Developing metrics for nursing quality of care for low- and middle-income countries: a scoping review linked to stakeholder engagement.

BACKGROUND:The use of appropriate and relevant nurse-sensitive indicators provides an opportunity to demonstrate the unique contributions of nurses to patient outcomes. The aim of this work was to develop relevant metrics to assess the quality of nursing care in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs) where they are scarce. MAIN BODY:We conducted a scoping review using EMBASE, CINAHL and MEDLINE databases of studies published in English focused on quality nursing care and with identified measurement methods. Indicators identified were reviewed by a diverse panel of nursing stakeholders in Kenya to develop a contextually appropriate set of nurse-sensitive indicators for Kenyan hospitals specific to the five major inpatient disciplines. We extracted data on study characteristics, nursing indicators reported, location and the tools used. A total of 23 articles quantifying the quality of nursing care services met the inclusion criteria. All studies identified were from high-income countries. Pooled together, 159 indicators were reported in the reviewed studies with 25 identified as the most commonly reported. Through the stakeholder consultative process, 52 nurse-sensitive indicators were recommended for Kenyan hospitals. CONCLUSIONS:Although nurse-sensitive indicators are increasingly used in high-income countries to improve quality of care, there is a wide heterogeneity in the way indicators are defined and interpreted. Whilst some indicators were regarded as useful by a Kenyan expert panel, contextual differences prompted them to recommend additional new indicators to improve the evaluations of nursing care provision in Kenyan hospitals and potentially similar LMIC settings. Taken forward through implementation, refinement and adaptation, the proposed indicators could be more standardised and may provide a common base to establish national or regional professional learning networks with the common goal of achieving high-quality care through quality improvement and learning

Professional identity transitions, violations and reconciliations among new nurses in low- and middle-income countries

We examine how new nurses construct their professional identity in Low- and Middle-Income Countries (LMICs) when they enter clinical practice and encounter practical norms violating procedural standards. We conducted interviews and focus group discussions with 47 Kenyan nurses. We describe new nurses experiencing ‘shock’ entering nursing practice (working and learning alone while responsible for many patients and doing ‘dirty work’), which contrasted with their idealized image and expectations of nursing and prior training. We explain this transition using theory about identity and identity work, which we argue elucidates nurses' experiences in LMICs. We suggest that nurses' transition into clinical practice violated pre-existing expectations for their professional identities, which then triggered identity work of ‘toughening up’, ‘maturing through experience’, and ‘learning practical norms’. Through this identity work, and finally experiencing satisfaction from caring for and nursing patients back to health, some nurses were able to restore their valued professional identity

Quality of comprehensive emergency obstetric care through the lens of clinical documentation on admission to labour ward

Background: Clinical documentation gives a chronological order of procedures and activities that a patient is given during their management.Objective: To determine the level of quality of comprehensive emergency obstetric care, through the lens of clinical documentation of process indicators of selected emergency obstetric conditions that mostly cause maternal mortality on admission to labour wardDesign: Multi-site cross sectional survey.Setting: Twenty two Government Hospitals in Kenya with capacity to offer comprehensive emergency obstetric care.Subjects: Process variables were abstracted from patient’ case records with a diagnosis of normal vaginal delivery, obstetric haemorrhage, severe pre eclampsia/eclampsia and emergency cesarean section.Results: Availability of structure indicators were graded excellent and good except for long gloves, misoprostol, ergometrin and parenteral cefuroxime that were graded low. A total of 1,216 records were abstracted for process analysis. The median (IQR) for the: six variables of obstetric history was five (4-5); five variables of antenatal profile was four (1-5); five variables of vital signs documentation was three (2-4); five variables for obstetric exam was four (4-5); seven variables of vaginal examination one (0-2); ten variables for partograph was seven (2-9); five variables for obstetric hemorrhage was three (2-4) and eleven variables for severe pre-eclampsia/eclampsia was five (3-6). The median (IQR) from decision-to-operate to caesarean section was three (2-4) hours.Conclusion: Quality of emergency obstetric care based on documentation depicts inadequacy. There is an urgent need to objectively address the need for proper clinical documentation as an indicator of quality performance

The Structured Operational Research and Training Initiative (SORT IT), second workshop using the national tuberculosis routinely collected program data

No Abstrac

Comparison of demographic and clinical characteristics between pulmonary and extra-pulmonary tuberculosis patients in Kiambu County, 2012-2015

Background: Tuberculosis (TB) continues to be a public health challenge globally. The most common organ to be involved is the lung although it can affect any organ in the body. The diagnosis of extra-pulmonary TB (EPTB) has faced many challenges mainly due to inadequate expertise to diagnose or lack of equipment for diagnosis.Objective: To compare the demographic and clinical characteristics between pulmonary and extrapulmonary tuberculosis in Kiambu CountyDesign: Retrospective cross-sectional studySetting: Kiambu County, KenyaSubjects: Tuberculosis patients notified in TIBU surveillance systemResults: Of the 15, 833 patients analyzed, 2,704 (17%) had extra-pulmonary tuberculosis. Male to female ratio was 1:1.7 in PTB and 1:1.3 in EPTB patients. There was declining trend of TB cases notified over the years for both PTB and EPTB. Pleural TB accounted for 38% with TB lymphadenitis accounting for 14% of the EPTB subtypes. TB-HIV co-infection was higher among EPTB (36%) compared to PTB (30%). The treatment success rate was 85% and 86% among PTB and EPTB cases respectively. The mortality was 10% among EPTB and 5% in PTB cases. The 5-14 age category were more likely to developing EPTB compared to PTB (AOR 4.67 95% CI (1.5-13.99). Kabete zone was most affected with EPTB (AOR 2.11(1.19-2.74) while a protective factor was observed among the HIV positive clients (AOR 0.58 (0.43 - 0.78)Conclusion: There was a general decline in cases for both EPTB and PTB. However, the age category most affected was 5-14 years. The co-infectivity rate was higher among the EPTB patients compared to the PTB patients. High index of suspicion and appropriate diagnostic tools are needed in evaluation particularly in EPTB which will assist in early management of the patients. ART uptake could play a big role in protecting HIV positive clients from getting EPTB

Lessons from a Health Policy and Systems Research programme exploring the quality and coverage of newborn care in Kenya.

There are global calls for research to support health system strengthening in low-income and middle-income countries (LMICs). To examine the nature and magnitude of gaps in access and quality of inpatient neonatal care provided to a largely poor urban population, we combined multiple epidemiological and health services methodologies. Conducting this work and generating findings was made possible through extensive formal and informal stakeholder engagement linked to flexibility in the research approach while keeping overall goals in mind. We learnt that 45% of sick newborns requiring hospital care in Nairobi probably do not access a suitable facility and that public hospitals provide 70% of care accessed with private sector care either poor quality or very expensive. Direct observations of care and ethnographic work show that critical nursing workforce shortages prevent delivery of high-quality care in high volume, low-cost facilities and likely threaten patient safety and nurses' well-being. In these challenging settings, routines and norms have evolved as collective coping strategies so health professionals maintain some sense of achievement in the face of impossible demands. Thus, the health system sustains a functional veneer that belies the stresses undermining quality, compassionate care. No one intervention will dramatically reduce neonatal mortality in this urban setting. In the short term, a substantial increase in the number of health workers, especially nurses, is required. This must be combined with longer term investment to address coverage gaps through redesign of services around functional tiers with improved information systems that support effective governance of public, private and not-for-profit sectors

Antenatal care and pregnancy outcomes in a safe motherhood health voucher system in rural Kenya, 2007-2013.

SETTING: A rural private health facility, Ruby Medical Centre (RMC), participating in a safe motherhood health voucher system for poor women in Kiambu County, Kenya. OBJECTIVES: Between 2007 and 2013, to determine 1) the number of women who delivered at the RMC, their characteristics and pregnancy-related outcomes, and 2) the number of women who received an incomplete antenatal care (ANC) package and associated factors. DESIGN: Retrospective cross-sectional study using routine programme data. RESULTS: During the study period, 2635 women delivered at the RMC: 50% were aged 16-24 years, 60% transferred in from other facilities and 59% started ANC in the third trimester of pregnancy. Of the 2635 women, 1793 (68%) received an incomplete ANC package: 347 (13%) missed essential blood tests, 312 (12%) missed the tetanus toxoid immunisation and 1672 (65%) had fewer than four visits. Presenting late and starting ANC elsewhere were associated with an incomplete package. One pregnancy-related mortality occurred; the stillbirth rate was 10 per 1000 births. CONCLUSION: This first assessment of the health voucher system in rural Kenya showed problems in ANC quality. Despite favourable pregnancy-related outcomes, increased efforts should be made to ensure earlier presentation of pregnant women, comprehensive ANC, and more consistent and accurate monitoring of reproductive indicators and interventions