A model-based sustainable productivity concept for the best decision-making in rough milling operations

[EN]There is a need in manufacturing as in machining of being more productive. However, at the same time, workshops are also urged for lesser energy waste in cutting operations. Specially, rough milling of impellers and bladed integrated disks of aircraft engines need an efficient use of energy due to the long cycle times. Indeed, to avoid dramatic tool failures and idle times, cutting conditions and operations tend to be very conservative. This is a multivariable problem, where process engineers need to handle several aspects such as milling operation type, toolpath strategies, cutting conditions, or clamping systems. There is no criterion embracing productivity and power consumption. In this sense, this work proposes a methodology that meets productivity and sustainability by using a specific cutting energy or sustainable productivity gain (SPG) factor. Three rough milling operations-slot, plunge nad trochoidal milling-were modelled and verified. A bottom-up approach based on data from developed mechanistic force models evaluated and compared different alternatives for making a slot, which is a common operation in that king of workpieces. Experimental data confirmed that serrated end milling with the highest SPG value of 1 is the best milling operation in terms of power consumption and mass removal rate (MRR). In the case of plunge milling technique achieve an SPG < 0.51 while trochoidal milling produces a very low SPG value.The authors acknowledge the support from the Spanish Government (JANO, CIEN Project, 2019.0760) and Basque Government (ELKARTEK19/46, KK-2019/00004). This research was funded by Tecnologico de Monterrey through the Research Group of Nanotechnology for Devices Design, and by the Consejo Nacional de Ciencia y Tecnologia de Mexico (Conacyt), Project Number 296176, and National Lab in Additive Manufacturing, 3D Digitizing and Computed Tomography (MADiT) LN299129. The authors also acknowledge the support from Garikoitz Goikoetxea and fruitful discussions with Mr. Jon Mendez (Guhring (c)) and Endika Monge (Hoffmann Group (c))

Effects of cutting conditions on forces and force coefficients in plunge milling operations

The modeling of milling forces is a crucial issue to understand milling processes. In the literature, many force models and experiments to identify force coefficients are found. The objective of this article is to develop a new approach, based on the traditional average force method, able to measure and compute the cutting coefficients for end mills used in plunging operations. This model has been used to evaluate the effect of the radial engagement on the cutting coefficients themselves, proposing a new strategy to update these values for different cutting parameters. This dependency of the cutting coefficient is particularly important for the determination of the stability lobe diagrams, used to predict the chatter conditions. In this article, the method to assess the cutting coefficients, the results of the experimental tests, and the effect of condition-dependent cutting coefficients on process stability are presented

Analytical prediction of stability limit in turning operations

Unstable cutting due to chatter vibrations is one of the most important problems during metal cutting operations. Chatter can be a limitation for productivity and surface quality in turning operations, especially when long and slender tools and parts are involved. In this study, an analytical stability method for turning process is presented. The model takes the cutting geometry into consideration, and proposes a new solution procedure for the dynamic chip thickness at the insert nose. The analytically calculated absolute stable depth of cuts are compared with the chatter test results, and a good agreement is observed

Plunge milling time optimization via mixed-integer nonlinear programming

International audiencePlunge milling is a recent and efficient production mean for machining deep workpieces, notably in aeronautics. This paper focuses on the minimization of the machining time by optimizing the values of the cutting parameters. Currently, neither Computer-Aided Manufacturing (CAM) software nor standard approaches take into account the tool path geometry and the control laws driving the tool displacements to propose optimal cutting parameter values, despite their significant impact. This paper contributes to plunge milling optimization through a Mixed-Integer NonLinear Programming (MINLP) approach, which enables us to determine optimal cutting parameter values that evolve along the tool path. It involves both continuous (cutting speed, feed per tooth) and, in contrast with standard approaches, integer (number of plunges) optimization variables, as well as nonlinear constraints. These constraints are related to the Computer Numerical Control (CNC) machine tool and to the cutting tool, taking into account the control laws. Computational results, validated on CNC machines and on representative test cases of engine housing, show that our methodology outperforms standard industrial engineering know-how approaches by up to 55% in terms of machining time

The difficulties of the assessment of tool life in CNC milling

In the manufacturing process, tool life is an important parameter in milling operations. The main objective of this paper is to explain how difficult is it to assess how much work a tool has undertaken before it must be changed. A number of ways of expressing tool life are currently used, including the conventional method based upon one of several configurations of the Taylor Tool Life Equation. These usually express tool life in terms of known material properties together with primary machining variables like speed, feed and depth of cut. Other approaches are based upon the extrapolation of a tool wear curve and considerations of the volume of metal removed. This initial investigation adopts an approach that is based upon a series of experiments, which produce data indicating the changes in machined feature form and dimension. For this study, a new test piece was designed in order to allow the indirect assessment of the tool flank wear by utilising a Coordinate Measuring Machine to accurately measure the workpieces. This work is intended to indicate how difficult it is to actually apply the existing methods to manage tool wear. The aim is to engineer a better way and to establish a methodology of measuring what the tool is actually doing in real time using the machine controller

CNC spindle signal investigation for the prediction of cutting tool health

The deterioration of cutting tools plays a significant role in the progression of subtractive manufacturing and substantially affects the quality of machined parts. Recognising this most organisations have implemented conventional methods for tool management. These reduce the economic loss associated with time-dependent and stochastic tool wear, and limit the damage arising from tools at end-of-life. However, significant costs still remain to be addressed and more development towards tool and process prognostics is desirable. In response, this work investigates process deterioration through the acquisition and processing of selected machine signals. This utilises the internal processor of a CNC Vertical Machining Centre and considers the possible applications of such an approach for the prediction of tool and process health. This paper considers the prediction of tool and process condition with a discussion of the assumptions, benefits, and limitations of such approaches. Furthermore, the efficacy of the approach is tested using the correlation between an offline measurement of part accuracy and an active measure of process variation

Cold Micro Metal Forming

This open access book contains the research report of the Collaborative Research Center “Micro Cold Forming” (SFB 747) of the University of Bremen, Germany. The topical research focus lies on new methods and processes for a mastered mass production of micro parts which are smaller than 1mm (by forming in batch size higher than one million). The target audience primarily comprises research experts and practitioners in production engineering, but the book may also be of interest to graduate students alike

Investigation of cutting mechanics in single point diamond turning of silicon

As a kind of brittle material, silicon will undergo brittle fracture at atmospheric pressure in conventional scale machining. Studies in the last two decades on hard and brittle materials including silicon, germanium, silicon nitride and silicon carbide have demonstrated ductile regime machining using single point diamond turning (SPDT) process. The mirror-like surface finish can be achieved in SPDT provided appropriate tool geometry and cutting parameters including feed rate, depth of cut and cutting speed are adopted.The research work in this thesis is based on combined experimental and numerical smoothed particle hydrodynamics (SPH) studies to provide an inclusive understanding of SPDT of silicon. A global perspective of tool and workpiece condition using experimental studies along with localized chip formation and stress distribution analysis using distinctive SPH approach offer a comprehensive insight of cutting mechanics of silicon and diamond tool wear. In SPH modelling of SPDT of silicon, the distribution of von Mises and hydrostatic stress at incipient and steady-state was found to provide the conditions pertinent to material failure, phase transformation, and ductile mode machining. The pressure-sensitive Drucker Prager (DP) material constitutive model was adopted to predict the machining response behaviour of silicon during SPDT. Inverse parametric analysis based on indentation test was carried out to determine the unknown DP parameters of silicon by analysing the loading-unloading curve for different DP parameters. A very first experimental study was conducted to determine Johnson-Cook (J-C) model constants for silicon. High strain rate compression tests using split Hopkinson pressure bar (SHPB) test as well as quasi-static tests using Instron fatigue testing machine were conducted to determine J-C model constants.The capability of diamond tools to maintain expedient conditions for high-pressure phase transformation (HPPT) as a function of rake angle and tool wear were investigated experimentally as well as using SPH approach. The proportional relationship of cutting forces magnitude and tool wear was found to differ owing to wear contour with different rake angles that influence the distribution of stresses and uniform hydrostatic pressure under the tool cutting edge. A new quantitative evaluation parameter for the tool wear resistance performance based on the cutting distance was also proposed. It was also found that the machinability of silicon could be improved by adopting novel surface defect machining (SDM) method.The ductile to brittle transition (DBT) with the progressive tool wear was found to initiate with the formation of lateral cracks at low tool wear volume which transform into brittle pitting damage at higher tool edge degradation. A significant variation in resistance to shear deformation as well as position shift of the maximum stress values was observed with the progressive tool wear. The magnitude and distribution of hydrostatic stress were also found to change significantly along the cutting edge of the new and worn diamond tools.As a kind of brittle material, silicon will undergo brittle fracture at atmospheric pressure in conventional scale machining. Studies in the last two decades on hard and brittle materials including silicon, germanium, silicon nitride and silicon carbide have demonstrated ductile regime machining using single point diamond turning (SPDT) process. The mirror-like surface finish can be achieved in SPDT provided appropriate tool geometry and cutting parameters including feed rate, depth of cut and cutting speed are adopted.The research work in this thesis is based on combined experimental and numerical smoothed particle hydrodynamics (SPH) studies to provide an inclusive understanding of SPDT of silicon. A global perspective of tool and workpiece condition using experimental studies along with localized chip formation and stress distribution analysis using distinctive SPH approach offer a comprehensive insight of cutting mechanics of silicon and diamond tool wear. In SPH modelling of SPDT of silicon, the distribution of von Mises and hydrostatic stress at incipient and steady-state was found to provide the conditions pertinent to material failure, phase transformation, and ductile mode machining. The pressure-sensitive Drucker Prager (DP) material constitutive model was adopted to predict the machining response behaviour of silicon during SPDT. Inverse parametric analysis based on indentation test was carried out to determine the unknown DP parameters of silicon by analysing the loading-unloading curve for different DP parameters. A very first experimental study was conducted to determine Johnson-Cook (J-C) model constants for silicon. High strain rate compression tests using split Hopkinson pressure bar (SHPB) test as well as quasi-static tests using Instron fatigue testing machine were conducted to determine J-C model constants.The capability of diamond tools to maintain expedient conditions for high-pressure phase transformation (HPPT) as a function of rake angle and tool wear were investigated experimentally as well as using SPH approach. The proportional relationship of cutting forces magnitude and tool wear was found to differ owing to wear contour with different rake angles that influence the distribution of stresses and uniform hydrostatic pressure under the tool cutting edge. A new quantitative evaluation parameter for the tool wear resistance performance based on the cutting distance was also proposed. It was also found that the machinability of silicon could be improved by adopting novel surface defect machining (SDM) method.The ductile to brittle transition (DBT) with the progressive tool wear was found to initiate with the formation of lateral cracks at low tool wear volume which transform into brittle pitting damage at higher tool edge degradation. A significant variation in resistance to shear deformation as well as position shift of the maximum stress values was observed with the progressive tool wear. The magnitude and distribution of hydrostatic stress were also found to change significantly along the cutting edge of the new and worn diamond tools

Advances in centerless grinding

La lavorazione di rettifica senza centri a tuffo \ue8 un processo ad alta produttivit\ue0 ma che pu\uf2 soffrire di instabilit\ue0 e condizioni mutevoli, dovuti alla propria configurazione geometrica e alle caratteristiche degli utensili abrasivi. Il presente lavoro si propone di presentare un approccio pratico alla scelta dei parametri di processo con uno studio sperimentale dei loro effetti sulle caratteristiche qualitative tipiche di questa lavorazion