High-Performance Placement and Routing for the Nanometer Scale.

Modern semiconductor manufacturing facilitates single-chip electronic systems that only five years ago required ten to twenty chips. Naturally, design complexity has grown within this period. In contrast to this growth, it is becoming common in the industry to limit design team size which places a heavier burden on design automation tools. Our work identifies new objectives, constraints and concerns in the physical design of systems-on-chip, and develops new computational techniques to address them. In addition to faster and more relevant design optimizations, we demonstrate that traditional design flows based on ``separation of concerns'' produce unnecessarily suboptimal layouts. We develop new integrated optimizations that streamline traditional chains of loosely-linked design tools. In particular, we bridge the gap between mixed-size placement and routing by updating the objective of global and detail placement to a more accurate estimate of routed wirelength. To this we add sophisticated whitespace allocation, and the combination provides increased routability, faster routing, shorter routed wirelength, and the best via counts of published techniques. To further improve post-routing design metrics, we present new global routing techniques based on Discrete Lagrange Multipliers (DLM) which produce the best routed wirelength results on recent benchmarks. Our work culminates in the integration of our routing techniques within an incremental placement flow to improve detailed routing solutions, shrink die sizes and reduce total chip cost. Not only do our techniques improve the quality and cost of designs, but also simplify design automation software implementation in many cases. Ultimately, we reduce the time needed for design closure through improved tool fidelity and the use of our incremental techniques for placement and routing.Ph.D.Computer Science & EngineeringUniversity of Michigan, Horace H. Rackham School of Graduate Studieshttp://deepblue.lib.umich.edu/bitstream/2027.42/64639/1/royj_1.pd

PeF: Poisson's Equation Based Large-Scale Fixed-Outline Floorplanning

Floorplanning is the first stage of VLSI physical design. An effective floorplanning engine definitely has positive impact on chip design speed, quality and performance. In this paper, we present a novel mathematical model to characterize non-overlapping of modules, and propose a flat fixed-outline floorplanning algorithm based on the VLSI global placement approach using Poisson's equation. The algorithm consists of global floorplanning and legalization phases. In global floorplanning, we redefine the potential energy of each module based on the novel mathematical model for characterizing non-overlapping of modules and an analytical solution of Poisson's equation. In this scheme, the widths of soft modules appear as variables in the energy function and can be optimized. Moreover, we design a fast approximate computation scheme for partial derivatives of the potential energy. In legalization, based on the defined horizontal and vertical constraint graphs, we eliminate overlaps between modules remained after global floorplanning, by modifying relative positions of modules. Experiments on the MCNC, GSRC, HB+ and ami49\_x benchmarks show that, our algorithm improves the average wirelength by at least 2\% and 5\% on small and large scale benchmarks with certain whitespace, respectively, compared to state-of-the-art floorplanners

Algorithmic techniques for physical design : macro placement and under-the-cell routing

With the increase of chip component density and new manufacturability constraints imposed by modern technology nodes, the role of algorithms for electronic design automation is key to the successful implementation of integrated circuits. Two of the critical steps in the physical design flows are macro placement and ensuring all design rules are honored after timing closure. This thesis proposes contributions to help in these stages, easing time-consuming manual steps and helping physical design engineers to obtain better layouts in reduced turnaround time. The first contribution is under-the-cell routing, a proposal to systematically connect standard cell components via lateral pins in the lower metal layers. The aim is to reduce congestion in the upper metal layers caused by extra metal and vias, decreasing the number of design rule violations. To allow cells to connect by abutment, a standard cell library is enriched with instances containing lateral pins in a pre-selected sharing track. Algorithms are proposed to maximize the numbers of connections via lateral connection by mapping placed cell instances to layouts with lateral pins, and proposing local placement modifications to increase the opportunities for such connections. Experimental results show a significant decrease in the number of pins, vias, and in number of design rule violations, with negligible impact on wirelength and timing. The second contribution, done in collaboration with eSilicon (a leading ASIC design company), is the creation of HiDaP, a macro placement tool for modern industrial designs. The proposed approach follows a multilevel scheme to floorplan hierarchical blocks, composed of macros and standard cells. By exploiting RTL information available in the netlist, the dataflow affinity between these blocks is modeled and minimized to find a macro placement with good wirelength and timing properties. The approach is further extended to allow additional engineer input, such as preferred macro locations, and also spectral and force methods to guide the floorplanning search. Experimental results show that the layouts generated by HiDaP outperforms those obtained by a state-of-the-art EDA physical design software, with similar wirelength and better timing when compared to manually designed tape-out ready macro placements. Layouts obtained by HiDaP have successfully been brought to near timing closure with one to two rounds of small modifications by physical design engineers. HiDaP has been fully integrated in the design flows of the company and its development remains an ongoing effort.A causa de l'increment de la densitat de components en els xip i les noves restriccions de disseny imposades pels últims nodes de fabricació, el rol de l'algorísmia en l'automatització del disseny electrònic ha esdevingut clau per poder implementar circuits integrats. Dos dels passos crucials en el procés de disseny físic és el placement de macros i assegurar la correcció de les regles de disseny un cop les restriccions de timing del circuit són satisfetes. Aquesta tesi proposa contribucions per ajudar en aquests dos reptes, facilitant laboriosos passos manuals en el procés i ajudant als enginyers de disseny físic a obtenir millors resultats en menys temps. La primera contribució és el routing "under-the-cell", una proposta per connectar cel·les estàndard usant pins laterals en les capes de metall inferior de manera sistemàtica. L'objectiu és reduir la congestió en les capes de metall superior causades per l'ús de metall i vies, i així disminuir el nombre de violacions de regles de disseny. Per permetre la connexió lateral de cel·les, estenem una llibreria de cel·les estàndard amb dissenys que incorporen connexions laterals. També proposem modificacions locals al placement per permetre explotar aquest tipus de connexions més sovint. Els resultats experimentals mostren una reducció significativa en el nombre de pins, vies i nombre de violacions de regles de disseny, amb un impacte negligible en wirelength i timing. La segona contribució, desenvolupada en col·laboració amb eSilicon (una empresa capdavantera en disseny ASIC), és el desenvolupament de HiDaP, una eina de macro placement per a dissenys industrials actuals. La proposta segueix un procés multinivell per fer el floorplan de blocks jeràrquics, formats per macros i cel·les estàndard. Mitjançant la informació RTL disponible en la netlist, l'afinitat de dataflow entre els mòduls es modela i minimitza per trobar macro placements amb bones propietats de wirelength i timing. La proposta també incorpora la possibilitat de rebre input addicional de l'enginyer, com ara suggeriments de les posicions de les macros. Finalment, també usa mètodes espectrals i de forçes per guiar la cerca de floorplans. Els resultats experimentals mostren que els dissenys generats amb HiDaP són millors que els obtinguts per eines comercials capdavanteres de EDA. Els resultats també mostren que els dissenys presentats poden obtenir un wirelength similar i millor timing que macro placements obtinguts manualment, usats per fabricació. Alguns dissenys obtinguts per HiDaP s'han dut fins a timing-closure en una o dues rondes de modificacions incrementals per part d'enginyers de disseny físic. L'eina s'ha integrat en el procés de disseny de eSilicon i el seu desenvolupament continua més enllà de les aportacions a aquesta tesi

Algorithmic techniques for physical design : macro placement and under-the-cell routing

With the increase of chip component density and new manufacturability constraints imposed by modern technology nodes, the role of algorithms for electronic design automation is key to the successful implementation of integrated circuits. Two of the critical steps in the physical design flows are macro placement and ensuring all design rules are honored after timing closure. This thesis proposes contributions to help in these stages, easing time-consuming manual steps and helping physical design engineers to obtain better layouts in reduced turnaround time. The first contribution is under-the-cell routing, a proposal to systematically connect standard cell components via lateral pins in the lower metal layers. The aim is to reduce congestion in the upper metal layers caused by extra metal and vias, decreasing the number of design rule violations. To allow cells to connect by abutment, a standard cell library is enriched with instances containing lateral pins in a pre-selected sharing track. Algorithms are proposed to maximize the numbers of connections via lateral connection by mapping placed cell instances to layouts with lateral pins, and proposing local placement modifications to increase the opportunities for such connections. Experimental results show a significant decrease in the number of pins, vias, and in number of design rule violations, with negligible impact on wirelength and timing. The second contribution, done in collaboration with eSilicon (a leading ASIC design company), is the creation of HiDaP, a macro placement tool for modern industrial designs. The proposed approach follows a multilevel scheme to floorplan hierarchical blocks, composed of macros and standard cells. By exploiting RTL information available in the netlist, the dataflow affinity between these blocks is modeled and minimized to find a macro placement with good wirelength and timing properties. The approach is further extended to allow additional engineer input, such as preferred macro locations, and also spectral and force methods to guide the floorplanning search. Experimental results show that the layouts generated by HiDaP outperforms those obtained by a state-of-the-art EDA physical design software, with similar wirelength and better timing when compared to manually designed tape-out ready macro placements. Layouts obtained by HiDaP have successfully been brought to near timing closure with one to two rounds of small modifications by physical design engineers. HiDaP has been fully integrated in the design flows of the company and its development remains an ongoing effort.A causa de l'increment de la densitat de components en els xip i les noves restriccions de disseny imposades pels últims nodes de fabricació, el rol de l'algorísmia en l'automatització del disseny electrònic ha esdevingut clau per poder implementar circuits integrats. Dos dels passos crucials en el procés de disseny físic és el placement de macros i assegurar la correcció de les regles de disseny un cop les restriccions de timing del circuit són satisfetes. Aquesta tesi proposa contribucions per ajudar en aquests dos reptes, facilitant laboriosos passos manuals en el procés i ajudant als enginyers de disseny físic a obtenir millors resultats en menys temps. La primera contribució és el routing "under-the-cell", una proposta per connectar cel·les estàndard usant pins laterals en les capes de metall inferior de manera sistemàtica. L'objectiu és reduir la congestió en les capes de metall superior causades per l'ús de metall i vies, i així disminuir el nombre de violacions de regles de disseny. Per permetre la connexió lateral de cel·les, estenem una llibreria de cel·les estàndard amb dissenys que incorporen connexions laterals. També proposem modificacions locals al placement per permetre explotar aquest tipus de connexions més sovint. Els resultats experimentals mostren una reducció significativa en el nombre de pins, vies i nombre de violacions de regles de disseny, amb un impacte negligible en wirelength i timing. La segona contribució, desenvolupada en col·laboració amb eSilicon (una empresa capdavantera en disseny ASIC), és el desenvolupament de HiDaP, una eina de macro placement per a dissenys industrials actuals. La proposta segueix un procés multinivell per fer el floorplan de blocks jeràrquics, formats per macros i cel·les estàndard. Mitjançant la informació RTL disponible en la netlist, l'afinitat de dataflow entre els mòduls es modela i minimitza per trobar macro placements amb bones propietats de wirelength i timing. La proposta també incorpora la possibilitat de rebre input addicional de l'enginyer, com ara suggeriments de les posicions de les macros. Finalment, també usa mètodes espectrals i de forçes per guiar la cerca de floorplans. Els resultats experimentals mostren que els dissenys generats amb HiDaP són millors que els obtinguts per eines comercials capdavanteres de EDA. Els resultats també mostren que els dissenys presentats poden obtenir un wirelength similar i millor timing que macro placements obtinguts manualment, usats per fabricació. Alguns dissenys obtinguts per HiDaP s'han dut fins a timing-closure en una o dues rondes de modificacions incrementals per part d'enginyers de disseny físic. L'eina s'ha integrat en el procés de disseny de eSilicon i el seu desenvolupament continua més enllà de les aportacions a aquesta tesi.Postprint (published version

Timing-Driven Macro Placement

Placement is an important step in the process of finding physical layouts for electronic computer chips. The basic task during placement is to arrange the building blocks of the chip, the circuits, disjointly within a given chip area. Furthermore, such positions should result in short circuit interconnections which can be routed easily and which ensure all signals arrive in time. This dissertation mostly focuses on macros, the largest circuits on a chip. In order to optimize timing characteristics during macro placement, we propose a new optimistic timing model based on geometric distance constraints. This model can be computed and evaluated efficiently in order to predict timing traits accurately in practice. Packing rectangles disjointly remains strongly NP-hard under slack maximization in our timing model. Despite of this we develop an exact, linear time algorithm for special cases. The proposed timing model is incorporated into BonnMacro, the macro placement component of the BonnTools physical design optimization suite developed at the Research Institute for Discrete Mathematics. Using efficient formulations as mixed-integer programs we can legalize macros locally while optimizing timing. This results in the first timing-aware macro placement tool. In addition, we provide multiple enhancements for the partitioning-based standard circuit placement algorithm BonnPlace. We find a model of partitioning as minimum-cost flow problem that is provably as small as possible using which we can avoid running time intensive instances. Moreover we propose the new global placement flow Self-Stabilizing BonnPlace. This approach combines BonnPlace with a force-directed placement framework. It provides the flexibility to optimize the two involved objectives, routability and timing, directly during placement. The performance of our placement tools is confirmed on a large variety of academic benchmarks as well as real-world designs provided by our industrial partner IBM. We reduce running time of partitioning significantly and demonstrate that Self-Stabilizing BonnPlace finds easily routable placements for challenging designs – even when simultaneously optimizing timing objectives. BonnMacro and Self-Stabilizing BonnPlace can be combined to the first timing-driven mixed-size placement flow. This combination often finds placements with competitive timing traits and even outperforms solutions that have been determined manually by experienced designers

On the Use of Directed Moves for Placement in VLSI CAD

Search-based placement methods have long been used for placing integrated circuits targeting the field programmable gate array (FPGA) and standard cell design styles. Such methods offer the potential for high-quality solutions but often come at the cost of long run-times compared to alternative methods. This dissertation examines strategies for enhancing local search heuristics---and in particular, simulated annealing---through the application of directed moves. These moves help to guide a search-based optimizer by focusing efforts on states which are most likely to yield productive improvement, effectively pruning the size of the search space. The engineering theory and implementation details of directed moves are discussed in the context of both field programmable gate array and standard cell designs. This work explores the ways in which such moves can be used to improve the quality of FPGA placements, improve the robustness of floorplan repair and legalization methods for mixed-size standard cell designs, and enhance the quality of detailed placement for standard cell circuits. The analysis presented herein confirms the validity and efficacy of directed moves, and supports the use of such heuristics within various optimization frameworks

Floorplan-guided placement for large-scale mixed-size designs

In the nanometer scale era, placement has become an extremely challenging stage in modern Very-Large-Scale Integration (VLSI) designs. Millions of objects need to be placed legally within a chip region, while both the interconnection and object distribution have to be optimized simultaneously. Due to the extensive use of Intellectual Property (IP) and embedded memory blocks, a design usually contains tens or even hundreds of big macros. A design with big movable macros and numerous standard cells is known as mixed-size design. Due to the big size difference between big macros and standard cells, the placement of mixed-size designs is much more difficult than the standard-cell placement. This work presents an efficient and high-quality placement tool to handle modern large-scale mixed-size designs. This tool is developed based on a new placement algorithm flow. The main idea is to use the fixed-outline floorplanning algorithm to guide the state-of-the-art analytical placer. This new flow consists of four steps: 1) The objects in the original netlist are clustered into blocks; 2) Floorplanning is performed on the blocks; 3) The blocks are shifted within the chip region to further optimize the wirelength; 4) With big macro locations fixed, incremental placement is applied to place the remaining objects. Several key techniques are proposed to be used in the first two steps. These techniques are mainly focused on the following two aspects: 1) Hypergraph clustering algorithm that can cut down the original problem size without loss of placement Quality of Results (QoR); 2) Fixed-outline floorplanning algorithm that can provide a good guidance to the analytical placer at the global level. The effectiveness of each key technique is demonstrated by promising experimental results compared with the state-of-the-art algorithms. Moreover, using the industrial mixed-size designs, the new placement tool shows better performance than other existing approaches

Broadening the Scope of Multi-Objective Optimizations in Physical Synthesis of Integrated Circuits.

In modern VLSI design, physical synthesis tools are primarily responsible for satisfying chip-performance constraints by invoking a broad range of circuit optimizations, such as buffer insertion, logic restructuring, gate sizing and relocation. This process is known as timing closure. Our research seeks more powerful and efficient optimizations to improve the state of the art in modern chip design. In particular, we integrate timing-driven relocation, retiming, logic cloning, buffer insertion and gate sizing in novel ways to create powerful circuit transformations that help satisfy setup-time constraints. State-of-the-art physical synthesis optimizations are typically applied at two scales: i) global algorithms that affect the entire netlist and ii) local transformations that focus on a handful of gates or interconnections. The scale of modern chip designs dictates that only near-linear-time optimization algorithms can be applied at the global scope — typically limited to wirelength-driven placement and legalization. Localized transformations can rely on more time-consuming optimizations with accurate delay models. Few techniques bridge the gap between fully-global and localized optimizations. This dissertation broadens the scope of physical synthesis optimization to include accurate transformations operating between the global and local scales. In particular, we integrate groups of related transformations to break circular dependencies and increase the number of circuit elements that can be jointly optimized to escape local minima. Integrated transformations in this dissertation are developed by identifying and removing obstacles to successful optimizations. Integration is achieved through mapping multiple operations to rigorous mathematical optimization problems that can be solved simultaneously. We achieve computational scalability in our techniques by leveraging analytical delay models and focusing optimization efforts on carefully selected regions of the chip. In this regard, we make extensive use of a linear interconnect-delay model that accounts for the impact of subsequent repeated insertion. Our integrated transformations are evaluated on high-performance circuits with over 100,000 gates. Integrated optimization techniques described in this dissertation ensure graceful timing-closure process and impact nearly every aspect of a typical physical synthesis flow. They have been validated in EDA tools used at IBM for physical synthesis of high-performance CPU and ASIC designs, where they significantly improved chip performance.Ph.D.Computer Science & EngineeringUniversity of Michigan, Horace H. Rackham School of Graduate Studieshttp://deepblue.lib.umich.edu/bitstream/2027.42/78744/1/iamyou_1.pd

Solving Hard Instances of Floorplacement

Physical Design of modern systems on chip is extremely challenging. Such digital integrated circuits often contain tens of millions of logic gates, intellectual property blocks, embedded memories and custom RTL blocks. At current and future technology nodes, their power and performance are impacted, more than ever, by the placement of their modules. However, our experiments show that traditional techniques for placement and floorplanning, and existing academic tools cannot reliably solve the placement task. To study this problem, we identify particularly difficult industrial instances and reproduce the failures of existing tools by modifying public-domain netlists. Furthermore, we propose algorithms that facilitate floorplacement of these difficult instances. Empirically, our techniques consistently produced legal placements, and on instances where comparison is possible, reduced wirelength by 3.5% over Capo 9.4 and 14.5 % over PATOMA 1.0 — the pre-existing tools that most frequently produced legal placements in our experiments