Statistical circuit simulations - from ‘atomistic’ compact models to statistical standard cell characterisation

This thesis describes the development and application of statistical circuit simulation methodologies to analyse digital circuits subject to intrinsic parameter fluctuations. The specific nature of intrinsic parameter fluctuations are discussed, and we explain the crucial importance to the semiconductor industry of developing design tools which accurately account for their effects. Current work in the area is reviewed, and three important factors are made clear: any statistical circuit simulation methodology must be based on physically correct, predictive models of device variability; the statistical compact models describing device operation must be characterised for accurate transient analysis of circuits; analysis must be carried out on realistic circuit components. Improving on previous efforts in the field, we posit a statistical circuit simulation methodology which accounts for all three of these factors. The established 3-D Glasgow atomistic simulator is employed to predict electrical characteristics for devices aimed at digital circuit applications, with gate lengths from 35 nm to 13 nm. Using these electrical characteristics, extraction of BSIM4 compact models is carried out and their accuracy in performing transient analysis using SPICE is validated against well characterised mixed-mode TCAD simulation results for 35 nm devices. Static d.c. simulations are performed to test the methodology, and a useful analytic model to predict hard logic fault limitations on CMOS supply voltage scaling is derived as part of this work. Using our toolset, the effect of statistical variability introduced by random discrete dopants on the dynamic behaviour of inverters is studied in detail. As devices scaled, dynamic noise margin variation of an inverter is increased and higher output load or input slew rate improves the noise margins and its variation. Intrinsic delay variation based on CV/I delay metric is also compared using ION and IEFF definitions where the best estimate is obtained when considering ION and input transition time variations. Critical delay distribution of a path is also investigated where it is shown non-Gaussian. Finally, the impact of the cell input slew rate definition on the accuracy of the inverter cell timing characterisation in NLDM format is investigated

Subthreshold and gate leakage current analysis and reduction in VLSI circuits

CMOS technology has scaled aggressively over the past few decades in an effort to enhance functionality, speed and packing density per chip. As the feature sizes are scaling down to sub-100nm regime, leakage power is increasing significantly and is becoming the dominant component of the total power dissipation. Major contributors to the total leakage current in deep submicron regime are subthreshold and gate tunneling leakage currents. The leakage reduction techniques developed so far were mostly devoted to reducing subthreshold leakage. However, at sub-65nm feature sizes, gate leakage current grows faster and is expected to surpass subthreshold leakage current. In this work, an extensive analysis of the circuit level characteristics of subthreshold and gate leakage currents is performed at 45nm and 32nm feature sizes. The analysis provides several key observations on the interdependency of gate and subthreshold leakage currents. Based on these observations, a new leakage reduction technique is proposed that optimizes both the leakage currents. This technique identifies minimum leakage vectors for a given circuit based on the number of transistors in OFF state and their position in the stack. The effectiveness of the proposed technique is compared to most of the mainstream leakage reduction techniques by implementing them on ISCAS89 benchmark circuits. The proposed leakage reduction technique proved to be more effective in reducing gate leakage current than subthreshold leakage current. However, when combined with dual-threshold and variable-threshold CMOS techniques, substantial subthreshold leakage current reduction was also achieved. A total savings of 53% for subthreshold leakage current and 26% for gate leakage current are reported

Architectural level delay and leakage power modelling of manufacturing process variation

PhD ThesisThe effect of manufacturing process variations has become a major issue regarding the estimation of circuit delay and power dissipation, and will gain more importance in the future as device scaling continues in order to satisfy market place demands for circuits with greater performance and functionality per unit area. Statistical modelling and analysis approaches have been widely used to reflect the effects of a variety of variational process parameters on system performance factor which will be described as probability density functions (PDFs). At present most of the investigations into statistical models has been limited to small circuits such as a logic gate. However, the massive size of present day electronic systems precludes the use of design techniques which consider a system to comprise these basic gates, as this level of design is very inefficient and error prone. This thesis proposes a methodology to bring the effects of process variation from transistor level up to architectural level in terms of circuit delay and leakage power dissipation. Using a first order canonical model and statistical analysis approach, a statistical cell library has been built which comprises not only the basic gate cell models, but also more complex functional blocks such as registers, FIFOs, counters, ALUs etc. Furthermore, other sensitive factors to the overall system performance, such as input signal slope, output load capacitance, different signal switching cases and transition types are also taken into account for each cell in the library, which makes it adaptive to an incremental circuit design. The proposed methodology enables an efficient analysis of process variation effects on system performance with significantly reduced computation time compared to the Monte Carlo simulation approach. As a demonstration vehicle for this technique, the delay and leakage power distributions of a 2-stage asynchronous micropipeline circuit has been simulated using this cell library. The experimental results show that the proposed method can predict the delay and leakage power distribution with less than 5% error and at least 50,000 times faster computation time compare to 5000-sample SPICE based Monte Carlo simulation. The methodology presented here for modelling process variability plays a significant role in Design for Manufacturability (DFM) by quantifying the direct impact of process variations on system performance. The advantages of being able to undertake this analysis at a high level of abstraction and thus early in the design cycle are two fold. First, if the predicted effects of process variation render the circuit performance to be outwith specification, design modifications can be readily incorporated to rectify the situation. Second, knowing what the acceptable limits of process variation are to maintain design performance within its specification, informed choices can be made regarding the implementation technology and manufacturer selected to fabricate the design

Development of a Universal MOSFET Gate Impedance Model

Scaling of CMOS technology to 100 nm & below and the endless pursuit of higher operating frequencies drive the need to accurately model effects that dominate at those feature sizes and frequencies. Current modeling techniques are frequency limited and require different models for different frequency ranges in order to achieve accuracy goals. In the foundry world, high frequency models are typically empirical in nature and significantly lag their low frequency counterparts in terms of availability. This tends to slow the adoption of new foundry technologies for high performance applications such as extremely high data rate serializer/deserializer transceiver cores. However, design cycle time and time to market while transitioning between technology nodes can be reduced by incorporating a reusable, industry-standard model. This work proposes such a model for device gate impedance that is simulator-friendly, compact, frequencyindependent, and relatively portable across technology nodes. This semi-empirical gate impedance model is based on depletion in the poly-silicon gate electrode. The effect of device length and single-leg width on the input impedance is studied with the aid of extensive measured data obtained from devices built in 110 nm and 180 nm technologies in the 1-20GHz frequency range. The measured data illustrates that the device input impedance has a non-linear frequency dependency. This variation in input impedance is the result of gate poly-silicon depletion, which can be modeled by an external RC network connected at the gate of the device. Excellent agreement between the simulation results and the measured data validates the model in the device active region for 1-20GHz frequency range. The gate impedance model is further modified by incorporating parasitic effects, extending its range to 200MHz-20GHz. This model performs accurately for 180 run, 110 nm and 90 nm technologies at different bias conditions and dimensions. The model and model parameter behavior are consistent across technology nodes thereby enabling re-usability and portability. The accuracy of this new gate impedance model is demonstrated in various applications: to validate the model extraction techniques for different device configurations, to assess the input data run-length variations on CML buffer performance and to estimate the jitter in ring oscillators

Design for Reliability and Low Power in Emerging Technologies

Die fortlaufende Verkleinerung von Transistor-Strukturgrößen ist einer der wichtigsten Antreiber für das Wachstum in der Halbleitertechnologiebranche. Seit Jahrzehnten erhöhen sich sowohl Integrationsdichte als auch Komplexität von Schaltkreisen und zeigen damit einen fortlaufenden Trend, der sich über alle modernen Fertigungsgrößen erstreckt. Bislang ging das Verkleinern von Transistoren mit einer Verringerung der Versorgungsspannung einher, was zu einer Reduktion der Leistungsaufnahme führte und damit eine gleichbleibenden Leistungsdichte sicherstellte. Doch mit dem Beginn von Strukturgrößen im Nanometerbreich verlangsamte sich die fortlaufende Skalierung. Viele Schwierigkeiten, sowie das Erreichen von physikalischen Grenzen in der Fertigung und Nicht-Idealitäten beim Skalieren der Versorgungsspannung, führten zu einer Zunahme der Leistungsdichte und, damit einhergehend, zu erschwerten Problemen bei der Sicherstellung der Zuverlässigkeit. Dazu zählen, unter anderem, Alterungseffekte in Transistoren sowie übermäßige Hitzeentwicklung, nicht zuletzt durch stärkeres Auftreten von Selbsterhitzungseffekten innerhalb der Transistoren. Damit solche Probleme die Zuverlässigkeit eines Schaltkreises nicht gefährden, werden die internen Signallaufzeiten üblicherweise sehr pessimistisch kalkuliert. Durch den so entstandenen zeitlichen Sicherheitsabstand wird die korrekte Funktionalität des Schaltkreises sichergestellt, allerdings auf Kosten der Performance. Alternativ kann die Zuverlässigkeit des Schaltkreises auch durch andere Techniken erhöht werden, wie zum Beispiel durch Null-Temperatur-Koeffizienten oder Approximate Computing. Wenngleich diese Techniken einen Großteil des üblichen zeitlichen Sicherheitsabstandes einsparen können, bergen sie dennoch weitere Konsequenzen und Kompromisse. Bleibende Herausforderungen bei der Skalierung von CMOS Technologien führen außerdem zu einem verstärkten Fokus auf vielversprechende Zukunftstechnologien. Ein Beispiel dafür ist der Negative Capacitance Field-Effect Transistor (NCFET), der eine beachtenswerte Leistungssteigerung gegenüber herkömmlichen FinFET Transistoren aufweist und diese in Zukunft ersetzen könnte. Des Weiteren setzen Entwickler von Schaltkreisen vermehrt auf komplexe, parallele Strukturen statt auf höhere Taktfrequenzen. Diese komplexen Modelle benötigen moderne Power-Management Techniken in allen Aspekten des Designs. Mit dem Auftreten von neuartigen Transistortechnologien (wie zum Beispiel NCFET) müssen diese Power-Management Techniken neu bewertet werden, da sich Abhängigkeiten und Verhältnismäßigkeiten ändern. Diese Arbeit präsentiert neue Herangehensweisen, sowohl zur Analyse als auch zur Modellierung der Zuverlässigkeit von Schaltkreisen, um zuvor genannte Herausforderungen auf mehreren Designebenen anzugehen. Diese Herangehensweisen unterteilen sich in konventionelle Techniken ((a), (b), (c) und (d)) und unkonventionelle Techniken ((e) und (f)), wie folgt: $\textbf{(a)}$ Analyse von Leistungszunahmen in Zusammenhang mit der Maximierung von Leistungseffizienz beim Betrieb nahe der Transistor Schwellspannung, insbesondere am optimalen Leistungspunkt. Das genaue Ermitteln eines solchen optimalen Leistungspunkts ist eine besondere Herausforderung bei Multicore Designs, da dieser sich mit den jeweiligen Optimierungszielsetzungen und der Arbeitsbelastung verschiebt. $\textbf{(b)}$ Aufzeigen versteckter Interdependenzen zwischen Alterungseffekten bei Transistoren und Schwankungen in der Versorgungsspannung durch „IR-drops“. Eine neuartige Technik wird vorgestellt, die sowohl Über- als auch Unterschätzungen bei der Ermittlung des zeitlichen Sicherheitsabstands vermeidet und folglich den kleinsten, dennoch ausreichenden Sicherheitsabstand ermittelt. $\textbf{(c)}$ Eindämmung von Alterungseffekten bei Transistoren durch „Graceful Approximation“, eine Technik zur Erhöhung der Taktfrequenz bei Bedarf. Der durch Alterungseffekte bedingte zeitlich Sicherheitsabstand wird durch Approximate Computing Techniken ersetzt. Des Weiteren wird Quantisierung verwendet um ausreichend Genauigkeit bei den Berechnungen zu gewährleisten. $\textbf{(d)}$ Eindämmung von temperaturabhängigen Verschlechterungen der Signallaufzeit durch den Betrieb nahe des Null-Temperatur Koeffizienten (N-ZTC). Der Betrieb bei N-ZTC minimiert temperaturbedingte Abweichungen der Performance und der Leistungsaufnahme. Qualitative und quantitative Vergleiche gegenüber dem traditionellen zeitlichen Sicherheitsabstand werden präsentiert. $\textbf{(e)}$ Modellierung von Power-Management Techniken für NCFET-basierte Prozessoren. Die NCFET Technologie hat einzigartige Eigenschaften, durch die herkömmliche Verfahren zur Spannungs- und Frequenzskalierungen zur Laufzeit (DVS/DVFS) suboptimale Ergebnisse erzielen. Dies erfordert NCFET-spezifische Power-Management Techniken, die in dieser Arbeit vorgestellt werden. $\textbf{(f)}$ Vorstellung eines neuartigen heterogenen Multicore Designs in NCFET Technologie. Das Design beinhaltet identische Kerne; Heterogenität entsteht durch die Anwendung der individuellen, optimalen Konfiguration der Kerne. Amdahls Gesetz wird erweitert, um neue system- und anwendungsspezifische Parameter abzudecken und die Vorzüge des neuen Designs aufzuzeigen. Die Auswertungen der vorgestellten Techniken werden mithilfe von Implementierungen und Simulationen auf Schaltkreisebene (gate-level) durchgeführt. Des Weiteren werden Simulatoren auf Systemebene (system-level) verwendet, um Multicore Designs zu implementieren und zu simulieren. Zur Validierung und Bewertung der Effektivität gegenüber dem Stand der Technik werden analytische, gate-level und system-level Simulationen herangezogen, die sowohl synthetische als auch reale Anwendungen betrachten

Ultra Low Power Design for Digital CMOS Circuits Operating Near Threshold

Circuits operating in the subthreshold region are synonymous to low energy operation. However, the penalty in performance is colossal. In this paper, we investigate how designing in moderate inversion region recuperates some of that lost performance, while remaining very near to the minimum energy point. An power based minimum energy delay modeling that is continuous over the weak, moderate, and strong inversion regions is presented. The effect of supply voltage and device sizing on the minimum energy and performance is determined. The proposed model is utilized to design a temperature to time generator at 32nm technology node asthe application of the proposed model