21 research outputs found
Plagiarism in second-language writing
Plagiarism is a broad and multidisciplinary field of study, and within second-language (L2)
writing, research on the topic goes back to the mid-1980s. In this review article we first
discuss the received view of plagiarism as a transgressive act and alternative understandings
which have been presented in the L1 and L2 writing literature. We then survey and identify
salient themes in the growing body of work relating to plagiarism, primarily from an L2
writing/applied linguistic perspective. These themes include terminological distinctions; views
of the role of textual plagiarism in language learning and a writer’s development; a concern
with students’ and teachers’ sometimes differing understanding of plagiarism; and
disciplinary differences in perceptions of plagiarism. We review research into the role of the
electronic media in changing orientations toward plagiarism, the potential role of culture as a
cause of plagiarism in the work of L2 writers, and pedagogical approaches to guiding
students away from plagiarism. Methodological issues in researching plagiarism are surveyed,
and the article concludes by suggesting directions for future research
Rhetorical functions of citations in high- and low-rated master's theses
This study compares rhetorical citation functions in eight high- and eight low-graded master's theses in the field of gender studies, written in English as a second language. The following rhetorical functions of citations are identified: attribution, exemplification, further reference, statement of use, application, evaluation, establishing links between sources, and comparison of one's own work with that of other authors. It is shown that both sets of theses use citations predominantly for attribution, suggesting that one of the functions of citation in student writing is knowledge display. The use of citation for non-attribution functions is found to be considerably lower in the low-rated theses than in the high-rated theses, both in the whole theses and in individual chapters. The findings show that there is a relationship between citation use and thesis grade, thus pointing to the importance of effective citation strategies for students’ academic success. In conclusion, the paper argues that source use and citation skills should receive more attention in EAP instruction and suggests activities focusing on this area of academic writing
Task requirements, task representation, and self-reported citation functions: An exploratory study of a successful L2 student's writing
This mixed-method study investigates the citation behaviour of a successful L2 postgraduate management student, Sofie, in two pieces of writing, written in response to two assignment tasks in two management modules. The tasks belonged to the same assignment type, but differed in the level of direction provided: one was a directed task, accompanied by lecturer guidance on readings, while the other was an open task, allowing students to select their own topic. The discourse-based interview approach (Odell, Goswami, & Harrington, 1983) was used to elicit Sofie's perceived citation functions, followed by quantifying the qualitative codings to allow for comparison. The findings show that some of the citation functions Sofie described were the same in both assignments, while others were task specific. Sofie used citations in both assignments to define terms and support her arguments. However, it was only in her assignment for the open task that she used citations to show the relevance of her chosen topic. Conversely, she frequently used citations to apply citees' concepts to her own analysis in the directed task, but not in the open task. We conclude by discussing the implications of our findings for L2 writing instruction. © 2013 Elsevier Ltd
Ethnography as method, methodology, and "deep theorizing": closing the gap between text and context in academic writing research
This article critically explores the value of ethnography for enhancing context-sensitive approaches to the study of academic writing. Drawing on data from two longitudinal studies, student writing in the United Kingdom and professional academic writing in Hungary, Slovakia, Spain, and Portugal, the author illustrates the different contributions ethnography can make to researching academic writing, depending on the level at which it is construed, as method, methodology, or "deep theorizing." In discussing the third level of ethnography, the author draws on recent debates around linguistic ethnography to explore how ethnography as deep theorizing can contribute to refining social practice accounts of academic writing through the specific notions of indexicality and orientation. By working through three levels of ethnography, her aim is to signal the ontological gap between text and context in academic writing research and to open up debate about how this gap can be narrowed