Linux kernel compaction through cold code swapping

There is a growing trend to use general-purpose operating systems like Linux in embedded systems. Previous research focused on using compaction and specialization techniques to adapt a general-purpose OS to the memory-constrained environment, presented by most, embedded systems. However, there is still room for improvement: it has been shown that even after application of the aforementioned techniques more than 50% of the kernel code remains unexecuted under normal system operation. We introduce a new technique that reduces the Linux kernel code memory footprint, through on-demand code loading of infrequently executed code, for systems that support virtual memory. In this paper, we describe our general approach, and we study code placement algorithms to minimize the performance impact of the code loading. A code, size reduction of 68% is achieved, with a 2.2% execution speedup of the system-mode execution time, for a case study based on the MediaBench II benchmark suite

NVSwap Latency-Aware Paging Using Non-Volatile Main Memory

Page relocation (paging) from DRAM to swap devices is an important task of a virtual memory system in operating systems. Existing Linux paging mechanisms have two main deficiencies: (1) they may incur a high I/O latency due to write interference on solid-state disks and aggressive memory page reclaiming rate under high memory pressure and (2) they do not provide predictable latency bound for latency-sensitive applications because they cannot control the allocation of system resources among concurrent processes sharing swap devices. In this thesis, we present the design and implementation of a latency-aware paging mechanism called NVSwap. It supports a hybrid swap space using both regular secondary storage devices (e.g., solid-state disks) and non-volatile main memory (NVMM). The design is more cost-effective than using only NVMM as swap spaces. Furthermore, NVSwap uses NVMM as a persistent paging buffer to serve the page-out requests and hide the latency of paging between the regular swap device and DRAM. It supports in-situ paging for pages in the persistent paging buffer avoiding the slow I/O path. Finally, NVSwap allows users to specify latency bounds for individual processes or a group of related processes and enforces the bounds by dynamically controlling the resource allocation of NVMM and page reclaiming rate in memory among scheduling units. We have implemented a prototype of NVSwap in the Linux kernel-3.16.74. Our results demonstrate that NVSwap reduces paging latency by up to 99% and provides performance guarantee and isolation among concurrent applications sharing swap devices

Extending Memory Capacity in Consumer Devices with Emerging Non-Volatile Memory: An Experimental Study

The number and diversity of consumer devices are growing rapidly, alongside their target applications' memory consumption. Unfortunately, DRAM scalability is becoming a limiting factor to the available memory capacity in consumer devices. As a potential solution, manufacturers have introduced emerging non-volatile memories (NVMs) into the market, which can be used to increase the memory capacity of consumer devices by augmenting or replacing DRAM. Since entirely replacing DRAM with NVM in consumer devices imposes large system integration and design challenges, recent works propose extending the total main memory space available to applications by using NVM as swap space for DRAM. However, no prior work analyzes the implications of enabling a real NVM-based swap space in real consumer devices. In this work, we provide the first analysis of the impact of extending the main memory space of consumer devices using off-the-shelf NVMs. We extensively examine system performance and energy consumption when the NVM device is used as swap space for DRAM main memory to effectively extend the main memory capacity. For our analyses, we equip real web-based Chromebook computers with the Intel Optane SSD, which is a state-of-the-art low-latency NVM-based SSD device. We compare the performance and energy consumption of interactive workloads running on our Chromebook with NVM-based swap space, where the Intel Optane SSD capacity is used as swap space to extend main memory capacity, against two state-of-the-art systems: (i) a baseline system with double the amount of DRAM than the system with the NVM-based swap space; and (ii) a system where the Intel Optane SSD is naively replaced with a state-of-the-art (yet slower) off-the-shelf NAND-flash-based SSD, which we use as a swap space of equivalent size as the NVM-based swap space

Secure Portable Execution Environments: A Review of Available Technologies

Live operating systems and virtualisation allow a known, defined, safe and secure execution environment to be loaded in to a PC’s memory and executed with either minimal or possibly no reliance on the PC’s internal hard disk drive. The ability to boot a live operating system or load a virtual environment (containing an operating system) from a USB storage device allows a secure portable execution environment to be created. Portable execution environments have typically been used by technologists, for example to recover data from a failing PC internal hard disk drive or to perform forensic analysis. However, with the commercial potential of portable execution environments becoming realised the requirement for such environments to be secure is becoming increasingly important. To be considered truly secure a portable execution environment should require authentication prior to loading the executing environment (from the USB mass storage device) and provide full encryption of the whole mass storage device. This paper discusses the outcomes from building four portable execution environments, using commercially available and/or freeware technologies. An overview is given of the emerging commercial requirement for secure portable USB execution environments, the security threats addressed and research performed in the area. The technologies and products considered in the review are outlined together with rationale behind the selection. The findings from the implementation of the four portable execution environments are discussed including successes, failures and difficulties encountered. A set of security requirements is defined which is used to gauge the effectiveness of each of the four environments

Memory Management for Emerging Memory Technologies

The Memory Wall, or the gap between CPU speed and main memory latency, is ever increasing. The latency of Dynamic Random-Access Memory (DRAM) is now of the order of hundreds of CPU cycles. Additionally, the DRAM main memory is experiencing power, performance and capacity constraints that limit process technology scaling. On the other hand, the workloads running on such systems are themselves changing due to virtualization and cloud computing demanding more performance of the data centers. Not only do these workloads have larger working set sizes, but they are also changing the way memory gets used, resulting in higher sharing and increased bandwidth demands. New Non-Volatile Memory technologies (NVM) are emerging as an answer to the current main memory issues. This thesis looks at memory management issues as the emerging memory technologies get integrated into the memory hierarchy. We consider the problems at various levels in the memory hierarchy, including sharing of CPU LLC, traffic management to future non-volatile memories behind the LLC, and extending main memory through the employment of NVM. The first solution we propose is “Adaptive Replacement and Insertion" (ARI), an adaptive approach to last-level CPU cache management, optimizing the cache miss rate and writeback rate simultaneously. Our specific focus is to reduce writebacks as much as possible while maintaining or improving miss rate relative to conventional LRU replacement policy, with minimal hardware overhead. ARI reduces writebacks on benchmarks from SPEC2006 suite on average by 32.9% while also decreasing misses on average by 4.7%. In a PCM based memory system, this decreases energy consumption by 23% compared to LRU and provides a 49% lifetime improvement beyond what is possible with randomized wear-leveling. Our second proposal is “Variable-Timeslice Thread Scheduling" (VATS), an OS kernel-level approach to CPU cache sharing. With modern, large, last-level caches (LLC), the time to fill the LLC is greater than the OS scheduling window. As a result, when a thread aggressively thrashes the LLC by replacing much of the data in it, another thread may not be able to recover its working set before being rescheduled. We isolate the threads in time by increasing their allotted time quanta, and allowing larger periods of time between interfering threads. Our approach, compared to conventional scheduling, mitigates up to 100% of the performance loss caused by CPU LLC interference. The system throughput is boosted by up to 15%. As an unconventional approach to utilizing emerging memory technologies, we present a Ternary Content-Addressable Memory (TCAM) design with Flash transistors. TCAM is successfully used in network routing but can also be utilized in the OS Virtual Memory applications. Based on our layout and circuit simulation experiments, we conclude that our FTCAM block achieves an area improvement of 7.9× and a power improvement of 1.64× compared to a CMOS approach. In order to lower the cost of Main Memory in systems with huge memory demand, it is becoming practical to extend the DRAM in the system with the less-expensive NVMe Flash, for a much lower system cost. However, given the relatively high Flash devices access latency, naively using them as main memory leads to serious performance degradation. We propose OSVPP, a software-only, OS swap-based page prefetching scheme for managing such hybrid DRAM + NVM systems. We show that it is possible to gain about 50% of the lost performance due to swapping into the NVM and thus enable the utilization of such hybrid systems for memory-hungry applications, lowering the memory cost while keeping the performance comparable to the DRAM-only system

Memory Management for Emerging Memory Technologies

The Memory Wall, or the gap between CPU speed and main memory latency, is ever increasing. The latency of Dynamic Random-Access Memory (DRAM) is now of the order of hundreds of CPU cycles. Additionally, the DRAM main memory is experiencing power, performance and capacity constraints that limit process technology scaling. On the other hand, the workloads running on such systems are themselves changing due to virtualization and cloud computing demanding more performance of the data centers. Not only do these workloads have larger working set sizes, but they are also changing the way memory gets used, resulting in higher sharing and increased bandwidth demands. New Non-Volatile Memory technologies (NVM) are emerging as an answer to the current main memory issues. This thesis looks at memory management issues as the emerging memory technologies get integrated into the memory hierarchy. We consider the problems at various levels in the memory hierarchy, including sharing of CPU LLC, traffic management to future non-volatile memories behind the LLC, and extending main memory through the employment of NVM. The first solution we propose is “Adaptive Replacement and Insertion" (ARI), an adaptive approach to last-level CPU cache management, optimizing the cache miss rate and writeback rate simultaneously. Our specific focus is to reduce writebacks as much as possible while maintaining or improving miss rate relative to conventional LRU replacement policy, with minimal hardware overhead. ARI reduces writebacks on benchmarks from SPEC2006 suite on average by 32.9% while also decreasing misses on average by 4.7%. In a PCM based memory system, this decreases energy consumption by 23% compared to LRU and provides a 49% lifetime improvement beyond what is possible with randomized wear-leveling. Our second proposal is “Variable-Timeslice Thread Scheduling" (VATS), an OS kernel-level approach to CPU cache sharing. With modern, large, last-level caches (LLC), the time to fill the LLC is greater than the OS scheduling window. As a result, when a thread aggressively thrashes the LLC by replacing much of the data in it, another thread may not be able to recover its working set before being rescheduled. We isolate the threads in time by increasing their allotted time quanta, and allowing larger periods of time between interfering threads. Our approach, compared to conventional scheduling, mitigates up to 100% of the performance loss caused by CPU LLC interference. The system throughput is boosted by up to 15%. As an unconventional approach to utilizing emerging memory technologies, we present a Ternary Content-Addressable Memory (TCAM) design with Flash transistors. TCAM is successfully used in network routing but can also be utilized in the OS Virtual Memory applications. Based on our layout and circuit simulation experiments, we conclude that our FTCAM block achieves an area improvement of 7.9× and a power improvement of 1.64× compared to a CMOS approach. In order to lower the cost of Main Memory in systems with huge memory demand, it is becoming practical to extend the DRAM in the system with the less-expensive NVMe Flash, for a much lower system cost. However, given the relatively high Flash devices access latency, naively using them as main memory leads to serious performance degradation. We propose OSVPP, a software-only, OS swap-based page prefetching scheme for managing such hybrid DRAM + NVM systems. We show that it is possible to gain about 50% of the lost performance due to swapping into the NVM and thus enable the utilization of such hybrid systems for memory-hungry applications, lowering the memory cost while keeping the performance comparable to the DRAM-only system

Elevating commodity storage with the SALSA host translation layer

To satisfy increasing storage demands in both capacity and performance, industry has turned to multiple storage technologies, including Flash SSDs and SMR disks. These devices employ a translation layer that conceals the idiosyncrasies of their mediums and enables random access. Device translation layers are, however, inherently constrained: resources on the drive are scarce, they cannot be adapted to application requirements, and lack visibility across multiple devices. As a result, performance and durability of many storage devices is severely degraded. In this paper, we present SALSA: a translation layer that executes on the host and allows unmodified applications to better utilize commodity storage. SALSA supports a wide range of single- and multi-device optimizations and, because is implemented in software, can adapt to specific workloads. We describe SALSA's design, and demonstrate its significant benefits using microbenchmarks and case studies based on three applications: MySQL, the Swift object store, and a video server.Comment: Presented at 2018 IEEE 26th International Symposium on Modeling, Analysis, and Simulation of Computer and Telecommunication Systems (MASCOTS