Comparison of existing aneurysm models and their path forward

The two most important aneurysm types are cerebral aneurysms (CA) and abdominal aortic aneurysms (AAA), accounting together for over 80\% of all fatal aneurysm incidences. To minimise aneurysm related deaths, clinicians require various tools to accurately estimate its rupture risk. For both aneurysm types, the current state-of-the-art tools to evaluate rupture risk are identified and evaluated in terms of clinical applicability. We perform a comprehensive literature review, using the Web of Science database. Identified records (3127) are clustered by modelling approach and aneurysm location in a meta-analysis to quantify scientific relevance and to extract modelling patterns and further assessed according to PRISMA guidelines (179 full text screens). Beside general differences and similarities of CA and AAA, we identify and systematically evaluate four major modelling approaches on aneurysm rupture risk: finite element analysis and computational fluid dynamics as deterministic approaches and machine learning and assessment-tools and dimensionless parameters as stochastic approaches. The latter score highest in the evaluation for their potential as clinical applications for rupture prediction, due to readiness level and user friendliness. Deterministic approaches are less likely to be applied in a clinical environment because of their high model complexity. Because deterministic approaches consider underlying mechanism for aneurysm rupture, they have improved capability to account for unusual patient-specific characteristics, compared to stochastic approaches. We show that an increased interdisciplinary exchange between specialists can boost comprehension of this disease to design tools for a clinical environment. By combining deterministic and stochastic models, advantages of both approaches can improve accessibility for clinicians and prediction quality for rupture risk.Comment: 46 pages, 5 figure

In-silico clinical trials for assessment of intracranial flow diverters

In-silico trials refer to pre-clinical trials performed, entirely or in part, using individualised computer models that simulate some aspect of drug effect, medical device, or clinical intervention. Such virtual trials reduce and optimise animal and clinical trials, and enable exploring a wider range of anatomies and physiologies. In the context of endovascular treatment of intracranial aneurysms, in-silico trials can be used to evaluate the effectiveness of endovascular devices over virtual populations of patients with different aneurysm morphologies and physiologies. However, this requires (i) a virtual endovascular treatment model to evaluate device performance based on a reliable performance indicator, (ii) models that represent intra- and inter-subject variations of a virtual population, and (iii) creation of cost-effective and fully-automatic workflows to enable a large number of simulations at a reasonable computational cost and time. Flow-diverting stents have been proven safe and effective in the treatment of large wide-necked intracranial aneurysms. The presented thesis aims to provide the ingredient models of a workflow for in-silico trials of flow-diverting stents and to enhance the general knowledge of how the ingredient models can be streamlined and accelerated to allow large-scale trials. This work contributed to the following aspects: 1) To understand the key ingredient models of a virtual treatment workflow for evaluation of the flow-diverter performance. 2) To understand the effect of input uncertainty and variability on the workflow outputs, 3) To develop generative statistical models that describe variability in internal carotid artery flow waveforms, and investigate the effect of uncertainties on quantification of aneurysmal wall shear stress, 4) As part of a metric to evaluate success of flow diversion, to develop and validate a thrombosis model to assess FD-induced clot stability, and 5) To understand how a fully-automatic aneurysm flow modelling workflow can be built and how computationally inexpensive models can reduce the computational costs

IMPACT OF HEMODYNAMIC VORTEX SPATIAL AND TEMPORAL CHARACTERISTICS ON ANALYSIS OF INTRACRANIAL ANEURYSMS

Subarachnoid hemorrhage is a potentially devastating pathological condition in which bleeding occurs into the space surrounding the brain. One of the prominent sources of subarachnoid hemorrhage are intracranial aneurysms (IA): degenerative, irregular expansions of area(s) of the cerebral vasculature. In the event of IA rupture, the resultant subarachnoid hemorrhage ends in patient mortality occurring in ~50% of cases, with survivors enduring significant neurological damage with physical or cognitive impairment. The seriousness of IA rupture drives a degree of clinical interest in understanding these conditions that promote both the development and possible rupture of the vascular malformations. Current metrics for the assessment of this pathology rely on measuring the geometric characteristics of a patient\u27s vessel and/or IA, as well as the hemodynamic stressors existing along the vessel wall. Comparatively less focus has been granted toward understanding the characteristics of much of the bulk-flow within the vasculature and how it may play a role in IAs. Specifically, swirling hemodynamic flow (vortices) have been suggested as a condition which exacerbates vascular changes leading to IAs, yet quantified measurements of the spatial and temporal characteristics of vortices remain overlooked. This dissertation studies the role of the spatial and temporal characteristics of vortex flow and how it plays a role on IA pathology. Its chapters are a collection of five (5) works into this matter. First, established methods for the identification of vortices was investigated, and a novel method for vortex identification and quantification of their characteristics was developed to overcome the limitations of previous methods. Second, the developed method for vortex identification/quantification was then applied to a simulation study to improve predictive models aimed at predicting areas of IA development from those unlikely to suffer this pathology. Third, assessing how the simulated repair of one IA impacts changes to hemodynamic conditions within other nearby un-repaired IAs in a multiple IA system. Fourth, it was determined if vortex identification/quantification improved predictive models aimed at differentiation ruptured from unruptured IAs. Fifth, impart vortical flow of differing characteristics onto cultured vascular cells to determine if vortex stability imparts varied levels of cellular changes

Towards Automatic Prediction of Outcome in Treatment of Cerebral Aneurysms

Intrasaccular flow disruptors treat cerebral aneurysms by diverting the blood flow from the aneurysm sac. Residual flow into the sac after the intervention is a failure that could be due to the use of an undersized device, or to vascular anatomy and clinical condition of the patient. We report a machine learning model based on over 100 clinical and imaging features that predict the outcome of wide-neck bifurcation aneurysm treatment with an intravascular embolization device. We combine clinical features with a diverse set of common and novel imaging measurements within a random forest model. We also develop neural network segmentation algorithms in 2D and 3D to contour the sac in angiographic images and automatically calculate the imaging features. These deliver 90% overlap with manual contouring in 2D and 83% in 3D. Our predictive model classifies complete vs. partial occlusion outcomes with an accuracy of 75.31%, and weighted F1-score of 0.74.Comment: 10 page

A framework for intracranial saccular aneurysm detection and quantification using morphological analysis of cerebral angiograms

Reliable early prediction of aneurysm rupture can greatly help neurosurgeons to treat aneurysms at the right time, thus saving lives as well as providing significant cost reduction. Most of the research efforts in this respect involve statistical analysis of collected data or simulation of hemodynamic factors to predict the risk of aneurysmal rupture. Whereas, morphological analysis of cerebral angiogram images for locating and estimating unruptured aneurysms is rarely considered. Since digital subtraction angiography (DSA) is regarded as a standard test by the American Stroke Association and American College of Radiology for identification of aneurysm, this paper aims to perform morphological analysis of DSA to accurately detect saccular aneurysms, precisely determine their sizes, and estimate the probability of their ruptures. The proposed diagnostic framework, intracranial saccular aneurysm detection and quantification, first extracts cerebrovascular structures by denoising angiogram images and delineates regions of interest (ROIs) by using watershed segmentation and distance transformation. Then, it identifies saccular aneurysms among segmented ROIs using multilayer perceptron neural network trained upon robust Haralick texture features, and finally quantifies aneurysm rupture by geometrical analysis of identified aneurysmic ROI. De-identified data set of 59 angiograms is used to evaluate the performance of algorithms for aneurysm detection and risk of rupture quantification. The proposed framework achieves high accuracy of 98% and 86% for aneurysm classification and quantification, respectively

Validation of a cerebral hemodynamic model with personalized calibration in patients with aneurysmal subarachnoid hemorrhage

This study aims to validate a numerical model developed for assessing personalized circle of Willis (CoW) hemodynamics under pathological conditions. Based on 66 computed tomography angiography images, investigations were obtained from 43 acute aneurysmal subarachnoid hemorrhage (aSAH) patients from a local neurovascular center. The mean flow velocity of each artery in the CoW measured using transcranial Doppler (TCD) and simulated by the numerical model was obtained for comparison. The intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) over all cerebral arteries for TCD and the numerical model was 0.88 (N = 561; 95% CI 0.84–0.90). In a subgroup of patients who had developed delayed cerebral ischemia (DCI), the ICC had decreased to 0.72 but remained constant with respect to changes in blood pressure, Fisher grade, and location of ruptured aneurysm. Our numerical model showed good agreement with TCD in assessing the flow velocity in the CoW of patients with aSAH. In conclusion, the proposed model can satisfactorily reproduce the cerebral hemodynamics under aSAH conditions by personalizing the numerical model with TCD measurements. Clinical trial registration: [http://www.trialregister.nl/], identifier [NL8114]

Proposal for Numerical Benchmarking of Fluid-Structure Interaction in Cerebral Aneurysms

Computational fluid dynamics is intensively used to deepen the understanding of aneurysm growth and rupture in the attempt to support physicians during therapy planning. Numerous studies have assumed fully-rigid vessel walls in their simulations, whose sole hemodynamics may fail to provide a satisfactory criterion for rupture risk assessment. Moreover, direct in-vivo observations of intracranial aneurysm pulsation have been recently reported, encouraging the development of fluid-structure interaction for their modelling and for new assessments. In this work, we describe a new fluid-structure interaction benchmark setting for the careful evaluation of different aneurysm shapes. The studied configurations consist of three real aneurysm domes positioned on a toroidal channel. All geometric features, meshing characteristics, flow quantities, comparisons with a rigid-wall model and corresponding plots are provided. Reported results emphasize the alteration of flow patterns and hemodynamic descriptors when moving from the rigid-wall model to the complete fluid-structure interaction framework, thereby underlining the importance of the coupling between hemodynamics and the surrounding vessel tissue.Comment: 23 pages, 14 figure

Machine learning and reduced order modelling for the simulation of braided stent deployment

Endoluminal reconstruction using flow diverters represents a novel paradigm for the minimally invasive treatment of intracranial aneurysms. The configuration assumed by these very dense braided stents once deployed within the parent vessel is not easily predictable and medical volumetric images alone may be insufficient to plan the treatment satisfactorily. Therefore, here we propose a fast and accurate machine learning and reduced order modelling framework, based on finite element simulations, to assist practitioners in the planning and interventional stages. It consists of a first classification step to determine a priori whether a simulation will be successful (good conformity between stent and vessel) or not from a clinical perspective, followed by a regression step that provides an approximated solution of the deployed stent configuration. The latter is achieved using a non-intrusive reduced order modelling scheme that combines the proper orthogonal decomposition algorithm and Gaussian process regression. The workflow was validated on an idealised intracranial artery with a saccular aneurysm and the effect of six geometrical and surgical parameters on the outcome of stent deployment was studied. The two-step workflow allows the classification of deployment conditions with up to 95% accuracy and real-time prediction of the stent deployed configuration with an average prediction error never greater than the spatial resolution of 3D rotational angiography (0.15 mm). These results are promising as they demonstrate the ability of these techniques to achieve simulations within a few milliseconds while retaining the mechanical realism and predictability of the stent deployed configuration

Hemodynamic study in a real intracranial aneurysm: an in vitro and in silico approach

Mestrado de dupla diplomação com o Centro Federal de Educação Tecnológica Celso Suckow da Fonseca - Cefet/RJIntracranial aneurysm (IA) is a cerebrovascular disease with high rates of mortality and morbidity when it ruptures. It is known that changes in the intra-aneurysmal hemodynamic load play a significant factor in the development and rupture of IA. However, these factors are not fully understood. In this sense, the main objective of this work is to study the hemodynamic behavior during the blood analogues flow inside an AI and to determine its influence on the evolution of this pathology. To this end, experimental and numerical studies were carried out, using a real AI model obtained using computerized angiography. In the experimental approach, it was necessary, in the initial phase, to develop and manufacture biomodels from medical images of real aneurysms. Two techniques were used to manufacture the biomodels: rapid prototyping and gravity casting. The materials used to obtain the biomodels were of low cost. After manufacture, the biomodels were compared to each other for their transparency and final structure and proved to be suitable for testing flow visualizations. Numerical studies were performed with the aid of the Ansys Fluent software, using computational fluid dynamics (CFD), using the finite volume method. Subsequently, flow tests were performed experimentally and numerically using flow rates calculated from the velocity curve of a patient's doppler test. The experimental and numerical tests, in steady-state, made it possible to visualize the three-dimensional behavior of the flow inside the aneurysm, identifying the vortex zones created throughout the cardiac cycle. Correlating the results obtained in the two analyzes, it was possible to identify that the areas of vortexes are characterized by low speed and with increasing the fluid flow, the vortexes are positioned closer to the wall. These characteristics are associated with the rupture of an intracranial aneurysm. There was also a good qualitative correlation between numerical and experimental results.O aneurisma intracraniano (AI) é uma patologia cerebrovascular com altas taxas de mortalidade e morbidade quando se rompe. Sabe-se que alterações na carga hemodinâmica intra-aneurismática exerce um fator significativo no desenvolvimento e ruptura de AI, porém, esses fatores não estão totalmente compreendidos. Nesse sentido, o objetivo principal deste trabalho é o de estudar o comportamento hemodinâmico durante o escoamento de fluidos análogos do sangue no interior de um AI e determinar a sua influência na evolução da patologia. Para tal, foram realizados estudos experimentais e numéricos, utilizando um modelo de AI real obtido por meio de uma angiografia computadorizada. Na abordagem experimental foi necessário, na fase inicial, desenvolver e fabricar biomodelos a partir de imagens médicas de um aneurisma real. No fabrico dos biomodelos foram utilizadas duas técnicas: a prototipagem rápida e o vazamento por gravidade. Os materiais utilizados para a obtenção dos biomodelos foram de baixo custo. Após a fabricação, os biomodelos foram comparados entre si quanto à sua transparência e estrutura final e verificou-se serem adequados para testes de visualizações do fluxo. Os estudos numéricos foram realizados com recurso ao software Ansys Fluent, utilizando a dinâmica dos fluidos computacional (CFD), através do método dos volumes finitos. Posteriormente, foram realizados testes de escoamento experimentais e numéricos, utilizando caudais determinados a partir da curva de velocidades do ensaio doppler de um paciente. Os testes experimentais e numéricos, em regime permanente, possibilitaram a visualização do comportamento tridimensional do fluxo no interior do aneurisma, identificando as zonas de vórtices criadas ao longo do ciclo cardíaco. Correlacionando os resultados obtidos nas duas análises, foi possível identificar que as áreas de vórtices são caracterizadas por uma baixa velocidade e com o aumento do caudal os vórtices posicionam-se mais próximos da parede. Essas características apresentadas estão associadas com a ruptura de aneurisma intracraniano. Verificou-se, também, uma boa correlação qualitativa entre os resultados numéricos e experimentais