10 research outputs found
Guiding Students to Success: A Systematic Review of Research on Guided Notes as an Instructional Strategy from 2009-2019
Guided notes were introduced decades ago, but there is still debate over their efficacy in improving student outcomes. The purpose of this study is to examine peer-reviewed research on guided notes for adult learners in general populations since 2009, understanding the effects of guided notes on student learning, the knowledge and content areas supported by guided notes, and the impact of modality. Results of the 22 included studies indicate that students perceive guided notes in a positive light, and guided notes improve results in certain knowledge domains especially with complex content. However, modality does not influence the efficacy of guided notes. Implications for practice in teaching and learning and recommendations for research were provided
Are undergraduate students studying smart? Insights into study strategies and habits across a programme of study
The approach that students take in their studies at university is critical not only for their academic success but is equally important in life-long learning for their career and professional development. Heutagogy is the study of self-determined learning and it is important that we appraise how students in higher education are developing their metacognitive awareness in how they learn and study effectively. Cognitive science is an interdisciplinary research area that involves the scientific study of the human mind. It helps provide new knowledge in relation to areas such as memory, problem solving, knowledge transfer and understanding of complex topics. Cognitive science has demonstrated that re-testing oneself on material when learning, enhances and promotes greater retention of knowledge compared to re-reading the material. Learning that is distributed or spaced out over multiple study sessions also allows for greater retention of knowledge in the longer-term compared to âcrammingâ of information. To evaluate the use of effective study approaches and habits across three different levels of study in an undergraduate pharmacy programme, a survey study was employed. A paper-based survey was completed by first-, second- and third-year undergraduate pharmacy students (n=192) during class sessions. Although there was some evidence of metacognitive awareness such as using testing (retrieval practice) with practice problems; across all years, suboptimal study approaches such as rereading, copying notes and cramming were endorsed. A schedule of deadlines shaped the organisation of study and time management for most students. Self-testing was predominantly used to test learning rather than an approach used during learning. There was evidence of a difference between the cohorts in relation to decisions for prioritizing studying, returning to review course material and re-reading. The evidence from this study demonstrates that learners would require training on metacognitive awareness and effective study strategies to enable their self-determined learning capabilities to evolve. The linear progression through a programme of study alone will not achieve this. There is a need to embed and emphasize effective strategies for learning into curricula and for faculty to utilise metacognitive awareness in their teaching
Are undergraduate students studying smart? Insights into study strategies and habits across a programme of study
This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, to view a copy of the license, see: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ https://doi.org/10.53761/1.19.2.8The approach that students take in their studies at university is critical not only for their academic success but is equally important in life-long learning for their career and professional development. Heutagogy is the study of self-determined learning and it is important that we appraise how students in higher education are developing their metacognitive awareness in how they learn and study effectively. Cognitive science is an interdisciplinary research area that involves the scientific study of the human mind. It helps provide new knowledge in relation to areas such as memory, problem solving, knowledge transfer and understanding of complex topics. Cognitive science has demonstrated that re-testing oneself on material when learning, enhances and promotes greater retention of knowledge compared to re-reading the material. Learning that is distributed or spaced out over multiple study sessions also allows for greater retention of knowledge in the longer-term compared to âcrammingâ of information. To evaluate the use of effective study approaches and habits across three different levels of study in an undergraduate pharmacy programme, a survey study was employed. A paper-based survey was completed by first-, second- and third-year undergraduate pharmacy students (n=192) during class sessions. Although there was some evidence of metacognitive awareness such as using testing (retrieval practice) with practice problems; across all years, suboptimal study approaches such as rereading, copying notes and cramming were endorsed. A schedule of deadlines shaped the organisation of study and time management for most students. Self-testing was predominantly used to test learning rather than an approach used during learning. There was evidence of a difference between the cohorts in relation to decisions for prioritizing studying, returning to review course material and re-reading. The evidence from this study demonstrates that learners would require training on metacognitive awareness and effective study strategies to enable their self-determined learning capabilities to evolve. The linear progression through a programme of study alone will not achieve this. There is a need to embed and emphasize effective strategies for learning into curricula and for faculty to utilise metacognitive awareness in their teaching.Peer reviewe
Note-taking and the decision to externalize memory
The purpose of this dissertation was to examine the relationship between note-taking and learning, particularly as it relates to the use of technology in the classroom. Two laboratory studies explore how taking and saving notes on a computer impacts memory for facts and the folders where notes for those facts are stored. A qualitative study provided an updated look at how students think about note-taking and how technology affects their note-taking habits. Another laboratory study explored the difference in recall for facts and folders when notes were taken by hand on note-cards and saved in physical folders or on a computer and saved in digital folders. The first two studies found that the act of choosing where to save notes improved memory for folders while decreasing memory for difficult facts. These results held true regardless of whether participants believed they would be able to use their notes. The qualitative study found that 10 out of the 14 students who were interviewed emphasized the process rather than the product of note-taking and most interviewed students (12 out of 14) altered their note-taking behavior if instructors posted lecture slides online. The final study found that memory for facts and folders was marginally better for participants who handwrote their notes but it may be because they spent more time completing the task
Videos, audio clips, and text materials: an investigation of media use in psychology learning
A variety of media are used in undergraduate psychology educationâfrom the traditional text
materials to videos. Research has identified multimedia materials, those that convey information through words and pictures, as particularly helpful for learning (e.g., Mayer, 1989; Mayer & Anderson, 1991), but it is not clear in what context multimedia are superior over single-medium materials. It is also unclear how experiences with all media can be supported to ensure learners understand the relevant information conveyed. The wide range of multimedia materials available and the unique nature of different content within psychology create a complex issue worthy of more research. The first two studies discussed herein use videos commonly used in Introduction to Psychology courses and compare learning outcomes of those videos as compared to their single-medium formats. The second study also investigates the impact of instructional support (i.e., advance organizers) on learning outcomes for each medium. The third study focuses on a different type of video used in Introduction to Psychology courses and examines the impact of two instructional supports (i.e., advance organizers and guidance embedded in the video) on learning outcomes. Findings suggest students perform well when taught through multimedia as well as single-medium formats for both retention and application instructional goals. However, advance organizers that emphasize key concepts and encourage note-taking prove to be particularly helpful for instruction that is in audio-only or text-only formats. Implications for media use and design in psychology instruction are discussed
Providing Intelligent and Adaptive Support in Concept Map-based Learning Environments
abstract: Concept maps are commonly used knowledge visualization tools and have been shown to have a positive impact on learning. The main drawbacks of concept mapping are the requirement of training, and lack of feedback support. Thus, prior research has attempted to provide support and feedback in concept mapping, such as by developing computer-based concept mapping tools, offering starting templates and navigational supports, as well as providing automated feedback. Although these approaches have achieved promising results, there are still challenges that remain to be solved. For example, there is a need to create a concept mapping system that reduces the extraneous effort of editing a concept map while encouraging more cognitively beneficial behaviors. Also, there is little understanding of the cognitive process during concept mapping. Whatâs more, current feedback mechanisms in concept mapping only focus on the outcome of the map, instead of the learning process.
This thesis work strives to solve the fundamental research question: How to leverage computer technologies to intelligently support concept mapping to promote meaningful learning? To approach this research question, I first present an intelligent concept mapping system, MindDot, that supports concept mapping via innovative integration of two features, hyperlink navigation, and expert template. The system reduces the effort of creating and modifying concept maps while encouraging beneficial activities such as comparing related concepts and establishing relationships among them. I then present the comparative strategy metric that modes student learning by evaluating behavioral patterns and learning strategies. Lastly, I develop an adaptive feedback system that provides immediate diagnostic feedback in response to both the key learning behaviors during concept mapping and the correctness and completeness of the created maps.
Empirical evaluations indicated that the integrated navigational and template support in MindDot fostered effective learning behaviors and facilitating learning achievements. The comparative strategy model was shown to be highly representative of learning characteristics such as motivation, engagement, misconceptions, and predicted learning results. The feedback tutor also demonstrated positive impacts on supporting learning and assisting the development of effective learning strategies that prepare learners for future learning. This dissertation contributes to the field of supporting concept mapping with designs of technological affordances, a process-based student model, an adaptive feedback tutor, empirical evaluations of these proposed innovations, and implications for future support in concept mapping.Dissertation/ThesisDoctoral Dissertation Computer Science 201
Recommended from our members
Student-Âsummarized videos in an Adaptive and Collaborative E-learning Environment (ACES)
The purpose of this research was to develop a collaborative e-Learning framework using summarised videos as learning media to provide a more efficient learning experience where participantsâ engagement and motivations are enhanced. The research aims to increase participantsâ overall learning level, understanding level; motivation and communication skills.
For this research, a collaborative environment has been built where students participate in a video sharing system allowing them to create their own summarized
Videos from existing course video material. Students can then share these videos with other system participants with the ability to view, rate and comment on videos. Instructors upload the core video footage, which the students are able to edit and summarize.
Two experiments were run with live modules within the Department of Informatics; a pilot study and full experiment. Feedback from the pilot study was used to develop the framework for the full study. The experiments involved pre and post participation surveys to measure satisfaction and awareness effects. Also, system participation data was used for analysis of engagement and other factors defining the outcomes of this experiment.
The findings showed a considerable increase in student satisfaction regarding their understanding and motivation with video summarization tool used in the experiments. The results of [the] collaboration aspect of the experiment showed a slight increase in their satisfaction on their learning level, however, it had minimal effect on studentsâ motivation and engagement as no significant difference was noted after using the system
ComprĂ©hension et stratĂ©gies dâexploration des documents pĂ©dagogiques illustrĂ©s
It is easier today to offer in one informative document many sources of information presented in different formats. Presenting various media can bring benefits in terms of learning performance, but dealing effectively with these different sources of information is complex. Therefore, offering documents guiding the learner when he is reading may be necessary to promote the construction of a qualitative mental model. Empirical studies that are conducted during this thesis endeavour to determine which formats are most effective while gradually increasing guidance within the document. Thus, four items are tested: the position of the picture relative to the text, the effect of the instructions, the text segmentation and the introduction of a guidance through a figure-ground contrast. Moreover, in order to bring new elements of reflection about how people explore an informative document and the impact of these strategies on performance, the eye movements of the learners were recorded. The results showed that changes in the format of information have an impact on the strategies of consultation of the document, including the increasing eye transitions between texts and illustrations. However, only the segmentation of the text in the form of semantic paragraphs brought benefits in terms of understandingIl est aujourdâhui plus aisĂ© de proposer dans un mĂȘme document dâapprentissage de nombreuses sources dâinformation prĂ©sentĂ©es sous des formats diffĂ©rents. Si prĂ©senter plusieurs mĂ©dias peut apporter des bĂ©nĂ©fices en termes de performances dâapprentissage, traiter efficacement ces diffĂ©rentes sources dâinformation est une activitĂ© complexe. Câest pourquoi, proposer des documents guidant lâapprenant lors de sa consultation peut sâavĂ©rer nĂ©cessaire afin de favoriser la construction dâun modĂšle mental de qualitĂ©. Les Ă©tudes empiriques menĂ©es au cours de cette thĂšse se sont attachĂ©es Ă dĂ©terminer quels formats Ă©taient les plus efficaces tout en augmentant progressivement le guidage au sein du document. Ainsi, ont Ă©tĂ© testĂ©s : la position de lâillustration par rapport au texte, lâeffet de la consigne, la segmentation du texte et lâintroduction dâun guidage via un contraste figure/fond. De plus, afin dâapporter de nouveaux Ă©lĂ©ments de rĂ©flexion quant Ă la maniĂšre dont les individus explorent un document dâapprentissage et lâimpact de ces stratĂ©gies sur les performances, les mouvements oculaires des apprenants ont Ă©tĂ© enregistrĂ©s. Les rĂ©sultats obtenus ont mis en Ă©vidence que les modifications du format de prĂ©sentation des informations avaient un impact sur les stratĂ©gies de consultation du document notamment sur lâaugmentation des transitions oculaires effectuĂ©es entre les textes et les illustrations. Cependant, seule la segmentation du texte sous forme de paragraphes sĂ©mantiques a permis dâobtenir des bĂ©nĂ©fices en termes de comprĂ©hension
Reciprocal teaching: investigation of its effectiveness as a method of whole class reading comprehension instruction at Key stage two
Reciprocal Teaching (RT) is a metacognitive training programme that was found to improve reading comprehension during the 1980s (Palincsar and Brown, 1984). Four strategies: predicting, clarifying, questioning and summarising are taught, then students gradually assume control of teaching within a heterogeneous small group until they are actively involved in constructing meaning from text. A review of the literature revealed that there is âvery littleâ research on RT in the UK (Brooks, 2013), little research worldwide in whole class settings, and little evidence that RT is effective for children under twelve (Cain, 2010). Three intervention studies presented here investigated the effectiveness of RT in whole class UK settings with young readers, and the effect of incorporating visualisation as an additional strategy (RTV). Study 1 was delivered by the researcher with three Year 5 classes (N=50). Results revealed a significant improvement in comprehension scores for the RT groups over a normal instruction group after ten hours of training, but no difference between the RT and RTV groups. A second mixed-methods study (Study 2) involved Year 3 children (N=12) with ten weeks of RT instruction, followed by ten weeks of RTV, delivered by the class teacher. Think-aloud protocols and interviews revealed an increase in strategy use. There was a significant improvement in reading comprehension scores immediately after the intervention, and a one year follow-up assessment showed improvement close to significance (p=.09). The third study (Study 3) in a different school with Year 3 children (N=28), replicated the results from Study 2, but with a significant increase in reading comprehension scores at the one-year follow-up assessment. Overall, the results revealed that RT was effective in three different whole class settings, with children as young as seven. Qualitative measures indicated that the instruction worked by increasing strategy use