Reduction of anti-malarial consumption after rapid diagnostic tests implementation in Dar es Salaam: a before-after and cluster randomized controlled study

ABSTRACT: BACKGROUND: Presumptive treatment of all febrile patients with anti-malarials leads to massive over-treatment. The aim was to assess the effect of implementing malaria rapid diagnostic tests (mRDTs) on prescription of anti-malarials in urban Tanzania. METHODS: The design was a prospective collection of routine statistics from ledger books and cross-sectional surveys before and after intervention in randomly selected health facilities (HF) in Dar es Salaam, Tanzania. The participants were all clinicians and their patients in the above health facilities. The intervention consisted of training and introduction of mRDTs in all three hospitals and in six HF. Three HF without mRDTs were selected as matched controls. The use of routine mRDT and treatment upon result was advised for all patients complaining of fever, including children under five years of age. The main outcome measures were: (1) anti-malarial consumption recorded from routine statistics in ledger books of all HF before and after intervention; (2) anti-malarial prescription recorded during observed consultations in cross-sectional surveys conducted in all HF before and 18 months after mRDT implementation. RESULTS: Based on routine statistics, the amount of artemether-lumefantrine blisters used post-intervention was reduced by 68% (95%CI 57-80) in intervention and 32% (9-54) in control HF. For quinine vials, the reduction was 63% (54-72) in intervention and an increase of 2.49 times (1.62-3.35) in control HF. Before-and-after cross-sectional surveys showed a similar decrease from 75% to 20% in the proportion of patients receiving anti-malarial treatment (Risk ratio 0.23, 95%CI 0.20-0.26). The cluster randomized analysis showed a considerable difference of anti-malarial prescription between intervention HF (22%) and control HF (60%) (Risk ratio 0.30, 95%CI 0.14-0.70). Adherence to test result was excellent since only 7% of negative patients received an anti-malarial. However, antibiotic prescription increased from 49% before to 72% after intervention (Risk ratio 1.47, 95%CI 1.37-1.59). CONCLUSIONS: Programmatic implementation of mRDTs in a moderately endemic area reduced drastically over-treatment with anti-malarials. Properly trained clinicians with adequate support complied with the recommendation of not treating patients with negative results. Implementation of mRDT should be integrated hand-in-hand with training on the management of other causes of fever to prevent irrational use of antibiotic

Specific detection of schistosoma DNA in stool and urine samples illustrates shortcomings of microscopy in population based surveys

Host-parasite interactio

Prevalence of respiratory viruses among febrile children with or without acute respiratory symptoms in Tanzania

Background Respiratory viruses are the most frequent cause of febrile illnesses in infants and young children but few investigations have assessed their impact and epidemiology in Africa . We investigated their rate in febrile outpatient children attending in Tanzania. Methods Children aged 2 months -10 years with fever >38 _C were recruited prospectively between April and December 2008. Medical history and clinical examination were recorded in a standardized fashion and nasopharyngeal swabs analyzed for the presence of 12 viruses by real-time PCR (FLUAV, FLUBV, RSV, MPV, HPIV-1/3, four types of HCoV, HBoV, PIC and HAdV). Ct values were used to provide semi-quantitative viral loads.Results Of 1005 febrile children enrolled, 623 (62%) had respiratory symptoms (URTI in 66%, bronchiolitis in 7% and clinical pneumonia in 27%); 156 (16%) had febrile illness that remained of unspecified etiology and 226 (22%) had other infectious diseases and no ARI (62 malaria, 56 gastroenteritis, 36 urinary tract and 72 others). The proportions of patients with at least one respiratory virus were 70%, 61% and 47% (Pvalue < 0.001) in these three groups. When excluding picornavirus and adenovirus these proportions were 48%, 24% and 26% (P-value < 0.001). Apart from picornavirus and adenovirus, influenza A and B viruses were the most frequent followed by coronavirus and RSV. The proportion of children with presumably high viral titers (Ct < 25) was higher in the group with respiratory symptoms (31%) than in the two other groups (21% and 16%). Influenza genotyping revealed strains that were similar to the ones circulating elsewhere in the world.Conclusion In African children with febrile illness, the prevalence of respiratory viruses, especially influenza A and B, is high particularly in the presence of respiratory symptoms, but also, although less so, in those with unspecified etiology or other infectious diseases. This highlights that these viruses are commonly circulating in Tanzanian children