Challenges in assessing and managing multi-hazard risks: a European stakeholders perspective

The latest evidence suggests that multi-hazards and their interrelationships (e.g., triggering, compound, and consecutive hazards) are becoming more frequent across Europe, underlying a need for resilience building by moving from single-hazard-focused to multi-hazard risk assessment and management. Although significant advancements were made in our understanding of these events, mainstream practice is still focused on risks due to single hazards (e.g., flooding, earthquakes, droughts), with a limited understanding of the stakeholder needs on the ground. To overcome this limitation, this paper sets out to understand the challenges for moving towards multi-hazard risk management through the perspective of European stakeholders. Based on five workshops across different European pilots (Danube Region, Veneto Region, Scandinavia, North Sea, and Canary Islands) and an expert workshop, we identify five prime challenges: i) governance, ii) knowledge of multi-hazards and multi-risks, iii) existing approaches to disaster risk management, iv) translation of science to policy and practice, and v) lack of data. These challenges are inherently linked and cannot be tackled in isolation with path dependency posing a significant hurdle in transitioning from single- to multi-hazard risk management. Going forward, we identify promising approaches for overcoming some of the challenges, including emerging approaches for multi-hazard characterisation, a common understanding of terminology, and a comprehensive framework for guiding multi-hazard risk assessment and management. We argue for a need to think beyond natural hazards and include other threats in creating a comprehensive overview of multi-hazard risks, as well as promoting thinking of multi-hazard risk reduction in the context of larger development goals

D1.2 Handbook of multi-hazard, multi-risk definitions and concepts

This report is the first output of Work Package 1: Diagnosis of the MYRIAD-EU project: Handbook of Multi-hazard, Multi-Risk Definitions and Concepts. The aim of the task was to (i) acknowledge the differences and promote consistency in understanding across subsequent work packages in the MYRIAD-EU project, (ii) improve the accessibility of our work to a broad array of stakeholders and (iii) strengthen consensus across the hazard and risk community through a common understanding of multi-hazard, multi-risk terminology and concepts. The work encompassed a mixed-methods approach, including internal consultations and data-generating exercises; literature reviews; external stakeholder engagement; adopting and building on a rich existing body of established glossaries. 140 terms are included in the glossary, 102 related to multi-hazard, multi-risk, disaster risk management and an additional 38 due to their relevance to the project, acknowledging the need for a common understanding amongst an interdisciplinary project consortium. We also include extended definitions related to concepts particularly of relevance to this project deliverable, including ‘multi-hazard’, ‘hazard interrelationships’, ‘multi-risk’ and ‘direct and indirect loss and risk’. Underpinned by a literature review and internal consultation, we include a specific section on indicators, how these might be applied within a multi-hazard and multi-risk context, and how existing indicators could be adapted to consider multi-risk management. We emphasise that there are a number of established glossaries that the project (and risk community) should make use of to strengthen the impact of the work we do, noting in our literature review a tendency in papers and reports to define words afresh. We conclude the report with a selection of key observations, including terminology matters – for all aspects of disaster risk management, for example communication, data collection, measuring progress and reporting against Sendai Framework targets. At the same time, we discuss when is it helpful to include ‘multi-‘ as a prefix, questioning whether part of the paradigm shift needed to successfully address complex challenges facing an interconnected world is through inherently seeing vulnerability, exposure and disaster risk through the lens of multiple, interrelated hazards. We emphasise that there is likely to be an evolution of the terminology throughout the project lifetime as terms are emerge or shift as the project evolves. Finally, we propose a roadmap for developing and testing draft multi-risk indicators in MYRIAD-EU. The WP1 team would like to acknowledge all the contributions of the consortium on this task and the feedback from the External Advisory Board, in particular the chair of the board Virginia Murray, Head of Global Disaster Risk Reduction at the UK Health Security Agency, and the contribution of Jenty Kirsch-Wood, Head of Global Risk Management and Reporting at UNDRR, for her reflections on the findings of this work

Middle East - North Africa and the millennium development goals : implications for German development cooperation

          Closed-loop controlled combustion is a promising technique to improve the overall performance of internal combustion engines and Diesel engines in particular. In order for this technique to be implemented some form of feedback from the combustion process is required. The feedback signal is processed and from it combustionrelated parameters are computed. These parameters are then fed to a control process which drives a series of outputs (e.g. injection timing in Diesel engines) to control their values. This paper’s focus lies on the processing and computation that is needed on the feedback signal before this is ready to be fed to the control process as well as on the electronics necessary to support it. A number of feedback alternatives are briefly discussed and for one of them, the in-cylinder pressure sensor, the CA50 (crank angle in which the integrated heat release curve reaches its 50% value) and the IMEP (Indicated Mean Effective Pressure) are identified as two potential control variables. The hardware architecture of a system capable of calculating both of them on-line is proposed and necessary feasibility size and speed considerations are made by implementing critical blocks in VHDL targeting a flash-based Actel ProASIC3 automotive-grade FPGA

Heavy Metal Recoverability Of MSWI Fly Ashes Along The Flue Gas Cooling Path

Each year, around 75’000t of fly ash from municipal solid waste incineration (MSWI fly ash) are produced and deposited on landfills in Switzerland. MSWI fly ash consists of boiler- and electrostatic precipitator ash and contains significant concentrations of heavy metals (e.g., Zn, Cu, Cd, Pb, Sb). From the year 2026 onwards, it will be mandatory to treat Swiss MSWI fly ashes with acid leaching in order to recover the heavy metals prior to deposition. However, it has not yet been legally determined whether the boiler ash is to be treated as fly ash. It could also be treated and deposited together with the bottom ash. Currently, the data available for boiler ashes are very limited, and their metal recovery potential has not been fully explored. Therefore, detailed chemical and mineralogical characterization was performed on the different MSWI ashes that form along the flue gas path (empty pass-ash (EA), boiler ashes (BOA) and electrostatic precipitator ash (ESPA)). Using a broad combination of methods (XRF, XRD, SEM), the ashes from six Swiss MSWI plants were characterized with respect to the chemical and mineralogical composition of major- and minor phases. Important parameters to estimate the suitability of a treatment are the contents of recoverable heavy metals and the extractability of the ashes. The focus was therefore laid on matrix phases affecting leachability (e.g. alkalinity, oxidation-reduction potential), as well as on the distribution and concentration of recoverable heavy metals and their binding forms. In order to estimate the need for metal recovery before landfilling, the contents of non-mobilizable pollutants such as Sb was also recorded along the flue gas path. EA and BOA showed comparable bulk chemical and mineralogical composition and are composed of two significantly different materials: the airborne ash particles (quenched melt droplets and refractory particles) and deposits formed on heat exchanger surfaces. It is mainly the deposits that contribute to the elevated heavy metal concentration, explained by the well-developed, large (Na,K)-PbSO4 crystals and the Zn-bearing matrix sulfates. The variation in the amount and chemical composition of the deposits controls the fluctuations in the bulk composition of EA and BOA. The ESPA shows different chemical and mineralogical characteristics than EA and BOA. The ESPA is enriched in the more volatile metals Zn, Pb, Cu, Cd; which are mainly present as chlorides and sulfates. The high content of salt-bound and thus easily soluble heavy metals together with the lower alkalinity and oxidation-reduction potential indicates, that ESPA has a better leachability compared to EA and BOA. These observations suggest that individual treatment of ESPA has higher potential for heavy metal recovery. Comparing the EA and BOA, however, no significant differences could be found in the parameters affecting extractability. The obtained results provide important insights into the formation of the different ash fractions and its geochemical characteristics. The data may serve as basis for re-evaluating disposal routes of ash fractions with poor extraction properties

Chemical associations and mobilization of heavy metals in fly ash from municipal solid waste incineration

This study focusses on chemical and mineralogical characterization of fly ash and leached filter cake and on the determination of parameters influencing metal mobilization by leaching. Three different leaching processes of fly ash from municipal solid waste incineration (MSWI) plants in Switzerland comprise neutral, acidic and optimized acidic (+ oxidizing agent) fly ash leaching have been investigated. Fly ash is characterized by refractory particles (Al-foil, unburnt carbon, quartz, feldspar) and newly formed high-temperature phases (glass, gehlenite, wollastonite) surrounded by characteristic dust rims. Metals are carried along with the flue gas (Fe-oxides, brass) and are enriched in mineral aggregates (quartz, feldspar, wollastonite, glass) or vaporized and condensed as chlorides or sulphates. Parameters controlling the mobilization of neutral and acidic fly ash leaching are pH and redox conditions, liquid to solid ratio, extraction time and temperature. Almost no depletion for Zn, Pb, Cu and Cd is achieved by performing neutral leaching. Acidic fly ash leaching results in depletion factors of 40% for Zn, 53% for Cd, 8% for Pb and 6% for Cu. The extraction of Pb and Cu are mainly limited due to a cementation process and the formation of a PbCu0-alloy-phase and to a minor degree due to secondary precipitation (PbCl2). The addition of hydrogen peroxide during acidic fly ash leaching (optimized acidic leaching) prevents this reduction through oxidation of metallic components and thus significantly higher depletion factors for Pb (57%), Cu (30%) and Cd (92%) are achieved. The elevated metal depletion using acidic leaching in combination with hydrogen peroxide justifies the extra effort not only by reduced metal loads to the environment but also by reduced deposition costs

HEX, PAX-8 and TTF-1 gene expression in human thyroid tissues: a comparative analysis with other genes involved in iodide metabolism

Objective Benign and malignant thyroid tumours are characterized by alterations of the expression level of thyroid-specific genes involved in the iodide metabolism. Imbalance in the levels of transcription factors has been recognized as a critical molecular event in the development of neoplasm. The delineation of eventual correlations existing between the expression of transcription factors and of putative target genes in physiological and pathological conditions could be relevant to better understand tumorigenesis. Patients and methods We examined the expression levels of transcription factors involved in thyroid development [thyroid transcription factor 1 (TTF-1), paired box gene 8 (PAX-8) and haematopoietically expressed homeobox (HEX)] in 101 thyroid tissues, including 14 normal thyroid tissues, 13 hyperfunctioning tissues, 27 benign adenomas and 47 follicular or papillary carcinomas. Then, we compared their expression levels with those of thyroid-specific genes involved in iodide metabolism. Results In benign tumours, PAX-8 and TTF-1 gene expression levels were not significantly different from the expression levels in normal tissues. However, a significant decrease was found in carcinomas. Interestingly, HEX gene expression was significantly decreased in both hyper- and hypofunctioning benign tissues and also in carcinomas. Expression levels of Pendred syndrome (PDS), natrium iodine symporter (NIS), thyroglobulin (Tg), thyroid peroxidase (TPO) and dual oxidase 1 or 2 (DUOX2) genes were significantly correlated with the expression of PAX-8 and with that of HEX. Expression level of TTF-1 was weakly correlated only with the expression levels of PDS and DUOX2. Conclusion Our findings suggest that alterations in the transcription factors PAX-8, TTF-1 and HEX gene expression, by acting individually or together, have a role in both thyroidal tumorigenesis and in the dedifferentiation process

Extraction of heavy metals from MSWI fly ash using hydrochloric acid and sodium chloride solution

Fly ash from municipal solid waste incineration contains a large potential for recyclable metals such as Zn, Pb, Cu and Cd. The Swiss Waste Ordinance prescribes the treatment of fly ash and recovery of metals to be implemented by 2021. More than 60% of the fly ash in Switzerland is acid leached according to the FLUWA process, which provides the basis for metal recovery. The investigation and optimization of the FLUWA process is of increasing interest and an industrial solution for direct metal recovery within Switzerland is in development. With this work, a detailed laboratory study on different filter cakes from fly ash leaching using HCl 5% (represents the FLUWA process) and concentrated sodium chloride solution (300 g/L) is described. This two-step leaching of fly ash is an efficient combination for the mobilization of a high percentage of heavy metals from fly ash (Pb, Cd ≥ 90% and Cu, Zn 70-80%). The depletion of these metals is mainly due to a combination of redox reaction and metal-chloride-complex formation. The results indicate a way forward for an improved metal depletion and recovery from fly ash that has potential for application at industrial scale