The (in)dependence of alternative splicing and gene duplication.

Alternative splicing (AS) and gene duplication (GD) both are processes that diversify the protein repertoire. Recent examples have shown that sequence changes introduced by AS may be comparable to those introduced by GD. In addition, the two processes are inversely correlated at the genomic scale: large gene families are depleted in splice variants and vice versa. All together, these data strongly suggest that both phenomena result in interchangeability between their effects. Here, we tested the extent to which this applies with respect to various protein characteristics. The amounts of AS and GD per gene are anticorrelated even when accounting for different gene functions or degrees of sequence divergence. In contrast, the two processes appear to be independent in their influence on variation in mRNA expression. Further, we conducted a detailed comparison of the effect of sequence changes in both alternative splice variants and gene duplicates on protein structure, in particular the size, location, and types of sequence substitutions and insertions/deletions. We find that, in general, alternative splicing affects protein sequence and structure in a more drastic way than gene duplication and subsequent divergence. Our results reveal an interesting paradox between the anticorrelation of AS and GD at the genomic level, and their impact at the protein level, which shows little or no equivalence in terms of effects on protein sequence, structure, and function. We discuss possible explanations that relate to the order of appearance of AS and GD in a gene family, and to the selection pressure imposed by the environment

Exon-phase symmetry and intrinsic structural disorder promote modular evolution in the human genome

A key signature of module exchange in the genome is phase symmetry of exons, suggestive of exon shuffling events that occurred without disrupting translation reading frame. At the protein level, intrinsic structural disorder may be another key element because disordered regions often serve as functional elements that can be effectively integrated into a protein structure. Therefore, we asked whether exon-phase symmetry in the human genome and structural disorder in the human proteome are connected, signalling such evolutionary mechanisms in the assembly of multi-exon genes. We found an elevated level of structural disorder of regions encoded by symmetric exons and a preferred symmetry of exons encoding for mostly disordered regions (>70% predicted disorder). Alternatively spliced symmetric exons tend to correspond to the most disordered regions. The genes of mostly disordered proteins (>70% predicted disorder) tend to be assembled from symmetric exons, which often arise by internal tandem duplications. Preponderance of certain types of short motifs (e.g. SH3-binding motif) and domains (e.g. high-mobility group domains) suggests that certain disordered modules have been particularly effective in exon-shuffling events. Our observations suggest that structural disorder has facilitated modular assembly of complex genes in evolution of the human genome. © 2013 The Author(s)

Age-dependent gain of alternative splice forms and biased duplication explain the relation between splicing and duplication.

We analyze here the relation between alternative splicing and gene duplication in light of recent genomic data, with a focus on the human genome. We show that the previously reported negative correlation between level of alternative splicing and family size no longer holds true. We clarify this pattern and show that it is sufficiently explained by two factors. First, genes progressively gain new splice variants with time. The gain is consistent with a selectively relaxed regime, until purifying selection slows it down as aging genes accumulate a large number of variants. Second, we show that duplication does not lead to a loss of splice forms, but rather that genes with low levels of alternative splicing tend to duplicate more frequently. This leads us to reconsider the role of alternative splicing in duplicate retention

Conservation of alternative splicing in sodium channels reveals evolutionary focus on release from inactivation and structural insights into gating

Voltage-gated sodium channels are critical for neuronal activity, and highly intolerant to variation. Even mutations that cause subtle changes in the activity these channels are sufficient to cause devastating inherited neurological diseases, such as epilepsy and pain. However, these channels do vary in healthy tissue. Alternative splicing modifies sodium channels, but the functional relevance and adaptive significance of this splicing remain poorly understood. Here we use a conserved alternate exon encoding part of the first domain of sodium channels to compare how splicing modifies different channels, and to ask whether the functional consequences of this splicing have been preserved in different genes. Although the splicing event is highly conserved, one splice variant has been selectively removed from Nav1.1 in multiple mammalian species, suggesting that the functional variation in Nav1.1 is less well-tolerated. We show for three human channels (Nav1.1, Nav1.2 and Nav1.7) splicing modifies the return from inactivated to deactivated states, and the differences between splice variants are occluded by antiepileptic drugs that bind to and stabilize inactivated states. A model based on structural data can replicate these changes, and indicates that splicing may exploit a distinct role of the first domain to change channel availability, and that the first domain of all three sodium channels plays a role in determining the rate at which the inactivation domain dissociates. Taken together, our data suggest that the stability of inactivated states is under tight evolutionary control, but that in Nav1.1 faster recovery from inactivation is associated with negative selection in mammals

Gene Structure Evolution of the Na+-Ca2+ Exchanger (NCX) Family

<p>Abstract</p> <p>Background</p> <p>The Na⁺-Ca²⁺exchanger (NCX) is an important regulator of cytosolic Ca²⁺levels. Many of its structural features are highly conserved across a wide range of species. Invertebrates have a single <it>NCX </it>gene, whereas vertebrate species have multiple <it>NCX </it>genes as a result of at least two duplication events. To examine the molecular evolution of <it>NCX </it>genes and understand the role of duplicated genes in the evolution of the vertebrate <it>NCX </it>gene family, we carried out phylogenetic analyses of <it>NCX </it>genes and compared <it>NCX </it>gene structures from sequenced genomes and individual clones.</p> <p>Results</p> <p>A single <it>NCX </it>in invertebrates and the protochordate <it>Ciona</it>, and the presence of at least four <it>NCX </it>genes in the genomes of teleosts, an amphibian, and a reptile suggest that a four member gene family arose in a basal vertebrate. Extensive examination of mammalian and avian genomes and synteny analysis argue that <it>NCX4 </it>may be lost in these lineages. Duplicates for <it>NCX1</it>, <it>NCX2</it>, and <it>NCX4 </it>were found in all sequenced teleost genomes. The presence of seven genes encoding <it>NCX </it>homologs may provide teleosts with the functional specialization analogous to the alternate splicing strategy seen with the three <it>NCX </it>mammalian homologs.</p> <p>Conclusion</p> <p>We have demonstrated that <it>NCX4 </it>is present in teleost, amphibian and reptilian species but has been secondarily and independently lost in mammals and birds. Comparative studies on conserved vertebrate homologs have provided a possible evolutionary route taken by gene duplicates subfunctionalization by minimizing homolog number.</p

The metazoan history of the COE transcription factors. Selection of a variant HLH motif by mandatory inclusion of a duplicated exon in vertebrates

<p>Abstract</p> <p>Background</p> <p>The increasing number of available genomic sequences makes it now possible to study the evolutionary history of specific genes or gene families. Transcription factors (TFs) involved in regulation of gene-specific expression are key players in the evolution of metazoan development. The low complexity COE (Collier/Olfactory-1/Early B-Cell Factor) family of transcription factors constitutes a well-suited paradigm for studying evolution of TF structure and function, including the specific question of protein modularity. Here, we compare the structure of <it>coe </it>genes within the metazoan kingdom and report on the mechanism behind a vertebrate-specific exon duplication.</p> <p>Results</p> <p>COE proteins display a modular organisation, with three highly conserved domains : a COE-specific DNA-binding domain (DBD), an Immunoglobulin/Plexin/transcription (IPT) domain and an atypical Helix-Loop-Helix (HLH) motif. Comparison of the splice structure of <it>coe </it>genes between cnidariae and bilateriae shows that the ancestral COE DBD was built from 7 separate exons, with no evidence for exon shuffling with other metazoan gene families. It also confirms the presence of an ancestral H1LH2 motif present in all COE proteins which partly overlaps the repeated H2d-H2a motif first identified in rodent EBF. Electrophoretic Mobility Shift Assays show that formation of COE dimers is mediated by this ancestral motif. The H2d-H2a α-helical repetition appears to be a vertebrate characteristic that originated from a tandem exon duplication having taken place prior to the splitting between gnathostomes and cyclostomes. We put-forward a two-step model for the inclusion of this exon in the vertebrate transcripts.</p> <p>Conclusion</p> <p>Three main features in the history of the <it>coe </it>gene family can be inferred from these analyses: (i) each conserved domain of the ancestral <it>coe </it>gene was built from multiple exons and the same scattered structure has been maintained throughout metazoan evolution. (ii) There exists a single <it>coe </it>gene copy per metazoan genome except in vertebrates. The H2a-H2d duplication that is specific to vertebrate proteins provides an example of a novel vertebrate characteristic, which may have been fixed early in the gnathostome lineage. (iii) This duplication provides an interesting example of counter-selection of alternative splicing.</p

Alternative Splicing and Gene Duplication in the Evolution of the FoxP Gene Subfamily

The FoxP gene subfamily of transcription factors is defined by its characteristic 110 amino acid long DNA-binding forkhead domain and plays essential roles in vertebrate biology. Its four members, FoxP1–P4, have been extensively characterized functionally. FoxP1, FoxP2, and FoxP4 are involved in lung, heart, gut, and central nervous system (CNS) development. FoxP3 is necessary and sufficient for the specification of regulatory T cells (Tregs) of the adaptive immune system

Divergence of exonic splicing elements after gene duplication and the impact on gene structures

An analysis of human exonic splicing elements in duplicated genes reveals their important role in the generation of new gene structures

Genomic evidence for non-random endemic populations of decaying exons from mammalian genes

<p>Abstract</p> <p>Background</p> <p>Functional diversification of genes in mammalian genomes is engendered by a number of processes, <it>e.g</it>., gene duplication and alternative splicing. Gene duplication is classically discussed as leading to <it>neofunctionalization </it>(generation of new functions), <it>subfunctionalization </it>(generation of a varied function), or <it>pseudogenization </it>(loss of the gene and its function).</p> <p>Results</p> <p>Here, we focus on the process of pseudogenization, but specifically for individual exons from genes. It is at present unclear to what extent pseudogenization of individual exon duplications affects gene evolution, <it>i.e</it>., is it a random phenomenon, or is it associated with specific types of genes and encoded proteins, and positions in gene structures? We gathered genomic evidence for <it>pseudogenic exons </it>(ΨEs, <it>i.e</it>., exons disabled by frameshifts and premature stop codons), to examine for significant trends in their distribution across four mammalian genomes (specifically human, cow, mouse and rat). Across these four genomes, we observed a consistent population of ΨEs, associated with 0.4–1.0% of genes. These ΨE populations exhibit codon substitution patterns that are typical of an endemic population of decaying sequences. In human, ΨEs have significant over-representation for functional categories related to 'ion binding' and 'nucleic-acid binding', compared to duplicated exons in general. Also, ΨEs tend to be associated with some protein domains that are abundant generally, <it>e.g</it>., Zinc-finger and immunoglobulin protein domains, but not others, <it>e.g</it>., EGF-like domains. Positionally, ΨEs are also significantly associated with the 5' end of genes, but despite this, individual stop codons are positioned so that there is significant avoidance of potential targeting to nonsense-mediated decay. In human, ΨEs are often associated with alternative splicing (in 22 out of 284 genes with ΨEs in their milieu), and can have different parts of their sequence differentially spliced in alternative transcripts. Some unusual cases of ΨEs embedded within 5' and 3' non-coding exons are observed.</p> <p>Conclusion</p> <p>Our results indicate the types of genes that harbour ΨEs, and demonstrate that ΨEs have non-random distribution within gene structures. These ΨEs may function in gene regulation through generation of transcribed pseudogenes, or regulatory alternate transcripts.</p

Biased exonization of transposed elements in duplicated genes: A lesson from the TIF-IA gene

Background: Gene duplication and exonization of intronic transposed elements are two mechanisms that enhance genomic diversity. We examined whether there is less selection against exonization of transposed elements in duplicated genes than in single-copy genes. Results: Genome-wide analysis of exonization of transposed elements revealed a higher rate of exonization within duplicated genes relative to single-copy genes. The gene for TIF-IA, an RNA polymerase I transcription initiation factor, underwent a humanoid-specific triplication, all three copies of the gene are active transcriptionally, although only one copy retains the ability to generate the TIF-IA protein. Prior to TIF-IA triplication, an Alu element was inserted into the first intron. In one of the non-protein coding copies, this Alu is exonized. We identified a single point mutation leading to exonization in one of the gene duplicates. When this mutation was introduced into the TIF-IA coding copy, exonization was activated and the level of the protein-coding mRNA was reduced substantially. A very low level of exonization was detected in normal human cells. However, this exonization was abundant in most leukemia cell lines evaluated, although the genomic sequence is unchanged in these cancerous cells compared to normal cells. Conclusion: The definition of the Alu element within the TIF-IA gene as an exon is restricted to certain types of cancers; the element is not exonized in normal human cells. These results further our understanding of the delicate interplay between gene duplication and alternative splicing and of the molecular evolutionary mechanisms leading to genetic innovations. This implies the existence of purifying selection against exonization in single copy genes, with duplicate genes free from such constrains