, and the feasibility of this type of study.</p> <p>Methods and design</p> <p>The study design combines methodologies on two separate samples in two phases. Firstly, a qualitative phase collected ethnographical and sociological data during consultation, followed by in-depth interviews with both patients and doctors independently. Secondly, a quantitative phase on a different sample of patients and physicians collected data via several questionnaires given to patients and doctors consisting of specific 'mirrored' questions asked post-consultation, as well as collecting information on patient and physician characteristics.</p> <p>Discussion</p> <p>The design and methodology used in this study were both successfully implemented, and readily accepted by doctors and patients alike. This type of multidisciplinary study shows great potential in providing further knowledge into the role of patient/physician interaction and its influence on maintaining or producing health inequalities. The next challenge in this study will be implementing the multidisciplinary approach during the data analysis.</p

Relationship between inpatient satisfaction and nurse absenteeism: an exploratory study using WHO-PATH performance indicators in France

<p>Abstract</p> <p>Background</p> <p>Indicators describing results of care are widely explored in term of patient satisfaction (PS). Among factors explaining PS, human resources indicators have been studied in terms of burnout or job satisfaction among healthcare professionals. No research work has set out to explore the effect of absenteeism on PS scores. The objective of this study was to explore interaction between rate of absenteeism among nurses and PS results.</p> <p>Methods</p> <p>France has taken part in a project named PATH (Performance Assessment Tool for Hospitals) of the World Health Organization, aiming to develop a tool for the assessment of hospital performance. In the first semester 2008, 25 volunteering short-stay hospitals (teaching, general and private) provide complete data on nurse short-absenteeism (periods of up to 7 consecutive days of sick leave) and on PS (a cross-sectional postal survey using a standardized validated French-language scale EQS-H exploring "quality of medical information" (MI) and "relationships with staff and daily routine" (RS)). A multi-level model was used to take into account of the hierarchical nature of the data.</p> <p>Results</p> <p>Two thousand and sixty-five patients responded to the satisfaction questionnaire (participation rate: 40.9%). The mean age of respondents was 58 yrs (± 19), 41% were men. The mean duration of hospitalisation was 7.5 days (± 11.1). The mean absenteeism rate for nurses was 0.24% (± 0.14).</p> <p>All the PS scores were significantly and negatively correlated with rate of short-absenteeism among nurses (MI score: <it>ρ </it>= -0.55, <it>p </it>< 0.01), RS score <it>ρ </it>= -0.47, <it>p </it>= 0.02). The mixed model found a significant relationship between rate of absenteeism among nurses and PS scores (MI: <it>p </it>= 0.027; RS: <it>p </it>= 0.017).</p> <p>Conclusion</p> <p>Results obtained in this study show that short-term absenteeism among nurses seems to be significantly and negatively correlated with PS. Our findings are an invitation to deepen our understanding of the impact of human resources on PS and to develop more specific projects.</p

Improvement of psychometric properties of a scale measuring inpatient satisfaction with care: a better response rate and a reduction of the ceiling effect

<p>Abstract</p> <p>Background</p> <p>The objective was to solve two problems of an already validated scale measuring inpatient opinion on care: 1) a high non-response rate for some items due to the "not applicable" response option and 2) a skewed score distribution with high ceiling effect.</p> <p>Methods</p> <p>The EQS-H scale ("échelle de qualité des soins en hospitalisation") comprised 26 items and 2 sub-scales of 13 items each, 'quality of medical information' (MI) and 'relationships with staff and daily routine' (RS). Three studies were conducted: a first mono-centre study (n = 552, response rate = 83.4%, self-completion of the scale the day before discharge) to construct a shorter version of the scale without the items with high non-response rate and maintaining those useful to ensure good internal validity (construct, convergent and divergent) and reliability; a second mono-centre study (n = 1246, response rate = 77.9%, self-completion of the scale before discharge) to confirm psychometric properties of the new version; a third multi-centre national study (n = 886, response rate 41.7%, self-completion at home 15 days after discharge) to test a new response pattern in order to reduce ceiling effect.</p> <p>Results</p> <p>Six items having a non-response rate >20% were deleted, increasing rates of exhaustive response to all items from 15% to 48%. Factorial analysis supported the evidence for removing 4 more items to ensure good internal validity and reliability of the new version. These good results (initial variance explained: 43%; Cronbach's α: 0.80 (MI) and 0.81 (RS)) were confirmed by the second study. The new response format produced a normalisation of the 2 scores with a large decrease in ceiling effect (25% to 4% for MI subscale and 61% to 8% for RS). Psychometric properties of the final version were excellent: the 2 subscales (8 items each) explained 66% of the variance in principal component analysis, Cronbach's α were respectively 0.92 (MI) and 0.93 (RS).</p> <p>Conclusion</p> <p>The new version of the EQS-H has better psychometric properties than the previous one. Rates of missing values are lower, and score distribution is normalized. An English version of this scale focused on quality of medical information delivered and on relationship with staff already exists, and this could be useful to conduct cross-cultural studies of health care service quality.</p

À propos des liens entre santé et migration (Commentaire)

Lombrail Pierre. À propos des liens entre santé et migration (Commentaire). In: Sciences sociales et santé. Volume 17, n°4, 1999. pp. 37-44