62 research outputs found
Undecidability of the Logic of Overlap Relation over Discrete Linear Orderings
5The validity/satisfiability problem for most propositional interval temporal logics is (highly) undecidable, under very weak assumptions on the class of interval structures in which they are interpreted. That, in particular, holds for most fragments of Halpern and Shoham’s interval modal logic HS. Still, decidability
is the rule for the fragments of HS with only one modal operator, based on an Allen’s relation. In this paper, we show that the logic O of the Overlap relation, when interpreted over discrete linear orderings, is an exception. The proof is based on a reduction from the undecidable octant tiling problem. This is one of the sharpest undecidability result for fragments of HS.openopenBRESOLIN Davide; DELLA MONICA Dario; GORANKO Valentin; MONTANARI Angelo; SCIAVICCO GuidoBresolin, Davide; DELLA MONICA, Dario; Goranko, Valentin; Montanari, Angelo; Sciavicco, Guid
An Integrated First-Order Theory of Points and Intervals over Linear Orders (Part II)
There are two natural and well-studied approaches to temporal ontology and
reasoning: point-based and interval-based. Usually, interval-based temporal
reasoning deals with points as a particular case of duration-less intervals. A
recent result by Balbiani, Goranko, and Sciavicco presented an explicit
two-sorted point-interval temporal framework in which time instants (points)
and time periods (intervals) are considered on a par, allowing the perspective
to shift between these within the formal discourse. We consider here two-sorted
first-order languages based on the same principle, and therefore including
relations, as first studied by Reich, among others, between points, between
intervals, and inter-sort. We give complete classifications of its
sub-languages in terms of relative expressive power, thus determining how many,
and which, are the intrinsically different extensions of two-sorted first-order
logic with one or more such relations. This approach roots out the classical
problem of whether or not points should be included in a interval-based
semantics. In this Part II, we deal with the cases of all dense and the case of
all unbounded linearly ordered sets.Comment: This is Part II of the paper `An Integrated First-Order Theory of
Points and Intervals over Linear Orders' arXiv:1805.08425v2. Therefore the
introduction, preliminaries and conclusions of the two papers are the same.
This version implements a few minor corrections and an update to the
affiliation of the second autho
Begin, After, and Later: a Maximal Decidable Interval Temporal Logic
Interval temporal logics (ITLs) are logics for reasoning about temporal
statements expressed over intervals, i.e., periods of time. The most famous ITL
studied so far is Halpern and Shoham's HS, which is the logic of the thirteen
Allen's interval relations. Unfortunately, HS and most of its fragments have an
undecidable satisfiability problem. This discouraged the research in this area
until recently, when a number non-trivial decidable ITLs have been discovered.
This paper is a contribution towards the complete classification of all
different fragments of HS. We consider different combinations of the interval
relations Begins, After, Later and their inverses Abar, Bbar, and Lbar. We know
from previous works that the combination ABBbarAbar is decidable only when
finite domains are considered (and undecidable elsewhere), and that ABBbar is
decidable over the natural numbers. We extend these results by showing that
decidability of ABBar can be further extended to capture the language
ABBbarLbar, which lays in between ABBar and ABBbarAbar, and that turns out to
be maximal w.r.t decidability over strongly discrete linear orders (e.g. finite
orders, the naturals, the integers). We also prove that the proposed decision
procedure is optimal with respect to the complexity class
Complexity of ITL model checking: some well-behaved fragments of the interval logic HS
Model checking has been successfully used in many computer science fields,
including artificial intelligence, theoretical computer science, and databases.
Most of the proposed solutions make use of classical, point-based temporal
logics, while little work has been done in the interval temporal logic setting.
Recently, a non-elementary model checking algorithm for Halpern and Shoham's
modal logic of time intervals HS over finite Kripke structures (under the
homogeneity assumption) and an EXPSPACE model checking procedure for two
meaningful fragments of it have been proposed. In this paper, we show that more
efficient model checking procedures can be developed for some expressive enough
fragments of HS
An Integrated First-Order Theory of Points and Intervals over Linear Orders (Part I)
There are two natural and well-studied approaches to temporal ontology and
reasoning: point-based and interval-based. Usually, interval-based temporal
reasoning deals with points as a particular case of duration-less intervals. A
recent result by Balbiani, Goranko, and Sciavicco presented an explicit
two-sorted point-interval temporal framework in which time instants (points)
and time periods (intervals) are considered on a par, allowing the perspective
to shift between these within the formal discourse. We consider here two-sorted
first-order languages based on the same principle, and therefore including
relations, as first studied by Reich, among others, between points, between
intervals, and inter-sort. We give complete classifications of its
sub-languages in terms of relative expressive power, thus determining how many,
and which, are the intrinsically different extensions of two-sorted first-order
logic with one or more such relations. This approach roots out the classical
problem of whether or not points should be included in a interval-based
semantics
An Approach to Fuzzy Modal Logic of Time Intervals
Temporal reasoning based on intervals is nowadays ubiquitous in artificial intelligence, and the most representative interval temporal logic, called HS, was introduced by Halpern and Shoham in the eighties. There has been a great effort in the past in studying the expressive power and computational properties of the satisfiability problem for HS and its fragments, but only recently HS has been proposed as a suitable formalism for artificial intelligence applications. Such applications highlighted some of the intrinsic limits of HS: Sometimes, when dealing with real-life data one is not able to express temporal relations and propositional labels in a definite, crisp way. In this paper, following the seminal ideas of Fitting and Zadeh, among others, we present a fuzzy generalization of HS that partially solves such problems of expressive power, and we prove that, as in the crisp case, its satisfiability problem is generally undecidable
Efficient Genomic Interval Queries Using Augmented Range Trees
Efficient large-scale annotation of genomic intervals is essential for
personal genome interpretation in the realm of precision medicine. There are 13
possible relations between two intervals according to Allen's interval algebra.
Conventional interval trees are routinely used to identify the genomic
intervals satisfying a coarse relation with a query interval, but cannot
support efficient query for more refined relations such as all Allen's
relations. We design and implement a novel approach to address this unmet need.
Through rewriting Allen's interval relations, we transform an interval query to
a range query, then adapt and utilize the range trees for querying. We
implement two types of range trees: a basic 2-dimensional range tree (2D-RT)
and an augmented range tree with fractional cascading (RTFC) and compare them
with the conventional interval tree (IT). Theoretical analysis shows that RTFC
can achieve the best time complexity for interval queries regarding all Allen's
relations among the three trees. We also perform comparative experiments on the
efficiency of RTFC, 2D-RT and IT in querying noncoding element annotations in a
large collection of personal genomes. Our experimental results show that 2D-RT
is more efficient than IT for interval queries regarding most of Allen's
relations, RTFC is even more efficient than 2D-RT. The results demonstrate that
RTFC is an efficient data structure for querying large-scale datasets regarding
Allen's relations between genomic intervals, such as those required by
interpreting genome-wide variation in large populations.Comment: 4 figures, 4 table
A Quantitative Extension of Interval Temporal Logic over Infinite Words
Model checking (MC) for Halpern and Shoham’s interval temporal logic HS has been recently investigated in a systematic way, and it is known to be decidable under three distinct semantics (state-based, trace-based and tree-based semantics), all of them assuming homogeneity in the propositional valuation. Here, we focus on the trace-based semantics, where the main semantic entities are the infinite execution paths (traces) of the given Kripke structure. We introduce a quantitative extension of HS over traces, called Difference HS (DHS), allowing one to express timing constraints on the difference among interval lengths (durations). We show that MC and satisfiability of full DHS are in general undecidable, so, we investigate the decidability border for these problems by considering natural syntactical fragments of DHS. In particular, we identify a maximal decidable fragment DHSsimple of DHS proving in addition that the considered problems for this fragment are at least 2Expspace-hard. Moreover, by exploiting new results on linear-time hybrid logics, we show that for an equally expressive fragment of DHSsimple, the problems are Expspace-complete. Finally, we provide a characterization of HS over traces by means of the one-variable fragment of a novel hybrid logic
- …