Transparent management of scratchpad memories in shared memory programming models

Cache-coherent shared memory has traditionally been the favorite memory organization for chip multiprocessors thanks to its high programmability. In this organization the cache hierarchy is in charge of moving the data and keeping it coherent between all the caches, enabling the usage of shared memory programming models where the programmer does not need to carry out any data management operation. Unfortunately, performing all the data management operations in hardware causes severe problems, being the primary concerns the power consumption originated in the caches and the amount of coherence traffic in the interconnection network. A good solution is to introduce ScratchPad Memories (SPMs) alongside the cache hierarchy, forming a hybrid memory hierarchy. SPMs are more power-efficient than caches and do not generate coherence traffic, but they degrade programmability. In particular, SPMs require the programmer to partition the data, to program data transfers, and to keep coherence between different copies of the data. A promising solution to exploit the benefits of the SPMs without harming programmability is to allow programmers to use shared memory programming models and to automatically generate code that manages the SPMs. Unfortunately, current compilers and runtime systems encounter serious limitations to automatically generate code for hybrid memory hierarchies from shared memory programming models. This thesis proposes to transparently manage the SPMs of hybrid memory hierarchies in shared memory programming models. In order to achieve this goal this thesis proposes a combination of hardware and compiler techniques to manage the SPMs in fork-join programming models and a set of runtime system techniques to manage the SPMs in task programming models. The proposed techniques allow to program hybrid memory hierarchies with these two well-known and easy-to-use forms of shared memory programming models, capitalizing on the benefits of hybrid memory hierarchies in power consumption and network traffic without harming programmability. The first contribution of this thesis is a hardware/software co-designed coherence protocol to transparently manage the SPMs of hybrid memory hierarchies in fork-join programming models. The solution allows the compiler to always generate code to manage the SPMs with tiling software caches, even in the presence of unknown memory aliasing hazards between memory references to the SPMs and to the cache hierarchy. On the software side, the compiler generates a special form of memory instruction for memory references with possible aliasing hazards. On the hardware side, the special memory instructions are diverted to the correct copy of the data using a set of directories that track what data is mapped to the SPMs. The second contribution of this thesis is a set of runtime system techniques to manage the SPMs of hybrid memory hierarchies in task programming models. The proposed runtime system techniques exploit the characteristics of these programming models to map the data specified in the task dependences to the SPMs. Different policies are proposed to mitigate the communication costs of the data transfers, overlapping them with other execution phases such as the task scheduling phase or the execution of the previous task. The runtime system can also reduce the number of data transfers by using a task scheduler that exploits data locality in the SPMs. In addition, the proposed techniques are combined with mechanisms that reduce the impact of fine-grained tasks, such as hardware runtime systems or large SPM sizes. The accomplishment of this thesis is that hybrid memory hierarchies can be programmed with fork-join and task programming models. Consequently, architectures with hybrid memory hierarchies can be exposed to the programmer as a shared memory multiprocessor, taking advantage of the benefits of the SPMs while maintaining the programming simplicity of shared memory programming models.La memoria compartida con coherencia de caches es la jerarquía de memoria más utilizada en multiprocesadores gracias a su programabilidad. En esta solución la jerarquía de caches se encarga de mover los datos y mantener la coherencia entre las caches, habilitando el uso de modelos de programación de memoria compartida donde el programador no tiene que realizar ninguna operación para gestionar las memorias. Desafortunadamente, realizar estas operaciones en la arquitectura causa problemas severos, siendo especialmente relevantes el consumo de energía de las caches y la cantidad de tráfico de coherencia en la red de interconexión. Una buena solución es añadir Memorias ScratchPad (SPMs) acompañando la jerarquía de caches, formando una jerarquía de memoria híbrida. Las SPMs son más eficientes en energía y tráfico de coherencia, pero dificultan la programabilidad ya que requieren que el programador particione los datos, programe transferencias de datos y mantenga la coherencia entre diferentes copias de datos. Una solución prometedora para beneficiarse de las ventajas de las SPMs sin dificultar la programabilidad es permitir que el programador use modelos de programación de memoria compartida y generar código para gestionar las SPMs automáticamente. El problema es que los compiladores y los entornos de ejecución actuales sufren graves limitaciones al gestionar automáticamente una jerarquía de memoria híbrida en modelos de programación de memoria compartida. Esta tesis propone gestionar automáticamente una jerarquía de memoria híbrida en modelos de programación de memoria compartida. Para conseguir este objetivo esta tesis propone una combinación de técnicas hardware y de compilador para gestionar las SPMs en modelos de programación fork-join, y técnicas en entornos de ejecución para gestionar las SPMs en modelos de programación basados en tareas. Las técnicas propuestas hacen que las jerarquías de memoria híbridas puedan programarse con estos dos modelos de programación de memoria compartida, de tal forma que las ventajas en energía y tráfico de coherencia se puedan explotar sin dificultar la programabilidad. La primera contribución de esta tesis en un protocolo de coherencia hardware/software para gestionar SPMs en modelos de programación fork-join. La propuesta consigue que el compilador siempre pueda generar código para gestionar las SPMs, incluso cuando hay posibles alias de memoria entre referencias a memoria a las SPMs y a la jerarquía de caches. En la solución el compilador genera instrucciones especiales para las referencias a memoria con posibles alias, y el hardware sirve las instrucciones especiales con la copia válida de los datos usando directorios que guardan información sobre qué datos están mapeados en las SPMs. La segunda contribución de esta tesis son una serie de técnicas para gestionar SPMs en modelos de programación basados en tareas. Las técnicas aprovechan las características de estos modelos de programación para mapear las dependencias de las tareas en las SPMs y se complementan con políticas para minimizar los costes de las transferencias de datos, como solaparlas con fases del entorno de ejecución o la ejecución de tareas anteriores. El número de transferencias también se puede reducir utilizando un planificador que tenga en cuenta la localidad de datos y, además, las técnicas se pueden combinar con mecanismos para reducir los efectos negativos de tener tareas pequeñas, como entornos de ejecución en hardware o SPMs de más capacidad. Las propuestas de esta tesis consiguen que las jerarquías de memoria híbridas se puedan programar con modelos de programación fork-join y basados en tareas. En consecuencia, las arquitecturas con jerarquías de memoria híbridas se pueden exponer al programador como multiprocesadores de memoria compartida, beneficiándose de las ventajas de las SPMs en energía y tráfico de coherencia y manteniendo la simplicidad de uso de los modelos de programación de memoria compartida

Generating, Optimizing, and Scheduling a Compiler Level Representation of Stream Parallelism

Stream parallelism is often cited as a powerful programming model for expressing parallel computation for multi-core and heterogeneous computers. It allows programmers to concisely describe the concurrency and communication requirements found in a program and it allows compilers and runtime systems to easily generate efficient code targeting parallel hardware. This type of stream parallelism is often restricted to use the Synchronous Dataflow (SDF) model and implemented using static compilation and scheduling techniques. While powerful, SDF and the associated static methods have real limitations when applied to general purpose programing on general purpose hardware. To increase generality, we can define stream parallelism as a graph of processes communicating with one another over unidirectional data channels. Although dynamic scheduling techniques have been developed for this more general model, the powerful compiler transformations that are available under the SDF model no longer apply. This is made worse by the fact that general purpose models are typically implemented as software frameworks on top of high-level general purpose languages. The Stream and Kernel Intermediate Representation (SKIR) is a compiler level representation of stream parallelism for general purpose languages. A SKIR compiler is able to recognize and take advantage of SDF style parallelism while allowing more general programs. This thesis presents the SKIR program representation and describes how it can be used as compiler target for several different high level languages. We show a dynamic scheduling mechanism for SKIR programs based on the concepts of coroutines and task stealing. We also propose code optimizations to reduce runtime overhead associated with dynamic scheduling. Such techniques are not possible in a high-level software framework and provide performance that meets or exceeds the performance of existing systems while providing greater generality and portability than static methods

Realizing Software Defined Radio - A Study in Designing Mobile Supercomputers.

The physical layer of most wireless protocols is traditionally implemented in custom hardware to satisfy the heavy computational requirements while keeping power consumption to a minimum. These implementations are time consuming to design and difficult to verify. A programmable hardware platform capable of supporting software implementations of the physical layer, or Software Defined Radio (SDR), has a number of advantages. These include support for multiple protocols, faster time-to-market, higher chip volumes, and support for late implementation changes. The challenge is to achieve this under the power budget of a mobile device. Wireless communications belong to an emerging class of applications with the processing requirements of a supercomputer but the power constraints of a mobile device -- mobile supercomputing. This thesis presents a set of design proposals for building a programmable wireless communication solution. In order to design a solution that can meet the lofty requirements of SDR, this thesis takes an application-centric design approach -- evaluate and optimize all aspects of the design based on the characteristics of wireless communication protocols. This includes a DSP processor architecture optimized for wireless baseband processing, wireless algorithm optimizations, and language and compilation tool support for the algorithm software and the processor hardware. This thesis first analyzes the software characteristics of SDR. Based on the analysis, this thesis proposes the Signal-Processing On-Demand Architecture (SODA), a fully programmable multi-core architecture that can support the computation requirements of third generation wireless protocols, while operating within the power budget of a mobile device. This thesis then presents wireless algorithm implementations and optimizations for the SODA processor architecture. A signal processing language extension (SPEX) is proposed to help the software development efforts of wireless communication protocols on SODA-like multi-core architecture. And finally, the SPIR compiler is proposed to automatically map SPEX code onto the multi-core processor hardware.Ph.D.Computer Science & EngineeringUniversity of Michigan, Horace H. Rackham School of Graduate Studieshttp://deepblue.lib.umich.edu/bitstream/2027.42/61760/1/linyz_1.pd

Reducing exception management overhead with software restart markers

Thesis (Ph. D.)--Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Dept. of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science, 2008.Includes bibliographical references (p. 181-196).Modern processors rely on exception handling mechanisms to detect errors and to implement various features such as virtual memory. However, these mechanisms are typically hardware-intensive because of the need to buffer partially-completed instructions to implement precise exceptions and enforce in-order instruction commit, often leading to issues with performance and energy efficiency. The situation is exacerbated in highly parallel machines with large quantities of programmer-visible state, such as VLIW or vector processors. As architects increasingly rely on parallel architectures to achieve higher performance, the problem of exception handling is becoming critical. In this thesis, I present software restart markers as the foundation of an exception handling mechanism for explicitly parallel architectures. With this model, the compiler is responsible for delimiting regions of idempotent code. If an exception occurs, the operating system will resume execution from the beginning of the region. One advantage of this approach is that instruction results can be committed to architectural state in any order within a region, eliminating the need to buffer those values. Enabling out-of-order commit can substantially reduce the exception management overhead found in precise exception implementations, and enable the use of new architectural features that might be prohibitively costly with conventional precise exception implementations. Additionally, software restart markers can be used to reduce context switch overhead in a multiprogrammed environment. This thesis demonstrates the applicability of software restart markers to vector, VLIW, and multithreaded architectures. It also contains an implementation of this exception handling approach that uses the Trimaran compiler infrastructure to target the Scale vectorthread architecture. I show that using software restart markers incurs very little performance overhead for vector-style execution on Scale.(cont.) Finally, I describe the Scale compiler flow developed as part of this work and discuss how it targets certain features facilitated by the use of software restart markersby Mark Jerome Hampton.Ph.D

Compiler techniques for scalable performance of stream programs on multicore architectures

Thesis (Ph. D.)--Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Dept. of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science, 2010.Cataloged from PDF version of thesis.Includes bibliographical references (p. 211-222).Given the ubiquity of multicore processors, there is an acute need to enable the development of scalable parallel applications without unduly burdening programmers. Currently, programmers are asked not only to explicitly expose parallelism but also concern themselves with issues of granularity, load-balancing, synchronization, and communication. This thesis demonstrates that when algorithmic parallelism is expressed in the form of a stream program, a compiler can effectively and automatically manage the parallelism. Our compiler assumes responsibility for low-level architectural details, transforming implicit algorithmic parallelism into a mapping that achieves scalable parallel performance for a given multicore target. Stream programming is characterized by regular processing of sequences of data, and it is a natural expression of algorithms in the areas of audio, video, digital signal processing, networking, and encryption. Streaming computation is represented as a graph of independent computation nodes that communicate explicitly over data channels. Our techniques operate on contiguous regions of the stream graph where the input and output rates of the nodes are statically determinable. Within a static region, the compiler first automatically adjusts the granularity and then exploits data, task, and pipeline parallelism in a holistic fashion. We introduce techniques that data-parallelize nodes that operate on overlapping sliding windows of their input, translating serializing state into minimal and parametrized inter-core communication. Finally, for nodes that cannot be data-parallelized due to state, we are the first to automatically apply software-pipelining techniques at a coarse granularity to exploit pipeline parallelism between stateful nodes. Our framework is evaluated in the context of the StreamIt programming language. StreamIt is a high-level stream programming language that has been shown to improve programmer productivity in implementing streaming algorithms. We employ the StreamIt Core benchmark suite of 12 real-world applications to demonstrate the effectiveness of our techniques for varying multicore architectures. For a 16-core distributed memory multicore, we achieve a 14.9x mean speedup. For benchmarks that include sliding-window computation, our sliding-window data-parallelization techniques are required to enable scalable performance for a 16-core SMP multicore (14x mean speedup) and a 64-core distributed shared memory multicore (52x mean speedup).by Michael I. Gordon.Ph.D

Compiling for stream processing

This paper describes a compiler for stream programs that efficiently schedules computational kernels and stream mem-ory operations, and allocates on-chip storage. Our compiler uses information about the program structure and estimates of kernel and memory operation execution times to overlap kernel execution with memory transfers, maximizing perfor-mance, and to optimize use of scarce on-chip memory, signif-icantly reducing external memory bandwidth. Our compiler applies optimizations such as strip-mining, loop unrolling, and software pipelining, at the level of kernels and stream memory operations. We evaluate the performance of our compiler on a suite of media and scientific benchmarks. Our results show that compiler management of on-chip storage reduces external memory bandwidth by 35 % to 93 % and reduces execution time by 23 % to 72 % compared to cache-like LRU management of the same storage. We show that strip-mining stream applications enables producer-consumer locality to be captured in on-chip storage reducing external bandwidth by 50 % to 80%. We also evaluate the sensitiv-ity of performance to the scheduling methods used and to critical resources. Overall, our compiler is able to overlap memory operations and manage local storage so that 78% to 96 % of program execution time is spent in running com-putational kernels