Analysis/Synthesis Comparison of Vocoders Utilized in Statistical Parametric Speech Synthesis

Tässä työssä esitetään kirjallisuuskatsaus ja kokeellinen osio tilastollisessa parametrisessa puhesynteesissä käytetyistä vokoodereista. Kokeellisessa osassa kolmen valitun vokooderin (GlottHMM, STRAIGHT ja Harmonic/Stochastic Model) analyysi-synteesi -ominaisuuksia tarkastellaan usealla tavalla. Suoritetut kokeet olivat vokooderiparametrien tilastollisten jakaumien analysointi, puheen tunnetilan tilastollinen vaikutus vokooderiparametrien jakaumiin sekä subjektiivinen kuuntelukoe jolla mitattiin vokooderien suhteellista analyysi-synteesi -laatua. Tulokset osoittavat että STRAIGHT-vokooderi omaa eniten Gaussiset parametrijakaumat ja tasaisimman synteesilaadun. GlottHMM-vokooderin parametrit osoittivat suurinta herkkyyttä puheen tunnetilan funktiona ja vokooderi sai parhaan, mutta laadultaan vaihtelevan kuuntelukoetuloksen. HSM-vokooderin LSF-parametrien havaittiin olevan Gaussisempia kuin GlottHMM-vokooderin LSF parametrit, mutta vokooderin havaittiin kärsivän kohinaherkkyydestä, ja se sai huonoimman kuuntelukoetuloksen.This thesis presents a literature study followed by an experimental part on the state-of-the-art vocoders utilized in statistical parametric speech synthesis. In the experimental part, the analysis/synthesis properties of three selected vocoders (GlottHMM, STRAIGHT and Harmonic/Stochastic Model) are examined. The performed tests were the analysis of vocoder parameter distributions, statistical testing on the effect of emotions to the vocoder parameter distributions, and a subjective listening test evaluating the vocoders' relative analysis/synthesis quality. The results indicate that the STRAIGHT vocoder has the most Gaussian parameter distributions and most robust synthesis quality, whereas the GlottHMM vocoder has the most emotion sensitive parameters and best but unreliable synthesis quality. The HSM vocoder's LSF parameters were found to be more Gaussian than the GlottHMM vocoder's LSF parameters. HSM was found to be sensitive to noise, and it scored the lowest score on the subjective listening test

HMM-based speech synthesis using an acoustic glottal source model

Parametric speech synthesis has received increased attention in recent years following the development of statistical HMM-based speech synthesis. However, the speech produced using this method still does not sound as natural as human speech and there is limited parametric flexibility to replicate voice quality aspects, such as breathiness. The hypothesis of this thesis is that speech naturalness and voice quality can be more accurately replicated by a HMM-based speech synthesiser using an acoustic glottal source model, the Liljencrants-Fant (LF) model, to represent the source component of speech instead of the traditional impulse train. Two different analysis-synthesis methods were developed during this thesis, in order to integrate the LF-model into a baseline HMM-based speech synthesiser, which is based on the popular HTS system and uses the STRAIGHT vocoder. The first method, which is called Glottal Post-Filtering (GPF), consists of passing a chosen LF-model signal through a glottal post-filter to obtain the source signal and then generating speech, by passing this source signal through the spectral envelope filter. The system which uses the GPF method (HTS-GPF system) is similar to the baseline system, but it uses a different source signal instead of the impulse train used by STRAIGHT. The second method, called Glottal Spectral Separation (GSS), generates speech by passing the LF-model signal through the vocal tract filter. The major advantage of the synthesiser which incorporates the GSS method, named HTS-LF, is that the acoustic properties of the LF-model parameters are automatically learnt by the HMMs. In this thesis, an initial perceptual experiment was conducted to compare the LFmodel to the impulse train. The results showed that the LF-model was significantly better, both in terms of speech naturalness and replication of two basic voice qualities (breathy and tense). In a second perceptual evaluation, the HTS-LF system was better than the baseline system, although the difference between the two had been expected to be more significant. A third experiment was conducted to evaluate the HTS-GPF system and an improved HTS-LF system, in terms of speech naturalness, voice similarity and intelligibility. The results showed that the HTS-GPF system performed similarly to the baseline. However, the HTS-LF system was significantly outperformed by the baseline. Finally, acoustic measurements were performed on the synthetic speech to investigate the speech distortion in the HTS-LF system. The results indicated that a problem in replicating the rapid variations of the vocal tract filter parameters at transitions between voiced and unvoiced sounds is the most significant cause of speech distortion. This problem encourages future work to further improve the system

Statistical parametric speech synthesis based on sinusoidal models

This study focuses on improving the quality of statistical speech synthesis based on sinusoidal models. Vocoders play a crucial role during the parametrisation and reconstruction process, so we first lead an experimental comparison of a broad range of the leading vocoder types. Although our study shows that for analysis / synthesis, sinusoidal models with complex amplitudes can generate high quality of speech compared with source-filter ones, component sinusoids are correlated with each other, and the number of parameters is also high and varies in each frame, which constrains its application for statistical speech synthesis. Therefore, we first propose a perceptually based dynamic sinusoidal model (PDM) to decrease and fix the number of components typically used in the standard sinusoidal model. Then, in order to apply the proposed vocoder with an HMM-based speech synthesis system (HTS), two strategies for modelling sinusoidal parameters have been compared. In the first method (DIR parameterisation), features extracted from the fixed- and low-dimensional PDM are statistically modelled directly. In the second method (INT parameterisation), we convert both static amplitude and dynamic slope from all the harmonics of a signal, which we term the Harmonic Dynamic Model (HDM), to intermediate parameters (regularised cepstral coefficients (RDC)) for modelling. Our results show that HDM with intermediate parameters can generate comparable quality to STRAIGHT. As correlations between features in the dynamic model cannot be modelled satisfactorily by a typical HMM-based system with diagonal covariance, we have applied and tested a deep neural network (DNN) for modelling features from these two methods. To fully exploit DNN capabilities, we investigate ways to combine INT and DIR at the level of both DNN modelling and waveform generation. For DNN training, we propose to use multi-task learning to model cepstra (from INT) and log amplitudes (from DIR) as primary and secondary tasks. We conclude from our results that sinusoidal models are indeed highly suited for statistical parametric synthesis. The proposed method outperforms the state-of-the-art STRAIGHT-based equivalent when used in conjunction with DNNs. To further improve the voice quality, phase features generated from the proposed vocoder also need to be parameterised and integrated into statistical modelling. Here, an alternative statistical model referred to as the complex-valued neural network (CVNN), which treats complex coefficients as a whole, is proposed to model complex amplitude explicitly. A complex-valued back-propagation algorithm using a logarithmic minimisation criterion which includes both amplitude and phase errors is used as a learning rule. Three parameterisation methods are studied for mapping text to acoustic features: RDC / real-valued log amplitude, complex-valued amplitude with minimum phase and complex-valued amplitude with mixed phase. Our results show the potential of using CVNNs for modelling both real and complex-valued acoustic features. Overall, this thesis has established competitive alternative vocoders for speech parametrisation and reconstruction. The utilisation of proposed vocoders on various acoustic models (HMM / DNN / CVNN) clearly demonstrates that it is compelling to apply them for the parametric statistical speech synthesis

Spectral discontinuity in concatenative speech synthesis – perception, join costs and feature transformations

This thesis explores the problem of determining an objective measure to represent human perception of spectral discontinuity in concatenative speech synthesis. Such measures are used as join costs to quantify the compatibility of speech units for concatenation in unit selection synthesis. No previous study has reported a spectral measure that satisfactorily correlates with human perception of discontinuity. An analysis of the limitations of existing measures and our understanding of the human auditory system were used to guide the strategies adopted to advance a solution to this problem. A listening experiment was conducted using a database of concatenated speech with results indicating the perceived continuity of each concatenation. The results of this experiment were used to correlate proposed measures of spectral continuity with the perceptual results. A number of standard speech parametrisations and distance measures were tested as measures of spectral continuity and analysed to identify their limitations. Time-frequency resolution was found to limit the performance of standard speech parametrisations.As a solution to this problem, measures of continuity based on the wavelet transform were proposed and tested, as wavelets offer superior time-frequency resolution to standard spectral measures. A further limitation of standard speech parametrisations is that they are typically computed from the magnitude spectrum. However, the auditory system combines information relating to the magnitude spectrum, phase spectrum and spectral dynamics. The potential of phase and spectral dynamics as measures of spectral continuity were investigated. One widely adopted approach to detecting discontinuities is to compute the Euclidean distance between feature vectors about the join in concatenated speech. The detection of an auditory event, such as the detection of a discontinuity, involves processing high up the auditory pathway in the central auditory system. The basic Euclidean distance cannot model such behaviour. A study was conducted to investigate feature transformations with sufficient processing complexity to mimic high level auditory processing. Neural networks and principal component analysis were investigated as feature transformations. Wavelet based measures were found to outperform all measures of continuity based on standard speech parametrisations. Phase and spectral dynamics based measures were found to correlate with human perception of discontinuity in the test database, although neither measure was found to contribute a significant increase in performance when combined with standard measures of continuity. Neural network feature transformations were found to significantly outperform all other measures tested in this study, producing correlations with perceptual results in excess of 90%

New methods for robust speech recognition

Ankara : Department of Electrical and Electronics Engineering and the Institute of Engineering and Science of Bilkent University, 1995.Thesis (Ph.D.) -- Bilkent University, 1995.Includes bibliographical references leaves 86-92.New methods of feature extraction, end-point detection and speech enhcincement are developed for a robust speech recognition system. The methods of feature extraction and end-point detection are based on wavelet analysis or subband analysis of the speech signal. Two new sets of speech feature parameters, SUBLSF’s and SUBCEP’s, are introduced. Both parameter sets are based on subband analysis. The SUBLSF feature parameters are obtained via linear predictive analysis on subbands. These speech feature parameters can produce better results than the full-band parameters when the noise is colored. The SUBCEP parameters are based on wavelet analysis or equivalently the multirate subband analysis of the speech signal. The SUBCEP parameters also provide robust recognition performance by appropriately deemphasizing the frequency bands corrupted by noise. It is experimentally observed that the subband analysis based feature parameters are more robust than the commonly used full-band analysis based parameters in the presence of car noise. The a-stable random processes can be used to model the impulsive nature of the public network telecommunication noise. Adaptive filtering are developed for Q-stable random processes. Adaptive noise cancelation techniques are used to reduce the mismacth between training and testing conditions of the recognition system over telephone lines. Another important problem in isolated speech recognition is to determine the boundaries of the speech utterances or words. Precise boundary detection of utterances improves the performance of speech recognition systems. A new distance measure based on the subband energy levels is introduced for endpoint detection.Erzin, EnginPh.D