Timely Long Tail Identification through Agent Based Monitoring and Analytics

The increasing complexity and scale of distributed systems has resulted in the manifestation of emergent behavior which substantially affects overall system performance. A significant emergent property is that of the "Long Tail", whereby a small proportion of task stragglers significantly impact job execution completion times. To mitigate such behavior, straggling tasks occurring within the system need to be accurately identified in a timely manner. However, current approaches focus on mitigation rather than identification, which typically identify stragglers too late in the execution lifecycle. This paper presents a method and tool to identify Long Tail behavior within distributed systems in a timely manner, through a combination of online and offline analytics. This is achieved through historical analysis to profile and model task execution patterns, which then inform online analytic agents that monitor task execution at runtime. Furthermore, we provide an empirical analysis of two large-scale production Cloud data enters that demonstrate the challenge of data skew within modern distributed systems, this analysis shows that approximately 5% of task stragglers caused by data skew impact 50% of the total jobs for batch processes. Our results demonstrate that our approach is capable of identifying task stragglers less than 11% into their execution lifecycle with 98% accuracy, signifying significant improvement over current state-of-the-art practice and enables far more effective mitigation strategies in large-scale distributed systems worldwide

An Approach for Modeling and Ranking Node-level Stragglers in Cloud Datacenters

The ability of servers to effectively execute tasks within Cloud datacenters varies due to heterogeneous CPU and memory capacities, resource contention situations, network configurations and operational age. Unexpectedly slow server nodes (node-level stragglers) result in assigned tasks becoming task-level stragglers, which dramatically impede parallel job execution. However, it is currently unknown how slow nodes directly correlate to task straggler manifestation. To address this knowledge gap, we propose a method for node performance modeling and ranking in Cloud datacenters based on analyzing parallel job execution tracelog data. By using a production Cloud system as a case study, we demonstrate how node execution performance is driven by temporal changes in node operation as opposed to node hardware capacity. Different sample sets have been filtered in order to evaluate the generality of our framework, and the analytic results demonstrate that node abilities of executing parallel tasks tend to follow a 3-parameter-loglogistic distribution. Further statistical attribute values such as confidence interval, quantile value, extreme case possibility, etc. can also be used for ranking and identifying potential straggler nodes within the cluster. We exploit a graph-based algorithm for partitioning server nodes into five levels, with 0.83% of node-level stragglers identified. Our work lays the foundation towards enhancing scheduling algorithms by avoiding slow nodes, reducing task straggler occurrence, and improving parallel job performance

Reducing Late-Timing Failure at Scale: Straggler Root-Cause Analysis in Cloud Datacenters

Task stragglers hinder effective parallel job execution in Cloud datacenters, resulting in late-timing failures due to the violation of specified timing constraints. Stragglertolerant methods such as speculative execution provide limited effectiveness due to (i) lack of precise straggler root-cause knowledge and (ii) straggler identification occurring too late within a job lifecycle. This paper proposes a method to ascertain underlying straggler root-causes by analyzing key parameters within large-scale distributed systems, and to determine the correlation between straggler occurrence and factors including resource contention, task concurrency, and server failures. Our preliminary study of a production Cloud datacenter indicates that the dominate straggler root-cause is resultant of high temporal resource contention. The result can assist in enhancing straggler prediction and mitigation for tolerating late-timing failures within large-scale distributed systems

Straggler Root-Cause and Impact Analysis for Massive-scale Virtualized Cloud Datacenters

Increased complexity and scale of virtualized distributed systems has resulted in the manifestation of emergent phenomena substantially affecting overall system performance. This phenomena is known as “Long Tail”, whereby a small proportion of task stragglers significantly impede job completion time. While work focuses on straggler detection and mitigation, there is limited work that empirically studies straggler root-cause and quantifies its impact upon system operation. Such analysis is critical to ascertain in-depth knowledge of straggler occurrence for focusing developmental and research efforts towards solving the Long Tail challenge. This paper provides an empirical analysis of straggler root-cause within virtualized Cloud datacenters; we analyze two large-scale production systems to quantify the frequency and impact stragglers impose, and propose a method for conducting root-cause analysis. Results demonstrate approximately 5% of task stragglers impact 50% of total jobs for batch processes, and 53% of stragglers occur due to high server resource utilization. We leverage these findings to propose a method for extreme straggler detection through a combination of offline execution patterns modeling and online analytic agents to monitor tasks at runtime. Experiments show the approach is capable of detecting stragglers less than 11% into their execution lifecycle with 95% accuracy for short duration jobs

Mitigate data skew caused stragglers through ImKP partition in MapReduce

Speculative execution is the mechanism adopted by current MapReduce framework when dealing with the straggler problem, and it functions through creating redundant copies for identified stragglers. The result of the quicker task will be adopted to improve the overall job execution performance. Although proved to be effective for contention caused stragglers, speculative execution can easily meet its bottleneck when mitigating data skew caused stragglers due to its replication nature: the identical unbalanced input data will lead to a slow speculative task. The Map inputs are typically even in size according to the HDFS block configuration, therefore the skew caused stragglers happen mainly in the Reduce phase because of the unknown intermediate key distribution. In this paper, we focus on mitigating data skew caused Reduce stragglers, propose ImKP, an Intermediate Key Pre-processing framework that enables the even distributed partition for Reduce inputs. A group based ranking technique has been developed that dramatically decreases the pre-processing time, and ImKP manages to eliminate this timing overhead through parallelizing the pre-processing with the file uploading procedure (from local file system to HDFS). For jobs that take input directly from HDFS, ImKP minimizes the overhead by storing the mapping result on every node within the cluster for reuse. Experiments are conducted on different datasets with various workloads. Results show that, compared to the popular hash partition, ImKP can dramatically decrease Reduce skew, achieving a 99.8% reduction in the coefficient of variation of the input sizes in average, and improve up to 29.37% job response performance

Adaptive Speculation for Efficient Internetware Application Execution in Clouds

Modern Cloud computing systems are massive in scale, featuring environments that can execute highly dynamic Internetware applications with huge numbers of interacting tasks. This has led to a substantial challenge the straggler problem, whereby a small subset of slow tasks significantly impede parallel job completion. This problem results in longer service responses, degraded system performance, and late timing failures that can easily threaten Quality of Service (QoS) compliance. Speculative execution (or speculation) is the prominent method deployed in Clouds to tolerate stragglers by creating task replicas at runtime. The method detects stragglers by specifying a predefined threshold to calculate the difference between individual tasks and the average task progression within a job. However, such a static threshold debilitates speculation effectiveness as it fails to capture the intrinsic diversity of timing constraints in Internetware applications, as well as dynamic environmental factors such as resource utilization. By considering such characteristics, different levels of strictness for replica creation can be imposed to adaptively achieve specified levels of QoS for different applications. In this paper we present an algorithm to improve the execution efficiency of Internetware applications by dynamically calculating the straggler threshold, considering key parameters including job QoS timing constraints, task execution progress, and optimal system resource utilization. We implement this dynamic straggler threshold into the YARN architecture to evaluate it’s effectiveness against existing state-of-the-art solutions. Results demonstrate that the proposed approach is capable of reducing parallel job response times by up to 20% compared to the static threshold, as well as a higher speculation success rate, achieving up to 66.67% against 16.67% in comparison to the static method

Intelligent Resource Scheduling at Scale: a Machine Learning Perspective

Resource scheduling in a computing system addresses the problem of packing tasks with multi-dimensional resource requirements and non-functional constraints. The exhibited heterogeneity of workload and server characteristics in Cloud-scale or Internet-scale systems is adding further complexity and new challenges to the problem. Compared with,,,, existing solutions based on ad-hoc heuristics, Machine Learning (ML) has the potential to improve further the efficiency of resource management in large-scale systems. In this paper we,,,, will describe and discuss how ML could be used to understand automatically both workloads and environments, and to help to cope with scheduling-related challenges such as consolidating co-located workloads, handling resource requests, guaranteeing application's QoSs, and mitigating tailed stragglers. We will introduce a generalized ML-based solution to large-scale resource scheduling and demonstrate its effectiveness through a case study that deals with performance-centric node classification and straggler mitigation. We believe that an MLbased method will help to achieve architectural optimization and efficiency improvement