MLET: A Power Efficient Approach for TCAM Based, IP Lookup Engines in Internet Routers

Routers are one of the important entities in computer networks specially the Internet. Forwarding IP packets is a valuable and vital function in Internet routers. Routers extract destination IP address from packets and lookup those addresses in their own routing table. This task is called IP lookup. Internet address lookup is a challenging problem due to the increasing routing table sizes. Ternary Content-Addressable Memories (TCAMs) are becoming very popular for designing high-throughput address lookup-engines on routers: they are fast, cost-effective and simple to manage. Despite the TCAMs speed, their high power consumption is their major drawback. In this paper, Multilevel Enabling Technique (MLET), a power efficient TCAM based hardware architecture has been proposed. This scheme is employed after an Espresso-II minimization algorithm to achieve lower power consumption. The performance evaluation of the proposed approach shows that it can save considerable amount of routing table's power consumption.Comment: 14 Pages, IJCNC 201

Design and Evaluation of Packet Classification Systems, Doctoral Dissertation, December 2006

Although many algorithms and architectures have been proposed, the design of efficient packet classification systems remains a challenging problem. The diversity of filter specifications, the scale of filter sets, and the throughput requirements of high speed networks all contribute to the difficulty. We need to review the algorithms from a high-level point-of-view in order to advance the study. This level of understanding can lead to significant performance improvements. In this dissertation, we evaluate several existing algorithms and present several new algorithms as well. The previous evaluation results for existing algorithms are not convincing because they have not been done in a consistent way. To resolve this issue, an objective evaluation platform needs to be developed. We implement and evaluate several representative algorithms with uniform criteria. The source code and the evaluation results are both published on a web-site to provide the research community a benchmark for impartial and thorough algorithm evaluations. We propose several new algorithms to deal with the different variations of the packet classification problem. They are: (1) the Shape Shifting Trie algorithm for longest prefix matching, used in IP lookups or as a building block for general packet classification algorithms; (2) the Fast Hash Table lookup algorithm used for exact flow match; (3) the longest prefix matching algorithm using hash tables and tries, used in IP lookups or packet classification algorithms;(4) the 2D coarse-grained tuple-space search algorithm with controlled filter expansion, used for two-dimensional packet classification or as a building block for general packet classification algorithms; (5) the Adaptive Binary Cutting algorithm used for general multi-dimensional packet classification. In addition to the algorithmic solutions, we also consider the TCAM hardware solution. In particular, we address the TCAM filter update problem for general packet classification and provide an efficient algorithm. Building upon the previous work, these algorithms significantly improve the performance of packet classification systems and set a solid foundation for further study

On using content addressable memory for packet classification

Packet switched networks such as the Internet require packet classification at every hop in order to ap-ply services and security policies to traffic flows. The relentless increase in link speeds and traffic volume imposes astringent constraints on packet classification solutions. Ternary Content Addressable Memory (TCAM) devices are favored by most network component and equipment vendors due to the fast and de-terministic lookup performance afforded by their use of massive parallelism. While able to keep up with high speed links, TCAMs suffer from exorbitant power consumption, poor scalability to longer search keys and larger filter sets, and inefficient support of multiple matches. The research community has responded with algorithms that seek to meet the lookup rate constraint with greater efficiency through the use of com-modity Random Access Memory (RAM) technology. The most promising algorithms efficiently achieve high lookup rates by leveraging the statistical structure of real filter sets. Due to their dependence on filter set characteristics, it is difficult to provision processing and memory resources for implementations that support a wide variety of filter sets. We show how several algorithmic advances may be leveraged to im-prove the efficiency, scalability, incremental update and multiple match performance of CAM-based packet classification techniques without degrading the lookup performance. Our approach, Label Encoded Content Addressable Memory (LECAM), represents a hybrid technique that utilizes decomposition, label encoding, and a novel Content Addressable Memory (CAM) architecture. By reducing the number of implementation parameters, LECAM provides a vehicle to carry several of the recent algorithmic advances into practice. We provide a thorough overview of CAM technologies and packet classification algorithms, along with a detailed discussion of the scaling issues that arise with longer search keys and larger filter sets. We also provide a comparative analysis of LECAM and standard TCAM using a collection of real and synthetic filter sets of various sizes and compositions

A Scalable High-Performance Memory-Less IP Address Lookup Engine Suitable for FPGA Implementation

RÉSUMÉ La recherche d'adresse IP est une opération très importante pour les routeurs Internet modernes. De nombreuses approches dans la littérature ont été proposées pour réaliser des moteurs de recherche d'adresse IP (Address Lookup Engine – ALE), à haute performance. Les ALE existants peuvent être classés dans l’une ou l’autre de trois catégories basées sur: les mémoires ternaires adressables par le contenu (TCAM), les Trie et les émulations de TCAM. Les approches qui se basent sur des TCAM sont coûteuses et elles consomment beaucoup d'énergie. Les techniques qui exploitent les Trie ont une latence non déterministe qui nécessitent généralement des accès à une mémoire externe. Les techniques qui exploitent des émulations de TCAM combinent généralement des TCAM avec des circuits à faible coût. Dans ce mémoire, l'objectif principal est de proposer une architecture d'ALE qui permet la recherche rapide d’adresses IP et qui apporte une solution aux principales lacunes des techniques basées sur des TCAM et sur des Trie. Atteindre une vitesse de traitement suffisante dans l'ALE est un aspect important. Des accélérateurs matériels ont été adoptés pour obtenir une le résultat de recherche à haute vitesse. Le FPGA permettent la mise en œuvre d’accélérateurs matériels reconfigurables spécialisés. Cinq architectures d’ALE de type émulation de TCAM sont proposés dans ce mémoire : une sérielle, une parallèle, une architecture dite IP-Split, une variante appelée IP-Split-Bucket et une version de l’IP-Split-Bucket qui supporte les mises à jours. Chaque architecture est construite à partir de l’architecture précédente de manière progressive dans le but d’en améliorer les performances. L'architecture sérielle utilise des mémoires pour stocker la table d’adresses de transmission et un comparateur pour effectuer une recherche sérielle sur les entrées. L'architecture parallèle stocke les entrées de la table dans les ressources logiques d’un FPGA, et elle emploie une recherche parallèle en utilisant N comparateurs pour une table avec N entrées. L’architecture IP-Split emploie un niveau de décodeurs pour éviter des comparaisons répétitives dans les entrées équivalentes de la table. L'architecture IP-Split-Bucket est une version améliorée de l'architecture précédente qui utilise une méthode de partitionnement visant à optimiser l'architecture IP-Split. L’IP-Split-Bucket qui supporte les mises à jour est la dernière architecture proposée. Elle soutient la mise à jour et la recherche à haute vitesse d'adresses IP. Les résultats d’implémentations montrent que l'architecture d’ALE qui offre les meilleures performances est l’IP-Split-Bucket, qui n’a pas recours à une ou plusieurs mémoires. Pour une table d’adresses de transmission IPv4 réelle comportant 524 k préfixes, l'architecture IP-Split-Bucket atteint un débit de 103,4 M paquets par seconde et elle consomme respectivement 23% et 22% des tables de conversion (LUTs) et des bascules (FFs) sur une puce Xilinx XC7V2000T.----------ABSTRACT High-performance IP address lookup is highly demanded for modern Internet routers. Many approaches in the literature describe a special purpose Address Lookup Engines (ALE), for IP address lookup. The existing ALEs can be categorised into the following techniques: Ternary Content Addressable Memories-based (TCAM-based), trie-based and TCAM-emulation. TCAM-based techniques are expensive and consume a lot of power, since they employ TCAMs in their architecture. Trie-based techniques have nondeterministic latency and external memory accesses, since they store the Forwarding Information Base (FIB) in the memory using a trie data structure. TCAM-emulation techniques commonly combine TCAMs with lower-cost circuits that handle less time-critical activities. In this thesis, the main objective is to propose an ALE architecture with fast search that addresses the main shortcomings of TCAM-based and trie-based techniques. Achieving an admissible throughput in the proposed ALE is its fundamental requirement due to the recent improvements of network systems and growth of Internet of Things (IoTs). For that matter, hardware accelerators have been adopted to achieve a high speed search. In this work, Field Programmable Gate Arrays (FPGAs) are specialized reconfigurable hardware accelerators chosen as the target platform for the ALE architecture. Five TCAM-emulation ALE architectures are proposed in this thesis: the Full-Serial, the Full-Parallel, the IP-Split, the IP-Split-Bucket and the Update-enabled IP-Split-Bucket architectures. Each architecture builds on the previous one with progressive improvements. The Full-Serial architecture employs memories to store the FIB and one comparator to perform a serial search on the FIB entries. The Full-Parallel architecture stores the FIB entries into the logical resources of the FPGA and employs a parallel search using one comparator for each FIB entry. The IP-Split architecture employs a level of decoders to avoid repetitive comparisons in the equivalent entries of the FIB. The IP-Split-Bucket architecture is an upgraded version of the previous architecture using a partitioning scheme aiming to optimize the IP-Split architecture. Finally, the Update-enabled IP-Split-Bucket supports high-update rate IP address lookup. The most efficient proposed architecture is the IP-Split-Bucket, which is a novel high-performance memory-less ALE. For a real-world FIB with 524 k IPv4 prefixes, IP-Split-Bucket achieves a throughput of 103.4M packets per second and consumes respectively 23% and 22% of the Look Up Tables (LUTs) and Flip-Flops (FFs) of a Xilinx XC7V2000T chip

An algorithm for fast route lookup and update

Increase in routing table sizes, number of updates, traffic, speed of links and migration to IPv6 have made IP address lookup, based on longest prefix matching, a major bottleneck for high performance routers. Several schemes are evaluated and compared based on complexity analysis and simulation results. A trie based scheme, called Linked List Cascade Addressable Trie (LLCAT) is presented. The strength of LLCAT comes from the fact that it is easy to be implemented in hardware, and also routing table update operations are performed incrementally requiring very few memory operations guaranteed for worst case to satisfy requirements of dynamic routing tables in high speed routers. Application of compression schemes to this algorithm is also considered to improve memory consumption and search time. The algorithm is implemented in C language and simulation results with real-life data is presented along with detailed description of the algorithm

Models, Algorithms, and Architectures for Scalable Packet Classification

The growth and diversification of the Internet imposes increasing demands on the performance and functionality of network infrastructure. Routers, the devices responsible for the switch-ing and directing of traffic in the Internet, are being called upon to not only handle increased volumes of traffic at higher speeds, but also impose tighter security policies and provide support for a richer set of network services. This dissertation addresses the searching tasks performed by Internet routers in order to forward packets and apply network services to packets belonging to defined traffic flows. As these searching tasks must be performed for each packet traversing the router, the speed and scalability of the solutions to the route lookup and packet classification problems largely determine the realizable performance of the router, and hence the Internet as a whole. Despite the energetic attention of the academic and corporate research communities, there remains a need for search engines that scale to support faster communication links, larger route tables and filter sets and increasingly complex filters. The major contributions of this work include the design and analysis of a scalable hardware implementation of a Longest Prefix Matching (LPM) search engine for route lookup, a survey and taxonomy of packet classification techniques, a thorough analysis of packet classification filter sets, the design and analysis of a suite of performance evaluation tools for packet classification algorithms and devices, and a new packet classification algorithm that scales to support high-speed links and large filter sets classifying on additional packet fields

Memory Management for Emerging Memory Technologies

The Memory Wall, or the gap between CPU speed and main memory latency, is ever increasing. The latency of Dynamic Random-Access Memory (DRAM) is now of the order of hundreds of CPU cycles. Additionally, the DRAM main memory is experiencing power, performance and capacity constraints that limit process technology scaling. On the other hand, the workloads running on such systems are themselves changing due to virtualization and cloud computing demanding more performance of the data centers. Not only do these workloads have larger working set sizes, but they are also changing the way memory gets used, resulting in higher sharing and increased bandwidth demands. New Non-Volatile Memory technologies (NVM) are emerging as an answer to the current main memory issues. This thesis looks at memory management issues as the emerging memory technologies get integrated into the memory hierarchy. We consider the problems at various levels in the memory hierarchy, including sharing of CPU LLC, traffic management to future non-volatile memories behind the LLC, and extending main memory through the employment of NVM. The first solution we propose is “Adaptive Replacement and Insertion" (ARI), an adaptive approach to last-level CPU cache management, optimizing the cache miss rate and writeback rate simultaneously. Our specific focus is to reduce writebacks as much as possible while maintaining or improving miss rate relative to conventional LRU replacement policy, with minimal hardware overhead. ARI reduces writebacks on benchmarks from SPEC2006 suite on average by 32.9% while also decreasing misses on average by 4.7%. In a PCM based memory system, this decreases energy consumption by 23% compared to LRU and provides a 49% lifetime improvement beyond what is possible with randomized wear-leveling. Our second proposal is “Variable-Timeslice Thread Scheduling" (VATS), an OS kernel-level approach to CPU cache sharing. With modern, large, last-level caches (LLC), the time to fill the LLC is greater than the OS scheduling window. As a result, when a thread aggressively thrashes the LLC by replacing much of the data in it, another thread may not be able to recover its working set before being rescheduled. We isolate the threads in time by increasing their allotted time quanta, and allowing larger periods of time between interfering threads. Our approach, compared to conventional scheduling, mitigates up to 100% of the performance loss caused by CPU LLC interference. The system throughput is boosted by up to 15%. As an unconventional approach to utilizing emerging memory technologies, we present a Ternary Content-Addressable Memory (TCAM) design with Flash transistors. TCAM is successfully used in network routing but can also be utilized in the OS Virtual Memory applications. Based on our layout and circuit simulation experiments, we conclude that our FTCAM block achieves an area improvement of 7.9× and a power improvement of 1.64× compared to a CMOS approach. In order to lower the cost of Main Memory in systems with huge memory demand, it is becoming practical to extend the DRAM in the system with the less-expensive NVMe Flash, for a much lower system cost. However, given the relatively high Flash devices access latency, naively using them as main memory leads to serious performance degradation. We propose OSVPP, a software-only, OS swap-based page prefetching scheme for managing such hybrid DRAM + NVM systems. We show that it is possible to gain about 50% of the lost performance due to swapping into the NVM and thus enable the utilization of such hybrid systems for memory-hungry applications, lowering the memory cost while keeping the performance comparable to the DRAM-only system

Memory Management for Emerging Memory Technologies

The Memory Wall, or the gap between CPU speed and main memory latency, is ever increasing. The latency of Dynamic Random-Access Memory (DRAM) is now of the order of hundreds of CPU cycles. Additionally, the DRAM main memory is experiencing power, performance and capacity constraints that limit process technology scaling. On the other hand, the workloads running on such systems are themselves changing due to virtualization and cloud computing demanding more performance of the data centers. Not only do these workloads have larger working set sizes, but they are also changing the way memory gets used, resulting in higher sharing and increased bandwidth demands. New Non-Volatile Memory technologies (NVM) are emerging as an answer to the current main memory issues. This thesis looks at memory management issues as the emerging memory technologies get integrated into the memory hierarchy. We consider the problems at various levels in the memory hierarchy, including sharing of CPU LLC, traffic management to future non-volatile memories behind the LLC, and extending main memory through the employment of NVM. The first solution we propose is “Adaptive Replacement and Insertion" (ARI), an adaptive approach to last-level CPU cache management, optimizing the cache miss rate and writeback rate simultaneously. Our specific focus is to reduce writebacks as much as possible while maintaining or improving miss rate relative to conventional LRU replacement policy, with minimal hardware overhead. ARI reduces writebacks on benchmarks from SPEC2006 suite on average by 32.9% while also decreasing misses on average by 4.7%. In a PCM based memory system, this decreases energy consumption by 23% compared to LRU and provides a 49% lifetime improvement beyond what is possible with randomized wear-leveling. Our second proposal is “Variable-Timeslice Thread Scheduling" (VATS), an OS kernel-level approach to CPU cache sharing. With modern, large, last-level caches (LLC), the time to fill the LLC is greater than the OS scheduling window. As a result, when a thread aggressively thrashes the LLC by replacing much of the data in it, another thread may not be able to recover its working set before being rescheduled. We isolate the threads in time by increasing their allotted time quanta, and allowing larger periods of time between interfering threads. Our approach, compared to conventional scheduling, mitigates up to 100% of the performance loss caused by CPU LLC interference. The system throughput is boosted by up to 15%. As an unconventional approach to utilizing emerging memory technologies, we present a Ternary Content-Addressable Memory (TCAM) design with Flash transistors. TCAM is successfully used in network routing but can also be utilized in the OS Virtual Memory applications. Based on our layout and circuit simulation experiments, we conclude that our FTCAM block achieves an area improvement of 7.9× and a power improvement of 1.64× compared to a CMOS approach. In order to lower the cost of Main Memory in systems with huge memory demand, it is becoming practical to extend the DRAM in the system with the less-expensive NVMe Flash, for a much lower system cost. However, given the relatively high Flash devices access latency, naively using them as main memory leads to serious performance degradation. We propose OSVPP, a software-only, OS swap-based page prefetching scheme for managing such hybrid DRAM + NVM systems. We show that it is possible to gain about 50% of the lost performance due to swapping into the NVM and thus enable the utilization of such hybrid systems for memory-hungry applications, lowering the memory cost while keeping the performance comparable to the DRAM-only system