Emergent Surgical Reduction and Fixation for Pipkin Type I Femoral Fractures

Nanjing Military Region [10MA073]The purpose of this study was to assess the effect of timing of large fragment fixation in patients with Pipkin type-I fractures. Patients with Pipkin type-I fractures from the authors' trauma center were prospectively observed between July 2007 and July 2010. Fragments that constituted more than one-fourth of the femoral head were included. Thirty-six patients were equally randomized to undergo emergent surgical reduction and fixation or secondary operative fixation after emergent closed reduction. No significant differences existed between the 2 groups with regard to the baseline characteristics, operating time, and blood loss (P>.05). However, the emergent surgical reduction and fixation group had a shorter hospital stay (P<.05). The results after more than 2-year follow-up showed that the complication and avascular necrosis rates were higher in the secondary operative fixation after emergent closed reduction group compared with the emergent surgical reduction and fixation group (P<.05). It was difficult to achieve an anatomically reduced femoral head when the fragments constituted more than one-fourth of the femoral head. Patients who underwent secondary operative fixation after emergent closed reduction had a high avascular necrosis rate and a relatively poor outcome. Emergent surgical reduction and fixation should be performed shortly after injury to enhance the treatment outcome