Neonatal DNA methylation profile in human twins is specified by a complex interplay between intrauterine environmental and genetic factors, subject to tissue-specific influence

Comparison between groups of monozygotic (MZ) and dizygotic (DZ) twins enables an estimation of the relative contribution of genetic and shared and nonshared environmental factors to phenotypic variability. Using DNA methylation profiling of ∼20,000 CpG sites as a phenotype, we have examined discordance levels in three neonatal tissues from 22 MZ and 12 DZ twin pairs. MZ twins exhibit a wide range of within-pair differences at birth, but show discordance levels generally lower than DZ pairs. Within-pair methylation discordance was lowest in CpG islands in all twins and increased as a function of distance from islands. Variance component decomposition analysis of DNA methylation in MZ and DZ pairs revealed a low mean heritability across all tissues, although a wide range of heritabilities was detected for specific genomic CpG sites. The largest component of variation was attributed to the combined effects of nonshared intrauterine environment and stochastic factors. Regression analysis of methylation on birth weight revealed a general association between methylation of genes involved in metabolism and biosynthesis, providing further support for epigenetic change in the previously described link between low birth weight and increasing risk for cardiovascular, metabolic, and other complex diseases. Finally, comparison of our data with that of several older twins revealed little evidence for genome-wide epigenetic drift with increasing age. This is the first study to analyze DNA methylation on a genome scale in twins at birth, further highlighting the importance of the intrauterine environment on shaping the neonatal epigenome

Whole-genome expression profiling of cord blood mononuclear cells from monozygotic twin pairs

© 2011 Roberta Helen AndronikosSubstantial variation in gene expression levels exists between individuals, within specific tissues or cell types. With gene expression being the primary mechanism through which genetic information is translated into phenotype, the extent, nature and sources of this variation constitutes an important aspect of human biology. Variation in gene expression levels reflects a complex interplay of genetic and environmental factors. Certain environmental factors and exposures can modify gene expression through epigenetic modifications of DNA and chromatin, thus regulating transcription in a manner largely independent of genetic variation. The sensitivity of epigenetic mechanisms to these factors offers a means through which the environment can modulate expression of the genotype, with effects upon gene expression and ultimately, the phenotype. Studies of variation in gene expression in monozygotic (genetically identical) twins support a substantial environmental contribution to variation in gene expression levels. It is known that the epigenetic and gene expression profiles of monozygotic twins diverge throughout life. Mounting evidence suggests that the period of pre-natal development represents a particularly sensitive one for the occurrence of environmentally induced changes to epigenetic status and gene activity. The current study forms part of a larger research program investigating epigenetic variation in twins and its association with birth weight, maternal nutrition and foetal genotype. The Peri-/Post-natal Epigenetic Twins Study (PETS) builds upon the ‘developmental origins of adult disease’ hypothesis, based on the association between low birth weight and increased risk of cardiovascular and metabolic disease in later life, and focuses on epigenetic changes occurring in utero as the basis of the ‘foetal programming’ phenomenon. The current study is based on the hypothesis that divergence of epigenetic and gene expression profiles occurs from conception in monozygotic twins, in response to differing environments as experienced in utero. This study investigates the gene expression profiles of the cord blood mononuclear cells (CBMCs) of twelve newborn monozygotic twin pairs, including six pairs with birth weight discordance at greater than 15%. Genome-wide expression profiling was performed using the Illumina® Human-6 v2 BeadChip system. Gene expression discordance within twin pairs was assessed using three measures. Of these, the measure of Euclidean distance was considered to be the most systematic and useful. Expression discordance was found to vary substantially across pairs in our sample, with expression discordance being generally lower within twin pairs than between unrelated individuals. A significant correlation was identified between expression discordance and chorionicity, with greater expression discordance in dichorionic pairs compared to monochorionic pairs. The measure of Euclidean distance was also applied to publicly available datasets from genome-wide expression profiling of comparable tissues from adult twin pairs, revealing higher levels of expression discordance within the adult pairs relative to the newborn pairs. All genes surveyed by the microarray analysis were ranked according to the degree of within-pair variation shown across twin pairs. This ranked gene list was subjected to gene ontology analysis to identify gene ontology (GO) terms for which the corresponding ranks were higher than expected. Of the 27 GO terms ranked significantly higher than expected, one third related to immune response or response to other external signals. This data supports our hypothesis that divergence of gene expression profiles occurs from conception in monozygotic twins, and is reflected in differential expression phenotypes detectable at birth. Taken together, these results highlight the role of environment in determining gene expression profiles, and the contribution of environmentally induced changes in gene expression to expression discordance within monozygotic twin pairs. The increased variation observed within dichorionic twin pairs, coupled with the prominence of genes involved in immune/external signal response amongst those showing increased variation across pairs, implies that this variation may arise in response to subtly differing environments experienced by co-twins in utero. Birth weight is a phenotype of particular interest in the Peri-/Post-natal Epigenetic Twins Study (PETS), due to the association of low birth weight with an elevated risk of cardiovascular and metabolic disease in later life. In this study, linear modelling identified 342 genes whose expression levels showed a significant association with birth weight in dichorionic twin pairs. Gene ontology analysis of these genes revealed significant over-representation of GO terms relating to protein dephosphorylation, a process intrinsic to many forms of signal transduction. These data imply a link between the environmental modulation of gene activity via signal response/transduction and the phenotype of birth weight. Due to the myriad number of signal transduction pathways and physiological processes regulated by protein phosphorylation and dephosphorylation, it is not possible to pinpoint with certainty those that may be linked to birth weight or implicated in the association between low birth weight and elevated disease risk from our data. However, these results do provide a basis for further investigation of the specific environmental factors involved in the determination of gene expression variants associated with birth weight. It is to be hoped that future analyses will assist in the identification of the mechanisms underlying the correlation between low birth weight and an elevated risk of cardiovascular and metabolic disease in later life

DNA methylation analysis of multiple tissues from newborn twins reveals both genetic and intrauterine components to variation in the human neonatal epigenome

Mounting evidence from both animal and human studies suggests that the epigenome is in constant drift over the life course in response to stochastic and environmental factors. In humans, this has been highlighted by a small number of studies that have demonstrated discordant DNA methylation patterns in adolescent or adult monozygotic (MZ) twin pairs. However, to date, it remains unclear when such differences emerge, and how prevalent they are across different tissues. To address this, we examined the methylation of four differentially methylated regions associated with the IGF2/H19 locus in multiple birth tissues derived from 91 twin pairs: 56 MZ and 35 dizygotic (DZ). Tissues included cord blood-derived mononuclear cells and granulocytes, human umbilical vein endothelial cells, buccal epithelial cells and placental tissue. Considerable variation in DNA methylation was observed between tissues and between unrelated individuals. Most interestingly, methylation discordance was also present within twin pairs, with DZ pairs showing greater discordance than MZ pairs. These data highlight the variable contribution of both intrauterine environmental exposures and underlying genetic factors to the establishment of the neonatal epigenome of different tissues and confirm the intrauterine period as a sensitive time for the establishment of epigenetic variability in humans. This has implications for the effects of maternal environment on the development of the newborn epigenome and supports an epigenetic mechanism for the previously described phenomenon of \u27fetal programming\u27 of disease risk