Active queue management as quality of service enabler for 5G networks

© 2019 IEEE. Personal use of this material is permitted. Permission from IEEE must be obtained for all other uses, in any current or future media, including reprinting/republishing this material for advertising or promotional purposes,creating new collective works, for resale or redistribution to servers or lists, or reuse of any copyrighted component of this work in other works.5G is envisioned as the key technology for guaranteeing low-latency wireless services. Packets will be marked with QoS Flow Indicators (QFI) for different forwarding treatment. 3GPP defines the end-to-end delay limits, but leaves the QoS provisioning methods as implementation dependent. Different services with different constraints will inevitably share queues at some network entity. On the one hand, maintaining the shared queues uncongested will guarantee a rapid packet delivery to the subsequent entity. A brief sojourn time is indispensable for an on time low-latency priority traffic delivery. On the other hand, if shared queues are maintained undersized, throughput will be squandered. In this paper, we propose the use of AQM techniques in 5G networks to guarantee delay limits of QoS flows. Through the evaluation of realistic delay-sensitive and background traffic, we compare different possible solutions. We show that AQM mechanisms together with limited queues, maintain the system uncongested, which reduces drastically the delay, while effectively achieving the maximum possible throughput.Peer ReviewedPostprint (author's final draft

Downstream Bandwidth Management for Emerging DOCSIS-based Networks

In this dissertation, we consider the downstream bandwidth management in the context of emerging DOCSIS-based cable networks. The latest DOCSIS 3.1 standard for cable access networks represents a significant change to cable networks. For downstream, the current 6 MHz channel size is replaced by a much larger 192 MHz channel which potentially can provide data rates up to 10 Gbps. Further, the current standard requires equipment to support a relatively new form of active queue management (AQM) referred to as delay-based AQM. Given that more than 50 million households (and climbing) use cable for Internet access, a clear understanding of the impacts of bandwidth management strategies used in these emerging networks is crucial. Further, given the scope of the change provided by emerging cable systems, now is the time to develop and introduce innovative new methods for managing bandwidth. With this motivation, we address research questions pertaining to next generation of cable access networks. The cable industry has had to deal with the problem of a small number of subscribers who utilize the majority of network resources. This problem will grow as access rates increase to gigabits per second. Fundamentally this is a problem on how to manage data flows in a fair manner and provide protection. A well known performance issue in the Internet, referred to as bufferbloat, has received significant attention recently. High throughput network flows need sufficiently large buffer to keep the pipe full and absorb occasional burstiness. Standard practice however has led to equipment offering very large unmanaged buffers that can result in sustained queue levels increasing packet latency. One reason why these problems continue to plague cable access networks is the desire for low complexity and easily explainable (to access network subscribers and to the Federal Communications Commission) bandwidth management. This research begins by evaluating modern delay-based AQM algorithms in downstream DOCSIS 3.0 environments with a focus on fairness and application performance capabilities of single queue AQMs. We are especially interested in delay-based AQM schemes that have been proposed to combat the bufferbloat problem. Our evaluation involves a variety of scenarios that include tiered services and application workloads. Based on our results, we show that in scenarios involving realistic workloads, modern delay-based AQMs can effectively mitigate bufferbloat. However they do not address the other problem related to managing the fairness. To address the combined problem of fairness and bufferbloat, we propose a novel approach to bandwidth management that provides a compromise among the conflicting requirements. We introduce a flow quantization method referred to as adaptive bandwidth binning where flows that are observed to consume similar levels of bandwidth are grouped together with the system managed through a hierarchical scheduler designed to approximate weighted fairness while addressing bufferbloat. Based on a simulation study that considers many system experimental parameters including workloads and network configurations, we provide evidence of the efficacy of the idea. Our results suggest that the scheme is able to provide long term fairness and low delay with a performance close to that of a reference approach based on fair queueing. A further contribution is our idea for replacing `tiered\u27 levels of service based on service rates with tiering based on weights. The application of our bandwidth binning scheme offers a timely and innovative alternative to broadband service that leverages the potential offered by emerging DOCSIS-based cable systems

Evaluation of Active Queue Management (AQM) Models in Low Latency Networks

Abstract: Low latency networks require the modification of the actual queuing management in order to avoid large queuing delay. Nowadays, TCP’s congestion control maximizes the throughput of the link providing benefits to large flow packets. However, nodes’ buffers may get fully filled, which would produce large time delays and packet dropping situations, named as bufferbloat problem. For actual time-sensitive applications demand, such as VoIP, online gaming or financial trading, these queueing times cause bad quality of service being directly noticed in user’s utilization. This work studies the different alternatives for active queue management (AQM) in the nodes links, optimizing the latency of the small flow packets and, therefore, providing better quality for low latency networks in congestion scenarios. AQM models are simulated in a dumbbell topology with ns3 software, which shows the diverse latency values (measured in RTT) according to network situations and the algorithm that has been installed. In detail, RED, CoDel, PIE, and FQ_CoDel algorithms are studied, plus the modification of the TCP sender’s congestion control with Alternative Backoff with ECN (ABE) algorithm. The simulations will display the best queueing times for the implementation that mixes FQ_CoDel with ABE, the one which maximizes the throughput reducing the latency of the packets. Thus, the modification of queueing management with FQ_CoDel and the implementation of ABE in the sender will solve the bufferbloat problem offering the required quality for low latency networks.Resumen Las redes de baja latencia requieren la modificación de la actual gestión de las colas con el fin de eludir los extensos tiempos de retardo. Hoy en d´ıa, el control de congestión de TCP maximiza el rendimiento (throughput) del enlace otorgando beneficio a los grandes flujos de datos, sin embargo, los buffers son plenamente cargados generando altos tiempos de retardo y fases de retirada de paquetes, llamada a esta situación el problema de Bufferbloat. Par las aplicaciones contempor´aneas como las llamadas VoIP, los juegos on-line o los intercambios financieros; estos tiempos de cola generan una mala calidad de servicio detectada directamente por los usuarios finales. Este trabajo estudia las diferentes alternativas de la gestión activa de colas (AQM), optimizando la latencia de los peque˜nos flujos y, por lo tanto, brindando una mejor calidad para las redes de baja latencia en situaciones de congestión. Los modelos AQM han sido evaluados en una topolog´ıa ’dumbbell’ mediante el simulador ns3, entregando resultados de latencia (medidos en RTT) de acuerdo con la situación del enlace y el algoritmo instalado en la cola. Concretamente, los algoritmos estudiados han sido RED, CoDel, PIE y FQ_CoDel; adem´as de la modificación del control de congestión TCP del emisor denominada ABE (Alternative Backoff with ECN). Las simulaciones que mejor resultados ofrecen son las que implementan combinación de FQ_CoDel con el algoritmo ABE, maximizando el rendimiento y reduciendo la latencia de los paquetes. Por lo tanto, la modificación con FQ_CoDel en las colas y la de ABE en el emisor ofrecen una solución al problema del Bufferbloat altamente solicitada por las redes de baja latencia

Dual Queue Coupled AQM: Deployable Very Low Queuing Delay for All

On the Internet, sub-millisecond queueing delay and capacity-seeking have traditionally been considered mutually exclusive. We introduce a service that offers both: Low Latency Low Loss Scalable throughput (L4S). When tested under a wide range of conditions emulated on a testbed using real residential broadband equipment, queue delay remained both low (median 100--300 $\mu$s) and consistent (99th percentile below 2 ms even under highly dynamic workloads), without compromising other metrics (zero congestion loss and close to full utilization). L4S exploits the properties of `Scalable' congestion controls (e.g., DCTCP, TCP Prague). Flows using such congestion control are however very aggressive, which causes a deployment challenge as L4S has to coexist with so-called `Classic' flows (e.g., Reno, CUBIC). This paper introduces an architectural solution: `Dual Queue Coupled Active Queue Management', which enables balance between Scalable and Classic flows. It counterbalances the more aggressive response of Scalable flows with more aggressive marking, without having to inspect flow identifiers. The Dual Queue structure has been implemented as a Linux queuing discipline. It acts like a semi-permeable membrane, isolating the latency of Scalable and `Classic' traffic, but coupling their capacity into a single bandwidth pool. This paper justifies the design and implementation choices, and visualizes a representative selection of hundreds of thousands of experiment runs to test our claims.Comment: Preprint. 17pp, 12 Figs, 60 refs. Submitted to IEEE/ACM Transactions on Networkin

Cocoa: Congestion Control Aware Queuing

Recent model-based congestion control algorithms such as BBR use repeated measurements at the endpoint to build a model of the network connection and use it to achieve optimal throughput with low queuing delay. Conversely, applying this model-based approach to Active Queue Management (AQM) has so far received less attention. We propose the new AQM scheduler cocoa based on fair queuing, which adapts the buffer size depending on the needs of each flow without requiring active participation from the endpoint. We implement this scheduler for the Linux kernel and show that it interacts well with the most common congestion control algorithms and can significantly increase throughput compared to fair CoDel while avoiding overbuffering

5GAuRA. D3.3: RAN Analytics Mechanisms and Performance Benchmarking of Video, Time Critical, and Social Applications

5GAuRA deliverable D3.3.This is the final deliverable of Work Package 3 (WP3) of the 5GAuRA project, providing a report on the project’s developments on the topics of Radio Access Network (RAN) analytics and application performance benchmarking. The focus of this deliverable is to extend and deepen the methods and results provided in the 5GAuRA deliverable D3.2 in the context of specific use scenarios of video, time critical, and social applications. In this respect, four major topics of WP3 of 5GAuRA – namely edge-cloud enhanced RAN architecture, machine learning assisted Random Access Channel (RACH) approach, Multi-access Edge Computing (MEC) content caching, and active queue management – are put forward. Specifically, this document provides a detailed discussion on the service level agreement between tenant and service provider in the context of network slicing in Fifth Generation (5G) communication networks. Network slicing is considered as a key enabler to 5G communication system. Legacy telecommunication networks have been providing various services to all kinds of customers through a single network infrastructure. In contrast, by deploying network slicing, operators are now able to partition one network into individual slices, each with its own configuration and Quality of Service (QoS) requirements. There are many applications across industry that open new business opportunities with new business models. Every application instance requires an independent slice with its own network functions and features, whereby every single slice needs an individual Service Level Agreement (SLA). In D3.3, we propose a comprehensive end-to-end structure of SLA between the tenant and the service provider of sliced 5G network, which balances the interests of both sides. The proposed SLA defines reliability, availability, and performance of delivered telecommunication services in order to ensure that right information is delivered to the right destination at right time, safely and securely. We also discuss the metrics of slicebased network SLA such as throughput, penalty, cost, revenue, profit, and QoS related metrics, which are, in the view of 5GAuRA, critical features of the agreement.Peer ReviewedPostprint (published version