To what extent do frameworks of reading development and the phonics screening check support the assessment of reading development in England?

The purpose of this article is to question the suitability of the phonics screening check in relation to models and theories of reading development. The article questions the appropriateness of the check by drawing on theoretical frameworks which underpin typical reading development. I examine the Simple View of Reading developed by Gough and Tunmer and Ehri’s model of reading development. The article argues that the assessment of children’s development in reading should be underpinned and informed by a developmental framework which identifies the sequential skills in reading development

Research issues in child development

First published in 1986, this authoritative book contains a selection of original, research based, reports of studies conducted in Australia and New Zealand in the field of Child Development. The topics have been arranged into four major sections - cognitive issues in development, language and reading development, perpetual motor development and social aspects of development. Both pure and applied research issues are presented, and the chapters cover child development from infancy to adolescence. The book's special strength lies in the diversity of topics tackled and the range of developmental research represented. Theoretical viewpoints are raised and empirical questions answered in the studies reported. The editors have systematically drawn together important contributions which reflected contemporary topics in child development at the time. Although no one common theoretical or empirical theme unites either each section or the whole book (which reflects the general scope and diversity of child development in the 1980s), the contributors in general see the child as developing through active interaction with his or her environment. This interactionist position is clearly preferred by most researchers, who realised that simplistic genetic or environmental models are inadequate to explain the complex development of the child. The editors were all active researchers in the area of child development at the time and each co-authored a chapter in the book. All published regularly in national and international journals and books, and were aware of current developments in their main areas of expertise. All those interested in issues in child development will find this book important reading, as it provides the reader with an excellent and diverse selection of studies, bearing on a wide range of empirical research

Dificuldades no desenvolvimento da lectoescrita: o papel das habilidades metalinguísticas

Este estudo investigou a relação entre habilidades metalingüísticas (consciência fonológica e sintática) e desempenho na leitura e na escrita (ortografia) de palavras isoladas. Foram formados três grupos de sujeitos: 20 crianças com dificuldades em leitura e escrita, cursando 3ª e 4ª séries (grupo 1); 20 crianças da 1ª série, com o mesmo nível de leitura e escrita dos sujeitos do grupo 1 (grupo 2) e 20 crianças da 3ª e 4ª séries, com a mesma idade cronológica dos sujeitos do grupo 1 (grupo 3). Esperava-se que o grupo 1 apresentasse escores inferiores nas habilidades metalingüísticas, quando comparado aos outros grupos. A hipótese foi confirmada apenas para os escores em consciência fonológica. Em relação à consciência sintática, não se observou diferença significativa entre os grupos 1 e 2, os quais tiveram um desempenho inferior ao do grupo 3. Os resultados mostraram que as dificuldades em leitura e escrita estão relacionadas predominantemente com problemas de natureza fonológica

'To be or not to be?': the politics of teaching phonics in England and New Zealand

There is currently intense national and international interest in which particular methods of teaching reading are the most effective for early literacy acquisition. The great bulk of research work that is cited in these debates, however, focuses almost exclusively on the evaluation and comparison of particular programmes underpinned either by phonics or whole language approaches (Soler and Openshaw, 2006). Despite the fact that policy makers and literacy educators around the world are able to draw upon a common body of literacy research, there is a huge variation in the extent to which phonics is adopted as the major programme in different national contexts. This article provides a comparative study of the widely differing reception accorded the teaching of phonics in England and New Zealand respectively