Benefits and costs of aphid phenological bet-hedging strategies

Intended readership I am looking for a host institute to research bet-hedging strategies in the seasonal reproductive mode switches of aphids. The intended methods leave room for collaborative side-projects beyond the study question (e.g. molecular control of photoperiodism, or sharing aphid lines from throughout Europe), so this article might be of interest to anyone working with aphids. In addition, I would be happy to receive feedback from experts in bet-hedging theory, phenotypic plasticity and photoperiodism. Summary Global change causes both mean temperature and temperature variability to increase. Organisms can cope with predictable change in means, but increasing variability is less tractable. One strategy to increase survival chances in unpredictable environments is diversified bet-hedging, i.e. spreading the risk by variation in phenotype expression. Despite being considered a general mechanism, definite evidence for bet-hedging is scarce, as it requires both the demonstration that phenotypic variance correlates with environmental variability, and that it maximizes fitness. When assessing fitness, one needs to account for both the benefits and costs of bet-hedging. Bet-hedgers produce suboptimal phenotypes in average years, resulting in decreased arithmetic mean fitness. But this temporary reduction is more than compensated by elevated fitness in harsh years, so this well-known short-term fitness effect is not considered a real cost of bet-hedging. In contrast to the effects on arithmetic mean fitness, I hypothesize that bet-hedging also carries a long-term (geometric mean) fitness costs, in that the ability to generate phenotypic variance is costly per se. With this research idea I seek evidence for bet-hedging and assess its costs and benefits, using aphids and their polyphenism in reproductive modes as model system. I plan to use aphid clones from environments along a gradient of temperature variability, and induce switches in reproductive modes under controlled conditions. To test for bet-hedging, I will correlate variance in phenotype determination with variability of the original environment. To determine the costs of bet-hedging, I will compare population growth of bet-hedgers with non-hedging clones. I will then combine benefits and costs of bet-hedging by calculating the geometric (long-term) mean fitness in predictable and unpredictable environments

Transgenerational plasticity and bet-hedging : a framework for reaction norm evolution

Decision-making under uncertain conditions favors bet-hedging (avoidance of fitness variance), whereas predictable environments favor phenotypic plasticity. However, entirely predictable or entirely unpredictable conditions are rarely found in nature. Intermediate strategies are required when the time lag between information sensing and phenotype induction is large (e.g., transgenerational plasticity) and when cues are only partially predictive of future conditions. Nevertheless, current theory regards plasticity and bet-hedging as distinct entities. We here develop a unifying framework: based on traits with binary outcomes like seed germination or diapause incidence we clarify that diversified bet-hedging (risk-spreading among one's offspring) and transgenerational plasticity are mutually exclusive strategies, arising from opposing changes in reaction norms (allocating phenotypic variance among or within environments). We further explain the relationship of this continuum with arithmetic mean maximization vs. conservative bet-hedging (a risk-avoidance strategy), and canalization vs. phenotypic variance in a three-dimensional continuum of reaction norm evolution. We discuss under which scenarios costs and limits may constrain the evolution of reaction norm shapes

Pea aphids (Hemiptera: Aphididae) have diurnal rhythms when raised independently of a host plant

Seasonal timing is assumed to involve the circadian clock, an endogenous mechanism to track time and measure day length. Some debate persists, however, and aphids were among the first organisms for which circadian clock involvement was questioned. Inferences about links to phenology are problematic, as the clock itself is little investigated in aphids. For instance, it is unknown whether aphids possess diurnal rhythms at all. Possibly, the close interaction with host plants prevents independent measurements of rhythmicity. We reared the pea aphid Acyrthosiphon pisum (Harris) on an artificial diet, and recorded survival, moulting, and honeydew excretion. Despite their plant-dependent life style, aphids were independently rhythmic under light-dark conditions. This first demonstration of diurnal aphid rhythms shows that aphids do not simply track the host plant's rhythmicity

A damping circadian clock drives weak oscillations in metabolism and locomotor activity of aphids (Acyrthosiphon pisum)

Timing seasonal events, like reproduction or diapause, is crucial for the survival of many species. Global change causes phenologies worldwide to shift, which requires a mechanistic explanation of seasonal time measurement. Day length (photoperiod) is a reliable indicator of winter arrival, but it remains unclear how exactly species measure day length. A reference for time of day could be provided by a circadian clock, by an hourglass clock, or, as some newer models suggest, by a damped circadian clock. However, damping of clock outputs has so far been rarely observed. To study putative clock outputs of Acyrthosiphon pisum aphids, we raised individual nymphs on coloured artificial diet, and measured rhythms in metabolic activity in light-dark illumination cycles of 16: 08 hours (LD) and constant conditions (DD). In addition, we kept individuals in a novel monitoring setup and measured locomotor activity. We found that A. pisum is day-active in LD, potentially with a bimodal distribution. In constant darkness rhythmicity of locomotor behaviour persisted in some individuals, but patterns were mostly complex with several predominant periods. Metabolic activity, on the other hand, damped quickly. A damped circadian clock, potentially driven by multiple oscillator populations, is the most likely explanation of our results

Creating ecologically sound buildings by integrating ecology, architecture and computational design

1. Research is revealing an increasing number of positive effects of nature for humans. At the same time, biodiversity in cities, where most humans live, is often low or in decline. Tangible solutions are needed to increase urban biodiversity. 2. Architecture is a key discipline that has considerable influence on the built-up area of cities, thereby influencing urban biodiversity. In general, architects do not design for biodiversity. Conversely, urban conservation planning generally focuses on the limited space free of buildings and does not embrace architecture as an important discipline for the creation of urban green infrastructure. 3. In this paper, we argue that the promotion of biodiversity needs to become a key driving force of architectural design. This requires a new multi-species design paradigm that considers both human and non-human needs. Such a design approach needs to maintain the standards of the architectural profession, including the aim to increase the well-being of humans in buildings. Yet, it also needs to add other stakeholders, organisms such as animals, plants and even microbiota. New buildings designed for humans and other inhabitants can then increase biodiversity in cities and also increase the benefits that humans can derive from close proximity to nature. 4. We review the challenges that this new design approach poses for both architecture and ecology and show that multi-species-design goes beyond existing approaches in architecture and ecology. The new design approach needs to make ecological knowledge available to the architectural design process, enabling practitioners to find architectural solutions that can facilitate synergies from a multi-species perspective. 5. We propose that a first step in creating such a multi-species habitat is the design of buildings with an ecolope, a multi criteria-designed building envelope that takes into account the needs of diverse organisms. Because there is no framework to design such an ecolope, we illustrate how multi-species design needs to draw on knowledge from ecology, as well as architecture, and design computation. 6. We discuss how architectures designed via a multi-species approach can be an important step in establishing beneficial human-nature relationships in cities, and contribute to human well-being and biodiversity conservation.Read the free Plain Language Summary for this article on the Journal blog

Wird die Phänologie der Erbsenblattlaus (AcyrthosiphonAcyrthosiphon pisumpisum) durch Tag-/Nachtrhythmik limitiert?

The rotation of the earth leads to a cyclic change of night and day. Numerous strategies evolved to cope with diurnal change, as it is generally advantageous to be synchronous to the cyclic change in abiotic conditions. Diurnal rhythms are regulated by the circadian clock, a molecular feedback loop of RNA and protein levels with a period of circa 24 hours. Despite its importance for individuals as well as for species interactions, our knowledge of circadian clocks is mostly confined to few model organisms. While the structuring of activity is generally adaptive, a rigid temporal organization also has its drawbacks. For example, the specialization to a diurnal pattern limits the breadth of the temporal niche. Organisms that are adapted to a diurnal life style are often poor predators or foragers during night time, constraining the time budget to only diurnal parts of the day/night cycle. Climate change causes shifts in phenology (seasonal timing) and northward range expansions, and changes in season or in latitude are associated with novel day length – temperature correlations. Thus, seasonal organisms will have some life history stages exposed to novel day lengths, and I hypothesized that the diurnal niche determines whether the day length changes are beneficial or harmful for the organism. I thus studied the effects of day length on life-history traits in a multi-trophic system consisting of the pea aphid Acyrthosiphon pisum and predatory larvae of Chrysoperla carnea (common green lacewing) and Episyrphus balteatus (marmalade hoverfly). In order to identify the mechanisms for phenological constraints I then focused on diurnal rhythms and the circadian clock of the pea aphid. Aphids reacted to shorter days with a reduced fecundity and shorter reproductive period. Short days did however not impact population growth, because the fitness constraints only became apparent late in the individual’s life. In contrast, E. balteatus grew 13% faster in the shorter day treatment and preyed on significantly more aphids, whereas C. carnea grew 13% faster under longer days and the elevation of predation rates was marginally significant. These results show that day length affects vital life-history traits, but that the direction and effect size depends on species. I hypothesized that the constraints or fitness benefits are caused by a constricted or expanded time budget, and hence depend on the temporal niche. E. balteatus is indeed night-active and C. carnea appears to be crepuscular, but very little data exists for A. pisum. Hence, I reared the pea aphid on an artificial diet and recorded survival, moulting and honeydew excretion. The activity patterns were clearly rhythmic and molting and honeydew excretion were elevated during day-time. Thus, the diurnal niche could explain the observed, but weak, day length constraints of aphids. The diurnal niche of some organisms is remarkably flexible, and a flexible diurnal niche may explain why the day length constrains were relatively low in A. pisum. I thus studied its circadian clock, the mechanism that regulates diurnal rhythms. First, I improved an artificial diet for A. pisum, and added the food colorant Brilliant Blue FCF. This food colorant stained gut and honeydew in low concentration without causing mortalities, and thus made honeydew excretion visible under dim red light. I then used the blue diet to raise individual aphids in 16:08 LD and constant darkness (DD), and recorded honeydew excretion and molting under red light every three hours. In addition, we used a novel monitoring setup to track locomotor activity continuously in LD and DD. Both the locomotor rhythm and honeydew excretion of A. pisum appeared to be bimodal, peaking in early morning and in the afternoon in LD. Both metabolic and locomotor rhythm persisted also for some time under constant darkness, indicating that the rhythms are driven by a functional circadian clock. However, the metabolic rhythm damped within three to four days, whereas locomotor rhythmicity persisted with a complex distribution of several free-running periods. These results fit to a damped circadian clock that is driven by multiple oscillator populations, a model that has been proposed to link circadian clocks and photoperiodism, but never empirically tested. Overall, my studies integrate constraints in phenological adaptation with a mechanistic explanation. I showed that a shorter day length can constrain some species of a trophic network while being beneficial for others, and linked the differences to the diurnal niche of the species. I further demonstrated that a flexible circadian clock may alleviate the constraints, potentially by increasing the plasticity of the diurnal niche.Die Rotation der Erde bedingt den zyklischen Wechsel von Tag und Nacht. Verschiedene Anpassungen an den täglichen Wechsel evolvierten, da es generell von Vorteil ist, mit der abiotischen Umwelt synchron zu sein. Die Tagesrhythmik wird von der circadianen Uhr reguliert, einem molekularen Rückkopplungsmechanismus auf RNA- und Protein- Ebene mit einer Periode von etwa 24 Stunden. Trotz der Bedeutung der circadianen Uhr, sowohl für Individuen als auch für Wechselwirkungen mit anderen Arten, ist unser Wissen auf wenige Modellorganismen beschränkt. Während die Strukturierung von Aktivitätsmustern im Wesentlichen adaptiv ist, kann eine strenge zeitliche Organisation auch Nachteile mit sich bringen. Zum Beispiel limitiert die Spezialisierung auf ein Aktivitätsmuster die Breite der zeitlichen Nische. So können tagaktive Organismen häufig nur schlecht in Dunkelheit Nahrung finden, so dass das Zeitbudget von der Tageszeit begrenzt wird. Der Klimawandel führt zu Veränderungen der Phänologie (saisonales Timing) und zur Ausbreitung der Arten Richtung Norden, und Veränderungen in der Phänologie oder im Breitengrad sind mit neuen Korrelationen von Tageslänge und Temperatur verknüpft. Daher werden einige Stadien im Lebenszyklus saisonaler Organismen neuen Tageslängen ausgesetzt. Ich habe die Hypothese aufgestellt, dass die zeitliche Nische bestimmt, ob Veränderungen in der Tageslänge für den Organismus von Vorteil oder von Nachteil sind. Daher untersuchte ich die Effekte von Tageslängen auf den Lebenszyklus von Arten in einem multi-trophischen System, bestehend aus der Erbsenblattlaus, Acyrthosiphon pisum und räuberisch lebenden Larven von Chrysoperla carnea (Gemeine Florfliege) und Episyrphus balteatus (Hainschwebfliege). Um die Mechanismen der Einschränkungen in der Phänologie zu verstehen, untersuchte ich anschließend die Tagesrhythmik und die circadiane Uhr der Erbsenblattlaus. Die Blattläuse haben auf Kurztagbedingungen mit einer niedrigeren Fruchtbarkeit und kürzerer Reproduktionsspanne reagiert. Kurze Tage haben jedoch nicht das Populationswachstum beeinflusst, da die Leistungseinbußen erst spät im Leben des Individuums in Erscheinung traten. Im Gegensatz zur Erbsenblattlaus entwickelte sich E. balteatus 13 % schneller unter Kurztagbedingungen und erbeutete signifikant mehr Blattläuse, während C. carnea sich 13% schneller unter Langtagbedingungen entwickelte und marginal höhere Prädationsraten erreichte. Diese Ergebnisse verdeutlichen, dass die Tageslänge wichtige Aspekte der Biologie von Organismen beeinflusst, aber dass die Richtung und Bedeutung von Art zu Art unterschiedlich ist. Ich nahm an, dass die Einschränkungen oder Vorteile durch ein verkleinertes oder vergrößertes Zeitbudget bestimmt werden und daher von der zeitlichen Nische abhängen. E. balteatus ist tatsächlich nachtaktiv, während C. carnea dämmerungsaktiv zu sein scheint. Für A. pisum existieren hingegen nur unzureichende Daten. Daher züchtete ich A. pisum auf künstlichem Futter und nahm Überlebensraten, Häutung und Honigtau-Exkretion auf. Die Aktivitätsmuster waren deutlich rhythmisch, und Häutung und Honigtau-Exkretion waren tagsüber erhöht. Daher kann die Einnischung auf Tagaktivität die beobachteten (aber schwachen) Nachteile kurzer Tage erklären. Die zeitliche Nische einiger Organismen ist überraschend flexibel, und eine flexible zeitliche Nische könnte erklären warum der Effekt der Tageslänge relativ niedrig in A. pisum war. Daher untersuchte ich die circadiane Uhr der Erbsenblattlaus, da dieser Mechanismus die Aktivitätsmuster reguliert. Zunächst verbesserte ich das künstliche Futter von A. pisum, und fügte den Lebensmittelfarbstoff Brilliant Blue FCF hinzu. Dieser Farbstoff färbte sowohl Magen als auch Honigtau in niedriger Konzentration ohne die Mortalität zu erhöhen, und machte dadurch die Exkretion von Honigtau unter schwachem Rotlicht sichtbar. Ich nutzte anschließend das blaue Futter, um Blattläuse einzeln in 16:08 LD und konstanter Dunkelheit (DD) aufzuziehen und dabei Honigtau-Exkretion und Häutungen alle drei Stunden zu notieren. Zusätzlichen nutzten wir ein neues Überwachungssystem um Aktivitätsmuster in Lokomotion kontinuierlich in LD und DD aufzuzeichnen. Sowohl Lokomotionsrhythmik als auch Honigtau-Exkretion von A. pisum schienen bimodal zu sein und erreichten früh morgens und nachmittags ihre Maximalwerte in LD. Beide Rhythmen bestanden auch unter konstanter Dunkelheit einige Zeit fort, was aufzeigt, dass die Rhythmen von einer funktionierenden inneren Uhr gesteuert werden. Die Rhythmik im Metabolismus dämpfte jedoch innerhalb von drei bis vier Tagen aus, während die Lokomotionsrhythmik mit einer komplexen Verteilung verschiedener free-running-Perioden fortbestand. Diese Ergebnisse passen zu einer gedämpften circadianen Uhr, die aus mehreren Oszillatorgruppen besteht. Ein solches Modell wurde vorgeschlagen, um circadiane Uhren mit Messungen der Photoperiode zu verknüpfen, aber nie empirisch überprüft. Insgesamt verbinden meine Versuche die Einschränkungen phänologischer Anpassung mit einer mechanistischen Erklärung. Ich zeigte, dass kürzere Tage einigen Arten eines trophischen Netzwerks Vorteile, anderen jedoch Nachteile verschafften, und habe diese Unterschiede auf die zeitliche Nische der Arten zurückgeführt. Ich habe weiterhin gezeigt, dass eine flexible circadiane Uhr die Nachteile lindern kann, möglicherweise weil sie die Plastizität der zeitlichen Nische erhöht

Supplemental materials for preprint: Transgenerational plasticity and bet-hedging: a framework for reaction norm evolution

S1: possible parameter space of r and f for different inflection points. Grey dots depict sample reaction norms across the range of possible parameters (darkness scales with inflection point). S2: Optimal reaction norm shapes for various growth rate functions and different levels of environmental predictability. Environments are normally distributed around a cue c with a mean of 9 h, all other parameters, coloring and line styles are the same as Fig. 4. S3: Python code that was used to generate the figures in the manuscrip

Diapause and bet‐hedging strategies in insects : a meta‐analysis of reaction norm shapes

Many organisms escape from lethal climatological conditions by entering a resistant resting stage called diapause, which needs to be optimally timed with seasonal change. As climate change exerts selection pressure on phenology, the evolution of mean diapause timing, but also of phenotypic plasticity and bet-hedging strategies is expected. The potential of the latter strategy as a means of coping with environmental unpredictability has received little attention in the climate change literature. Populations should be adapted to spatial variation in local conditions; contemporary patterns of phenological strategies across a geographic range may hence provide information about their evolvability. We thus extracted 458 diapause reaction norms from 60 studies. First, we correlated mean diapause timing with mean winter onset. Then we partitioned the reaction norm variance into a temporal component (phenotypic plasticity) and among-offspring variance (diversified bet-hedging) and correlated this variance composition with variability of winter onset. Mean diapause timing correlated reasonably well with mean winter onset, except for populations at high latitudes, which apparently failed to track early onsets. Variance among offspring was, however, limited and correlated only weakly with environmental variability, indicating little scope for bet-hedging. The apparent lack of phenological bet-hedging strategies may pose a risk in a less predictable climate, but we also highlight the need for more data on alternative strategies