Credibility analysis of textual claims with explainable evidence

Despite being a vast resource of valuable information, the Web has been polluted by the spread of false claims. Increasing hoaxes, fake news, and misleading information on the Web have given rise to many fact-checking websites that manually assess these doubtful claims. However, the rapid speed and large scale of misinformation spread have become the bottleneck for manual verification. This calls for credibility assessment tools that can automate this verification process. Prior works in this domain make strong assumptions about the structure of the claims and the communities where they are made. Most importantly, black-box techniques proposed in prior works lack the ability to explain why a certain statement is deemed credible or not. To address these limitations, this dissertation proposes a general framework for automated credibility assessment that does not make any assumption about the structure or origin of the claims. Specifically, we propose a feature-based model, which automatically retrieves relevant articles about the given claim and assesses its credibility by capturing the mutual interaction between the language style of the relevant articles, their stance towards the claim, and the trustworthiness of the underlying web sources. We further enhance our credibility assessment approach and propose a neural-network-based model. Unlike the feature-based model, this model does not rely on feature engineering and external lexicons. Both our models make their assessments interpretable by extracting explainable evidence from judiciously selected web sources. We utilize our models and develop a Web interface, CredEye, which enables users to automatically assess the credibility of a textual claim and dissect into the assessment by browsing through judiciously and automatically selected evidence snippets. In addition, we study the problem of stance classification and propose a neural-network-based model for predicting the stance of diverse user perspectives regarding the controversial claims. Given a controversial claim and a user comment, our stance classification model predicts whether the user comment is supporting or opposing the claim.Das Web ist eine riesige Quelle wertvoller Informationen, allerdings wurde es durch die Verbreitung von Falschmeldungen verschmutzt. Eine zunehmende Anzahl an Hoaxes, Falschmeldungen und irreführenden Informationen im Internet haben viele Websites hervorgebracht, auf denen die Fakten überprüft und zweifelhafte Behauptungen manuell bewertet werden. Die rasante Verbreitung großer Mengen von Fehlinformationen sind jedoch zum Engpass für die manuelle Überprüfung geworden. Dies erfordert Tools zur Bewertung der Glaubwürdigkeit, mit denen dieser Überprüfungsprozess automatisiert werden kann. In früheren Arbeiten in diesem Bereich werden starke Annahmen gemacht über die Struktur der Behauptungen und die Portale, in denen sie gepostet werden. Vor allem aber können die Black-Box-Techniken, die in früheren Arbeiten vorgeschlagen wurden, nicht erklären, warum eine bestimmte Aussage als glaubwürdig erachtet wird oder nicht. Um diesen Einschränkungen zu begegnen, wird in dieser Dissertation ein allgemeines Framework für die automatisierte Bewertung der Glaubwürdigkeit vorgeschlagen, bei dem keine Annahmen über die Struktur oder den Ursprung der Behauptungen gemacht werden. Insbesondere schlagen wir ein featurebasiertes Modell vor, das automatisch relevante Artikel zu einer bestimmten Behauptung abruft und deren Glaubwürdigkeit bewertet, indem die gegenseitige Interaktion zwischen dem Sprachstil der relevanten Artikel, ihre Haltung zur Behauptung und der Vertrauenswürdigkeit der zugrunde liegenden Quellen erfasst wird. Wir verbessern unseren Ansatz zur Bewertung der Glaubwürdigkeit weiter und schlagen ein auf neuronalen Netzen basierendes Modell vor. Im Gegensatz zum featurebasierten Modell ist dieses Modell nicht auf Feature-Engineering und externe Lexika angewiesen. Unsere beiden Modelle machen ihre Einschätzungen interpretierbar, indem sie erklärbare Beweise aus sorgfältig ausgewählten Webquellen extrahieren. Wir verwenden unsere Modelle zur Entwicklung eines Webinterfaces, CredEye, mit dem Benutzer die Glaubwürdigkeit einer Behauptung in Textform automatisch bewerten und verstehen können, indem sie automatisch ausgewählte Beweisstücke einsehen. Darüber hinaus untersuchen wir das Problem der Positionsklassifizierung und schlagen ein auf neuronalen Netzen basierendes Modell vor, um die Position verschiedener Benutzerperspektiven in Bezug auf die umstrittenen Behauptungen vorherzusagen. Bei einer kontroversen Behauptung und einem Benutzerkommentar sagt unser Einstufungsmodell voraus, ob der Benutzerkommentar die Behauptung unterstützt oder ablehnt

Biomedical Information Extraction Pipelines for Public Health in the Age of Deep Learning

abstract: Unstructured texts containing biomedical information from sources such as electronic health records, scientific literature, discussion forums, and social media offer an opportunity to extract information for a wide range of applications in biomedical informatics. Building scalable and efficient pipelines for natural language processing and extraction of biomedical information plays an important role in the implementation and adoption of applications in areas such as public health. Advancements in machine learning and deep learning techniques have enabled rapid development of such pipelines. This dissertation presents entity extraction pipelines for two public health applications: virus phylogeography and pharmacovigilance. For virus phylogeography, geographical locations are extracted from biomedical scientific texts for metadata enrichment in the GenBank database containing 2.9 million virus nucleotide sequences. For pharmacovigilance, tools are developed to extract adverse drug reactions from social media posts to open avenues for post-market drug surveillance from non-traditional sources. Across these pipelines, high variance is observed in extraction performance among the entities of interest while using state-of-the-art neural network architectures. To explain the variation, linguistic measures are proposed to serve as indicators for entity extraction performance and to provide deeper insight into the domain complexity and the challenges associated with entity extraction. For both the phylogeography and pharmacovigilance pipelines presented in this work the annotated datasets and applications are open source and freely available to the public to foster further research in public health.Dissertation/ThesisDoctoral Dissertation Biomedical Informatics 201

Literature Based Discovery (LBD): Towards Hypothesis Generation and Knowledge Discovery in Biomedical Text Mining

Biomedical knowledge is growing in an astounding pace with a majority of this knowledge is represented as scientific publications. Text mining tools and methods represents automatic approaches for extracting hidden patterns and trends from this semi structured and unstructured data. In Biomedical Text mining, Literature Based Discovery (LBD) is the process of automatically discovering novel associations between medical terms otherwise mentioned in disjoint literature sets. LBD approaches proven to be successfully reducing the discovery time of potential associations that are hidden in the vast amount of scientific literature. The process focuses on creating concept profiles for medical terms such as a disease or symptom and connecting it with a drug and treatment based on the statistical significance of the shared profiles. This knowledge discovery approach introduced in 1989 still remains as a core task in text mining. Currently the ABC principle based two approaches namely open discovery and closed discovery are mostly explored in LBD process. This review starts with general introduction about text mining followed by biomedical text mining and introduces various literature resources such as MEDLINE, UMLS, MESH, and SemMedDB. This is followed by brief introduction of the core ABC principle and its associated two approaches open discovery and closed discovery in LBD process. This review also discusses the deep learning applications in LBD by reviewing the role of transformer models and neural networks based LBD models and its future aspects. Finally, reviews the key biomedical discoveries generated through LBD approaches in biomedicine and conclude with the current limitations and future directions of LBD.Comment: 43 Pages, 5 Figures, 4 Table

Empirical Methodology for Crowdsourcing Ground Truth

The process of gathering ground truth data through human annotation is a major bottleneck in the use of information extraction methods for populating the Semantic Web. Crowdsourcing-based approaches are gaining popularity in the attempt to solve the issues related to volume of data and lack of annotators. Typically these practices use inter-annotator agreement as a measure of quality. However, in many domains, such as event detection, there is ambiguity in the data, as well as a multitude of perspectives of the information examples. We present an empirically derived methodology for efficiently gathering of ground truth data in a diverse set of use cases covering a variety of domains and annotation tasks. Central to our approach is the use of CrowdTruth metrics that capture inter-annotator disagreement. We show that measuring disagreement is essential for acquiring a high quality ground truth. We achieve this by comparing the quality of the data aggregated with CrowdTruth metrics with majority vote, over a set of diverse crowdsourcing tasks: Medical Relation Extraction, Twitter Event Identification, News Event Extraction and Sound Interpretation. We also show that an increased number of crowd workers leads to growth and stabilization in the quality of annotations, going against the usual practice of employing a small number of annotators.Comment: in publication at the Semantic Web Journa

Web knowledge bases

Knowledge is key to natural language understanding. References to specific people, places and things in text are crucial to resolving ambiguity and extracting meaning. Knowledge Bases (KBs) codify this information for automated systems — enabling applications such as entity-based search and question answering. This thesis explores the idea that sites on the web may act as a KB, even if that is not their primary intent. Dedicated kbs like Wikipedia are a rich source of entity information, but are built and maintained at an ongoing cost in human effort. As a result, they are generally limited in terms of the breadth and depth of knowledge they index about entities. Web knowledge bases offer a distributed solution to the problem of aggregating entity knowledge. Social networks aggregate content about people, news sites describe events with tags for organizations and locations, and a diverse assortment of web directories aggregate statistics and summaries for long-tail entities notable within niche movie, musical and sporting domains. We aim to develop the potential of these resources for both web-centric entity Information Extraction (IE) and structured KB population. We first investigate the problem of Named Entity Linking (NEL), where systems must resolve ambiguous mentions of entities in text to their corresponding node in a structured KB. We demonstrate that entity disambiguation models derived from inbound web links to Wikipedia are able to complement and in some cases completely replace the role of resources typically derived from the KB. Building on this work, we observe that any page on the web which reliably disambiguates inbound web links may act as an aggregation point for entity knowledge. To uncover these resources, we formalize the task of Web Knowledge Base Discovery (KBD) and develop a system to automatically infer the existence of KB-like endpoints on the web. While extending our framework to multiple KBs increases the breadth of available entity knowledge, we must still consolidate references to the same entity across different web KBs. We investigate this task of Cross-KB Coreference Resolution (KB-Coref) and develop models for efficiently clustering coreferent endpoints across web-scale document collections. Finally, assessing the gap between unstructured web knowledge resources and those of a typical KB, we develop a neural machine translation approach which transforms entity knowledge between unstructured textual mentions and traditional KB structures. The web has great potential as a source of entity knowledge. In this thesis we aim to first discover, distill and finally transform this knowledge into forms which will ultimately be useful in downstream language understanding tasks

Product Question Answering in E-Commerce: A Survey

Product question answering (PQA), aiming to automatically provide instant responses to customer's questions in E-Commerce platforms, has drawn increasing attention in recent years. Compared with typical QA problems, PQA exhibits unique challenges such as the subjectivity and reliability of user-generated contents in E-commerce platforms. Therefore, various problem settings and novel methods have been proposed to capture these special characteristics. In this paper, we aim to systematically review existing research efforts on PQA. Specifically, we categorize PQA studies into four problem settings in terms of the form of provided answers. We analyze the pros and cons, as well as present existing datasets and evaluation protocols for each setting. We further summarize the most significant challenges that characterize PQA from general QA applications and discuss their corresponding solutions. Finally, we conclude this paper by providing the prospect on several future directions

SentiBench - a benchmark comparison of state-of-the-practice sentiment analysis methods

In the last few years thousands of scientific papers have investigated sentiment analysis, several startups that measure opinions on real data have emerged and a number of innovative products related to this theme have been developed. There are multiple methods for measuring sentiments, including lexical-based and supervised machine learning methods. Despite the vast interest on the theme and wide popularity of some methods, it is unclear which one is better for identifying the polarity (i.e., positive or negative) of a message. Accordingly, there is a strong need to conduct a thorough apple-to-apple comparison of sentiment analysis methods, \textit{as they are used in practice}, across multiple datasets originated from different data sources. Such a comparison is key for understanding the potential limitations, advantages, and disadvantages of popular methods. This article aims at filling this gap by presenting a benchmark comparison of twenty-four popular sentiment analysis methods (which we call the state-of-the-practice methods). Our evaluation is based on a benchmark of eighteen labeled datasets, covering messages posted on social networks, movie and product reviews, as well as opinions and comments in news articles. Our results highlight the extent to which the prediction performance of these methods varies considerably across datasets. Aiming at boosting the development of this research area, we open the methods' codes and datasets used in this article, deploying them in a benchmark system, which provides an open API for accessing and comparing sentence-level sentiment analysis methods

Self-supervised learning in natural language processing

Most natural language processing (NLP) learning algorithms require labeled data. While this is given for a select number of (mostly English) tasks, the availability of labeled data is sparse or non-existent for the vast majority of use-cases. To alleviate this, unsupervised learning and a wide array of data augmentation techniques have been developed (Hedderich et al., 2021a). However, unsupervised learning often requires massive amounts of unlabeled data and also fails to perform in difficult (low-resource) data settings, i.e., if there is an increased distance between the source and target data distributions (Kim et al., 2020). This distributional distance can be the case if there is a domain drift or large linguistic distance between the source and target data. Unsupervised learning in itself does not exploit the highly informative (labeled) supervisory signals hidden in unlabeled data. In this dissertation, we show that by combining the right unsupervised auxiliary task (e.g., sentence pair extraction) with an appropriate primary task (e.g., machine translation), self-supervised learning can exploit these hidden supervisory signals more efficiently than purely unsupervised approaches, while functioning on less labeled data than supervised approaches. Our self-supervised learning approach can be used to learn NLP tasks in an efficient manner, even when the amount of training data is sparse or the data comes with strong differences in its underlying distribution, e.g., stemming from unrelated languages. For our general approach, we applied unsupervised learning as an auxiliary task to learn a supervised primary task. Concretely, we have focused on the auxiliary task of sentence pair extraction for sequence-to-sequence primary tasks (i.e., machine translation and style transfer) as well as language modeling, clustering, subspace learning and knowledge integration for primary classification tasks (i.e., hate speech detection and sentiment analysis). For sequence-to-sequence tasks, we show that self-supervised neural machine translation (NMT) achieves competitive results on high-resource language pairs in comparison to unsupervised NMT while requiring less data. Further combining self-supervised NMT with unsupervised NMT-inspired augmentation techniques makes the learning of low-resource (similar, distant and unrelated) language pairs possible. Further, using our self-supervised approach, we show how style transfer can be learned without the need for parallel data, generating stylistic rephrasings of highest overall performance on all tested tasks. For sequence-to-label tasks, we underline the benefit of auxiliary task-based augmentation over primary task augmentation. An auxiliary task that showed to be especially beneficial to the primary task performance was subspace learning, which led to impressive gains in (cross-lingual) zero-shot classification performance on similar or distant target tasks, also on similar, distant and unrelated languages.Die meisten Lernalgorithmen der Computerlingistik (CL) benötigen gelabelte Daten. Diese sind zwar für eine Auswahl an (hautpsächlich Englischen) Aufgaben verfügbar, für den Großteil aller Anwendungsfälle sind gelabelte Daten jedoch nur spärrlich bis gar nicht vorhanden. Um dem gegenzusteuern, wurde eine große Auswahl an Techniken entwickelt, welche sich das unüberwachte Lernen oder Datenaugmentierung zu eigen machen (Hedderich et al., 2021a). Unüberwachtes Lernen benötigt jedoch massive Mengen an ungelabelten Daten und versagt, wenn es mit schwierigen (resourcenarmen) Datensituationen konfrontiert wird, d.h. wenn eine größere Distanz zwischen der Quellen- und Zieldatendistributionen vorhanden ist (Kim et al., 2020). Eine distributionelle Distanz kann zum Beispiel der Fall sein, wenn ein Domänenunterschied oder eine größere sprachliche Distanz zwischen der Quellenund Zieldaten besteht. Unüberwachtes Lernen selbst nutzt die hochinformativen (gelabelten) Überwachungssignale, welche sich in ungelabelte Daten verstecken, nicht aus. In dieser Dissertation zeigen wir, dass selbstüberwachtes Lernen, durch die Kombination der richtigen unüberwachten Hilfsaufgabe (z.B. Satzpaarextraktion) mit einer passenden Hauptaufgabe (z.B. maschinelle Übersetzung), diese versteckten Überwachsungssignale effizienter ausnutzen kann als pure unüberwachte Lernalgorithmen, und dabei auch noch weniger gelabelte Daten benötigen als überwachte Lernalgorithmen. Unser selbstüberwachter Lernansatz erlaubt es uns, CL Aufgaben effizient zu lernen, selbst wenn die Trainingsdatenmenge spärrlich ist oder die Daten mit starken distributionellen Differenzen einher gehen, z.B. weil die Daten von zwei nicht verwandten Sprachen stammen. Im Generellen haben wir unüberwachtes Lernen als Hilfsaufgabe angewandt um eine überwachte Hauptaufgabe zu erlernen. Konkret haben wir uns auf Satzpaarextraktion als Hilfsaufgabe für Sequenz-zu-Sequenz Hauptaufgaben (z.B. maschinelle Übersetzung und Stilübertragung) konzentriert sowohl als auch Sprachmodelierung, Clustern, Teilraumlernen und Wissensintegration zum erlernen von Klassifikationsaufgaben (z.B. Hassredenidentifikation und Sentimentanalyse). Für Sequenz-zu-Sequenz Aufgaben zeigen wir, dass selbstüberwachte maschinelle Übersetzung (MÜ) im Vergleich zur unüberwachten MÜ wettbewerbsfähige Ergebnisse auf resourcenreichen Sprachpaaren erreicht und währenddessen weniger Daten zum Lernen benötigt. Wenn selbstüberwachte MÜ mit Augmentationstechniken, inspiriert durch unüberwachte MÜ, kombiniert wird, wird auch das Lernen von resourcenarmen (ähnlichen, entfernt verwandten und nicht verwandten) Sprachpaaren möglich. Außerdem zeigen wir, wie unser selbsüberwachter Lernansatz es ermöglicht Stilübertragung ohne parallele Daten zu erlernen und dabei stylistische Umformulierungen von höchster Qualität auf allen geprüften Aufgaben zu erlangen. Für Sequenz-zu-Label Aufgaben unterstreichen wir den Vorteil, welchen hilfsaufgabenseitige Augmentierung über hauptaufgabenseitige Augmentierung hat. Eine Hilfsaufgabe welche sich als besonders hilfreich für die Qualität der Hauptaufgabe herausstellte ist das Teilraumlernen, welches zu beeindruckenden Leistungssteigerungen für (sprachübergreifende) zero-shot Klassifikation ähnlicher und entfernter Zielaufgaben (auch für ähnliche, entfernt verwandte und nicht verwandte Sprachen) führt

Predictive Analysis on Twitter: Techniques and Applications

Predictive analysis of social media data has attracted considerable attention from the research community as well as the business world because of the essential and actionable information it can provide. Over the years, extensive experimentation and analysis for insights have been carried out using Twitter data in various domains such as healthcare, public health, politics, social sciences, and demographics. In this chapter, we discuss techniques, approaches and state-of-the-art applications of predictive analysis of Twitter data. Specifically, we present fine-grained analysis involving aspects such as sentiment, emotion, and the use of domain knowledge in the coarse-grained analysis of Twitter data for making decisions and taking actions, and relate a few success stories