Ultra-low Voltage Digital Circuits and Extreme Temperature Electronics Design

Certain applications require digital electronics to operate under extreme conditions e.g., large swings in ambient temperature, very low supply voltage, high radiation. Such applications include sensor networks, wearable electronics, unmanned aerial vehicles, spacecraft, and energyharvesting systems. This dissertation splits into two projects that study digital electronics supplied by ultra-low voltages and build an electronic system for extreme temperatures. The first project introduces techniques that improve circuit reliability at deep subthreshold voltages as well as determine the minimum required supply voltage. These techniques address digital electronic design at several levels: the physical process, gate design, and system architecture. This dissertation analyzes a silicon-on-insulator process, Schmitt-trigger gate design, and asynchronous logic at supply voltages lower than 100 millivolts. The second project describes construction of a sensor digital controller for the lunar environment. Parts of the digital controller are an asynchronous 8031 microprocessor that is compatible with synchronous logic, memory with error detection and correction, and a robust network interface. The digitial sensor ASIC is fabricated on a silicon-germanium process and built with cells optimized for extreme temperatures

On the Evaluation of SEEs on Open-Source Embedded Static RAMs

3Static RAM modules are widely adopted in high performance systems. Single Event Effects (SEEs) resilient memories are required in many embedded systems applied in automotive and aerospace applications to increase their overall resiliency against SEEs. The current SEE resilient SRAM modules are obtained by applying radiation-hardened by design solutions which leads to elevated area overhead and difficulty to tune the resiliency capability with respect to the particle’s radiation profile. To overcome these limitations, we propose a methodology for the analysis and mitigation of embedded SRAMs generated by the OpenRAM memory compiler. A technology-oriented radiation analysis tool is presented to support the interaction of the charged radiation particles with the SRAM layout and depict the sensitive transistors of the SRAM memory. A selective duplication of the sensitive transistors has been applied to the 6T-SRAM cell designed at the layout level. The designed cell is included in the OpenRAM compiler and used to generate a mitigated 8Kb SRAM-bank. We evaluated the SEEs sensitivity by comparative simulation-based radiation analysis observing a reduction more than 6 times with respect to the original 6T-SRAM cell for the SEE sensitivity at high energy heavy ions particles, with negligible degradation of operations margins and power consumption and area overhead of less than ̴4%.partially_openopenAzimi, Sarah; De Sio, Corrado; Sterpone, LucaAzimi, Sarah; De Sio, Corrado; Sterpone, Luc

Analyzing stability concerns in the presence of variations in Subthreshold SRAM

In this work, we analyse the stability of the SRAM bitcells when operating in subthreshold supply voltages.We propose a new bit cell with higher stability than 6T Bitcell,that is able to discharge the bit lines in 41% less time than the 6T as it's discharge path is only of single transistor

Subthreshold Dual Mode Logic

In this brief, we introduce a novel low-power dual mode logic (DML) family, designed to operate in the subthreshold region. The proposed logic family can be switched between static and dynamic modes of operation according to system requirements. In static mode, the DML gates feature very low-power dissipation with moderate performance, while in dynamic mode they achieve higher performance, albeit with increased power dissipation. This is achieved with a simple and intuitive design concept. SPICE and Monte Carlo simulations compare performance, power dissipation, and robustness of the proposed DML gates to their CMOS and domino counterparts in the 80-nm process. Measurements of an 80-nm test chip are presented in order to prove the proposed concept

Static noise margin analysis for CMOS logic cells in near-threshold

The advancement of semiconductor technology enabled the fabrication of devices with faster switching activity and chips with higher integration density. However, these advances are facing new impediments related to energy and power dissipation. Besides, the increasing demand for portable devices leads the circuit design paradigm to prioritize energy efficiency instead of performance. Altogether, this scenario motivates engineers towards reducing the supply voltage to the near and subthreshold regime to increase the lifespan of battery-powered devices. Even though operating in these regime offer interesting energy-frequency trade-offs, it brings challenges concerning noise tolerance. As the supply voltage reduces, the available noise margins decrease, and circuits become more prone to functional failures. In addition, near and subthreshold circuits are more susceptible to manufacturing variability, hence further aggravating noise issues. Other issues, such as wire minimization and gate fan-out, also contribute to the relevance of evaluating the noise margin of circuits early in the design Accordingly, this work investigates how to improve the static noise margin of digital synchronous circuits that will operate at the near/subthreshold regime. This investigation produces a set of three original contributions. The first is an automated tool to estimate the static noise margin of CMOS combinational cells. The second contribution is a realistic static noise margin estimation methodology that considers process-voltage-temperature variations. Results show that the proposed methodology allows to reduce up to 70% of the static noise margin pessimism. Finally, the third contribution is the noise-aware cell design methodology and the inclusion of a noise evaluation of complex circuits during the logic synthesis. The resulting library achieved higher static noise margin (up to 24%) and less spread among different cells (up to 62%).Os avanços na tecnologia de semicondutores possibilitou que se fabricasse dispositivos com atividade de chaveamento mais rápida e com maior capacidade de integração de transistores. Estes avanços, todavia, impuseram novos empecilhos relacionados com a dissipação de potência e energia. Além disso, a crescente demanda por dispositivos portáteis levaram à uma mudança no paradigma de projeto de circuitos para que se priorize energia ao invés de desempenho. Este cenário motivou à reduzir a tensão de alimentação com qual os dispositivos operam para um regime próximo ou abaixo da tensão de limiar, com o objetivo de aumentar sua duração de bateria. Apesar desta abordagem balancear características de performance e energia, ela traz novos desafios com relação a tolerância à ruído. Ao reduzirmos a tensão de alimentação, também reduz-se a margem de ruído disponível e, assim, os circuitos tornam-se mais suscetíveis à falhas funcionais. Somado à este efeito, circuitos com tensões de alimentação nestes regimes são mais sensíveis à variações do processo de fabricação, logo agravando problemas com ruído. Existem também outros aspectos, tais como a miniaturização das interconexões e a relação de fan-out de uma célula digital, que incentivam a avaliação de ruído nas fases iniciais do projeto de circuitos integrados Por estes motivos, este trabalho investiga como aprimorar a margem de ruído estática de circuitos síncronos digitais que irão operar em tensões no regime de tensão próximo ou abaixo do limiar. Esta investigação produz um conjunto de três contribuições originais. A primeira é uma ferramenta capaz de avaliar automaticamente a margem de ruído estática de células CMOS combinacionais. A segunda contribuição é uma metodologia realista para estimar a margem de ruído estática considerando variações de processo, tensão e temperatura. Os resultados obtidos mostram que a metodologia proposta permitiu reduzir até 70% do pessimismo das margens de ruído estática, Por último, a terceira contribuição é um fluxo de projeto de células combinacionais digitais considerando ruído, e uma abordagem para avaliar a margem de ruído estática de circuitos complexos durante a etapa de síntese lógica. A biblioteca de células resultante deste fluxo obteve maior margem de ruído (até 24%) e menor variação entre diferentes células (até 62%)

Ultra low-power fault-tolerant SRAM design in 90nm CMOS technology

With the increment of mobile, biomedical and space applications, digital systems with low-power consumption are required. As a main part in digital systems, low-power memories are especially desired. Reducing the power supply voltages to sub-threshold region is one of the effective approaches for ultra low-power applications. However, the reduced Static Noise Margin (SNM) of Static Random Access Memory (SRAM) imposes great challenges to the subthreshold SRAM design. The conventional 6-transistor SRAM cell does not function properly at sub-threshold supply voltage range because it has no enough noise margin for reliable operation. In order to achieve ultra low-power at sub-threshold operation, previous research work has demonstrated that the read and write decoupled scheme is a good solution to the reduced SNM problem. A Dual Interlocked Storage Cell (DICE) based SRAM cell was proposed to eliminate the drawback of conventional DICE cell during read operation. This cell can mitigate the singleevent effects, improve the stability and also maintain the low-power characteristic of subthreshold SRAM, In order to make the proposed SRAM cell work under different power supply voltages from 0.3 V to 0.6 V, an improved replica sense scheme was applied to produce a reference control signal, with which the optimal read time could be achieved. In this thesis, a 2K ~8 bits SRAM test chip was designed, simulated and fabricated in 90nm CMOS technology provided by ST Microelectronics. Simulation results suggest that the operating frequency at VDD = 0.3 V is up to 4.7 MHz with power dissipation 6.0 ƒÊW, while it is 45.5 MHz at VDD = 0.6 V dissipating 140 ƒÊW. However, the area occupied by a single cell is larger than that by conventional SRAM due to additional transistors used. The main contribution of this thesis project is that we proposed a new design that could simultaneously solve the ultra low-power and radiation-tolerance problem in large capacity memory design

Architecting SkyBridge-CMOS

As the scaling of CMOS approaches fundamental limits, revolutionary technology beyond the end of CMOS roadmap is essential to continue the progress and miniaturization of integrated circuits. Recent research efforts in 3-D circuit integration explore pathways of continuing the scaling by co-designing for device, circuit, connectivity, heat and manufacturing challenges in a 3-D fabric-centric manner. SkyBridge fabric is one such approach that addresses fine-grained integration in 3-D, achieves orders of magnitude benefits over projected scaled 2-D CMOS, and provides a pathway for continuing scaling beyond 2-D CMOS. However, SkyBridge fabric utilizes only single type transistors in order to reduce manufacture complexity, which limits its circuit implementation to dynamic logic. This design choice introduces multiple challenges for SkyBridge such as high switching power consumption, susceptibility to noise, and increased complexity for clocking. In this thesis we propose a new 3-D fabric, similar in mindset to SkyBridge, but with static logic circuit implementation in order to mitigate the afore-mentioned challenges. We present an integrated framework to realize static circuits with vertical nanowires, and co-design it across all layers spanning fundamental fabric structures to large circuits. The new fabric, named as SkyBridge-CMOS, introduces new technology, structures and circuit designs to meet the additional requirements for implementing static circuits. One of the critical challenges addressed here is integrating both n-type and p-type nanowires. Molecular bonding process allows precise control between different doping regions, and novel fabric components are proposed to achieve 3-D routing between various doping regions. Core fabric components are designed, optimized and modeled with their physical level information taken into account. Based on these basic structures we design and evaluate various logic gates, arithmetic circuits and SRAM in terms of power, area footprint and delay. A comprehensive evaluation methodology spanning material/device level to circuit level is followed. Benchmarking against 16nm 2-D CMOS shows significant improvement of up to 50X in area footprint and 9.3X in total power efficiency for low power applications, and 3X in throughput for high performance applications. Also, better noise resilience and better power efficiency can be guaranteed when compared with original SkyBridge fabrics

Robust low-power digital circuit design in nano-CMOS technologies

Device scaling has resulted in large scale integrated, high performance, low-power, and low cost systems. However the move towards sub-100 nm technology nodes has increased variability in device characteristics due to large process variations. Variability has severe implications on digital circuit design by causing timing uncertainties in combinational circuits, degrading yield and reliability of memory elements, and increasing power density due to slow scaling of supply voltage. Conventional design methods add large pessimistic safety margins to mitigate increased variability, however, they incur large power and performance loss as the combination of worst cases occurs very rarely. In-situ monitoring of timing failures provides an opportunity to dynamically tune safety margins in proportion to on-chip variability that can significantly minimize power and performance losses. We demonstrated by simulations two delay sensor designs to detect timing failures in advance that can be coupled with different compensation techniques such as voltage scaling, body biasing, or frequency scaling to avoid actual timing failures. Our simulation results using 45 nm and 32 nm technology BSIM4 models indicate significant reduction in total power consumption under temperature and statistical variations. Future work involves using dual sensing to avoid useless voltage scaling that incurs a speed loss. SRAM cache is the first victim of increased process variations that requires handcrafted design to meet area, power, and performance requirements. We have proposed novel 6 transistors (6T), 7 transistors (7T), and 8 transistors (8T)-SRAM cells that enable variability tolerant and low-power SRAM cache designs. Increased sense-amplifier offset voltage due to device mismatch arising from high variability increases delay and power consumption of SRAM design. We have proposed two novel design techniques to reduce offset voltage dependent delays providing a high speed low-power SRAM design. Increasing leakage currents in nano-CMOS technologies pose a major challenge to a low-power reliable design. We have investigated novel segmented supply voltage architecture to reduce leakage power of the SRAM caches since they occupy bulk of the total chip area and power. Future work involves developing leakage reduction methods for the combination logic designs including SRAM peripherals

Designing energy-efficient sub-threshold logic circuits using equalization and non-volatile memory circuits using memristors

The very large scale integration (VLSI) community has utilized aggressive complementary metal-oxide semiconductor (CMOS) technology scaling to meet the ever-increasing performance requirements of computing systems. However, as we enter the nanoscale regime, the prevalent process variation effects degrade the CMOS device reliability. Hence, it is increasingly essential to explore emerging technologies which are compatible with the conventional CMOS process for designing highly-dense memory/logic circuits. Memristor technology is being explored as a potential candidate in designing non-volatile memory arrays and logic circuits with high density, low latency and small energy consumption. In this thesis, we present the detailed functionality of multi-bit 1-Transistor 1-memRistor (1T1R) cell-based memory arrays. We present the performance and energy models for an individual 1T1R memory cell and the memory array as a whole. We have considered TiO2- and HfOx-based memristors, and for these technologies there is a sub-10% difference between energy and performance computed using our models and HSPICE simulations. Using a performance-driven design approach, the energy-optimized TiO2-based RRAM array consumes the least write energy (4.06 pJ/bit) and read energy (188 fJ/bit) when storing 3 bits/cell for 100 nsec write and 1 nsec read access times. Similarly, HfOx-based RRAM array consumes the least write energy (365 fJ/bit) and read energy (173 fJ/bit) when storing 3 bits/cell for 1 nsec write and 200 nsec read access times. On the logic side, we investigate the use of equalization techniques to improve the energy efficiency of digital sequential logic circuits in sub-threshold regime. We first propose the use of a variable threshold feedback equalizer circuit with combinational logic blocks to mitigate the timing errors in digital logic designed in sub-threshold regime. This mitigation of timing errors can be leveraged to reduce the dominant leakage energy by scaling supply voltage or decreasing the propagation delay. At the fixed supply voltage, we can decrease the propagation delay of the critical path in a combinational logic block using equalizer circuits and, correspondingly decrease the leakage energy consumption. For a 8-bit carry lookahead adder designed in UMC 130 nm process, the operating frequency can be increased by 22.87% (on average), while reducing the leakage energy by 22.6% (on average) in the sub-threshold regime. Overall, the feedback equalization technique provides up to 35.4% lower energy-delay product compared to the conventional non-equalized logic. We also propose a tunable adaptive feedback equalizer circuit that can be used with sequential digital logic to mitigate the process variation effects and reduce the dominant leakage energy component in sub-threshold digital logic circuits. For a 64-bit adder designed in 130 nm our proposed approach can reduce the normalized delay variation of the critical path delay from 16.1% to 11.4% while reducing the energy-delay product by 25.83% at minimum energy supply voltage. In addition, we present detailed energy-performance models of the adaptive feedback equalizer circuit. This work serves as a foundation for the design of robust, energy-efficient digital logic circuits in sub-threshold regime

Modeling and Mitigation of Soft Errors in Nanoscale SRAMs

Energetic particle (alpha particle, cosmic neutron, etc.) induced single event data upset or soft error has emerged as a key reliability concern in SRAMs in sub-100 nanometre technologies. Low operating voltage, small node capacitance, high packing density, and lack of error masking mechanisms are primarily responsible for the soft error susceptibility of SRAMs. In addition, since SRAM occupies the majority of die area in system-on-chips (SoCs) and microprocessors, different leakage reduction techniques, such as, supply voltage reduction, gated grounding, etc., are applied to SRAMs in order to limit the overall chip leakage. These leakage reduction techniques exponentially increase the soft error rate in SRAMs. The soft error rate is further accentuated by process variations, which are prominent in scaled-down technologies. In this research, we address these concerns and propose techniques to characterize and mitigate soft errors in nanoscale SRAMs. We develop a comprehensive analytical model of the critical charge, which is a key to assessing the soft error susceptibility of SRAMs. The model is based on the dynamic behaviour of the cell and a simple decoupling technique for the non-linearly coupled storage nodes. The model describes the critical charge in terms of NMOS and PMOS transistor parameters, cell supply voltage, and noise current parameters. Consequently, it enables characterizing the spread of critical charge due to process induced variations in these parameters and to manufacturing defects, such as, resistive contacts or vias. In addition, the model can estimate the improvement in critical charge when MIM capacitors are added to the cell in order to improve the soft error robustness. The model is validated by SPICE simulations (90nm CMOS) and radiation test. The critical charge calculated by the model is in good agreement with SPICE simulations with a maximum discrepancy of less than 5%. The soft error rate estimated by the model for low voltage (sub 0.8 V) operations is within 10% of the soft error rate measured in the radiation test. Therefore, the model can serve as a reliable alternative to time consuming SPICE simulations for optimizing the critical charge and hence the soft error rate at the design stage. In order to limit the soft error rate further, we propose an area-efficient multiword based error correction code (MECC) scheme. The MECC scheme combines four 32 bit data words to form a composite 128 bit ECC word and uses an optimized 4-input transmission-gate XOR logic. Thus MECC significantly reduces the area overhead for check-bit storage and the delay penalty for error correction. In addition, MECC interleaves two composite words in a row for limiting cosmic neutron induced multi-bit errors. The ground potentials of the composite words are controlled to minimize leakage power without compromising the read data stability. However, use of composite words involves a unique write operation where one data word is written while other three data words are read to update the check-bits. A power efficient word line signaling technique is developed to facilitate the write operation. A 64 kb SRAM macro with MECC is designed and fabricated in a commercial 90nm CMOS technology. Measurement results show that the SRAM consumes 534 μW at 100 MHz with a data latency of 3.3 ns for a single bit error correction. This translates into 82% per-bit energy saving and 8x speed improvement over recently reported multiword ECC schemes. Accelerated neutron radiation test carried out at TRIUMF in Vancouver confirms that the proposed MECC scheme can correct up to 85% of soft errors