6 research outputs found
Who teaches primary physical education? Change and transformation through the eyes of subject leaders
This is an Accepted Manuscript of an article published by Taylor & Francis in Sport, Education and Society on 02/07/2015, available online: DOI: http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/13573322.2015.1061987Primary physical education (PE) lessons tend to be taught by one, or a combination of, three different groups: generalist classroom teachers, specialist primary PE teachers and so-called âadults other than teachersâ, who are almost exclusively sports coaches. Drawing upon data gathered from one-to-one interviews with 36 subject leaders (SLs), this study sought answers to two main questions: âWho delivers primary PE nowadays?â and âWhat are the consequences?â The findings revealed that the most common model for the delivery of PE involved responsibility being shared between the generalist class teacher and either a sports coach or specialist PE teacher. The SLs recognised strengths and weaknesses in all of the three main approaches used. However, while they favoured the use of specialist teachers because of their subject knowledge and expertise, the more prosaic constraints of cost and flexibility meant that the use of coaches had become increasingly popular. Whether or not, the growth of coaches is de-professionalizing the delivery of PE, it certainly appears to be exacerbating any existing tendency to turn primary PE into a pale imitation of the sport-biased curricular of secondary schools. Ironically, the apparent âthreatâ to the status of PE in the primary curriculum (as well as the status of PE specialists) posed by the growth of coaches in curricular PE in primary schools may well be exaggerated by the Primary PE and Sport Premium which appears to have added momentum to a change of direction regarding staffing the subject â towards sports coaches and away from generalist classroom teachers and PE specialists. As the shift towards outsourcing PE to commercial sports coaches becomes increasingly commonplace it seems appropriate to talk of transformation, rather than mere change, in the delivery of primary PE
Emerging school sport development policy, practice and governance in England: Big Society, autonomy and decentralisation
International interest in developing mass sports participation through systems of school and community sports development has become a growing field of public leisure policy interest. This research paper considers the policy change from School Sport Partnerships to the new 2012 School Games model of networked partnerships to establish characteristics of the changes in governance modes and implications from practice in England. The research project is based on a regional case study drawing upon indepth,face-to-face interviews with key public policy stakeholders to inform an analysis of change. Initial findings indicate that the emergent networks are characterised by more networked-based mode of governance than previous hierarchical models present under UK New Labour. The study also shows the fragility of a reliance on partnership structures and the potential implications for incongruence in delivering policy outcomes and improving access to physical activity and school sport opportunities
Knowing primary physical education movement culture
A thesis submitted in partial fulfilment of the
requirements of the University of Wolverhampton for the
degree of Doctor of Philosophy by PublicationBackground: Mind-body dualisms create particular difficulties for researching and justifying learning and knowledge within PE practices. These issues are compounded in the UK by prevailing cognitivistic ideas of education, knowledge and learning. Crum (1993) suggests reconceptualising PE as movement culture as a potential solution to the limitations created by dualistic positions within education. How knowledge and learning within movement culture is positioned, however, was left underdeveloped by Crum. The aim of this thesis is to explore an embodied, action position on knowledge and learning, as a potential solution to this issue. Purpose: This thesis is driven by two purposes. The first; to examine and discuss how John Deweyâs theorising of knowledge and learning within experience provides a theoretical position on knowledge and learning within movement culture. The second; to utilise this position to explore how pupilsâ and teachersâ actions within primary PE lessons constitute and negotiate the movement cultures within their school. Findings: In adopting a position which dissolves mind-body dualisms, movement culture allows the practical work of PE lessons to be considered as contexts of knowledge production. This opens up our understanding of different ways of knowing in PE through pupilsâ epistemological âaction-in-PE-settingsâ. Rather than creating another hybrid of educational ideology by objectifying what to âdoâ or âknowâ, movement culture keeps the âwhoâ of participation in PE practice in view. Such a position is achieved because pupils are seen as âcoming to knowâ through their immediate and continuous experiences of sports and physical activities both in PE and beyond the school gates. By dissolving traditional dualisms within educational ideology, movement culture allows ideologies and assumptions about learning in PE to be decoded and managed. It also provides a framework to explore subject-matter for learning and analyses some of the disconnections which exist within PE practice. Conclusions: Reconceptualising PE as movement culture is not intended to create a logic of practice to which I claim PE should ascribe. In this thesis, movement culture offers a position from which to consider the continuity between PE and pupilsâ lives within and outside of the school gates. Such a standpoint can challenge our ideas as to what subject-matter could be within PE and the possibilities of learning outcomes other than those that focus on performance sport or bodily training for fitness. From a research perspective questions arise in relation to understanding very young pupilsâ experiences of knowing within PE and how learning and knowledge are embodied across other subject areas. Addressing such questions may help to support new understandings of learning and knowledge within schools that are concurrent with developing new methodologies and research tools. These may in turn support the continuing development of pedagogical practices
Recommended from our members
The construction and experience of ability in physical education
This thesis was submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy and awarded by Brunel University.This thesis explores how notions of ability are socially constructed, defined and experienced within physical education (PE). Pierre Bourdieuâs concepts are used to examine the processes through an acknowledgement and consideration of the culture where pupilsâ and teachersâ notions of ability are configured, reconfigured, and experienced. The study covered one academic school year in a North London mixed comprehensive school. Fifteen pupils participated in focus groups and individual interviews. The pupils were a mixture of boys (11) and girls (4), a range of abilities and ages (11 â 16 years old), and experienced PE predominantly in ability groups. In addition, six PE teachers were interviewed and PE lesson observations were conducted throughout the study. The findings identify various processes and interactions between individuals and also between individuals and the field that contribute towards the social construction of ability in PE. The findings highlight the complex and dynamic nature of the PE experience where notions of ability and the related practices have a bearing. Hierarchical ability-based practices were apparent that served to reinforce dominant notions of ability but there were other practices that could potentially challenge âlegitimateâ notions of ability. The study highlights some of the constraints that teachers face in their attempts to integrate broader notions of ability, especially within a performative culture. Variations across the individual experience highlight considerations for pupils in terms of becoming physically literate and reaching their potential. The study aims to raise key questions for stakeholders in considering how ability-based practices work in facilitating a learning environment that supports all levels of ability and preparing all young people for lifelong activity. In addition it stresses the need for greater agreement amongst stakeholders on the purpose of PE in the current climate and suggests that a review of the aims of PE is warranted
An analysis of the concept reflective practice and an investigation into the development of student teachersâ reflective practice within the context of action research
This thesis was submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy and awarded by Brunel University.In recent decades, reflective practice has become a key driver and an increasingly
influential referent in the professional development of student teachers. Yet, the complex,
somewhat elusive boundaries of reflective practice make this phenomenon difficult to
define. The purpose of this study was to analyse and synthesise existing literature and
research in order to better understand the multi-faceted nature of reflective practice. From
an informed platform, a new conceptual framework was designed both to capture and
investigate nine dimensions of reflective practice in which student teachers could
demonstrate capacity and commitment.
Eighty year 4 student teachers, who had undertaken action research projects during
their final school experience, and thirteen university lecturers, who had guided the student
teachers throughout this enterprise, were participants in this study. Data were gathered
through questionnaires and semi-structured interviews that incorporated a series of closed
and open-ended responses. Quantitative data were analysed to calculate statistical
frequencies, percentages, means and standard deviations; and, qualitative data via analytic
induction methods to identify common themes and to extract narratives of experience.
Findings showed that a majority (>90%) of student teachers perceived their capacity
and commitment to engage in six dimensions of reflective practice [and most (>80%) in
eight] had influenced their professional development. These perceptions were not wholly
congruent with those of dissertation supervisors with variance between supervisors also
evident. Qualitative distinctions, in the use of three types of reflective conversation, were
found between male and female student teachers and within each gender group. Several
constraints in the development of student teachersâ reflective practice also emerged.
Further research is recommended into: what evidence and criteria shape judgments
about reflective practice; how school-based staff might effectively support student teachersâ
development of reflective practice; and, how the framework designed for this study might
be replicated and refined to enhance reflective practice in personal professional
development across disciplines