The Good of Play in John Finnis’s «Natural Law and Natural Rights»

Despite the scrutiny that has been given to John Finnis’s masterwork, Natural Law and Natural Rights, relatively little attention has been given to a feature of that work that plays a recurring role, namely, the place of the basic human good of play in the book. In addition to a number of passing references, that good is discussed in an extended way on three occasions. The first is when the good of play is introduced, as part of Finnis’s taxonomy of basic human goods; the second is in his discussion of Aristotle’s understanding of friendship, when Finnis reframes Aristotle’s friendship of pleasure as instead friendship of play; and then finally, in Finnis’s concluding chapter, with its discussion of the «further point» of morality, where Finnis, following Plato, describes the point of morality as participation in a divine play. Play’s presence at the end of Natural Law and Natural Rights, indeed, in one of the culminating passages of the book, suggests that this good should be paid more attention than has been given to it. After a review of Finnis’s various discussions of play, I argue that Finnis’s account provides resources for answering Thomas Nagel’s skeptical doubts about life’s meaning; and for furthering Finnis’s own claims about the authority of law.A pesar del análisis a que se ha visto sometida la obra maestra de Finnis, Natural Law and Natural Rights, se le ha prestado relativamente poca atención a un rasgo de la misma: el recurrentemente citado bien humano del juego y el lugar que su estudio ocupa en dicho libro. La primera referencia aparece con ocasión de la presentación de dicho bien como parte de la taxonomía de bienes humanos básicos finnisianos. La segunda, figura de la mano de un análisis sobre la amistad aristotélica, en el que Finnis reformula dicha noción, originalmente entendida como relación de placer, en términos de relación de participación en un juego. Finalmente, en el último capítulo, Finnis, se refiere al juego, siguiendo a Platón, cuando sostiene que la referencia adicional de la moralidad queda descrita como participación en una obra divina. La presencia del juego al final de Natural Law and Natural Rights, de hecho, en uno de los pasajes culminantes del libro, sugiere que a este bien se le debe prestar más atención de la que se le ha venido dispensado. Después de revisar las diversas discusiones de Finnis sobre el juego, sostengo que su relato ofrece recursos para responder a las dudas escépticas de Thomas Nagel sobre el sentido de la vida y para ofrecer un mayor recorrido a las afirmaciones de Finnis acerca de la autoridad del derecho

Religious perspectives on human suffering: Implications for medicine and bioethics

The prevention and relief of suffering has long been a core medical concern. But while this is a laudable goal, some question whether medicine can, or should, aim for a world without pain, sadness, anxiety, despair or uncertainty. To explore these issues, we invited experts from six of the world’s major faith traditions to address the following question. Is there value in suffering? And is something lost in the prevention and/or relief of suffering? While each of the perspectives provided maintains that suffering should be alleviated and that medicine’s proper role is to prevent and relieve suffering by ethical means, it is also apparent that questions regarding the meaning and value of suffering are beyond the realm of medicine. These perspectives suggest that medicine and bioethics has much to gain from respectful consideration of religious discourse surrounding suffering. Keywords Suffering; religion; medicine; bioethic

A review of quantitative structure-activity relationship modelling approaches to predict the toxicity of mixtures

Exposure to chemicals generally occurs in the form of mixtures. However, the great majority of the toxicity data, upon which chemical safety decisions are based, relate only to single compounds. It is currently unfeasible to test a fully representative proportion of mixtures for potential harmful effects and, as such, in silico modelling provides a practical solution to inform safety assessment. Traditional methodologies for deriving estimations of mixture effects, exemplified by principles such as concentration addition (CA) and independent action (IA), are limited as regards the scope of chemical combinations to which they can reliably be applied. Development of appropriate quantitative structure-activity relationships (QSARs) has been put forward as a solution to the shortcomings present within these techniques – allowing for the potential formulation of versatile predictive tools capable of capturing the activities of a full contingent of possible mixtures. This review addresses the current state-of-the-art as regards application of QSAR towards mixture toxicity, discussing the challenges inherent in the task, whilst considering the strengths and limitations of existing approaches. Forty studies are examined within – through reference to several characteristic elements including the nature of the chemicals and endpoints modelled, the form of descriptors adopted, and the principles behind the statistical techniques employed. Recommendations are in turn provided for practices which may assist in further advancing the field, most notably with regards to ensuring confidence in the acquired predictions.publishedVersio

Some results of a radon survey in 207 Serbian schools

In this paper the results of radon concentration measurements performed in 207 schools in 7 communities of Southern Serbia are presented. The annual radon concentration varied from 17 Bqm-3 to 428 Bq m-3 with a median value of 96 Bq m-3. The arithmetic mean (AM) of the 207 annual averages was 118 Bq m-3 with a standard deviation (SD) of 78 Bq m-3. The best distribution fitting of radon concentration by log-normal function was obtained. The log-normal parameters are the following: geometric mean (GM) = Bq m-3, geometric standard deviation (GSD) = 1.9. In addition, a spatial distribution of the indoor radon concentration over the investigated areas is observed.JRC.E.8-Nuclear securit

Deaths due to differentiated thyroid cancer: A 46-year perspective

From 1940 to 1986, a total of 798 patients were treated for differentiated thyroid carcinoma. One hundred and seventy-two patients died during the follow-up period: 42 (24.4%) patients from thyroid cancer, 14 (8.1%) from other causes with extensive thyroid cancer present, 75 (43.6%) with no thyroid cancer, and 41 (23.8%) with an unknown status of thyroid cancer . Of the 42 patients dying due to thyroid cancer, 15 were male and 27, female. Mean age at diagnosis was 48.3±17.7 years with one-third of patients age 45 or younger at the time of the initial diagnosis. The primary tumors were large (>4 cm) and 59.5% of the patients had local invasion and/or cervical metastasis. Distant metastases were present in 9 (21.4%) patients at the time of diagnosis . Surgical therapy included total thyroidectomy (72.1%) and limited or radical neck dissection (69.4%). Radioactive iodine ( 131 I) was used to treat residual cancer and/or distant metastasis in 73.8% of the patients. External radiation therapy was used to treat locally advanced or recurrent disease in 52.3% of the patients. Distant metastases and local recurrence were identified earlier in patients with follicular thyroid cancer whose survival time and disease-free interval were significantly shorter ( p < 0.001) than that of patients with papillary neoplasms. However, the survival and disease-free intervals were often very long in both papillary and follicular thyroid cancer deaths . Onset of differentiated thyroid cancer before the age of 40 years does not preclude serious sequelae and death. Since no known histopathologic features can consistently predict outcome, we continue to advocate aggressive treatment of all patients with differentiated thyroid cancer . Entre 1940 et 1986, 798 patients au total ont été traités pour un cancer différencié de la thyroïde. Cent-soixant-douze patients sont morts par la suite: 42 (24.4%) de leur cancer, 14 (8.1%) d'une autre cause alors que des signes d'extension du cancer étaient présents, 75 (43.6%) d'une autre cause sans signe de cancer, et 41 (23.8%) sans qu'on ait pu connaître le stade du cancer. Des 42 patients morts de leur cancer, il y avait 15 hommes et 27 femmes. L'âge moyen au moment du diagnostic était de 48.3±17.7 ans: un tiers des patients avait 45 ans ou moins au moment du diagnostic. Les tumeurs primitives avaient plus de 4 cm et 59.5% des patients présentaient un envahissement local et/ou une métastase cervicale. Les métastases à distance ont été détectées chez 9 (21.4%) patients au moment du diagnostic. Une thyroïdectomie totale a été effectuée chez 72.1% des patients, associée à un curage cervical limité ou radical chez 69.4% des patients. Chez 73.8% des patients on a traité le tissu cancéreux résiduel et/ou des métastases à distance par de l'I 131. La radiothérapie a été utilisée pour traiter les patients présentant une extension importante ou une récidive chez 52.3% des patients. Des métastases à distance et des récidives ont été identifiées précocement chez les patients ayant un cancer folliculaire. Dans ce groupe de patients, la survie et l'intervalle de temps sans maladie étaient significativement plus courts ( p <0.001) que chez les patients ayant un cancer papillaire. Il faut cependant noter que la survie et l'intervalle de temps sans maladie étaient très longs dans les 2 groupes de patients. La découverte d'un cancer différencié de la thyroïde avant l'âge de 40 ans n'est pas un facteur pronostique particulier. Puisqu'il n'y pas de facteur histologique permettant de prévoir l'évolution, nous continuons de préconiser un traitement agressif chez tout patient présentant un cancer différencié de la thyroïde. En el período 1940–1986, un total de 798 pacientes recibieron tratamiento para carcinoma tiroideo; 172 murieron en el curso del seguimiento: 42 (24.4%) por cancer tiroideo, 14 (8.1%) por otras causas pero con presencia de extenso cáncer tiroideo, 75 (43.6%) libres de cáncer tiroideo, y 41 (23.8%) con estado desconocido en cuanto al cancer tiroideo.Peer Reviewedhttp://deepblue.lib.umich.edu/bitstream/2027.42/41283/1/268_2005_Article_BF01655866.pd

Interacting mindreaders

Could interacting mindreaders be in a position to know things which they would be unable to know if they were manifestly passive observers? This paper argues that they could. Mindreading is sometimes reciprocal: the mindreader's target reciprocates by taking the mindreader as a target for mindreading. The paper explains how such reciprocity can significantly narrow the range of possible interpretations of behaviour where mindreaders are, or appear to be, in a position to interact. A consequence is that revisions and extensions are needed to standard theories of the evidential basis of mindreading. The view also has consequences for understanding how abilities to interact combined with comparatively simple forms of mindreading may explain the emergence, in evolution or development, of sophisticated forms of social cognition