Analyzing a Decision Support System for Resource Planning and Surgery Scheduling

AbstractThis study aims to propose a decision support system based on optimization modelling for operating room resource planning and sequence dependent scheduling of surgery operations. We conduct a simulation experiment using real world data collected from the local hospital to evaluate the proposed model. The obtained results are compared with real surgery schedules, planned at the local hospital. The experiment shows that the efficiency of schedules produced by the proposed model are significantly improved, in terms of less surgery turnover time, increased utilization of operating rooms and minimized make-span, compared to the real schedules. Moreover, the proposed optimization based decision support system enables analysis of surgery scheduling in relation to resource planning

Operating room rescheduling

Due to surgery duration variability and arrivals of emergency surgeries, the planned Operating Room (OR) schedule is disrupted throughout the day which may lead to a change in the start time of the elective surgeries. These changes may result in undesirable situations for patients, wards or other involved departments, and therefore, the OR schedule has to be adjusted. In this paper, we develop a decision support system which assists the OR manager in this decision by providing the three best adjusted OR schedules. The system considers the preferences of all involved stakeholders and only evaluates the OR schedules that satisfy the imposed resource constraints. The decision rules used for this system are based on a thorough analysis of the OR rescheduling problem. We model this problem as an Integer Linear Program (ILP) which objective is to minimize the deviation from the preferences of the considered stakeholders. By applying this ILP to instances from practice, we determined that the given preferences mainly lead to (i) shifting a surgery and (ii) scheduling a break between two surgeries. By using these changes in the decision support system, less surgeries are canceled and the perceived workload of all departments is reduced. The system can also be used to judge the acceptability of a proposed initial OR schedule

Taxonomic classification of planning decisions in health care: a review of the state of the art in OR/MS

We provide a structured overview of the typical decisions to be made in resource capacity planning and control in health care, and a review of relevant OR/MS articles for each planning decision. The contribution of this paper is twofold. First, to position the planning decisions, a taxonomy is presented. This taxonomy provides health care managers and OR/MS researchers with a method to identify, break down and classify planning and control decisions. Second, following the taxonomy, for six health care services, we provide an exhaustive specification of planning and control decisions in resource capacity planning and control. For each planning and control decision, we structurally review the key OR/MS articles and the OR/MS methods and techniques that are applied in the literature to support decision making

Stochastic surgery selection and sequencing under dynamic emergency break-ins

Anticipating the impact of urgent emergency arrivals on operating room schedules remains methodologically and computationally challenging. This paper investigates a model for surgery scheduling, in which both surgery durations and emergency patient arrivals are stochastic. When an emergency patient arrives he enters the first available room. Given the sets of surgeries available to each operating room for that day, as well as the distributions of the main stochastic variables, we aim to find the per-room surgery sequences that minimise a joint objective, which includes over- and under-utilisation, the amount of cancelled patients, as well as the risk that emergencies suffer an excessively long waiting time. We show that a detailed analysis of emergency break-ins and their disruption of the schedule leads to a lower total cost compared to less sophisticated models. We also map the trade-off between the threshold for excessive waiting time, and the set of other objectives. Finally, an efficient heuristic is proposed to accurately estimate the value of a solution with significantly less computational effort.Anticipating the impact of urgent emergency arrivals on operating room schedules remains methodologically and computationally challenging. This paper investigates a model for surgery scheduling, in which both surgery durations and emergency patient arrivals are stochastic. When an emergency patient arrives he enters the first available room. Given the sets of surgeries available to each operating room for that day, as well as the distributions of the main stochastic variables, we aim to find the per-room surgery sequences that minimise a joint objective, which includes over- and under-utilisation, the amount of cancelled patients, as well as the risk that emergencies suffer an excessively long waiting time. We show that a detailed analysis of emergency break-ins and their disruption of the schedule leads to a lower total cost compared to less sophisticated models. We also map the trade-off between the threshold for excessive waiting time, and the set of other objectives. Finally, an efficient heuristic is proposed to accurately estimate the value of a solution with significantly less computational effort.A

Operating room planning and scheduling: A literature review.

This paper provides a review of recent research on operating room planning and scheduling. We evaluate the literature on multiple fields that are related to either the problem setting (e.g. performance measures or patient classes) or the technical features (e.g. solution technique or uncertainty incorporation). Since papers are pooled and evaluated in various ways, a diversified and detailed overview is obtained that facilitates the identification of manuscripts related to the reader's specific interests. Throughout the literature review, we summarize the significant trends in research on operating room planning and scheduling and we identify areas that need to be addressed in the future.Health care; Operating room; Scheduling; Planning; Literature review;

Visualizing the demand for various resources as a function of the master surgery schedule: A case study.

This paper presents a software system that visualizes the impact of the master surgery schedule on the demand for various resources throughout the rest of the hospital. The master surgery schedule can be seen as the engine that drives the hospital. Therefore, it is very important for decision makers to have a clear image on how the demand for resources is linked to the surgery schedule. The software presented in this paper enables schedulers to instantaneously view the impact of, e.g., an exchange of two block assignments in the master surgery schedule on the expected resource consumption pattern. A case study entailing a large Belgian surgery unit illustrates how the software can be used to assist in building better surgery schedules.Assignment; Case studies; Consumption; Decision; Demand; Exchange; Expected; Image; Impact; Management; Operating room scheduling; Resource management; Scheduling; Software; Studies; Visualization;

Visualizing the demand for various resources as a function of the master surgery schedule: A case study.

Case studies; Demand; Problems; Project scheduling; Scheduling; Studies;

A survey of health care models that encompass multiple departments

In this survey we review quantitative health care models to illustrate the extent to which they encompass multiple hospital departments. The paper provides general overviews of the relationships that exists between major hospital departments and describes how these relationships are accounted for by researchers. We find the atomistic view of hospitals often taken by researchers is partially due to the ambiguity of patient care trajectories. To this end clinical pathways literature is reviewed to illustrate its potential for clarifying patient flows and for providing a holistic hospital perspective

Human-Machine Collaborative Optimization via Apprenticeship Scheduling

Coordinating agents to complete a set of tasks with intercoupled temporal and resource constraints is computationally challenging, yet human domain experts can solve these difficult scheduling problems using paradigms learned through years of apprenticeship. A process for manually codifying this domain knowledge within a computational framework is necessary to scale beyond the ``single-expert, single-trainee" apprenticeship model. However, human domain experts often have difficulty describing their decision-making processes, causing the codification of this knowledge to become laborious. We propose a new approach for capturing domain-expert heuristics through a pairwise ranking formulation. Our approach is model-free and does not require enumerating or iterating through a large state space. We empirically demonstrate that this approach accurately learns multifaceted heuristics on a synthetic data set incorporating job-shop scheduling and vehicle routing problems, as well as on two real-world data sets consisting of demonstrations of experts solving a weapon-to-target assignment problem and a hospital resource allocation problem. We also demonstrate that policies learned from human scheduling demonstration via apprenticeship learning can substantially improve the efficiency of a branch-and-bound search for an optimal schedule. We employ this human-machine collaborative optimization technique on a variant of the weapon-to-target assignment problem. We demonstrate that this technique generates solutions substantially superior to those produced by human domain experts at a rate up to 9.5 times faster than an optimization approach and can be applied to optimally solve problems twice as complex as those solved by a human demonstrator.Comment: Portions of this paper were published in the Proceedings of the International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence (IJCAI) in 2016 and in the Proceedings of Robotics: Science and Systems (RSS) in 2016. The paper consists of 50 pages with 11 figures and 4 table