Performance and security issues of TCP bulk data transfer in a last mile wireless scenario - investigations and solutions

Master'sMASTER OF SCIENC

Challenges on the way of implementing TCP over 5G networks

5G cellular communication, especially with its hugely available bandwidth provided by millimeter-wave, is a promising technology to fulfill the coming high demand for vast data rates. These networks can support new use cases such as Vehicle to Vehicle and augmented reality due to its novel features such as network slicing along with the mmWave multi-gigabit-per-second data rate. Nevertheless, 5G cellular networks suffer from some shortcomings, especially in high frequencies because of the intermittent nature of channels when the frequency rises. Non-line of sight state, is one of the significant issues that the new generation encounters. This drawback is because of the intense susceptibility of higher frequencies to blockage caused by obstacles and misalignment. This unique characteristic can impair the performance of the reliable transport layer widely deployed protocol, TCP, in attaining high throughput and low latency throughout a fair network. As a result, the protocol needs to adjust the congestion window size based on the current situation of the network. However, TCP is not able to adjust its congestion window efficiently, and it leads to throughput degradation of the protocol. This paper presents a comprehensive analysis of reliable end-to-end communications in 5G networks. It provides the analysis of the effects of TCP in 5G mmWave networks, the discussion of TCP mechanisms and parameters involved in the performance over 5G networks, and a survey of current challenges, solutions, and proposals. Finally, a feasibility analysis proposal of machine learning-based approaches to improve reliable end-to-end communications in 5G networks is presented.This work was supported by the Secretaria d’Universitats i Recerca del Departament d’Empresa i Coneixement de la Generalitat de Catalunya under Grant 2017 SGR 376.Peer ReviewedPostprint (published version

TCP performance enhancement in wireless networks via adaptive congestion control and active queue management

The transmission control protocol (TCP) exhibits poor performance when used in error-prone wireless networks. Remedy to this problem has been an active research area. However, a widely accepted and adopted solution is yet to emerge. Difficulties of an acceptable solution lie in the areas of compatibility, scalability, computational complexity and the involvement of intermediate routers and switches. This dissertation rexriews the current start-of-the-art solutions to TCP performance enhancement, and pursues an end-to-end solution framework to the problem. The most noticeable cause of the performance degradation of TCP in wireless networks is the higher packet loss rate as compared to that in traditional wired networks. Packet loss type differentiation has been the focus of many proposed TCP performance enhancement schemes. Studies conduced by this dissertation research suggest that besides the standard TCP\u27s inability of discriminating congestion packet losses from losses related to wireless link errors, the standard TCP\u27s additive increase and multiplicative decrease (AIMD) congestion control algorithm itself needs to be redesigned to achieve better performance in wireless, and particularly, high-speed wireless networks. This dissertation proposes a simple, efficient, and effective end-to-end solution framework that enhances TCP\u27s performance through techniques of adaptive congestion control and active queue management. By end-to-end, it means a solution with no requirement of routers being wireless-aware or wireless-specific . TCP-Jersey has been introduced as an implementation of the proposed solution framework, and its performance metrics have been evaluated through extensive simulations. TCP-Jersey consists of an adaptive congestion control algorithm at the source by means of the source\u27s achievable rate estimation (ARE) —an adaptive filter of packet inter-arrival times, a congestion indication algorithm at the links (i.e., AQM) by means of packet marking, and a effective loss differentiation algorithm at the source by careful examination of the congestion marks carried by the duplicate acknowledgment packets (DUPACK). Several improvements to the proposed TCP-Jersey have been investigated, including a more robust ARE algorithm, a less computationally intensive threshold marking algorithm as the AQM link algorithm, a more stable congestion indication function based on virtual capacity at the link, and performance results have been presented and analyzed via extensive simulations of various network configurations. Stability analysis of the proposed ARE-based additive increase and adaptive decrease (AJAD) congestion control algorithm has been conducted and the analytical results have been verified by simulations. Performance of TCP-Jersey has been compared to that of a perfect , but not practical, TCP scheme, and encouraging results have been observed. Finally the framework of the TCP-Jersey\u27s source algorithm has been extended and generalized for rate-based congestion control, as opposed to TCP\u27s window-based congestion control, to provide a design platform for applications, such as real-time multimedia, that do not use TCP as transport protocol yet do need to control network congestion as well as combat packet losses in wireless networks. In conclusion, the framework architecture presented in this dissertation that combines the adaptive congestion control and active queue management in solving the TCP performance degradation problem in wireless networks has been shown as a promising answer to the problem due to its simplistic design philosophy complete compatibility with the current TCP/IP and AQM practice, end-to-end architecture for scalability, and the high effectiveness and low computational overhead. The proposed implementation of the solution framework, namely TCP-Jersey is a modification of the standard TCP protocol rather than a completely new design of the transport protocol. It is an end-to-end approach to address the performance degradation problem since it does not require split mode connection establishment and maintenance using special wireless-aware software agents at the routers. The proposed solution also differs from other solutions that rely on the link layer error notifications for packet loss differentiation. The proposed solution is also unique among other proposed end-to-end solutions in that it differentiates packet losses attributed to wireless link errors from congestion induced packet losses directly from the explicit congestion indication marks in the DUPACK packets, rather than inferring the loss type based on packet delay or delay jitter as in many other proposed solutions; nor by undergoing a computationally expensive off-line training of a classification model (e.g., HMM), or a Bayesian estimation/detection process that requires estimations of a priori loss probability distributions of different loss types. The proposed solution is also scalable and fully compatible to the current practice in Internet congestion control and queue management, but with an additional function of loss type differentiation that effectively enhances TCP\u27s performance over error-prone wireless networks. Limitations of the proposed solution architecture and areas for future researches are also addressed

STCP: A New Transport Protocol for High-Speed Networks

Transmission Control Protocol (TCP) is the dominant transport protocol today and likely to be adopted in future high‐speed and optical networks. A number of literature works have been done to modify or tune the Additive Increase Multiplicative Decrease (AIMD) principle in TCP to enhance the network performance. In this work, to efficiently take advantage of the available high bandwidth from the high‐speed and optical infrastructures, we propose a Stratified TCP (STCP) employing parallel virtual transmission layers in high‐speed networks. In this technique, the AIMD principle of TCP is modified to make more aggressive and efficient probing of the available link bandwidth, which in turn increases the performance. Simulation results show that STCP offers a considerable improvement in performance when compared with other TCP variants such as the conventional TCP protocol and Layered TCP (LTCP)

Contribution to reliable end-to-end communication over 5G networks using advanced techniques

5G cellular communication, especially with its hugely available bandwidth provided by millimeter-wave, is a promising technology to fulfill the coming high demand for vast data rates. These networks can support new use cases such as Vehicle to Vehicle and augmented reality due to its novel features such as network slicing along with the mmWave multi-gigabit-persecond data rate. Nevertheless, 5G cellular networks suffer from some shortcomings, especially in high frequencies because of the intermittent nature of channels when the frequency rises. Non-line of sight state is one of the significant issues that the new generation encounters. This drawback is because of the intense susceptibility of higher frequencies to blockage caused by obstacles and misalignment. This unique characteristic can impair the performance of the reliable transport layer widely deployed protocol, TCP, in attaining high throughput and low latency throughout a fair network. As a result, the protocol needs to adjust the congestion window size based on the current situation of the network. However, TCP cannot adjust its congestion window efficiently, which leads to throughput degradation of the protocol. This thesis presents a comprehensive analysis of reliable end-to-end communications in 5G networks and analyzes TCP’s behavior in one of the 3GPP’s well-known s cenarios called urban deployment. Furtherm ore, two novel TCPs bas ed on artificial intelligence have been proposed to deal with this issue. The first protocol uses Fuzzy logic, a subset of artificial intelligence, and the second one is based on deep learning. The extensively conducted simulations showed that the newly proposed protocols could attain higher performance than common TCPs, such as BBR, HighSpeed, Cubic, and NewReno in terms of throughput, RTT, and sending rate adjustment in the urban scenario. The new protocols' superiority is achieved by employing smartness in the conges tions control mechanism of TCP, which is a powerful enabler in fos tering TCP’s functionality. To s um up, the 5G network is a promising telecommunication infrastructure that will revolute various aspects of communication. However, different parts of the Internet, such as its regulations and protocol stack, will face new challenges, which need to be solved in order to exploit 5G capacity, and without intelligent rules and protocols, the high bandwidth of 5G, especially 5G mmWave will be wasted. Two novel schemes to solve the issues have been proposed based on an Artificial Intelligence subset technique called fuzzy and a machine learning-based approach called Deep learning to enhance the performance of 5G mmWave by improving the functionality of the transport layer. The obtained results indicated that the new schemes could improve the functionality of TCP by giving intelligence to the protocol. As the protocol works more smartly, it can make sufficient decisions on different conditions.La comunicació cel·lular 5G, especialment amb l’amplada de banda molt disponible que proporciona l’ona mil·limètrica, és una tecnologia prometedora per satisfer l’elevada demanda de grans velocitats de dades. Aquestes xarxes poden admetre casos d’ús nous, com ara Vehicle to Vehicle i realitat augmentada, a causa de les seves novetats, com ara el tall de xarxa juntament amb la velocitat de dades mWave de multi-gigabit per segon. Tot i això, les xarxes cel·lulars 5G pateixen algunes deficiències, sobretot en freqüències altes a causa de la naturalesa intermitent dels canals quan augmenta la freqüència. L’estat de no visió és un dels problemes significatius que troba la nova generació. Aquest inconvenient es deu a la intensa susceptibilitat de freqüències més altes al bloqueig causat per obstacles i desalineació. Aquesta característica única pot perjudicar el rendiment del protocol TCP, àmpliament desplegat, de capa de transport fiable en aconseguir un alt rendiment i una latència baixa en tota una xarxa justa. Com a resultat, el protocol ha d’ajustar la mida de la finestra de congestió en funció de la situació actual de la xarxa. Tot i això, TCP no pot ajustar la seva finestra de congestió de manera eficient, cosa que provoca una degradació del rendiment del protocol. Aquesta tesi presenta una anàlisi completa de comunicacions extrem a extrem en xarxes 5G i analitza el comportament de TCP en un dels escenaris coneguts del 3GPP anomenat desplegament urbà. A més, s'han proposat dos TCP nous basats en intel·ligència artificial per tractar aquest tema. El primer protocol utilitza la lògica Fuzzy, un subconjunt d’intel·ligència artificial, i el segon es basa en l’aprenentatge profund. Les simulacions àmpliament realitzades van mostrar que els protocols proposats recentment podrien assolir un rendiment superior als TCP habituals, com ara BBR, HighSpeed, Cubic i NewReno, en termes de rendiment, RTT i ajust d’índex d’enviament en l’escenari urbà. La superioritat dels nous protocols s’aconsegueix utilitzant la intel·ligència en el mecanisme de control de congestions de TCP, que és un poderós facilitador per fomentar la funcionalitat de TCP. En resum, la xarxa 5G és una prometedora infraestructura de telecomunicacions que revolucionarà diversos aspectes de la comunicació. No obstant això, diferents parts d’Internet, com ara les seves regulacions i la seva pila de protocols, s’enfrontaran a nous reptes, que cal resoldre per explotar la capacitat 5G, i sens regles i protocols intel·ligents, l’amplada de banda elevada de 5G, especialment 5G mmWave, pot ser desaprofitat. S'han proposat dos nous es quemes per resoldre els problemes basats en una tècnica de subconjunt d'Intel·ligència Artificial anomenada “difusa” i un enfocament basat en l'aprenentatge automàtic anomenat “Aprenentatge profund” per millorar el rendiment de 5G mmWave, millorant la funcionalitat de la capa de transport. Els resultats obtinguts van indicar que els nous esquemes podrien millorar la funcionalitat de TCP donant intel·ligència al protocol. Com que el protocol funciona de manera més intel·ligent, pot prendre decisions suficients en diferents condicionsPostprint (published version

Improved algorithms for TCP congestion control

Reliable and efficient data transfer on the Internet is an important issue. Since late 70’s the protocol responsible for that has been the de facto standard TCP, which has proven to be successful through out the years, its self-managed congestion control algorithms have retained the stability of the Internet for decades. However, the variety of existing new technologies such as high-speed networks (e.g. fibre optics) with high-speed long-delay set-up (e.g. cross-Atlantic links) and wireless technologies have posed lots of challenges to TCP congestion control algorithms. The congestion control research community proposed solutions to most of these challenges. This dissertation adds to the existing work by: firstly tackling the highspeed long-delay problem of TCP, we propose enhancements to one of the existing TCP variants (part of Linux kernel stack). We then propose our own variant: TCP-Gentle. Secondly, tackling the challenge of differentiating the wireless loss from congestive loss in a passive way and we propose a novel loss differentiation algorithm which quantifies the noise in packet inter arrival times and use this information together with the span (ratio of maximum to minimum packet inter arrival times) to adapt the multiplicative decrease factor according to a predefined logical formula. Finally, extending the well-known drift model of TCP to account for wireless loss and some hypothetical cases (e.g. variable multiplicative decrease), we have undertaken stability analysis for the new version of the model

Control de Congestión TCP y mecanismos AQM

En los últimos años se ha ido poniendo énfasis particularmente en la importancia del retraso sobre la capacidad. Hoy en día, nuestras redes se están volviendo más y más sensibles a la latencia debido a la proliferación de aplicaciones y servicios como el VoIP, la IPTV o el juego online donde un retardo bajo es esencial para un desempeño adecuado y una buena experiencia de usuario. La mayor parte de este retraso innecesario se debe al mal funcionamiento de algunos búferes que pueblan internet. En vez de desempeñar la tarea para la que fueron creados, absorber eventuales ráfagas de paquetes con el fin de prevenir su pérdida, hacen creer al mecanismo de control de congestión que la ruta hacia el destino actual tiene más ancho de banda que el que posee realmente. Cuando la pérdida de paquetes ocurre, si es que lo hace, es demasiado tarde y el daño en el enlace, en forma de tiempo de transmisión adicional, ya se ha producido. En este trabajo de fín de grado intentaremos arrojar luz sobre una solución específica cuyo objetivo es el de reducir el retardo extra producido por esos hinchados búferes, la Gestión Avanzada de Colas o Active Queue Management (AQM). Hemos testeado un grupo de estos algoritmos AQM junto con diferentes modificaciones del control de congestión de TCP con el fín de entender las interacciones generadas entre esos dos mecanismos, realizando simulaciones en varios escenarios caracterísiticos tales como enlaces transoceánicos o enlaces de acceso a red, entre otros.In recent years, the relevance of delay over throughput has been particularly emphasized. Nowadays our networks are getting more and more sensible to latency due to the proliferation of applications and services like VoIP, IPTV or online gaming where a low delay is essential for a proper performance and a good user experience. Most of this unnecessary delay is created by the misbehaviour of many bu ers that populate Internet. Instead of performing the task for what they were created for, absorbing eventual packet bursts to prevent loss, they deceive the sender's congestion control mechanisms into believing that the current path to the destination has more bandwidth than it really has. When the loss event occurs, if it does, it's too late and the damage on the path, in terms of additional transmission time, has been done. On this bachelor thesis we will try to throw light over an speci c solution that aims to reduce the extra delay produced by these bloated bu ers: Active Queue Management. We have tested a bunch of AQM algorithms with di erent TCP modi cations in order to understand the interactions between these two mechanisms. We performed simulations testing various characteristic scenarios like Transoceanic links or Access link scenarios, among other.Ingeniería Telemátic

Mobile Networking

We point out the different performance problems that need to be addressed when considering mobility in IP networks. We also define the reference architecture and present a framework to classify the different solutions for mobility management in IP networks. The performance of the major candidate micro-mobility solutions is evaluated for both real-time (UDP) and data (TCP) traffic through simulation and by means of an analytical model. Using these models we compare the performance of different mobility management schemes for different data and real-time services and the network resources that are needed for it. We point out the problems of TCP in wireless environments and review some proposed enhancements to TCP that aim at improving TCP performance. We make a detailed study of how some of micro-mobility protocols namely Cellular IP, Hawaii and Hierarchical Mobile IP affect the behavior of TCP and their interaction with the MAC layer. We investigate the impact of handoffs on TCP by means of simulation traces that show the evolution of segments and acknowledgments during handoffs.Publicad

Explicit congestion control algorithms for time-varying capacity media

Tese de doutoramento. Engenharia Electrotécnica e de Computadores. Faculdade de Engenharia. Universidade do Porto. 200

Performance evaluation of TCP-based applications over DVB-RCS DAMA schemes

Transmission Control Protocol (TCP) performance over Digital Video Broadcasting-Return Channel via Satellite (DVB-RCS) standard is greatly affected by the total delay, which is mainly clue to two components, propagation delay and access delay. Both are significant because they are dependent oil the long propagation path of the satellite link. I-lie former is intrinsic and due to radio wave propagation over the satellite channel for both TCP packets and acknowledgements. It is regulated by the control loop that governs TCP. The latter is due to the control loop that governs the demand assignment Multiple access (DAMA) signalling exchange between satellite terminals and the network control center. necessary to manage return link resources. DAMA is adopted in DVB-RCS standard to achieve flexible and efficient use of the shared resources. Therefore, performance of TCP over DVB-RCS may degrade due to the exploitation of two nested control loops also depending oil both file selected DAMA algorithm and the traffic profile. This paper analyses the impact of basic DAMA implementation oil TCP-based applications over a DVB-RCS link for a large Set Of study Cases. To provide a detailed overview of TCP performance in DVB-RCS environment, the analysis includes both theoretical approach and simulation campaign. Copyright (C) 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd