Strategies for synthesis of yardsticks and abaci for nanometre distance measurements by pulsed EPR

Silvia Valera is grateful for support by EPSRC and Bela E. Bode acknowledges support by EastCHEM.Pulsed electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) techniques have been found to be an efficient tool for elucidation of structure in complex biological systems as they give access to distances in the nanometre range. These measurements can provide additional structural information such as relative orientations, structural flexibility or aggregation states. A wide variety of model systems for calibration and optimisation of pulsed experiments has been synthesised. Their design is based on mimicking biological systems or materials in specific properties such as the distances themselves and the distance distributions. Here, we review selected approaches to the synthesis of chemical systems bearing two or more spin centres, such as nitroxide or trityl radicals, metal ions or combinations thereof and sketch their application in pulsed EPR distance measurements.Publisher PDFPeer reviewe

Molekulare Struktur mit Abstand - quantitative Interpretation von Puls Elektron-Elektron Doppelresonanzdaten

Pulsed electron-electron double resonance (PELDOR) is a well established method concerning nanometer distance measurements involving two nitroxide spin-labels. In this thesis the applicability of this method to count the number of spins is tested. Furthermore, this work explored the limits, up to which PELDOR data obtained on copper(II)-nitroxide complexes can be quantitatively interpreted. Spin counting provides access to oligomerization studies – monitoring the assembly of homo- or hetero-oligomers from singly labeled compounds. The experimental calibration was performed using model systems, which contain one to four nitroxide radicals. The results show that monomers, dimers, trimers, and tetramers can be distinguished within an error of 5% in the number of spins. Moreover, a detailed analysis of the distance distributions in model complexes revealed that more than one distance can be extracted from complexes bearing several spins, as for example three different distances were resolved in a model tetramer – the other three possible distances being symmetry related. Furthermore, systems exhibiting mixtures of oligomeric states complicate the analysis of the data, because the average number of spin centers contributes nonlinearly to the signal and different relaxation behavior of the oligomers has to be treated explicitly. Experiments solving these problems are proposed in the thesis. Thus, for the first time spin counting has been experimentally calibrated using fully characterized test systems bearing up to four spins. Moreover, the behavior of mixtures was quantitatively interpreted. In addition, it has been shown that several spin-spin distances within a molecule can be extracted from a single dataset. In the second part of the thesis PELDOR experiments on a spin-labeled copper(II)-porphyrin have been quantitatively analyzed. Metal-nitroxide distance measurements are a valuable tool for the triangulation of paramagnetic metal ions. Therefore, X-band PELDOR experiments at different frequencies have been performed. The data exhibits only weak orientation selection, but a fast damping of the oscillation. The experimental data has been interpreted based upon quantitative simulations. The influence of orientation selection, conformational flexibility, spin-density distribution, exchange interaction J, as well as anisotropy and strains of the g-tensor has been examined. An estimate of the spin-density delocalization has been obtained by density functional theory calculations. The dipolar interaction tensor was calculated from the point-charge model, the extension of the point-dipole approximation to several spin bearing centers. Even assuming asymmetric spin distributions induced by an ensemble of asymmetrically distorted porphyrins the effect of delocalization on the PELDOR time trace is weak. The observed damping of dipolar oscillations has been only reproduced by simulations, if a small distribution in J was assumed. It has been shown that the experimental damping of dipolar modulations is not solely due to conformational heterogeneity. In conclusion the quantitative interpretation of PELDOR data is extended to copper-nitroxide- and multi-spin-systems. The influence of the mean distance, of the number of coupled spins, of the conformational flexibility, of spin-density distribution and of the electronic structure of the spin centers has been analyzed using model systems. The insights on model compounds mimicking spin-labeled biomacromolecules – in oligomeric or metal bound states – calibrate the method with respect to the information that can be deduced from the experimental data. The resulting in-depth understanding allows correlating experimental results (from for example biological systems) with models of structure and dynamics. It also opens new fields for PELDOR as for example triangulation of metal centers and oligomerization studies. In general, this thesis has demonstrated that modern pulsed electron paramagnetic resonance techniques in combination with quantitative data analysis can contribute to a detailed insight into molecular structure and dynamics

Monitoring complex formation by relaxation-induced pulse electron paramagnetic resonance distance measurements

Funding: EPSRC DTC and Wellcome (099149/Z/12/Z).Biomolecular complexes are often multimers fueling the demand for methods that allow unraveling their composition and geometric arrangement. Pulse electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy is increasingly applied for retrieving geometric information on the nanometer scale. The emerging RIDME (relaxation-induced dipolar modulation enhancement) technique offers improved sensitivity in distance experiments involving metal centers (e.g. on metalloproteins or proteins labelled with metal ions). Here, a mixture of a spin labelled ligand with increasing amounts of paramagnetic CuII ions allowed accurate quantification of ligand-metal binding in the model complex formed. The distance measurement was highly accurate and critical aspects for identifying multimerization could be identified. The potential to quantify binding in addition to the high-precision distance measurement will further increase the scope of EPR applications.Publisher PDFPeer reviewe

Spectroscopically orthogonal labelling to disentangle site-specific nitroxide label distributions

Funding: The authors acknowledge support by the Wellcome Trust (204821/Z/16/Z), the Leverhulme Trust (RPG-2018-397), and the EPSRC (EP/X016455/1). BEB acknowledges equipment funding by BBSRC (BB/R013780/1 and BB/T017740/1).Biomolecular applications of pulse dipolar electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy (PDS) are becoming increasingly valuable in structural biology. Site-directed spin labelling of proteins is routinely performed using nitroxides, with paramagnetic metal ions and other organic radicals gaining popularity as alternative spin centres. Spectroscopically orthogonal spin labelling using different types of labels potentially increases the information content available from a single sample. When analysing experimental distance distributions between two nitroxide spin labels, the site-specific rotamer information has been projected into the distance and is not readily available, and the contributions of individual labelling sites to the width of the distance distribution are not obvious from the PDS data. Here, we exploit the exquisite precision of labelling double-histidine (dHis) motifs with CuII chelate complexes. The contribution of this label to the distance distribution widths in model protein GB1 has been shown to be negligible. By combining a dHis CuII labelling site with cysteine-specific nitroxide labelling, we gather insights on the label rotamers at two distinct sites, comparing their contributions to distance distributions based on different in silico modelling approaches and structural models. From this study, it seems advisable to consider discrepancies between different in silico modelling approaches when selecting labelling sites for PDS studies.Publisher PDFPeer reviewe

Pulse dipolar electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy distance measurements at low nanomolar concentrations : the CuII-trityl case

Funding: To meet institutional and research funder open access requirements, any accepted manuscript arising shall be open access under a Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) reuse licence with zero embargo. The authors acknowledge support by a University of St Andrews-University of Bonn Collaborative Research Grant, by the Wellcome Trust (204821/Z/16/Z), and by the EPSRC (EP/X016455/1). B.E.B. acknowledges equipment funding by BBSRC (BB/R013780/1 and BB/T017740/1). O.S. thanks the DFG for funding (420322655). C.A.H. thanks the DAAD for a travel and research scholarship. The authors thank the StAnD (St Andrews and Dundee) EPR grouping for long-standing support and the St Andrews mass spectrometry and proteomics facility for equipment access.Recent sensitivity enhancements in pulse dipolar EPR spectroscopy (PDS) have afforded distance measurements at submicromolar spin concentrations. This development opens the path for new science, as more biomolecular systems can be investigated at their respective physiological concentrations. Here, we demonstrate that the combination of orthogonal spin labelling using CuII ions and trityl yields a more than 3-fold sensitivity increase compared to the established CuII-nitroxide labelling strategy. Application of the recently developed variable-time RIDME method yields a further approximately 2.5-fold increase compared to the commonly used constant-time RIDME. This overall increase in sensitivity of almost an order of magnitude makes distance measurements in the range of 3 nm with protein concentrations as low as 10 nM feasible, more than two times lower than previously reported. We expect that experiments at single digit nanomolar concentrations are imminent, which has the potential to transform biological PDS applications.Publisher PDFPeer reviewe

In-lipid structure of pressure sensitive domains hints mechanosensitive channel functional diversity

This project was supported by a BBSRC grant (BB/S018069/1) to C.P., who was supported by the Royal Society of Edinburgh, Tenovus (T15/41) and Carnegie Trust (OS000256), at the initial stages of this project. Further C.P. acknowledges support from the University of St Andrews for the C.K. studentship and the University of Leeds and the Chinese Scholarship Council for the Y.M. studentship. B.E.B. and C.P. acknowledge support by the Leverhulme Trust (RPG-2018–397). This work was also supported by previous Wellcome Trust [099149/Z/12/Z] and BBSRC equipment grants (BB/R013780/1).The mechanosensitive channel of large conductance (MscL) from Mycobacterium tuberculosis has been used as structural model for rationalizing functional observations in multiple MscL orthologues. Although these orthologues adopt similar structural architectures, they reportedly present significant functional differences. Subtle structural discrepancies on mechanosensitive channel nano-pockets are known to affect mechanical gating and may be linked to large variability in tension sensitivity among these membrane channels. Here we modify the nano-pocket regions of MscL from Escherichia coli and Mycobacterium tuberculosis and employ PELDOR/DEER distance and 3pESEEM deuterium accessibility measurements to interrogate channel structure within lipids, in which both channels adopt a closed conformation. Significant in-lipid structural differences between the two constructs suggest a more compact EcMscL at the membrane inner-leaflet, as a consequence of a rotated TM2 helix. Observed differences within lipids could explain EcMscL’s higher tension sensitivity and should be taken into account in extrapolated models used for MscL gating rationalization.Publisher PDFPeer reviewe

Pulse EPR distance measurements to study multimers and multimerisation

This work was supported by funding from the European Union (Marie Curie Actions REA 334496), the Carnegie Trust (70098), the EPSRC (EP/M024660/1) and a Wellcome Trust multi-user equipment grant (099149/Z/12/Z).Pulse dipolar electron paramagnetic resonance (PD-EPR) has become a powerful tool for structural biology determining distances on the nanometre scale. Recent advances in hardware, methodology, and data analysis have widened the scope to complex biological systems. PD-EPR can be applied to systems containing lowly populated conformers or displaying large intrinsic flexibility, making them all but intractable for cryo-electron microscopy and crystallography. Membrane protein applications are of particular interest due to the intrinsic difficulties for obtaining high-resolution structures of all relevant conformations. Many drug targets involved in critical cell functions are multimeric channels or transporters. Here, common approaches for introducing spin labels for PD-EPR cause the presence of more than two electron spins per multimeric complex. This requires careful experimental design to overcome detrimental multi-spin effects and to secure sufficient distance resolution in presence of multiple distances. In addition to obtaining mere distances, PD-EPR can also provide information on multimerisation degrees allowing to study binding equilibria and to determine dissociation constants.PostprintPeer reviewe

Binding dynamics of a monomeric SSB protein to DNA : a single-molecule multi-process approach

People Programme of the European Union’s Seventh Framework Programme [REA 334496 to B.E.B.]; Leonardo da Vinci European Union Programme (to M.F.G.); Wellcome Trust [099149/Z/12/Z, 091825/Z/10/Z]. Funding for open access charge: Wellcome Trust; University of St Andrews.Single-stranded DNA binding proteins (SSBs) are ubiquitous across all organisms and are characterized by the presence of an OB (oligonucleotide/oligosaccharide/oligopeptide) binding motif to recognize single-stranded DNA (ssDNA). Despite their critical role in genome maintenance, our knowledge about SSB function is limited to proteins containing multiple OB-domains and little is known about single OB-folds interacting with ssDNA. Sulfolobus solfataricus SSB (SsoSSB) contains a single OB-fold and being the simplest representative of the SSB-family may serve as a model to understand fundamental aspects of SSB:DNA interactions. Here, we introduce a novel approach based on the competition between Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET), protein-induced fluorescence enhancement (PIFE) and quenching to dissect SsoSSB binding dynamics at single monomer resolution. We demonstrate that SsoSSB follows a monomer-by-monomer binding mechanism that involves a positive-cooperativity component between adjacent monomers. We found that SsoSSB dynamic behaviour is closer to that of Replication Protein A than to Escherichia coli SSB; a feature that might be inherited from the structural analogies of their DNA-binding domains. We hypothesize that SsoSSB has developed a balance between highdensity binding and a highly dynamic interaction with ssDNA to ensure efficient protection of the genome but still allow access to ssDNA during vital cellular processes.Publisher PDFPeer reviewe

Verbi in serie: una prospettiva tipologica

The authors acknowledge EPSRC (EP/K503162/1) for funding this research.Na2MoO2−δF4+δ (δ ∼ 0.08) displays a unique variant of the perovskite structure, with simultaneous (Na,vacancy) ordering on the A-site, (Na,Mo) ordering on the B-site, (O,F) ordering on the anion site and an unusual NaNbO3-like octahedral tilt system.Publisher PDFPeer reviewe

A general model to optimise CuII labelling efficiency of double-histidine motifs for pulse dipolar EPR applications

JLW is supported by the BBSRC DTP Eastbio. We thank the Leverhulme Trust for support (RPG-2018-397). This work was supported by equipment funding through the Wellcome Trust (099149/Z/12/Z) and BBSRC (BB/R013780/1). We gratefully acknowledge ISSF support to the University of St Andrews from the Wellcome Trust.Electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) distance measurements are making increasingly important contributions to studies of biomolecules underpinning health and disease by providing highly accurate and precise geometric constraints. Combining double-histidine (dH) motifs with CuII spin labels shows promise for further increasing the precision of distance measurements, and for investigating subtle conformational changes. However, non-covalent coordination-based spin labelling is vulnerable to low binding affinity. Dissociation constants of dH motifs for CuII-nitrilotriacetic acid were previously investigated via relaxation induced dipolar modulation enhancement (RIDME), and demonstrated the feasibility of exploiting the double histidine motif for EPR applications at sub-μM protein concentrations. Herein, the feasibility of using modulation depth quantitation in CuII-CuII RIDME to simultaneously estimate a pair of non-identical independent KD values in such a tetra-histidine model protein is addressed. Furthermore, we develop a general speciation model to optimise CuII labelling efficiency, in dependence of pairs of identical or disparate KD values and total CuII label concentration. We find the dissociation constant estimates are in excellent agreement with previously determined values, and empirical modulation depths support the proposed model.Publisher PDFPeer reviewe