A contribution to dog ecology and dog-related zoonoses in Bamako, Mali

Zoonoses are diseases which are transmitted between vertebrate animals and humans. Neglected zoonoses are often endemic, under-reported, misdiagnosed and affect mostly poor and marginalised populations, which are living in close proximity to their animals. They cause enormous human suffering and death, contributing as well to significant economic losses as they often affect livestock. They do not rank as high priorities of governments and international public health communities, although frequently cures exist and control in the animal reservoirs is often highly cost effective. To date, very little is known about neglected canine zoonoses in West Africa, particularly in Mali. The main objectives of this PhD thesis were to assess baseline dog population dynamics and the epidemiology of dog-related zoonotic diseases, namely rabies, echinococcosis and leishmaniasis. A randomised cross-sectional Knowledge, Attitudes and Practices (KAP) study was conducted in about 3’000 households throughout Bamako. Additionally, biological samples were collected from dogs. Subsequent laboratory analysis included microscopic, immunodiagnostic and molecular methods. Following the baseline assessment study, the generated knowledge was used to test small scale interventions with two pilot rabies vaccination campaigns. These results contribute vital information towards planning effective and sustainable canine rabies control programmes in Mali

Low coverage of central point vaccination against dog rabies in Bamako, Mali

Canine rabies remains an important public-health problem in Africa. Dog mass vaccination is the recommended method for rabies control and elimination. We report on the first small-scale mass dog vaccination campaign trial in Bamako, Mali. Our objective was to estimate coverage of the vaccination campaign and to quantify determinants of intervention effectiveness. In September 2013, a central point vaccination campaign - free of cost for dog owners - was carried out in 17 posts on three consecutive days within Bamako's Commune 1. Vaccination coverage and the proportion of ownerless dogs were estimated by combining mark-recapture household and transect surveys using Bayesian modeling. The estimated vaccination coverage was 17.6% (95% Credibility Interval, CI: 14.4-22.1%) which is far below the World Health Organization (WHO) recommended vaccination coverage of 70%. The Bayesian estimate for the owned dog population of Commune 1 was 3459 dogs (95% CI: 2786-4131) and the proportion of ownerless dogs was about 8%. The low coverage observed is primarily attributed to low participation by dog owners. Dog owners reported several reasons for not bringing their dogs to the vaccination posts. The most frequently reported reasons for non-attendance were lack of information (25%) and the inability to handle the dog (16%). For 37% of respondents, no clear reason was given for non-vaccination. Despite low coverage, the vaccination campaign in Bamako was relatively easy to implement, both in terms of logistics and organization. Almost half of the participating dog owners brought their pets on the first day of the campaign. Participatory stakeholder processes involving communities and local authorities are needed to identify effective communication channels and locally adapted vaccination strategies, which could include both central-point and door-to-door vaccination

The contribution of livestock to urban resilience: the case of Bamako, Mali

Urban livestock keeping is increasing in many sub-Saharan African cities, but detailed contextual information on its extent, challenges, and potential is limited. A cross-sectional household study was done in 2010 in Bamako, Mali. Thirty-two of 67 quarters were randomly selected with selection probability proportional to the size of the human population of the communes. Questionnaire interviews were done with a head of household in 1141 households, comprising 19,816 people in total. Sheep were kept by 16% (95% CI 14-18), while 21% (95% CI 17-24) kept poultry. The sheep to human ratio was 4:100, with an extrapolated city-wide population of 67,636 sheep (95% CI 61,018-75,595). The poultry to human ratio was 11:100, with an extrapolated city-wide population of 191,802 chickens (95% CI 176,212-208,772). For urban livestock holders, household-level enterprise gross margins were calculated for sheep production at USD 103 and poultry production at USD 50 annually. The annual gross margin was estimated at USD 35 per sheep and USD 17 per chicken. Based on these figures, the city-wide urban livestock total gross margin for Bamako in 2010 was estimated at USD 5.6 million. Detailed population data help clarify the urban livestock animal human interface in diverse contexts and highlight the important contributions that urban small-holder production adds to food security and resilience. The potential for urban livestock production informs decision-makers in developing adapted, sustainable policies in resource-constrained environments

Rabies surveillance-response in Mali in the past 18 years and requirements for the future

Rabies is endemic in Mali, but little is known about the distribution of rabies and its surveillance across the country. Documenting the evolution of rabies and the problems related to surveillance is useful to facilitate elimination of human rabies by 2030.; Data collected at the Central Veterinary Laboratory (LCV) from 1999 to 2017 and through the surveillance system functioning at household, health and veterinary structure levels, as established by the Global Vaccine Alliance funded project on the burden of rabies, between 2016 and 2017 in Bamako and the Sikasso region were used in this study. All data on animals examined for rabies by the direct fluorescence antibody test (DFA) during the specified time period were summarized, and the proportion of rabies positive tested among animals suspected of rabies was estimated. From the number of dogs tested positive for rabies, a cumulative incidence was estimated for the total canine population. The number of positive tested samples was divided by the product of the estimated canine population and number of years (18). In addition, the number of human rabies cases was analyzed to estimate a cumulative incidence.; Among all animal samples suspected for rabies, 93.2% [95% CI 90.6-95.3] were positive by the DFA test. From the 486 included animal samples, 94.7% [95% CI 92.3-96.5] were domestic dogs with 90.9% [95% CI 87.9-93.3] positive, which stands out as the main reservoir of rabies in Mali. Cats, cattle, sheep and donkeys also tested positive using the DFA test. The cumulative incidence of canine rabies was estimated at 0.371 [95% CI: 0.336-0.408] / 10'000 dogs. The highest incidence was observed in Bamako, the capital of Mali, with a cumulative incidence of 2.242 [95% CI: 2.001-2.504] / 10'000 dogs, followed by Koulikoro with 0.335 [95% CI: 0.258-0.429] / 10'000 dogs. For other areas far from LCV, the cumulative incidence was low, with zero in Kidal. Nationally reported cases of human rabies declined in recent years with an average of 12.6 [95% CI: 8.7-16.5] deaths per year. This result gives an annual incidence of 0.1047 [0.0742-0.1352] / 100'000 inhabitants.; Over the past 18 years, rabies is endemically stable in Mali despite the decrease in reported human cases. The disparity among regions in number of samples tested indicates a low level of clinical and laboratory surveillance and likely a high level of underreporting. Dogs play the main role in rabies transmission in Mali. Monitoring of and decisions for post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) includes other animals (cats, cattle, and monkeys) involved in transmission. Mali should develop a national rabies strategy to include better communication between the public health and animal health sectors, strengthening of laboratory surveillance capacity, mass vaccination of dogs and guaranteed access to PEP

Molecular characterization of canine rabies virus, Mali, 2006-2013

We genetically characterized 32 canine rabies viruses isolated in Mali during 2006-2013 and identified 3 subgroups that belonged to the Africa 2 lineage. We also detected subgroup F rabies virus. This information should be useful for development of mass vaccination campaigns for dogs and eventual large-scale control programs in this country