Integrating mental health services into human immunodeficiency virus clinics: Lessons from task-sharing between clinical and lay healthcare providers in Ethiopia

Background: Globally, mental health problems are more common among people living with human immunodeficiency virus (PLHIV) than among the general population. Mental health problems affect human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) treatment adherence and retention. To address this challenge, partners used a tasksharing approach among lay healthcare works and clinicians to integrate mental health services into HIV services at pilot hospitals in the Amhara and Tigray regions of Ethiopia. In this model, trained lay healthcare workers proactively screened patients using a mental health screening tool and subsequently linked potential clients with trained clinicians working at HIV clinics for further diagnosis and treatment. Methods: We retrospectively gathered secondary data, including demographic characteristics and diagnosis information, from mental health clinicians’ and case managers’ quarterly reports from HIV clinics during the implementation period (January 1, 2013 to March 31, 2014). Results: During the initial three-month implementation period of the project (January to March 2013), case managers screened 5,862 PLHIV for mental health disorders. Case managers referred 687 (11.7%) patients with suspected mental health disorders to clinicians for further evaluation and management. Of the total patients screened by case managers in this period, clinicians confirmed that 454 (7.7%) had a mental health disorder. Overall, the concordance between the case managers’ screening results and the clinicians’ diagnoses was 67.8% over the 15-month pilot implementation period. Conclusions: Routine screening of PLHIV for mental health disorders helps to proactively identify and manage patients with co-morbidities. The integration of mental health services into HIV care through a task-sharing approach is a feasible strategy that could increase access to mental health services among PLHIV. [Ethiop .J. Health Dev. 2020; 34(1):05-13] Keywords: Mental health, task-sharing, integration, HIV, Ethiopia, Afric

Economic evaluation of Health Extension Program packages in Ethiopia

Background Ethiopia launched the Health Extension Program (HEP) in 2004, aimed at ensuring equitable community-level healthcare services through Health Extension Workers. Despite the program’s being a flagship initiative, there is limited evidence on whether investment in the program represents good value for money. This study assessed the cost and cost-effectiveness of HEP interventions to inform policy decisions for resource allocation and priority setting in Ethiopia. Methods Twenty-one health care interventions were selected under the hygiene and sanitation, family health services, and disease prevention and control sub-domains. The ingredient bottom-up and top-down costing method was employed. Cost and cost-effectiveness were assessed from the provider perspective. Health outcomes were measured using life years gained (LYG). Incremental cost per LYG in relation to the gross domestic product (GDP) per capita of Ethiopia (US$852.80) was used to ascertain the cost-effectiveness. All costs were collected in Ethiopian birr and converted to United States dollars (US$) using the average exchange rate for 2018 (US$1 = 27.67 birr). Both costs and health outcomes were discounted by 3 Result The average unit cost of providing selected hygiene and sanitation, family health, and disease prevention and control services with the HEP was US$0.70, US$4.90, and US$7.40, respectively. The major cost driver was drugs and supplies, accounting for 53% and 68%, respectively, of the total cost. The average annual cost of delivering all the selected interventions was US$9,897. All interventions fall within 1 times GDP per capita per LYG, indicating that they are very cost-effective (ranges: US$22–$295 per LYG). Overall, the HEP is cost-effective by investing US$77.40 for every LYG. Conclusion The unit cost estimates of HEP interventions are crucial for priority-setting, resource mobilization, and program planning. This study found that the program is very cost-effective in delivering community health services.publishedVersio

Immunization data quality and factors influencing data generation, handling and use in Wogera District, Northern Ethiopia, 2020

Abstract Background: Data quality is a vital metric in health information systems to ascertain improved health of individuals and community as well. Immunization data are critical inputs in assessing national performance of expanded program on immunization and child health improvement. Inconsistent health data happens when variations arise in the report and re-count from the source documents. Aim: This study aimed to assess immunization data quality and factors influencing data generation, handling, and use. Methods: Both qualitative and quantitative data were used. Immunization recording and reporting documents were reviewed at 41 health facilities of primary health care units. Twenty health workforces were interviewed on healthcare data quality, generation, handling, and use. The Statistical Package for the Social Sciences (SPSS) for windows version 26 was used to perform quantitative data analysis and open code version 4.02 was used for qualitative data analysis. Data accuracy was presented using mean and standard deviation of data verification factor. Results: Over-reporting of immunization data elements was observed. The highest accuracy (75%) was reported for full immunization at health center level followed by 62.5% for measles. The difference between verification factor of ideal reports and observed values, indicates that there is over reporting in all immunization data elements by 44% (27-61%), 46% (=31-61%), 40% (12-61%), 37% (11-63%), and 38% (12-64%) in BCG, Penta 1, Penta 3, measles, and full immunization, respectively. Supervision, availability of recording and reporting tools, training, motivation, attitudes towards healthcare data, hard to reach areas and manual documentation were influencing factors of immunization data quality, generation, handling, and use. Conclusion: The study revealed that health facilities over-reported immunization data elements in primary health care units. Attentions should be given to address organization, behavioral, technical, and contextual factors influencing immunization data quality, generation, handling, and use. [Ethiop. J. Health Dev. 2021; 35(SI-3):56-64] Keywords: Immunization data quality, Factors influencing, Verification factor, Wogera distric

Continuum of maternity care among rural women in Ethiopia: does place and frequency of antenatal care visit matter?

IntroductionThe ministry of health (MOH) of Ethiopia recommends 4 or more focused antenatal care (ANC) visits at health centre (HC) or at a higher level of health facility (HF). In Ethiopia, few studies investigated time dimension of maternal health continuum of care but lack data regarding place dimension and its effect on continuum of care. The aim of this study is to estimate effect of place of ANC-1 visit and adherence to MOH's recommendations of MOH for ANC visits on continuum of care rural in Ethiopia.MethodsWe used data collected from 1431 eligible women included in the National Health Extension Program (HEP) assessment survey that covered 6324 households from 62 woredas in nine regions. The main outcome variable is continuum of care (CoC), which is the uptake of all recommended ANC visits, institutional delivery and postnatal care services. Following descriptive analysis, Propensity Score Matching was used to estimate the effect of place of ANC-1 visit on completion of CoC. Zero inflated Poisson regression was used to model the effect of adherence to MOH recommendation of ANC visits on intensity of maternal health continuum of care.ResultOnly 13.9% of eligible women completed the continuum of care, and place of first antenatal care (ANC) visit was not significantly associated with the completion of continuum of care (β = 0.04, 95% CI = -0.02, 0.09). Adherence of ANC visit to the MOH recommendation (at least 4 ANC visits at higher HFs than health posts (HPs)) increased the likelihood of higher intensity of continuum of care (aIRR = 1.29, 95% CI: 1.26, 1.33). Moreover, the intensity of continuum of care was positively associated with being in agrarian areas (aIRR = 1.17, 95% CI: 1.06, 1.29), exposed to HEP (IRR = 1.22, 95% CI: 1.16, 1.28), being informed about danger signs (aIRR = 1.14, 95% CI: 1.11, 1.18) and delivery of second youngest child at HF (IRR = 1.16, 95% CI: 1.13, 1.20). Increasing age of women was negatively associated with use of services (IRR = 0.90, 95% CI: 0.87, 0.94).ConclusionCompletion of maternal health continuum of care is very low in Ethiopia, however most of the women use at least one of the services. Completion of continuum of care was not affected by place of first ANC visit. Adherence to MOH recommendation of ANC visit increased the intensity of continuum of care. Intensity of continuum of care was positively associated with residing in agrarian areas, HEP exposure, danger sign told, delivery of second youngest child at health facility. To boost the uptake of all maternal health services, it is crucial to work on quality of health facilities, upgrading the infrastructures of HPs and promoting adherence to MOH recommendations of ANC visit

The Implementation of Social and Behavior Change Communication Intervention to Improve Immunization Demand: A qualitative study in Awabel District, Northwest Ethiopia

AbstractBackground: Immunization coverage in Ethiopia is low, and dropout rates are high. Social Behavior Change Communication (SBCC) interventions were introduced as a means of combating the ‘demand-side’ immunization barriers. However, Little research exists in terms of the efficacy of the SBCC intervention, in terms of promoting uptake, and improving the immunization demands in Ethiopia.Aim: To explore the current implementation status, and perceived effectiveness of SBCC intervention, barriers and facilitators with new strategies aimed at effective implementation of the SBCC intervention in Awabel District, Northwest Ethiopia.Methods: A phenomenological qualitative study was conducted from January 1- October 31, 2020. In-dept interviews were conducted with fifteen key-informants using a piloted semi-structured interview guide. Participants were purposively selected, which comprised of mangers, Expanded Program of Immunization (EPI) focal personnel, Health Extension Workers (HEWs), Women Development Armies (WDAs), mothers and community representatives. Six vaccination sessions were observed. Coding was done to identify patterns. Thematic analysis was performed using Open Code 4. 02.Results: Interpersonal communication, community conversation, social mobilization and family modeling were used as SBCC approaches. HEWs were the key source of information. Religious leaders were among the major stakeholders that encourage immunization. SBCC was perceived as an effective measure to improve immunization demand. There were multiple barriers for implementation of SBCC interventions including limited resources, lack of awareness, geographic barriers, traditional beliefs, lack of incentives, and limited EPI staff and health facility operating hours. Engagement of fathers and religious leaders, strengthening the WDA, and allocation of more resources were listed as possible strategies to tackle barriers.Conclusion: The implementation of SBCC interventions is important to improve immunization demand. Despite its effectiveness, there are several multi-level barriers to its successful implementation. Further, greater investments are required to improve infrastructures, staff employment and capacity building. [Ethiop. J. Health Dev. 2021; 35(SI-3):49-55]Keywords: Immunization, SBCC, Ethiopi

Women's Independent Household Decision Making Power and its influence on their Autonomy in relation to Child Vaccinations: a mixed-method study among Women of Reproductive Age in Northwest Ethiopia

AbstractBackground: The importance of women’s empowerment in influencing health outcomes has received attention globally, but there is limited information in Ethiopia on the relationship between women's household decision making power and the autonomy of decision making in relation to child vaccinations.Aim: The study aimed to assess the role of women's household decision making power on their autonomy in relation to child vaccinations.Methods: A community based mixed method study design was conducted among women who had 12–23-month-old children in Wogera district, Ethiopia. The sample size was determined using a single population proportion formula for the quantitative aspect of the study and the data collection for the qualitative study continued until saturation. The quantitative data was collected using a piloted questionnaire. SPSS software was used for quantitative data analyses. X2-square test was conducted to explore the association between women's household decision making power and their autonomy in relation to decision making around child vaccinations. Framework analysis was employed to analyse qualitative data using open code software.Results: A total of 584 women participated in the quantitative study and 13 In-depth interviews (IDI) with 13 key informants (KII)were conducted for the qualitative study. Majority, 88.2% (95% CI: 85.7, 90.6) of the respondents have autonomy to vaccinate children. This study showed that nearly two-thirds, 61.6% of the women had household decision making power. Respondents of the qualitative study noted that women had low household decision making power. Women's household decision making power is associated with women's autonomy to vaccinate children (x2=92.775a, df=1, P<0.001).Conclusions: The overall level of women’s household decision making power was relatively low compared to EDHS reports whereas women's autonomy to chid vaccination was high. There was a strong relationship between women’s household decision making power and their autonomy in relation to child vaccinations. It is therefore important to implement activities, for example, provision of behavioural change communication (BCC) in the community, that can improve women’s household decision making power which in turn will influence child vaccination coverage. [Ethiop. J. Health Dev. 2021; 35(SI-3):86-97]Key words: Women, Household decision making power, Women's autonomy, Vaccinatio

Full immunization coverage and its determinants among children aged 12-23 months in Wogera district, Northwest Ethiopia

AbstractBackground: Immunization is considered one of the most affordable health initiatives for children. Though there is good progress in Ethiopia, the amount of fully vaccinated children, is still below the target. Possible challenges include women having home visits and men’s’ involvement in vaccination uptake. Therefore, this study aimed to determine full immunization coverage and its determinants among children aged 12- 23 months in Wogera districts, Northwest Ethiopia.Aim: This study aimed to determine the full immunization coverage and its determinants among children aged 12-23 months, and to assess the level of immunization coverage and its determinants in Wogera districts, Northwest Ethiopia.Methods: A community-based cross-sectional study was conducted in Wogera district from May 28-June 25/2020. Cluster sampling method was used to recruit 598 study participants. Interviewer administered questionnaire was used to collect data. A bivariable and multivariable logistic regression analysis was done to identify factors associated with full immunization. Odds ratios with 95% Confidence intervals were used to determine significant variables.Results: A total of 584 mothers who had children aged 12-23 months participated in this study. The full immunization coverage was 76.5% (95%CI 73.2-79.8). Mother age >40 years (AOR=7.37, 95% CI: 1.65, 32); mothers who initiate vaccine uptake(woman empowerment) (AOR=1.57, 95% CI: 1.13-2.39); mothers who had 1-3 ANC visit (AOR=2.51, 95% CI:1.14, 5.52), and 4+ ANC follow up (AOR=2.73,95% CI: 1.26, 5.91); r health extension worker's home visit during the first weeks of postpartum period (AOR=1.76,95% CI:1.10, 2.84), and males involved in child immunization (AOR=3.27, 95% CI:1.84, 5.81) was positively associated with being fully vaccinated , however, birth order of 6 and above (AOR=0.35, 95% CI: 0.14, 0.86) was negatively associated with being fully vaccinated.Conclusion: In this study, the full immunization coverage is found to be suboptimal, and it is far from the expected national target coverage. Maternal health care uptake; women empowerment; home visits by HEW during the first week of the postpartum period and male involvement in child immunization were found to be predictors of being fully vaccinated. [Ethiop. J. Health Dev. 2021; 35(SI-3):16-27]Keywords: Full immunization, Children12-23 months, Northwest Ethiopia, Male involvemen

COVID-19 Vaccine Hesitancy and its Reasons in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia: A Cross-Sectional Study

BACKGROUND: Coronavirus disease (COVID-19) vaccine hesitancy becomes the major bottleneck to the global healthcare system in minimizing the spread of the virus. This study aimed at assessing COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy and its reasons among residents of Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. METHODS:  A community-based cross-sectional survey was conducted between May 16 to 29, 2021 in purposively selected four districts of Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. A structured questionnaire was developed and then designed on Google Forms platforms to collect data from study participants after obtaining a verbal consent form. A total of 422 study participants were included in the survey. Data were entered into Microsoft Excel and then exported to the Statistical Package for the Social Sciences (SPSS) version 25 for analysis.  RESULTS: Face masks and alcohol hand rub/ sanitizer are used by 50. 7 and 24.9% of respondents when required. COVID-19 was thought to have been generated by humans by a substantial percentage of study participants (38.2%). About half (50.7%) and 24.9% of respondents use face masks and alcohol hand rub/sanitizer always when it is required, respectively. A large number of study participants (38.2%) believed that origin of COVID-19 is man-made. Overall, 242 (57.4%) of study participants reported COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy. Fear of vaccine side effects (49.6%) was the most common reason for hesitancy. Doubt about its effectiveness (33.9%), not having enough information about the COVID-19 vaccine, preferring another way of protection, and unreliable of the vaccine (due to its short development period) were also the most frequently mentioned reasons for not receiving the COVID-19 vaccine. CONCLUSIONS: COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy rate was high in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia during the study period. Fear of side effects, doubts about its effectiveness, and not having enough information about the COVID-19 vaccine were major reasons for hesitancy. Continuous awareness creation to the community on the importance of vaccination is warranted by health professionals and healthcare cadres

Strategies to revitalize immunization service provision in urban settings of Ethiopia

AbstractBackground: Improving routine immunization in the urban population is an essential element to address immunization coverage and equity. In rural areas, deliberate efforts are made to reach the populations using adapted strategies such as outreaches while specificities of urban populations are generally not considered in immunization programs of Ethiopia.Aim: To explore the barriers and alternative strategies for immunization service provision in urban settings of Ethiopia.Methods: A qualitative study with a phenomenological study design was conducted in selected cities of Addis Ababa, Dire Dawa and Mekele from June to August 2020. Data was collected at different levels of the health system and the community by using a piloted interview guide. Thirty-five key informants and nine in-depth interviews were conducted. Audio-records of interviews were transcribed verbatim, coded and thematic analysis was performed using Open code version 4.02. software.Results: Our finding revealed that the routine immunization service provision strategy in Addis Ababa, Dire Dawa and Mekele cities was a static approach. Service inaccessibility, poor defaulter tracking mechanisms, substandard service in private facilities, shortage of supplies, and lack of training were the main barriers. We explored alternative strategies to revitalize the Expanded Program on Immunization (EPI) including, expanding services to marginalized populations, outreach/home to home service provision, expanding services to private health facilities, and inter-facility linkage through digitalization.Conclusions: The existing immunization service provision strategies in urban settings are not adequate to reach all children. Immunization service inaccessibility and substandard services were the main barriers hindering service provision. Program managers should expand routine service access to marginalized populations through outreach services, by strengthening the public-private partnership, and integrating technological innovations (like digitalization of the EPI program and application of mHealth reminders) to facilitate inter-facility linkage. [Ethiop. J. Health Dev. 2021; 35(SI-3):98-110]Keywords: Immunization, Vaccination, Urban, Revitalize, Private Facility, Ethiopi