Modeling and Evaluation of a Ridesharing Matching System from Multi-Stakeholders\u27 Perspective

With increasing travel demand and mobility service quality expectations, demand responsive innovative services continue to emerge. Ridesharing is an established, yet evolving, mobility option that can provide more customized, reliable shared service without any new investment in the transportation infrastructure. To maximize the benefits of ridesharing service, efficient matching and distribution of riders among available drivers can provide a reliable mobility option under most operating conditions. Service efficiency of ridesharing depends on the system performance (e.g., trip travel time, trip delay, trip distance, detour distance, and trip satisfaction) acceptable to diverse mobility stakeholders (e.g., riders, drivers, ridesharing operators, and transportation agencies). This research modeled the performance of a ridesharing service system considering four objectives: (i) minimization of system-wide passengers’ waiting time, (ii) minimization of system-wide vehicle miles travelled (VMT), (iii) minimization of system-wide detour distance, and (iv) maximization of system-wide drivers’ profit. Tradeoff evaluation of objectives revealed that system-wide VMT minimization objective performed best with least sacrifices on the other three objectives from their respective best performance level based on set of routes generated in this study. On the other hand, system-wide drivers’ profit maximization objective provided highest monetary incentives for drivers and riders in terms of maximizing profit and saving travel cost respectively. System-wide minimization of detour distance was found to be least flexible in providing shared rides. The findings of this research provide useful insights on ridesharing system modeling and performance evaluation, and can be used in developing and implementing ridesharing service considering multiple stakeholders’ concerns

A multi-functional simulation platform for on-demand ride service operations

On-demand ride services or ride-sourcing services have been experiencing fast development in the past decade. Various mathematical models and optimization algorithms have been developed to help ride-sourcing platforms design operational strategies with higher efficiency. However, due to cost and reliability issues (implementing an immature algorithm for real operations may result in system turbulence), it is commonly infeasible to validate these models and train/test these optimization algorithms within real-world ride sourcing platforms. Acting as a useful test bed, a simulation platform for ride-sourcing systems will be very important to conduct algorithm training/testing or model validation through trails and errors. While previous studies have established a variety of simulators for their own tasks, it lacks a fair and public platform for comparing the models or algorithms proposed by different researchers. In addition, the existing simulators still face many challenges, ranging from their closeness to real environments of ride-sourcing systems, to the completeness of different tasks they can implement. To address the challenges, we propose a novel multi-functional and open-sourced simulation platform for ride-sourcing systems, which can simulate the behaviors and movements of various agents on a real transportation network. It provides a few accessible portals for users to train and test various optimization algorithms, especially reinforcement learning algorithms, for a variety of tasks, including on-demand matching, idle vehicle repositioning, and dynamic pricing. In addition, it can be used to test how well the theoretical models approximate the simulated outcomes. Evaluated on real-world data based experiments, the simulator is demonstrated to be an efficient and effective test bed for various tasks related to on-demand ride service operations

Optimization of vehicular networks in smart cities: from agile optimization to learnheuristics and simheuristics

Vehicular ad hoc networks (VANETs) are a fundamental component of intelligent transportation systems in smart cities. With the support of open and real-time data, these networks of inter-connected vehicles constitute an ‘Internet of vehicles’ with the potential to significantly enhance citizens’ mobility and last-mile delivery in urban, peri-urban, and metropolitan areas. However, the proper coordination and logistics of VANETs raise a number of optimization challenges that need to be solved. After reviewing the state of the art on the concepts of VANET optimization and open data in smart cities, this paper discusses some of the most relevant optimization challenges in this area. Since most of the optimization problems are related to the need for real-time solutions or to the consideration of uncertainty and dynamic environments, the paper also discusses how some VANET challenges can be addressed with the use of agile optimization algorithms and the combination of metaheuristics with simulation and machine learning methods. The paper also offers a numerical analysis that measures the impact of using these optimization techniques in some related problems. Our numerical analysis, based on real data from Open Data Barcelona, demonstrates that the constructive heuristic outperforms the random scenario in the CDP combined with vehicular networks, resulting in maximizing the minimum distance between facilities while meeting capacity requirements with the fewest facilities.Peer ReviewedPostprint (published version

Online Relocating and Matching of Ride-Hailing Services: A Model-Based Modular Approach

This study proposes an innovative model-based modular approach (MMA) to dynamically optimize order matching and vehicle relocation in a ride-hailing platform. MMA utilizes a two-layer and modular modeling structure. The upper layer determines the spatial transfer patterns of vehicle flow within the system to maximize the total revenue of the current and future stages. With the guidance provided by the upper layer, the lower layer performs rapid vehicle-to-order matching and vehicle relocation. MMA is interpretable, and equipped with the customized and polynomial-time algorithm, which, as an online order-matching and vehicle-relocation algorithm, can scale past thousands of vehicles. We theoretically prove that the proposed algorithm can achieve the global optimum in stylized networks, while the numerical experiments based on both the toy network and realistic dataset demonstrate that MMA is capable of achieving superior systematic performance compared to batch matching and reinforcement-learning based methods. Moreover, its modular and lightweight modeling structure further enables it to achieve a high level of robustness against demand variation while maintaining a relatively low computational cost

Developing Optimal Peer-to-Peer Ridesharing Strategies

69A43551747123Thanks to recent developments in ride-hailing transit services, the Peer-to-Peer (P2P) ridematching problem has been actively considered in academia in recent years. P2P ridematching not only reduces travel costs for riders but also benefits drivers by saving them money in exchange for their additional travel time and costs. However, assigning riders to drivers in an efficient way is a complex problem that requires a focus on maximizing the benefits for both riders and drivers. This study first aims to formulate a multi-driver multirider (MDMR) P2P ride-matching problem based on rational preferences and cost allocation for both driver and rider. This model also enables riders to transfer between multiple drivers to complete their journeys if needed. To solve the ride-matching problem, a Tabu Search (TS) for system optimum ride-matchings and Greedy Matching (GM) algorithm for the stable ridematchings were created to produce stable ride-matchings

Planning of Truck Platoons: a Literature Review and Directions for Future Research

A truck platoon is a set of virtually linked trucks that drive closely behind one another using automated driving technology. Benefits of truck platooning include cost savings, reduced emissions, and more efficient utilization of road capacity. To fully reap these benefits in the initial phases requires careful planning of platoons based on trucks’ itineraries and time schedules. This paper provides a framework to classify various new transportation planning problems that arise in truck platooning, surveys relevant operations research models for these problems in the literature and identifies directions for future research

On the Empty Miles of Ride-Sourcing Services: Theory, Observation and Countermeasures

The proliferation of smartphones in recent years has catalyzed the rapid growth of ride-sourcing services such as Uber, Lyft, and Didi Chuxing. Such on-demand e-hailing services significantly reduce the meeting frictions between drivers and riders and provide the platform with unprecedented flexibility and challenges in system management. A big issue that arises with service expansion is the empty miles produced by ride-sourcing vehicles. To overcome the physical and temporal frictions that separate drivers from customers and effectively reposition themselves towards desired destinations, ride-sourcing vehicles generate a significant number of vacant trips. These empty miles traveled result in inefficient use of the available fleet and increase traffic demand, posing substantial impacts on system operations. To tackle the issues, my dissertation is dedicated to deepening our understanding of the formation and the externalities of empty miles, and then proposing countermeasures to bolster system performance. There are two essential and interdependent contributors to empty miles generated by ride-sourcing vehicles: cruising in search of customers and deadheading to pick them up, which are markedly dictated by forces from riders, drivers, the platform, and policies imposed by regulators. In this dissertation, we structure our study of this complex process along three primary axes, respectively centered on the strategies of a platform, the behaviors of drivers, and the concerns of government agencies. In each axis, theoretical models are established to help understand the underlying physics and identify the trade-offs and potential issues that drive behind the empty miles. Massive data from Didi Chuxing, a dominant ride-sourcing company in China, are leveraged to evidence the presence of matters discussed in reality. Countermeasures are then investigated to strengthen management upon the empty miles, balance the interests of different stakeholders, and improve the system performance. Although this dissertation scopes out ride-sourcing services, the models, analyses, and solutions can be readily adapted to address related issues in other types of shared-use mobility services.PHDCivil EngineeringUniversity of Michigan, Horace H. Rackham School of Graduate Studieshttp://deepblue.lib.umich.edu/bitstream/2027.42/163209/1/xzt_1.pd

Ridesharing Using Adaptive Waiting Time

The culture of sharing by the advances in communication technologies has entered a new era, and ever since, sharing instead of ownership has been sharply increasing in individuals’ behaviors. Particularly in transportation, concepts of sharing a ride in either carpooling or ridesharing have been adopting for 70 years. During the past fifteen years, the revolution in communication devices has formed the online version of ridesharing that responds to transportation needs shortly. Ridesharing is considered to be a strategy to mitigate congestion and air pollution by increasing the occupancy rate of vehicles in the road network. An online ridesharing framework is an end-to-end framework that manages the request and matches the passengers to accomplish their rides together. In this thesis, we studied the online ridesharing problem and proposed an end-to-end framework to handle the passengers. In our end-to-end framework, we design the objective with respect to the passenger’s perspective. We assume that all the passengers tend to share their ride to reduce their transportation costs using vehicles. When two passengers get matched to accomplish their ride together, they accept a deviation from their shortest path to make sharing possible. To minimize the information provided by passengers, we define scheduling flexibility using a system-wide fixed flexibility factor ϵ, which indicates the tolerable increase in travel duration, proportional to the shortest path duration. For a trip, scheduling flexibility is the amount of time that the system has to divide between the detour from the shortest path and the waiting time to find a proper match. To split the scheduling flexibility between the detour and the waiting time, we introduce the concept of adaptive waiting time, which is the key enabler of our framework to provide a quality match for passengers. For a passenger, the optimal waiting time with respect to ϵ minimizes the expected travel cost. In this work, we use future demand to calculate the expected travel cost. We carefully design a simulation to observe the ability of our framework to match the passengers. The trip cost and trip duration are approximated using Gradient boosting trees, and we simplify the NYC road network as a grid network. The proposed approach works for 24 hours to handle 356049 ride requests on a rectangle with an area equal to 44 km2. We analyze several metrics to indicate the quality of the matching process. The simulation results show that by using our approach, 75.2% of the passengers can share their ride by increasing the trip duration for 4.334 minutes on average, and it leads to reducing the total cost by 12% and reducing the total traveled distance by 14.29%

Shared Mobility - Operations and Economics

In the last decade, ubiquity of the internet and proliferation of smart personal devices have given rise to businesses that are built on the foundation of the sharing economy. The mobility market has implemented the sharing economy model in many forms, including but not limited to, carsharing, ride-sourcing, carpooling, taxi-sharing, ridesharing, bikesharing, and scooter sharing. Among these shared-use mobility services, ridesharing services, such as peer-to-peer (P2P) ridesharing and ride-pooling systems, are based on sharing both the vehicle and the ride between users, offering several individual and societal benefits. Despite these benefits, there are a number of operational and economic challenges that hinder the adoption of various forms of ridesharing services in practice. This dissertation attempts to address these challenges by investigating these systems from two different, but related, perspectives. The successful operation of ridesharing services in practice requires solving large-scale ride-matching problems in short periods of time. However, the high computational complexity and inherent supply and demand uncertainty present in these problems immensely undermines their real-time application. In the first part of this dissertation, we develop techniques that provide high-quality, although not necessarily optimal, system-level solutions that can be applied in real time. More precisely, we propose a distributed optimization technique based on graph partitioning to facilitate the implementation of dynamic P2P ridesharing systems in densely populated metropolitan areas. Additionally, we combine the proposed partitioning algorithm with a new local search algorithm to design a proactive framework that exploits historical demand data to optimize dynamic dispatching of a fleet of vehicles that serve on-demand ride requests. The main purpose of these methods is to maximize the social welfare of the corresponding ridesharing services. Despite the necessity of developing real-time algorithmic tools for operation of ridesharing services, solely maximizing the system-level social welfare cannot result in increasing the penetration of shared mobility services. This fact motivated the second stream of research in this dissertation, which revolves around proposing models that take economic aspects of ridesharing systems into account. To this end, the second part of this dissertation studies the impact of subsidy allocation on achieving and maintaining a critical mass of users in P2P ridesharing systems under different assumptions. First, we consider a community-based ridesharing system with ride-back guarantee, and propose a traveler incentive program that allocates subsidies to a carefully selected set of commuters to change their travel behavior, and thereby, increase the likelihood of finding more compatible and profitable matches. We further introduce an approximate algorithm to solve large-scale instances of this problem efficiently. In a subsequent study for a cooperative ridesharing market with role flexibility, we show that there may be no stable outcome (a collusion-free pricing and allocation scheme). Hence, we introduced a mathematical formulation that yields a stable outcome by allocating the minimum amount of external subsidy. Finally, we propose a truthful subsidy scheme to determine matching, scheduling, and subsidy allocation in a P2P ridesharing market with incomplete information and a budget constraint on payment deficit. The proposed mechanism is shown to guarantee important economic properties such as dominant-strategy incentive compatibility, individual rationality, budget-balance, and computational efficiency. Although the majority of the work in this dissertation focuses on ridesharing services, the presented methodologies can be easily generalized to tackle related issues in other types of shared-use mobility services.PHDCivil EngineeringUniversity of Michigan, Horace H. Rackham School of Graduate Studieshttp://deepblue.lib.umich.edu/bitstream/2027.42/169843/1/atafresh_1.pd