Layout regularity metric as a fast indicator of process variations

Integrated circuits design faces increasing challenge as we scale down due to the increase of the effect of sensitivity to process variations. Systematic variations induced by different steps in the lithography process affect both parametric and functional yields of the designs. These variations are known, themselves, to be affected by layout topologies. Design for Manufacturability (DFM) aims at defining techniques that mitigate variations and improve yield. Layout regularity is one of the trending techniques suggested by DFM to mitigate process variations effect. There are several solutions to create regular designs, like restricted design rules and regular fabrics. These regular solutions raised the need for a regularity metric. Metrics in literature are insufficient for different reasons; either because they are qualitative or computationally intensive. Furthermore, there is no study relating either lithography or electrical variations to layout regularity. In this work, layout regularity is studied in details and a new geometrical-based layout regularity metric is derived. This metric is verified against lithographic simulations and shows good correlation. Calculation of the metric takes only few minutes on 1mm x 1mm design, which is considered fast compared to the time taken by simulations. This makes it a good candidate for pre-processing the layout data and selecting certain areas of interest for lithographic simulations for faster throughput. The layout regularity metric is also compared against a model that measures electrical variations due to systematic lithographic variations. The validity of using the regularity metric to flag circuits that have high variability using the developed electrical variations model is shown. The regularity metric results compared to the electrical variability model results show matching percentage that can reach 80%, which means that this metric can be used as a fast indicator of designs more susceptible to lithography and hence electrical variations

PROBE3.0: A Systematic Framework for Design-Technology Pathfinding with Improved Design Enablement

We propose a systematic framework to conduct design-technology pathfinding for PPAC in advanced nodes. Our goal is to provide configurable, scalable generation of process design kit (PDK) and standard-cell library, spanning key scaling boosters (backside PDN and buried power rail), to explore PPAC across given technology and design parameters. We build on PROBE2.0, which addressed only area and cost (AC), to include power and performance (PP) evaluations through automated generation of full design enablements. We also improve the use of artificial designs in the PPAC assessment of technology and design configurations. We generate more realistic artificial designs by applying a machine learning-based parameter tuning flow. We further employ clustering-based cell width-regularized placements at the core of routability assessment, enabling more realistic placement utilization and improved experimental efficiency. We demonstrate PPAC evaluation across scaling boosters and artificial designs in a predictive technology node.Comment: 14 pages, 17 figures, submitted to IEEE Trans. on CA

Manufacturability Aware Design.

The aim of this work is to provide solutions that optimize the tradeoffs among design, manufacturability, and cost of ownership posed by technology scaling and sub-wavelength lithography. These solutions may take the form of robust circuit designs, cost-effective resolution technologies, accurate modeling considering process variations, and design rules assessment. We first establish a framework for assessing the impact of process variation on circuit performance, product value and return on investment on alternative processes. Key features include comprehensive modeling and different handling on die-to-die and within-die variation, accurate models of correlations of variation, realistic and quantified projection to future process nodes, and performance sensitivity analysis to improved control of individual device parameter and variation sources. Then we describe a novel minimum cost of correction methodology which determines the level of correction of each layout feature such that the prescribed parametric yield is attained with minimum RET (Resolution Enhancement Technology) cost. This timing driven OPC (Optical Proximity Correction) insertion flow uses a mathematical programming based slack budgeting algorithm to determine OPC level for all polysilicon gate geometries. Designs adopting this methodology show up to 20% MEBES (Manufacturing Electron Beam Exposure System) data volume reduction and 39% OPC runtime improvement. When the systematic correction residual errors become unavoidable, we analyze their impact on a state-of-art microprocessor's speedpath skew. A platform is created for diagnosing and improving OPC quality on gates with specific functionality such as critical gates or matching transistors. Significant changes in full-chip timing analysis indicate the necessity of a post-OPC performance verification design flow. Finally, we quantify the performance, manufacturability and mask cost impact of globally applying several common restrictive design rules. Novel approaches such as locally adapting FDRs (flexible design rules) based on image parameters range, and DRC Plus (preferred design rule enforcement with 2D pattern matching) are also described.Ph.D.Electrical EngineeringUniversity of Michigan, Horace H. Rackham School of Graduate Studieshttp://deepblue.lib.umich.edu/bitstream/2027.42/57676/2/jiey_1.pd

Regular cell design approach considering lithography-induced process variations

The deployment delays for EUVL, forces IC design to continue using 193nm wavelength lithography with innovative and costly techniques in order to faithfully print sub-wavelength features and combat lithography induced process variations. The effect of the lithography gap in current and upcoming technologies is to cause severe distortions due to optical diffraction in the printed patterns and thus degrading manufacturing yield. Therefore, a paradigm shift in layout design is mandatory towards more regular litho-friendly cell designs in order to improve line pattern resolution. However, it is still unclear the amount of layout regularity that can be introduced and how to measure the benefits and weaknesses of regular layouts. This dissertation is focused on searching the degree of layout regularity necessary to combat lithography variability and outperform the layout quality of a design. The main contributions that have been addressed to accomplish this objective are: (1) the definition of several layout design guidelines to mitigate lithography variability; (2) the proposal of a parametric yield estimation model to evaluate the lithography impact on layout design; (3) the development of a global Layout Quality Metric (LQM) including a Regularity Metric (RM) to capture the degree of layout regularity of a layout implementation and; (4) the creation of different layout architectures exploiting the benefits of layout regularity to outperform line-pattern resolution, referred as Adaptive Lithography Aware Regular Cell Designs (ALARCs). The first part of this thesis provides several regular layout design guidelines derived from lithography simulations so that several important lithography related variation sources are minimized. Moreover, a design level methodology, referred as gate biasing, is proposed to overcome systematic layout dependent variations, across-field variations and the non-rectilinear gate effect (NRG) applied to regular fabrics by properly configuring the drawn transistor channel length. The second part of this dissertation proposes a lithography yield estimation model to predict the amount of lithography distortion expected in a printed layout due to lithography hotspots with a reduced set of lithography simulations. An efficient lithography hotspot framework to identify the different layout pattern configurations, simplify them to ease the pattern analysis and classify them according to the lithography degradation predicted using lithography simulations is presented. The yield model is calibrated with delay measurements of a reduced set of identical test circuits implemented in a CMOS 40nm technology and thus actual silicon data is utilized to obtain a more realistic yield estimation. The third part of this thesis presents a configurable Layout Quality Metric (LQM) that considering several layout aspects provides a global evaluation of a layout design with a single score. The LQM can be leveraged by assigning different weights to each evaluation metric or by modifying the parameters under analysis. The LQM is here configured following two different set of partial metrics. Note that the LQM provides a regularity metric (RM) in order to capture the degree of layout regularity applied in a layout design. Lastly, this thesis presents different ALARC designs for a 40nm technology using different degrees of layout regularity and different area overheads. The quality of the gridded regular templates is demonstrated by automatically creating a library containing 266 cells including combinational and sequential cells and synthesizing several ITC'99 benchmark circuits. Note that the regular cell libraries only presents a 9\% area penalty compared to the 2D standard cell designs used for comparison and thus providing area competitive designs. The layout evaluation of benchmark circuits considering the LQM shows that regular layouts can outperform other 2D standard cell designs depending on the layout implementation.Los continuos retrasos en la implementación de la EUVL, fuerzan que el diseño de IC se realice mediante litografía de longitud de onda de 193 nm con innovadoras y costosas técnicas para poder combatir variaciones de proceso de litografía. La gran diferencia entre la longitud de onda y el tamaño de los patrones causa severas distorsiones debido a la difracción óptica en los patrones impresos y por lo tanto degradando el yield. En consecuencia, es necesario realizar un cambio en el diseño de layouts hacia diseños más regulares para poder mejorar la resolución de los patrones. Sin embargo, todavía no está claro el grado de regularidad que se debe introducir y como medir los beneficios y los perjuicios de los diseños regulares. El objetivo de esta tesis es buscar el grado de regularidad necesario para combatir las variaciones de litografía y mejorar la calidad del layout de un diseño. Las principales contribuciones para conseguirlo son: (1) la definición de diversas reglas de diseño de layout para mitigar las variaciones de litografía; (2) la propuesta de un modelo para estimar el yield paramétrico y así evaluar el impacto de la litografía en el diseño de layout; (3) el diseño de una métrica para analizar la calidad de un layout (LQM) incluyendo una métrica para capturar el grado de regularidad de un diseño (RM) y; (4) la creación de diferentes tipos de layout explotando los beneficios de la regularidad, referidos como Adaptative Lithography Aware Regular Cell Designs (ALARCs). La primera parte de la tesis, propone las diversas reglas de diseño para layouts regulares derivadas de simulaciones de litografía de tal manera que las fuentes de variación de litografía son minimizadas. Además, se propone una metodología de diseño para layouts regulares, referida como "gate biasing" para contrarrestar las variaciones sistemáticas dependientes del layout, las variaciones en la ventana de proceso del sistema litográfico y el efecto de puerta no rectilínea para configurar la longitud del canal del transistor correctamente. La segunda parte de la tesis, detalla el modelo de estimación del yield de litografía para predecir mediante un número reducido de simulaciones de litografía la cantidad de distorsión que se espera en un layout impreso debida a "hotspots". Se propone una eficiente metodología que identifica los distintos patrones de un layout, los simplifica para facilitar el análisis de los patrones y los clasifica en relación a la degradación predecida mediante simulaciones de litografía. El modelo de yield se calibra utilizando medidas de tiempo de un número reducido de idénticos circuitos de test implementados en una tecnología CMOS de 40nm y de esta manera, se utilizan datos de silicio para obtener una estimación realista del yield. La tercera parte de este trabajo, presenta una métrica para medir la calidad del layout (LQM), que considera diversos aspectos para dar una evaluación global de un diseño mediante un único valor. La LQM puede ajustarse mediante la asignación de diferentes pesos para cada métrica de evaluación o modificando los parámetros analizados. La LQM se configura mediante dos conjuntos de medidas diferentes. Además, ésta incluye una métrica de regularidad (RM) para capturar el grado de regularidad que se aplica en un diseño. Finalmente, esta disertación presenta los distintos diseños ALARC para una tecnología de 40nm utilizando diversos grados de regularidad y diferentes impactos en área. La calidad de estos diseños se demuestra creando automáticamente una librería de 266 celdas incluyendo celdas combinacionales y secuenciales y, sintetizando diversos circuitos ITC'99. Las librerías regulares solo presentan un 9% de impacto en área comparado con diseños de celdas estándar 2D y por tanto proponiendo diseños competitivos en área. La evaluación de los circuitos considerando la LQM muestra que los diseños regulares pueden mejorar otros diseños 2D dependiendo de la implementación del layout

DFM Techniques for the Detection and Mitigation of Hotspots in Nanometer Technology

With the continuous scaling down of dimensions in advanced technology nodes, process variations are getting worse for each new node. Process variations have a large influence on the quality and yield of the designed and manufactured circuits. There is a growing need for fast and efficient techniques to characterize and mitigate the effects of different sources of process variations on the design's performance and yield. In this thesis we have studied the various sources of systematic process variations and their effects on the circuit, and the various methodologies to combat systematic process variation in the design space. We developed abstract and accurate process variability models, that would model systematic intra-die variations. The models convert the variation in process into variation in electrical parameters of devices and hence variation in circuit performance (timing and leakage) without the need for circuit simulation. And as the analysis and mitigation techniques are studied in different levels of the design ow, we proposed a flow for combating the systematic process variation in nano-meter CMOS technology. By calculating the effects of variability on the electrical performance of circuits we can gauge the importance of the accurate analysis and model-driven corrections. We presented an automated framework that allows the integration of circuit analysis with process variability modeling to optimize the computer intense process simulation steps and optimize the usage of variation mitigation techniques. And we used the results obtained from using this framework to develop a relation between layout regularity and resilience of the devices to process variation. We used these findings to develop a novel technique for fast detection of critical failures (hotspots) resulting from process variation. We showed that our approach is superior to other published techniques in both accuracy and predictability. Finally, we presented an automated method for fixing the lithography hotspots. Our method showed success rate of 99% in fixing hotspots

Design Methodologies and Architecture Solutions for High-Performance Interconnects

ABSTRACT In Deep Sub-Micron (DSM) technologies, interconnects play a crucial role in the correct functionality and largely impact the performance of complex System-on-Chip (SoC) designs. For technologies of 0.25µm and below, wiring capacitance dominates gate capacitance, thus rapidly increasing the interconnect-induced delay. Moreover, the coupling capacitance becomes a significant portion of the on-chip total wiring capacitance, and coupling between adjacent wires cannot be considered as a second-order effect any longer. As a consequence, the traditional top-down design methodology is ineffective, since the actual wiring delays can be computed only after layout parasitic extraction, when the physical design is completed. Fixing all the timing violations often requires several time-consuming iterations of logical and physical design, and it is essentially a trial-and-error approach. Increasingly tighter time-to-market requirements dictate that interconnect parasitics must be taken into account during all phases of the design flow, at different level of abstractions. However, given the aggressive technology scaling trends and the growing design complexity, this approach will only temporarily ameliorate the interconnect problem. We believe that in order to achieve gigascale designs in the nanometer regime, a novel design paradigm, based on new forms of regularity and newly created IP (Intellectual Property) blocks must be developed, to provide a direct path from system-level architectural exploration to physical implementation

Conquering Process Variability: A Key Enabler for Profitable Manufacturing in Advanced Technology Nodes

Abstract – Achieving the required time to market with economically acceptable yield levels and maintaining them in volume production has become a very challenging task in the most advanced technology nodes. One of the primary reasons is the relative increase in process variability in each generation. This paper will describe a comprehensive study of the main sources of variability and their effects on active devices, interconnect and ultimately product performance and yield. We will present benchmarking of yield loss components for different product classes. We will then propose several approaches for variability reduction in the design, yield ramp and volume manufacturing phases. EVOLUTION OF YIELD LOSS MECHANISMS In the older technology generations, manufacturing yield loss was dominated by random defects. By the time volum