Efficient Automated Driving Strategies Leveraging Anticipation and Optimal Control

Automated vehicles and advanced driver assistance systems bring computation, sensing, and communication technologies that exceed human abilities in some ways. For example, automated vehicles may sense a panorama all at once, do not suffer from human impairments and distractions, and could wirelessly communicate precise data with neighboring vehicles. Prototype and commercial deployments have demonstrated the capability to relieve human operators of some driving tasks up to and including fully autonomous taxi rides in some areas. The ultimate impact of this technology’s large-scale market penetration on energy efficiency remains unclear, with potential negative factors like road use by empty vehicles competing with positive ones like automatic eco-driving. Fundamentally enabled by historic and look-ahead data, this dissertation addresses the use of automated driving and driver assistance to optimize vehicle motion for energy efficiency. Facets of this problem include car following, co-optimized acceleration and lane change planning, and collaborative multi-agent guidance. Optimal control, especially model predictive control, is used extensively to improve energy efficiency while maintaining safe and timely driving via constraints. Techniques including chance constraints and mixed integer programming help overcome uncertainty and non-convexity challenges. Extensions of these techniques to tractor trailers on sloping roads are provided by making use of linear parameter-varying models. To approach the wheel-input energy eco-driving problem over generally shaped sloping roads with the computational potential for closed-loop implementation, a linear programming formulation is constructed. Distributed and collaborative techniques that enable connected and automated vehicles to accommodate their neighbors in traffic are also explored and compared to centralized control. Using simulations and vehicle-in-the-loop car following experiments, the proposed algorithms are benchmarked against others that do not make use of look-ahead information

Impacts of Connected and Automated Vehicles on Energy and Traffic Flow: Optimal Control Design and Verification Through Field Testing

This dissertation assesses eco-driving effectiveness in several key traffic scenarios that include passenger vehicle transportation in highway driving and urban driving that also includes interactions with traffic signals, as well as heavy-duty line-haul truck transportation in highway driving with significant road grade. These studies are accomplished through both traffic microsimulation that propagates individual vehicle interactions to synthesize large-scale traffic patterns that emerge from the eco-driving strategies, and through experimentation in which real prototyped connected and automated vehicles (CAVs) are utilized to directly measure energy benefits from the designed eco-driving control strategies. In particular, vehicle-in-the-loop is leveraged for the CAVs driven on a physical test track to interact with surrounding traffic that is virtually realized through said microsimulation software in real time. In doing so, model predictive control is designed and implemented to create performative eco-driving policies and to select vehicle lane, as well as enforce safety constraints while autonomously driving a real vehicle. Ultimately, eco-driving policies are both simulated and experimentally vetted in a variety of typical driving scenarios to show up to a 50% boost in fuel economy when switching to CAV drivers without compromising traffic flow. The first part of this dissertation specifically assesses energy efficiency of connected and automated passenger vehicles that exploit intention-sharing sourced from both neighboring vehicles in a highway scene and from traffic lights in an urban scene. Linear model predictive control is implemented for CAV motion planning, whereby chance constraints are introduced to balance between traffic compactness and safety, and integer decision variables are introduced for lane selection and collision avoidance in multi-lane environments. Validation results are shown from both large-scale microsimulation and through experimentation of real prototyped CAVs. The second part of this dissertation then assesses energy efficiency of automated line-haul trucks when tasked to aerodynamically platoon. Nonlinear model predictive control is implemented for motion planning, and simulation and experimentation are conducted for platooning verification under highway conditions with traffic. Then, interaction-aware and intention-sharing cooperative control is further introduced to eliminate experimentally measured platoon disengagements that occur on real highways when using only status-sharing control. Finally, the performance of automated drivers versus human drivers are compared in a point-to-point scenario to verify fundamental eco-driving impacts -- experimentally showing eco-driving to boost energy economy by 11% on average even in simple driving scenarios

An Optimization Approach for Energy Efficient Coordination Control of Vehicles in Merging Highways

Environmental concerns along with stronger governmental regulations regarding automotive fuel-economy and greenhouse-gas emissions are contributing to the push for development of more sustainable transportation technologies. Furthermore, the widespread use of the automobile gives rise to other issues such as traffic congestion and increasing traffic accidents. Consequently, two main goals of new technologies are the reduction of vehicle fuel consumption and emissions and the reduction of traffic congestion. While an extensive list of published work addresses the problem of fuel consumption reduction by optimizing the vehicle powertrain operations, particularly in the case of hybrid electric vehicles (HEV), approaches like eco-driving and traffic coordination have been studied more recently as alternative methods that can, in addition, address the problem of traffic congestion and traffic accidents reduction. This dissertation builds on some of those approaches, with particular emphasis on autonomous vehicle coordination control. In this direction, the objective is to derive an optimization approach for energy efficient and safe coordination control of vehicles in merging highways. Most of the current optimization-based centralized approaches to this problem are solved numerically, at the expense of a high computational load which limits their potential for real-time implementation. In addition, closed-form solutions, which are desired to facilitate traffic analysis and the development of approaches to address interconnected merging/intersection points and achieve further traffic improvements at the road-network level, are very limited in the literature. In this dissertation, through the application of the Pontryagin’s minimum principle, a closed-form solution is obtained which allows the implementation of a real-time centralized optimal control for fleets of vehicles. The results of applying the proposed framework show that the system can reduce the fuel consumption by up to 50% and the travel time by an average of 6.9% with respect to a scenario with not coordination strategy. By integrating the traffic coordination scheme with in-vehicle energy management, a two level optimization system is achieved which allows assessing the benefits of integrating hybrid electric vehicles into the road network. Regarding in-vehicle energy optimization, four methods are developed to improve the tuning process of the equivalent consumption optimization strategy (ECMS). First, two model predictive control (MPC)-based strategies are implemented and the results show improvements in the efficiency obtained with the standard ECMS implementation. On the other hand, the research efforts focus in performing analysis of the engine and electric motor operating points which can lead to the optimal tuning of the ECMS with reduced iterations. Two approaches are evaluated and even though the results in fuel economy are slightly worse than those for the standard ECMS, they show potential to significantly reduce the tuning time of the ECMS. Additionally, the benefits of having less aggressive driving profiles on different powertrain technologies such as conventional, plug-in hybrid and electric vehicles are studied

Optimal trajectory planning meets network-level routing: Integrated control framework for emerging mobility systems

In this paper, we introduce a hierarchical decision-making framework for emerging mobility systems. Despite numerous studies focusing on optimizing vehicle flow, practical feasibility has often been overlooked. To address this gap, we present a route-recovery method and energy-optimal trajectory planning tailored for connected and automated vehicles (CAVs) to ensure the realization of optimal flow. Our approach identifies the optimal vehicle flow to minimize total travel time while considering consistent mobility demands in urban settings. We deploy a heuristic route-recovery algorithm that assigns routes to CAVs and departure/arrival time at each road segment. Furthermore, we propose an efficient coordination method that rapidly solves constrained optimization problems by flexibly piecing together unconstrained energy-optimal trajectories. The proposed method has the potential to effectively generate optimal vehicle flow, contributing to the reduction of travel time and energy consumption in urban areas.Comment: 17 pages, 11 figure

Optimal speed trajectory and energy management control for connected and automated vehicles

Connected and automated vehicles (CAVs) emerge as a promising solution to improve urban mobility, safety, energy efficiency, and passenger comfort with the development of communication technologies, such as vehicle-to-vehicle (V2V) and vehicle-to-infrastructure (V2I). This thesis proposes several control approaches for CAVs with electric powertrains, including hybrid electric vehicles (HEVs) and battery electric vehicles (BEVs), with the main objective to improve energy efficiency by optimising vehicle speed trajectory and energy management system. By types of vehicle control, these methods can be categorised into three main scenarios, optimal energy management for a single CAV (single-vehicle), energy-optimal strategy for the vehicle following scenario (two-vehicle), and optimal autonomous intersection management for CAVs (multiple-vehicle). The first part of this thesis is devoted to the optimal energy management for a single automated series HEV with consideration of engine start-stop system (SSS) under battery charge sustaining operation. A heuristic hysteresis power threshold strategy (HPTS) is proposed to optimise the fuel economy of an HEV with SSS and extra penalty fuel for engine restarts. By a systematic tuning process, the overall control performance of HPTS can be fully optimised for different vehicle parameters and driving cycles. In the second part, two energy-optimal control strategies via a model predictive control (MPC) framework are proposed for the vehicle following problem. To forecast the behaviour of the preceding vehicle, a neural network predictor is utilised and incorporated into a nonlinear MPC method, of which the fuel and computational efficiencies are verified to be effective through comparisons of numerical examples between a practical adaptive cruise control strategy and an impractical optimal control method. A robust MPC (RMPC) via linear matrix inequality (LMI) is also utilised to deal with the uncertainties existing in V2V communication and modelling errors. By conservative relaxation and approximation, the RMPC problem is formulated as a convex semi-definite program, and the simulation results prove the robustness of the RMPC and the rapid computational efficiency resorting to the convex optimisation. The final part focuses on the centralised and decentralised control frameworks at signal-free intersections, where the energy consumption and the crossing time of a group of CAVs are minimised. Their crossing order and velocity trajectories are optimised by convex second-order cone programs in a hierarchical scheme subject to safety constraints. It is shown that the centralised strategy with consideration of turning manoeuvres is effective and outperforms a benchmark solution invoking the widely used first-in-first-out policy. On the other hand, the decentralised method is proposed to further improve computational efficiency and enhance the system robustness via a tube-based RMPC. The numerical examples of both frameworks highlight the importance of examining the trade-off between energy consumption and travel time, as small compromises in travel time could produce significant energy savings.Open Acces

Saving Fuel for Heavy-Duty Vehicles Using Connectivity and Automation

The booming of e-commerce is placing an increasing burden on freight transport system by demanding faster and larger amount of delivery. Despite the variety in freight transport means, the dominant freight transport method is still ground transport, or specifically, transport by heavy-duty vehicles. Roughly one-third of the annual ground freight transport expense goes to fuel expenses. If fuel costs could be reduced, the finance of freight transport would be improved and may increase the transport volume without additional charge to average consumers. A further benefit of reducing fuel consumption would be the related environmental impact. The fuel consumption of the heavy-duty vehicles, despite being the minority of road vehicles, has a major influence on the whole transportation sector, which is a major contributor to greenhouse gas emissions. Thus, saving fuel for heavy-duty trucks would also reduce greenhouse gas emission, leading to environmental benefits. For decades, researchers and engineers have been seeking to improve the fuel economy of heavy-duty vehicles by focusing on vehicles themselves, working on advancing the vehicle design in many aspects. More recently, attention has turned to improve fuel efficiency while driving in the dynamic traffic environment. Fuel savings effort may be realized due to advancements in connected and automated vehicle technologies, which provide more information for vehicle design and control. This dissertation presents state-of-the-art techniques that utilize connectivity and automation to improve the fuel economy of heavy-duty vehicles, while allowing them to stay safe in real-world traffic environments. These techniques focus on three different levels of vehicle control, and can result in significant fuel improvements at each level. Starting at the powertrain level, a gear shift schedule design approach is proposed based on hybrid system theory. The resulting design improves fuel economy without comprising driveability. This new approach also unifies the gear shift logic design of human-driven and automated vehicles, and shows a large potential in fuel saving when enhanced with higher level connectivity and automation. With this potential in mind, at the vehicle level, a fuel-efficient predictive cruise control algorithm is presented. This mechanism takes into account road elevation, wind, and aggregated traffic information acquired via connectivity. Moreover, a systematic tool to tune the optimization parameters to prioritize different objectives is developed. While the algorithm and the tool are shown to be beneficial for heavy-duty vehicles when they are in mild traffic, such benefits may not be attainable when the traffic is dense. Thus, at the traffic level, when a heavy-duty vehicle needs to interact with surrounding vehicles in dense traffic, a connected cruise control algorithm is proposed. This algorithm utilizes beyond-line-of-sight information, acquired through vehicle-to-vehicle communication, to gain a better understanding of the surrounding traffic so that the vehicle can response to traffic in a fuel efficient way. These techniques can bring substantial fuel economy improvements when applied individually. In practice, it is important to integrate these three techniques at different levels in a safe manner, so as to acquire the overall benefits. To achieve this, a safety verification method is developed for the connected cruise control, to coordinate the algorithms at the vehicle level and the traffic level, maximizing the fuel benefits while staying safe.PHDMechanical EngineeringUniversity of Michigan, Horace H. Rackham School of Graduate Studieshttps://deepblue.lib.umich.edu/bitstream/2027.42/147523/1/hchaozhe_1.pd