Oscillation Control Algorithms for Resonant Sensors with Applications to Vibratory Gyroscopes

We present two oscillation control algorithms for resonant sensors such as vibratory gyroscopes. One control algorithm tracks the resonant frequency of the resonator and the other algorithm tunes it to the specified resonant frequency by altering the resonator dynamics. Both algorithms maintain the specified amplitude of oscillations. The stability of each of the control systems is analyzed using the averaging method, and quantitative guidelines are given for selecting the control gains needed to achieve stability. The effects of displacement measurement noise on the accuracy of tracking and estimation of the resonant frequency are also analyzed. The proposed control algorithms are applied to two important problems in a vibratory gyroscope. The first is the leading-following resonator problem in the drive axis of MEMS dual-mass vibratory gyroscope where there is no mechanical linkage between the two proof-masses and the second is the on-line modal frequency matching problem in a general vibratory gyroscope. Simulation results demonstrate that the proposed control algorithms are effective. They ensure the proof-masses to oscillate in an anti-phase manner with the same resonant frequency and oscillation amplitude in a dual-mass gyroscope, and two modal frequencies to match in a general vibratory gyroscope

Characterization of MEMS Coriolis Vibratory Gyroscopes

A MEMS Gyroscope is a micromachined inertial sensor that can measure the angle of orientation or the angular rate of rotation. These devices have the potential to be used in high precision navigation, safety and consumer electronics applications. Due to their complexity, MEMS Gyroscopes are prone to have imperfections that inhibit their full potential. By deeply characterizing these sensors, it is possible to validate fabrication methodologies, apply control circuit mechanisms, and design alternative mechanical structures that improve the performance. In this project, a streamlined methodology for testing and characterizing these devices is presented and executed. Analysis to the obtained results is given. Aditionally, a prototype circuit was designed to operate the sensors in a closed-loop mode. Two families of gyroscopes with different thickness were characterized - 40 m and 100 m. The devices presented low sensitivity thresholds due to the presence of a large quadrature error. A phase sensitive demodulation solution was provided to eliminate this noise source. The 40 m presented an overall better performance. A Python Script to extract key noise performance parameters was also displayed.Giroscópios MEMS são micro sensores inerciais que conseguem medir o ângulo de orientação ou a variação ângular de uma rotação. Estes dispositivos têm o potencial de ser usados em aplicações de alta precisão para sistemas de navegação, segurança e para eletrónica comercial. Devido à sua complexidade, os Giroscópios MEMS são propensos a imperfeições que inibem o seu potencial máximo. Através da caracterização extensa destes sensores, é possível validar as metodologias de fabricação, aplicar circuitos de controlo e projetar estruturas mecânicas alternativas que melhorem a sua performance. Neste projeto é apresentada uma metodologia substanciada para testar e caracterizar estes dispositivos. Os resultados obtidos foram analisados. Adicionalmente, foi desenhado um protótipo de um circuito que opera os sensores em circuito fechado. Duas famílias de giroscópios com diferentes espessuras foram caracterizadas - 40 m e 100 m. Os dispositivos apresentaram baixos graus de sensibilidade devido a uma forte influência do erro de quadratura. Foi aplicada uma demodulação sensível à fase para melhoramento da performance. Um programa em Python para extrair parâmetros de ruído na resposta é apresentado

Adaptive Control of a Vibratory Angle Measuring Gyroscope

This paper presents an adaptive control algorithm for realizing a vibratory angle measuring gyroscope so that rotation angle can be directly measured without integration of angular rate, thus eliminating the accumulation of numerical integration errors. The proposed control algorithm uses a trajectory following approach and the reference trajectory is generated by an ideal angle measuring gyroscope driven by the estimate of angular rate and the auxiliary sinusoidal input so that the persistent excitation condition is satisfied. The developed control algorithm can compensate for all types of fabrication imperfections such as coupled damping and stiffness, and mismatched stiffness and un-equal damping term in an on-line fashion. The simulation results show the feasibility and effectiveness of the developed control algorithm that is capable of directly measuring rotation angle without the integration of angular rate

Characterization, Control and Compensation of MEMS Rate and Rate-Integrating Gyroscopes.

Inertial sensing has important applications in navigation, safety, and entertainment. Areas of active research include improved device structures, control schemes, tuning methods, and detection paradigms. A powerful and flexible characterization and control system built on commercial programmable hardware is especially needed for studying mode-matched gyroscopes and rate-integrated gyroscopes. A gyroscope can be operated in a mode-matched rate-mode for increased sensitivity or rate-integrating mode for greatly increased dynamic range and bandwidth, however control is challenging and the performance is sensitive to the matching of the modes. This thesis proposes a system built on open and inexpensive software-defined radio (SDR) hardware and open source software for gyroscope characterization and control. The characterization system measures ring-down of devices with damping times and automatically tunes the vibration modes from over 40 Hz mismatch to better than 100 mHz in 3 minutes. When used for rate-gyroscope operation the system provides an FPGA implementation of rate gyroscope control with amplitude, rate and quadrature closed-loop control in the SDR hardware which demonstrates 400% improvement in noise and stability over open-loop operation. The system also operates in a RIG mode with hybrid software/firmware control and demonstrates continuous operation for several hours, unlike previous systems which are limited by the gyroscope ring-down time. The hybrid mode also has a simulation module for development of advanced gyroscope control algorithms. Advanced controls proposed for RIG operation show over 1000% improvement in effective frequency and damping mismatch in simulation and 25% reduction in drift due to damping mismatch in a test RIG. By tuning the compensation, the drift can be reduced by almost 90%, with worst case drift decreased to -41 deg/s and RMS drift to -21 deg/s. Harmonic analysis of the anisotropy in a rate-integrating gyroscope measured with this control system is presented to guide development of new error models which will further improve performance.PHDElectrical EngineeringUniversity of Michigan, Horace H. Rackham School of Graduate Studieshttp://deepblue.lib.umich.edu/bitstream/2027.42/96121/1/jagregor_1.pd

Development of dynamic model and control techniques for microelectromechanical gyroscopes

In this thesis we investigate the effects of stiffness, damping and temperature on the performance of a MEMS vibratory gyroscope. The stiffness and damping parameters are chosen because they can be appropriately designed to synchronize the drive and sense mode resonance to enhance the sensitivity and stability of MEMS gyroscope. Our results show that increasing the drive axis stiffness from its tuned value by 50%, reduces the sense mode magnitude by ~27% and augments the resonance frequency by ~21%. The stiffness and damping are mildly sensitive to typical variations in operating temperature. The stiffness decreases by 0.30%, while the damping increases by 3.81% from their initial values, when the temperature is raised from -40 to 60C. Doubling the drive mode damping from its tuned value reduces the oscillation magnitude by 10%, but ~0.20% change in the resonance frequency. The predicted effects of stiffness, damping and temperature can be utilized to design a gyroscope for the desired operating condition

CMOS systems and circuits for sub-degree per hour MEMS gyroscopes

The objective of our research is to develop system architectures and CMOS circuits that interface with high-Q silicon microgyroscopes to implement navigation-grade angular rate sensors. The MEMS sensor used in this work is an in-plane bulk-micromachined mode-matched tuning fork gyroscope (M² – TFG ), fabricated on silicon-on-insulator substrate. The use of CMOS transimpedance amplifiers (TIA) as front-ends in high-Q MEMS resonant sensors is explored. A T-network TIA is proposed as the front-end for resonant capacitive detection. The T-TIA provides on-chip transimpedance gains of 25MΩ, has a measured capacitive resolution of 0.02aF /√Hz at 15kHz, a dynamic range of 104dB in a bandwidth of 10Hz and consumes 400μW of power. A second contribution is the development of an automated scheme to adaptively bias the mechanical structure, such that the sensor is operated in the mode-matched condition. Mode-matching leverages the inherently high quality factors of the microgyroscope, resulting in significant improvement in the Brownian noise floor, electronic noise, sensitivity and bias drift of the microsensor. We developed a novel architecture that utilizes the often ignored residual quadrature error in a gyroscope to achieve and maintain perfect mode-matching (i.e.0Hz split between the drive and sense mode frequencies), as well as electronically control the sensor bandwidth. A CMOS implementation is developed that allows mode-matching of the drive and sense frequencies of a gyroscope at a fraction of the time taken by current state of-the-art techniques. Further, this mode-matching technique allows for maintaining a controlled separation between the drive and sense resonant frequencies, providing a means of increasing sensor bandwidth and dynamic range. The mode-matching CMOS IC, implemented in a 0.5μm 2P3M process, and control algorithm have been interfaced with a 60μm thick M2−TFG to implement an angular rate sensor with bias drift as low as 0.1°/hr ℃ the lowest recorded to date for a silicon MEMS gyro.Ph.D.Committee Chair: Farrokh Ayazi; Committee Member: Jennifer Michaels; Committee Member: Levent Degertekin; Committee Member: Paul Hasler; Committee Member: W. Marshall Leac

Force to Rebalance Control of HRG and Suppression of Its Errors on the Basis of FPGA

A novel design of force to rebalance control for a hemispherical resonator gyro (HRG) based on FPGA is demonstrated in this paper. The proposed design takes advantage of the automatic gain control loop and phase lock loop configuration in the drive mode while making full use of the quadrature control loop and rebalance control loop in controlling the oscillating dynamics in the sense mode. First, the math model of HRG with inhomogeneous damping and frequency split is theoretically analyzed. In addition, the major drift mechanisms in the HRG are described and the methods that can suppress the gyro drift are mentioned. Based on the math model and drift mechanisms suppression method, four control loops are employed to realize the manipulation of the HRG by using a FPGA circuit. The reference-phase loop and amplitude control loop are used to maintain the vibration of primary mode at its natural frequency with constant amplitude. The frequency split is readily eliminated by the quadrature loop with a DC voltage feedback from the quadrature component of the node. The secondary mode response to the angle rate input is nullified by the rebalance control loop. In order to validate the effect of the digital control of HRG, experiments are carried out with a turntable. The experimental results show that the design is suitable for the control of HRG which has good linearity scale factor and bias stability

Energy efficient control of electrostatically actuated MEMS

Plenty of Micro-electro-mechanical Systems (MEMS) devices are actuated using electrostatic forces, and specially, parallel-plate actuators are extensively used, due to the simplicity of their design. Nevertheless, parallel-plate actuators have some limitations due to the nonlinearity of the generated force. The dissertation analyzes the dynamics of the lumped electrostatically actuated nonlinear system, in order to obtain insight on its characteristics, define desired performance goals and implement a controller for energy efficient robustly stable actuation of MEMS resonators. In the first part of the dissertation, the modeling of the electromechanical lumped system is developed. From a complete distributed parameters model for MEMS devices which rely on electrostatic actuation, a concentrated parameters simplification is derived to be used for analysis and control design. Based on the model, energy analysis of the pull-in instability is performed. The classic approach is revisited to extend the results to models with a nonlinear springs. Analysis of the effect of dynamics is studied as an important factor for the stability of the system. From this study, the Resonant Pull-in Condition for parallel-plate electrostatically actuated MEMS resonators is defined and experimentally validated. Given the importance of the nonlinear dynamics and its richness in behaviors, Harmonic Balance is chosen as a tool to characterize the steady-state oscillation of the resonators. This characterization leads to the understanding of the key factors for large and stable oscillation of resonators. An important conclusion is reached, Harmonic Balance predicts that any oscillation amplitude is possible for any desired frequency if the appropriate voltage is applied to the resonator. And the energy consumption is dependent on this chosen oscillation frequency. Based on Harmonic Balance results, four main goals are defined for the control strategy: Stable oscillation with large amplitudes of motion; Robust oscillation independently of MEMS imperfections; Pure sinus-like oscillation for high-grade sensing; and Low energy consumption. The second part of the dissertation deals with the controller selection, design and verification. A survey of prior work on MEMS control confirms that existing control approaches cannot provide the desired performance. Consequently, a new three-stage controller is proposed to obtain the desired oscillation with the expected stability and energy efficiency. The controller has three different control loops. The first control loop includes a Robust controller designed using on µ-synthesis, to deal with MEMS resonators uncertainties. The second control loop includes an Internal-Model-Principle Resonant controller, to generate the desired control action to obtain the desired oscillation. And the third control loop handles the energy consumption minimization through an Extremum Seeking Controller, which selects the most efficient working frequency for the desired oscillation. The proposed controller is able to automatically generate the needed control voltage, as predicted by the Harmonic Balance analysis, to operate the parallel-plate electrostatically actuated MEMS resonator at the desired oscillation. Performance verification of stability, robustness, sinus-like oscillation and energy efficiency is carried out through simulation. Finally, the needed steps for a real implementation are analyzed. Independent two-sided actuation for full-range amplitude oscillation is introduced to overcome the limitations of one-sided actuation. And a modification of standard Electromechanical Amplitude Modulation is analyzed and validated for position feedback implementation. With these improvements, a MEMS resonator with the desired specifications for testing the proposed control is designed for fabrication. Based on this design, testing procedure is discussed as future work.Molts microsistemes (MEMS) són actuats amb forces electrostàtiques, i especialment, els actuadors electrostàtics de plaques paral.leles són molt usats, degut a la simplicitat del seu disseny. Tot i això, aquests actuadors tenen limitacions degut a la no-linealitat de les forces generades. La tesi analitza el sistema mecànic no-lineal actuat electrostàticament que forma el MEMS, per tal d'entendre'n les característiques, definir objectius de control de l'oscil.lació, i implementar un controlador robust, estable i eficient energèticament. A la primera part de la tesi es desenvolupa el modelat del sistema electromecànic complert. A partir de la formulació de paràmetres distribuïts aplicada a dispositius MEMS amb actuació electrostàtica, es deriva una formulació de paràmetres concentrats per a l'anàlisi i el disseny del control. Basat en aquest model, s'analitza energèticament la inestabilitat anomenada Pull-in, ampliant els resultats de l'enfocament clàssic al model amb motlles no-lineals. Dins de l'anàlisi, l'evolució dinàmica s'estudia per ser un factor important per a l'estabilitat. D'aquest estudi, la Resonant Pull-in Condition per a actuadors electrostàtics de plaques paral.leles es defineix i es valida experimentalment. Donada la importància de la dinàmica no-lineal del sistema i la seva riquesa de comportaments, s'utilitza Balanç d'Harmònics per tal de caracteritzar les oscil.lacions en estacionari. Aquesta caracterització permet entendre els factors claus per a obtenir oscil.lacions estables i d'amplitud elevada. El Balanç d'Harmònics dóna una conclusió important: qualsevol amplitud d'oscil.lació és possible per a qualsevol freqüència desitjada si s'aplica el voltatge adequat al ressonador. I el consum energètic associat a aquesta oscil.lació depèn de la freqüència triada. Llavors, basat en aquests resultats, quatre objectius es plantegen per a l'estratègia de control: oscil.lació estable amb amplituds elevades; robustesa de l'oscil.lació independentment de les imperfeccions dels MEMS; oscil.lació sinusoïdal sense harmònics per a aplicacions d'alta precisió; i baix consum energètic. La segona part de la tesi tracta la selecció, disseny i verificació dun controlador adequat per a aquests objectius. La revisió dels treballs existents en control de MEMS confirma que cap dels enfocaments actuals permet obtenir els objectius desitjats. En conseqüència, es proposa el disseny d'un nou controlador amb tres etapes per tal d'obtenir l'oscil.lació desitjada amb estabilitat i eficiència energètica. El controlador té tres llaços de control. Al primer llaç, un controlador robust dissenyat amb µ-síntesis gestiona les incertes es dels MEMS. El segon llaç inclou un controlador Ressonant, basat en el Principi del Model Intern, per a generar l'acció de control necessària per a obtenir l'oscil.lació desitjada. I el tercer llaç de control gestiona la minimització de l'energia consumida mitjançant un controlador basat en Extremum Seeking, el qual selecciona la freqüència de treball més eficient energèticament per a l'oscil.lació triada. El controlador proposat és capaç de generar automàticament el voltatge necessari, igual al previst pel Balanç d'Harmònics, per tal d'operar electrostàticament amb plaques paral.leles els ressonadors MEMS. Mitjançant simulació se'n verifica l'estabilitat, robustesa, inexistència d'harmònics i eficiència energètica de l'oscil.lació. Finalment, la implementació real és analitzada. En primer lloc, un nou esquema d'actuació per dos costats amb voltatges independents es proposa per aconseguir l'oscil.lació del ressonador en tot el rang d'amplituds. I en segon lloc, una modificació del sensat amb Modulació d'Amplitud Electromecànica s'utilitza per tancar el llaç de control de posició. Amb aquestes millores, un ressonador MEMS es dissenya per a ser fabricat i validar el control. Basat en aquest disseny, es proposa un procediment de test plantejat com a treball futur.Postprint (published version