Vibration isolation with smart fluid dampers: a benchmarking study

The non-linear behaviour of electrorheological (ER) and magnetorheological (MR) dampers makes it difficult to design effective control strategies, and as a consequence a wide range of control systems have been proposed in the literature. These previous studies have not always compared the performance to equivalent passive systems, alternative control designs, or idealised active systems. As a result it is often impossible to compare the performance of different smart damper control strategies. This article provides some insight into the relative performance of two MR damper control strategies: on/off control and feedback linearisation. The performance of both strategies is benchmarked against ideal passive, semi-active and fully active damping. The study relies upon a previously developed model of an MR damper, which in this work is validated experimentally under closed-loop conditions with a broadband mechanical excitation. Two vibration isolation case studies are investigated: a single-degree-of-freedom mass-isolator, and a two-degree-of-freedom system that represents a vehicle suspension system. In both cases, a variety of broadband mechanical excitations are used and the results analysed in the frequency domain. It is shown that although on/off control is more straightforward to implement, its performance is worse than the feedback linearisation strategy, and can be extremely sensitive to the excitation conditions

Hardware-in-the-loop simulation of magnetorheological dampers for vehicle suspension systems

Magnetorheological (MR) fluids provide an elegant means to enhance vibration control in primary vehicle suspensions. Such fluids can rapidly modify their flow characteristics in response to a magnetic field, so they can be used to create semi-active dampers. However, the behaviour of MR dampers is inherently non-linear and as a consequence, the choice of an effective control strategy remains an unresolved problem. Previous research has developed a method to linearize the damper's force/velocity response, to allow implementation of classical control techniques. In the present study, this strategy is used to implement skyhook damping laws within primary automotive suspensions. To simulate the vehicle suspension, a two-degree-of-freedom quarter car model is used, which is excited by realistic road profiles. The controller performance is investigated experimentally using the hardware-in-the-loop-simulation (HILS) method. This experimental method is described in detail and its performance is validated against numerical simulations for a simplified problem. The present authors demonstrate that feedback linearization can provide significant performance enhancements in terms of passenger comfort, road holding, and suspension working space compared with other control strategies. Furthermore, feedback linearization is shown to desensitize the controller to uncertainties in the input excitation such as changes in severity of the road surface roughness

State of the art of control schemes for smart systems featuring magneto-rheological materials

This review presents various control strategies for application systems utilizing smart magneto-rheological fluid (MRF) and magneto-rheological elastomers (MRE). It is well known that both MRF and MRE are actively studied and applied to many practical systems such as vehicle dampers. The mandatory requirements for successful applications of MRF and MRE include several factors: advanced material properties, optimal mechanisms, suitable modeling, and appropriate control schemes. Among these requirements, the use of an appropriate control scheme is a crucial factor since it is the final action stage of the application systems to achieve the desired output responses. There are numerous different control strategies which have been applied to many different application systems of MRF and MRE, summarized in this review. In the literature review, advantages and disadvantages of each control scheme are discussed so that potential researchers can develop more effective strategies to achieve higher control performance of many application systems utilizing magneto-rheological materials

Vibration control strategies for proof-mass actuators

Proof-mass actuators have been considered for a broad range of structural vibration control problems, from seismic protection for tall buildings to the improvement of metal machining productivity by stabilizing the self-excited vibrations known as chatter. This broad range of potential applications means that a variety of controllers have been proposed, without drawing direct comparisons with other controller designs that have been considered for different applications. This article takes three controllers that are potentially suitable for the machining chatter problem: Direct velocity feedback, tuned-mass-damper control (or vibration absorber control), and active-tuned-mass-damper control (or active vibration absorber control). These control strategies are restated within the more general framework of Virtual Passive Control. Their performance is first compared using root locus techniques, with a model based on experimental data, including the low frequency dynamics of the proof-mass. The frequency response of the test structure is then illustrated under open and closed-loop conditions. The application of the control strategies to avoid machine-tool chatter vibrations is then discussed, without going into detail on the underlying physical mechanisms of chatter. It is concluded that virtual passive absorber control is more straightforward to implement than virtual skyhook damping, and may be better suited to the problem of machining chatter

Prototyping a new car semi-active suspension by variational feedback controller

New suspension systems electronically controlled are presented and mounted on board of a real car. The system consists of variable semi-active magneto-rheological dampers that are controlled through an electronic unit that is designed on the basis of a new optimal theoretical control, named VFC-Variational Feedback Controller. The system has been mounted on board of a BMW Series 1 car, and a set of experimental tests have been conducted in real driving conditions. The VFC reveals, because of its design strategy, to be able to enhance simultaneously both the comfort performance as well as the handling capability of the car. Preliminary comparisons with several industrially control methods adopted in the automotive field, among them skyhook and groundhook, show excellent results

Innovative magnetorheological devices for shock and vibration mitigation

Vibration and impact protection have been a popular topic in research fields, which could directly affect the passengers’ and drivers’ comfort and safety, even cause spines fracture. Therefore, an increasing number of vehicle suspensions and aircraft landing gears are proposed and manufactured. Magnetorheological fluids (MRFs), as a smart material, are growly applied into the above device owing to its unique properties such as fast response, reversible properties, and broad controllable range, which could improve the vibration/impact mitigation performance. MRF was utilized to achieve adaptive parameters of the vehicle suspensions by controlling the magnetic field strength of the MRF working areas. Generally, the magnetic field is provided by a given current, subsequently, it would consume massive energy from a long-term perspective. Thus, a self-powered concept was applied as well. This thesis reports a compact stiffness controllable MR damper with a self-powered capacity. After the prototype of the MR damper, its property tests were conducted to verify the stiffness controllability and the energy generating ability using a hydraulic Instron test system. Then, a quarter-car test rig was built, and the semi-active MR suspension integrated with the self-powered MR damper was installed on a test rig. Two controllers, one based on short-time Fourier transform (STFT) and a classical skyhook controller was developed to control the stiffness. The evaluation results demonstrate that the proposed MR damper incorporated with STFT controller or skyhook controller could suppress the response displacements and accelerations obviously comparing with the conventional passive systems

The use of novel mechanical devices for enhancing the performance of railway vehicles

Following successful implementation of inerters for passive mechanical control in racing cars, this research studies potential innovative solutions for railway vehicle suspensions by bringing the inerter concept to the design of mechatronic systems. The inerter is a kinetic energy storage device which reacts to relative accelerations; together with springs and dampers, it can implement a range of mechanical networks distinguished by their frequency characteristics. This thesis investigates advantages of inerter-based novel devices to simplify the design of active solutions. Most of the research work is devoted to the enhancement of vertical ride quality; integrated active-plus-novel-passive solutions are proposed for the secondary suspensions. These are defined by different active control strategies and passive configurations including inerters. By optimisation of the suspension parameters, a synergy between passive and active configurations is demonstrated for a range of ride quality conditions. The evidence of cooperative work is found in the reduction of the required active forces and suspension travelling. This reveals a potential for reducing the actuator size. Benefits on power requirements and actuator dynamic compensation were also identified. One of the strategies features a nonlinear control law proposed here to compensate for 'sky-hook' damping effects on suspension deflection; this, together with inerter-based devices attains up to 50% in active force reduction for a setting providing 30% of ride quality enhancement. The study is developed from both, an analytical and an engineering perspective. Validation of the results with a more sophisticated model is performed. The lateral stability problem was briefly considered towards the end of the investigation. A potential use of inerter-based devices to replace the static yaw stiffness by dynamic characteristics was identified. This leads to a synergy with 'absolute stiffness', an active stability solution for controlling the wheelset 'hunting' problem, for reducing the creep forces developed during curve negotiation

An adaptive neuro fuzzy hybrid control strategy for a semiactive suspension with magneto rheological damper

The main function of a vehicle suspension system is to isolate the vehicle body from external excitation in order to improve passenger comfort and road holding and to stabilise its movement. This paper considers the implementation of an adaptive neuro fuzzy inference system (ANFIS) with a fuzzy hybrid control technique to control a quarter vehicle suspension system with a semiactive magneto rheological (MR) damper. A quarter car suspension model is set up with an MR damper and a semiactive controller consisting of a fuzzy hybrid skyhook-groundhook controller and an ANFIS model is also designed. The fuzzy hybrid controller is used to generate the desired control force, and the ANFIS is designed to model the inverse dynamics of MR damper in order to obtain a desired current. Finally, numerical simulations of the semiactive suspensions with the ANFIS- hybrid controller, the traditional hybrid controller, and passive suspension are compared. The results of simulations show that the proposed ANFIS-hybrid controller provides better isolation performance than the other controllers

Advanced suspension system using magnetorheological technology for vehicle vibration control

In the past forty years, the concept of controllable vehicle suspension has attracted extensive attention. Since high price of an active suspension system and deficiencies on a passive suspension, researchers pay a lot attention to semi-active suspension. Magneto-rheological fluid (MRF) is always an ideal material of semi-active structure. Thanks to its outstanding features like large yield stress, fast response time, low energy consumption and significant rheological effect. MR damper gradually becomes a preferred component of semi-active suspension for improving the riding performance of vehicle. However, because of the inherent nonlinear nature of MR damper, one of the challenging aspects of utilizing MR dampers to achieve high levels of performance is the development of an appropriate control strategy that can take advantage of the unique characteristics of MR dampers. This is why this project has studied semi-active MR control technology of vehicle suspensions to improve their performance. Focusing on MR semi-active suspension, the aim of this thesis sought to develop system structure and semi-active control strategy to give a vehicle opportunity to have a better performance on riding comfort. The issues of vibration control of the vehicle suspension were systematically analysed in this project. As a part of this research, a quarter-car test rig was built; the models of suspension and MR damper were established; the optimization work of mechanical structure and controller parameters was conducted to further improve the system performance; an optimized MR damper (OMRD) for a vehicle suspension was designed, fabricated, and tested. To utilize OMRD to achieve higher level of performance, an appropriate semi-active control algorithm, state observer-based Takagi-Sugeno fuzzy controller (SOTSFC), was designed for the semi-active suspension system, and its feasibility was verified through an experiment. Several tests were conducted on the quarter-car suspension to investigate the real effect of this semiactive control by changing suspension damping. In order to further enhance the vibration reduction performance of the vehicle, a fullsize variable stiffness and variable damping (VSVD) suspension was further designed, fabricated, and tested in this project. The suspension can be easily installed into a vehicle suspension system without any change to the original configuration. A new 3- degree of freedom (DOF) phenomenological model to further accurately describe the dynamic characteristic of the VSVD suspension was also presented. Based on a simple on-off controller, the performance of the variable stiffness and damping suspension was verified numerically. In addition, an innovative TS fuzzy modelling based VSVD controller was designed. The TS fuzzy modelling controller includes a skyhook damping control module and a state observer based stiffness control module which considering road dominant frequency in real-time. The performance evaluation of the VSVD control algorithm was based on the quarter-car test rig which equipping the VSVD suspension. The experiment results showed that this strategy increases riding comfort effectively, especially under off-road working condition. The semi-active control system developed in this thesis can be adapted and used on a vehicle suspension in order to better control vibration

Design of Cab Suspensions and Semi-Active Seat Damping Control Strategies for Tractor Semi-Trailers

This thesis uses a high fidelity vertical plane ride model of the tractor semi-trailer to study the effect of different cab design configurations and semi-active seat damper control strategies on the driver’s ride comfort. The secondary suspensions of a tractor have been an area of particular interest because of the considerable ride comfort improvements they provide. A gap exists in the current engineering domain of an easily configurable high fidelity low computational cost simulation tool to analyze the ride of a tractor semi-trailer. A 15 degree of freedom model of the tractor semi-trailer was used to develop a simulation tool in the Matlab/Simulink environment. The simulation tool developed was verified against TruckSim. The contributions of the different modes of vibration to the ride comfort were analyzed. It is shown in this work that the ride at the driver’s seat can be significantly improved by relocating the cab mounts near the nodes of the 1st mode of bending of the tractor frame and by employing a full cab suspension. The developed simulation tool was used to quantify the improvements in the driver ride comfort. To develop seat isolation systems, the truck seat was modeled as a base excited 1 d.o.f. system. It is shown in this work that two optimal solutions exist depending on the spatial characteristics of the base excitation. One of the optimal solutions can be physically realized in the form of a passive spring and a passive damper in parallel. The other optimal solution can be approximated by a passive spring and a continuously variable damper in parallel. A fuzzy logic based switch mechanism was developed to switch between two realizations of the optimal solutions. A recursive least square estimator was developed to estimate the seat load and the stiffness of the spring using the same signals as the controller thus allowing universal application of the seat damper controller. The resultant controller is shown to provide the best ride comfort over various types of road surfaces. A model predictive controller for the seat damper was also developed for this work. A novel method was developed to model the bounds on the seat suspension stroke as hard constraints of the optimization problem. An efficient scheme was developed to include the frequency weighted acceleration in the performance index of the optimization problem. It is shown in this work that the MPC based seat damper controller provides better ride comfort in some specific scenarios. This work contributes towards the furthering the knowledge-base of the issues encompassing the ride quality of a tractor semi-trailer. The efficacy of the developed tractor semi-trailer ride simulation tool as a design and analysis tool is presented in this work