An American Advantage? How American and Swiss Criminal Defense Attorneys Evaluate Forensic DNA Evidence

AbstractCritics of the American system of justice sometimes perceive “inquisitorialism” as an attractive alternative. In this article we will report a comparative study investigating the way forensic DNA evidence is handled in criminal prosecutions in the Swiss and American systems, focusing particularly on the behavior of criminal defense lawyers. We will argue that the successes and failures of American and Swiss lawyers in this context offer important insights into the relative strengths and limitations of adversarial and non-adversarial legal systems

Les nouvelles lignes directrices du European Network of Forensic Sciences Institut en matière d’évaluation et de communication des résultats d’analyses et d’expertises scientifiques

Au printemps 2015, le European Network of Forensic Science Institutes a publié des lignes directrices visant à unifier les méthodes de travail des scientifiques agissant comme auxiliaires de la justice, plus précisément l’évaluation des résultats d’analyses scientifiques (logique du raisonnement) et la communication de ces résultats aux magistrats. Cette contribution a pour but d’expliciter ces lignes directrices et d’expliquer en quoi il est primordial que la justice suisse les adopte. — Im Frühjahr 2015 publizierte das ENFSI (European Network of Forensic Science Institutes) Leitlinien für die Vereinheitlichung wissenschaftlicher Arbeitsmethoden, insbesondere für Bewertung von wissenschaftlichen Untersuchungsergebnissen (Logik der Befundbewertung) und die Berichterstattung zuhanden der Justiz. Dieser Beitrag erläutert diese Richtlinien und erklärt, weshalb es wichtig ist, dass sie in die Schweizer Justizpraxis Eingang finden

After uniqueness: the evolution of forensic science opinions

Big changes are occurring in forensic science, particularly among experts who compare the patterns found in fingerprints, footwear impressions, toolmarks, handwriting, and the like. Forensic examiners are reaching conclusions in new ways and changing the language they use in reports and testimony. This article explains these changes and the challenges they pose for lawyers and judges

An American Advantage? How American and Swiss Criminal Defense Attorneys Evaluate Forensic DNA Evidence

Critics of the American system of justice sometimes perceive "inquisitorialism” as an attractive alternative. In this article we will report a comparative study investigating the way forensic DNA evidence is handled in criminal prosecutions in the Swiss and American systems, focusing particularly on the behavior of criminal defense lawyers. We will argue that the successes and failures of American and Swiss lawyers in this context offer important insights into the relative strengths and limitations of adversarial and non-adversarial legal systems

Critical collapse of a massive vector field

We perform numerical simulations of the critical gravitational collapse of a massive vector field. The result is that there are two critical solutions. One is equivalent to the Choptuik critical solution for a massless scalar field. The other is periodic.Comment: 7 pages, 4 figure