369 research outputs found
Wittgenstein, Modern Music, and the Myth of Progress
Georg Henrik von Wright was not only the first interpreter of Wittgenstein, who argued that Spenglerâs work had reinforced and helped Wittgenstein to articulate his view of life, but also the first to consider seriously that Wittgensteinâs attitude to his times makes him unique among the great philosophers, that the philosophical problems which Wittgenstein was struggling, indeed his view of the nature of philosophy, were somehow connected with features of our culture or civilization.
In this paper I draw inspiration and courage from Von Wrightâs insistence that trying to understand Wittgenstein in relation to his times is a philosophic task in its own right in order to probe into a relatively obscure region in Wittgensteinâs thought: his relation to the music of his times. It is a topic, on which Von Wright, and most other prominent Wittgenstein scholars, have said very little, but it is also one, which Wittgenstein himself attested was so important to him that he felt without it he was sure to be misunderstood.
I offer textual and historical evidence in support of my claim that, parallel to Wittgensteinâs exposure to Spenglerâs Decline of the West in 1930, he was also introduced to the music theory of Heinrich Schenker, which helped him to articulate, partly by way of critique, a complex and unique position concerning the modern music of his times, which exhibits his rejection of what Von Wright later dubbed âthe myth of progressâ. As Von Wright observed in other regions of Wittgensteinâs work, he believed also with regards to the arts and to music in particular, neither in a brilliant future nor in the good old days.
I argue that Wittgenstein actually made a distinction between three kinds of modern music: (a) bad modern music, which is clearly a case of confusing means for ends, the hallmark of the myth of progress, as Von Wright observed; (b) vacuous modern music, which embodies some sort of diffidence, a difficulty to see through the omnipresence of what Von Wright called (following Habermas) a âcolonializationâ of reified measures of progress; (c) good modern music, a paradoxical notion for Wittgenstein, which betokens the unlikely yet possible striving to penetrate through what appears as dissolution of the resemblances which unite this cultureâs ways of life by rendering this condition as expressible and intransitively understandable. In the context of this third category, I offer an interpretation of Wittgensteinâs complex remarks on the music of Gustav Mahler, which palpably show that the problem of good modern music and the problem of philosophizing in the time of civilization were one and the same in Wittgensteinâs mind.
I conclude that, with regards to Von Wrightâs own critical view of the modern myth of progress, we can learn from Wittgenstein that progress in the realm of art is closely aligned with the ideal of the perfection of man, yet transcending a social or political context. It is the ideal of cultural cohesion: affinity that the arts show to other human practices and cultural artifacts of its period. Wittgensteinâs tentative notion of good modern music (and its circumscription by his notion of the music of the future) may show its true colors when viewed in the context of Von Wrightâs plea not to abandon work for progress as a critical task
Toward an Aesthetics of New-Media Environments
In this paper I suggest that, over and above the need to explore and understand the technological newness of computer art works, there is a need to address the aesthetic signiïŹcance of the changes and effects that such technological newness brings about, considering the whole environmental transaction pertaining to new media, including what they can or do offer and what users do or can do with such offerings, and how this whole package is integrated into our living spaces and activities. I argue that, given the primacy of computer-based interaction in the new-media, the notion of âornamentalityâ indicates the ground-ïŹoor aesthetics of new-media environments. I locate ornamentality not only in the logically constitutive principles of the new-media (hypertextuality and interactivity) but also in their multiform cultural embodiments (decoration as cultural interface). I utilize Kendall Waltonâs theory of ornamentality in order to construe a puzzle pertaining to the ornamental erosion of information in new-media environments. I argue that insofar as we consider new-media to be conduits of âreal-lifeâ, the excessive density of ornamental devices prevalent in certain new-media environments forces us to conduct our inquiries under conditions of neustic uncertainty, that is, uncertainty concerning the kind of relationship that we, the users, have to the propositional content mediated. I conclude that this puzzle calls our attention to a peculiar interrogatory complexity inherent in any game of knowledge-seeking conducted across the infosphere, which is not restricted to the simplest form of data retrieval, especially in mixed-reality environments and when the knowledge sought is embodied mimetically
âA small, shabby crystal, yet a crystalâ: A life of music in Wittgensteinâs Denkbewegungen
Ludwig Wittgenstein's life and writings attest the extraordinary importance that the art of music had for him. It would be fair to say even that among the great philosophers of the twentieth century he was one of the most musically sensitive. Wittgensteinâs Denkbewegungen contains some of his most unique remarks on music, which bear witness not only to the level of his engagement in thinking about music, but also to the intimate connection in his mind between musical acculturation, the perils of modernity, and the challenge, which was very personal to Wittgenstein, of philosophizing amidst what he believed was a dissolution of the resemblances which unite his cultureâs ways of life. In particular, Denkbewegungen contains unique remarks on modern music, the problem of Gustav Mahlerâs music, and the music of the future. Also, it contains, among other things, some unusually forward-looking remarks on the differences between Brahms and Bruckner, which both probe deeply into the nature of musical creativity and anticipate his later philosophical move beyond the inner/outer divide in his last writings. I shall offer a close reading of Wittgensteinâs remarks on music in Denkbewegungen, which situates them in the broader context of his philosophical development in his middle-period and beyond. I aim to show the deep integration of Wittgensteinâs thinking about music with his philosophical development, his deep sense of cultural lamentation, and his development as a person and as a philosophical expositor
The Philosophical Significance of Wittgensteinâs Experiments on Rhythm, Cambridge 1912â13
Wittgensteinâs experiments on rhythm, conducted in Charles Myersâs laboratory in Cambridge during the years 1912â13, are his earliest recorded engagement in thinking about music, not just appreciating it, and philosophizing by means of musical thinking. In this essay, I set these experiments within their appropriate intellectual, scientific, and philosophical context in order to show that, its minor scientific importance notwithstanding, this onetime excursion into empirical research provided an early onset for Wittgensteinâs career-long exploration of the philosophically pervasive implications of aspects. Dramatically moving beyond the conceptual limitations, which were inscribed by Charles Myersâs scientific program, Wittgenstein got a glimpse of a philosophical angle, which was bound to become very important to him not only in aesthetics, but also for his overarching philosophical development. He became interested in what we actually do when we re-phrase, compare, come up with good similes in order to illuminate something definite within the space of possibility, so a new aspect may come to life
Impurely Musical Make-Believe
In this study we offer a new way of applying Kendall Waltonâs theory of make-believe to musical experiences in terms of psychologically inhibited games of make-believe, which Walton attributes chiefly to ornamental representations. Reading Waltonâs theory somewhat against the grain, and supplementing our discussion with a set of instructive examples, we argue that there is clear theoretical gain in explaining certain important aspects of composition and performance in terms of psychologically inhibited games of make-believe consisting of two interlaced game-worlds. Such complex games can accommodate a continuous rich spectrum of congruent modes of listening, which broaches both the formalist-type and the narrativist-type. We conclude that this sort of oblique reading of Waltonâs original theory actually complements and completes Waltonâs recent theoretic angle concerning thoughtwriting in music by way of affording it with a suitable conception for a mechanism of appropriation for music
Recommended from our members
Resources allocated to tackling the tax gap: a comparative EU study
Since the onset of the global financial crisis in 2008 and the development of austerity as a widespread economic strategy there has been continuing focus on the tax gap as an issue, which is the difference between the amount of tax that should, theoretically, be collected by a tax authority within the prevailing system that a tax jurisdiction has legislated for and the actual amount of tax collected. The efficiency, or otherwise, of a tax authority in tackling the tax gap has come to be seen as a measure of its effectiveness in raising revenue, whether to balance budgets or fund additional government spending. Despite this, relatively little formal attention has been given to technical dimensions of the tax gap, or to the link between that tax gap and tax authority spending. We have sought to address these last issues. In the process we have appraised the quality of the data available for this process, including whether available GDP data is reliable as a basis for estimation; whether data on tax collected is comparable and whether available data on tax authority spending is appropriate for this purpose. Data on estimates of the shadow economy have also been appraised as a consequence. Whilst it has proved possible to prepare new estimates of the tax gap for EU member states limitations in the resulting estimates are highlighted. In addition, weaknesses in all other data sources are noted, and their suitability is questioned. The resulting analysis of tax authority expenditure and its relationship to the tax gap is, consequently, heavily constrained, but in any event no apparent statistical association is noted. It is suggested that other approaches to the 2 management of the tax, and the effectiveness of tax authorities, are required, with a recommendation that tax spillover assessments be considered as an alternative
A surrogate for the soul: Wittgenstein and Schoenberg
This article challenges a widespread assumption, arguing that Wittgenstein and the Austrian composer Arnold Schoenberg had little in common beyond their shared cultural heritage, overlapping social circles in fin-de-ciecle Vienna. The article explores Wittgenstein's aesthetic inclinations and the intellectual and philosophical influences that may have reinforced them. The article culminates in an attempt to form a Wittgensteinian response to Schoenberg's dodecaphonic language and to answer the question as to why Wittgenstein and Schoenberg arrived at very different ideas about contemporary music and the music of the future
Layer-by-layer nanoparticles for glaucoma therapy
Glaucoma, a sever neurodegenerative ocular disease, is one of the leading causes of blindness worldwide. An increased intraocular pressure (IOP) is regarded as its main risk factor. The IOP is generated in the anterior eye due to a resistance to the outflow of the aqueous humor through the trabecular outflow pathway. Recently, connective tissue growth factor (CTGF) was identified to increase the resistance to aqueous humor outflow by enhancing the extracellular matrix deposition and contractility of cells in the trabecular meshwork (TM). Post transcriptional gene silencing using small interfering RNA (siRNA) is an elegant strategy to reduce elevated levels of CTGF and consequently IOP. Nevertheless, delivering nucleic acids of this type remains a challenge. This work describes the development of hyaluronic acid functionalized layer-by-layer nanoparticles for the delivery of siRNA to the TM
Measure for Measure: Wittgenstein's Critique of the Augustinian Picture of Music
This article concerns the distinction between memory-time and information-time, which appeared in Wittgensteinâs middle-period lectures and writings, and its relation to Wittgensteinâs career-long reflection about musical understanding. While the idea of âinformation-timeâ entails a public frame of reference typically pertaining to objects which persist in physical time, the idea of pure âmemory-timeâ involves the totality of oneâs present memories and expectations that do now provide any way of measuring time-spans. I argue that Wittgensteinâs critique of Augustine notion of pure memory-time entails ipso facto a critique of an influential idea of musical motion, which has been recurring in the work of some major philosophers of music up until the present day. The article connects Wittgensteinâs critical remarks on the confused foundations of such âAugustinian Picture of Musicâ with his emphasis on the notion of phrasing or characterization in language and music. Wittgensteinâs reversal of Augustinian priorities regarding musical time brings to surface the particularity of expression and the aesthetically ârightâ in music, evoked by Wittgensteinâs remarks on simultaneity and tempo in music and language. Wittgenstein renders musical simultaneity as enabled by a âprotocolâ which inheres in musizieren, in the aptly collaborative quest for drawing in significance by means of the phrasing and re-phrasing of a passage in order to characterize it, enabling by means of such comparative investigation meaningful distinctions between right and wrong
Development of design criteria for an electrochemical water reclamation system
Electrochemical system design to recover water from human urin
- âŠ