Effect of 16P11.2 copy number variants on cognitive traits and brain structures

The 600kb 16p11.2 CNVs (breakpoints 4–5, 29.6-30.2 Mb-Hg19) are among the most frequent genetic risk factors for neurodevelopmental and psychiatric conditions: A 10-fold enrichment of deletions and duplications is observed in autism cohorts and a 10-fold enrichment of duplications in schizophrenia cohorts. Previous studies demonstrated “mirror” effects of both CNVs on body mass index and head circumference (deletion>control>duplication). However, the large global effect of brain size and the sample size of the two previous neuroimaging studies limited the interpretation of the analyses on regional brain structures, any estimate of the effect size, and the generalizability of the results across different ascertainments of the patients. In the first part of my Ph.D., I analyze structural magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) on 78 deletion carriers, 71 duplication carriers, and 212 controls. I show that both CNVs affect in a “mirror” way the volume and the cortical surface of the insula (Cohen’s d>1), whilst other brain regions are preferentially altered in either the deletion carriers (calcarine cortex and superior, middle, transverse temporal gyri, Cohen’s d>1) or the duplication carriers (caudate and hippocampus, Cohen’s d of 0.5 to 1). Results are generalizable across scanning sites, computational methods, age, sex, ascertainment for psychiatric disorders. They partially overlap with results of meta-analyses performed across psychiatric disorders. In the second part, I characterize the developmental trajectory of global brain metrics and regional brain structures in the 16p11.2 CNV carriers. I adapt a previously published longitudinal pipeline and normalizing method, derived from 339 typically developing individuals aged from 4.5 to 20 years old. From this population of reference, I Z-score our cross-sectional 16p11.2 dataset and show that all the brain alterations in the 16p11.2 carriers are already present at 4.5 years old and follow parallel trajectories to the controls. In summary, my results suggest that brain alterations, present in childhood and stable across adolescence and adulthood, are related to the risk conferred by the 16p11.2 CNVs, regardless of the carriers’ symptoms. Additional factors are therefore likely required for the development of psychiatric disorders. I highlight the relevance of studying genetic risk factors and mechanisms as a complement to groups defined by behavioral criteria. Further studies comparing multiple CNVs and monogenic conditions, from the earliest age, are required to understand the onset of neuroanatomical alterations and their overlap between different genetic risk factors for neurodevelopmental disorders. -- Les variations en nombre de copies (CNV), au locus 16p11.2 et d’une taille d’600kb (points de cassure 4–5, 29.6-30.2 Mb-Hg19) représentent un des facteurs de risque génétique les plus fréquents parmi les troubles psychiatriques : 10% d’enrichissement en délétion et duplication pour les troubles du spectre autistique, 10% d’enrichissement en duplication pour la schizophrénie. Les effets « miroirs » des deux CNVs sur l’indice de masse corporelle et le périmètre cranien ont déjà été démontrés (délétion>contrôle>duplication). Cependant, les différences en taille de cerveau et les échantillons des deux précédentes études de neuro- imagerie ont limité les analyses des régions cérébrales, l’estimation de la taille des effets, et la généralisation des résultats selon les modes de recrutement des patients. Dans cette thèse, j’analyse les images par résonance magnétique (IRM) de 78 porteurs de la délétion, 71 porteurs de la duplication et 212 participants contrôles. Je montre que les deux CNVs sont associées à des différences « en miroir » du volume et de la surface corticale de l’insula (Cohen’s d>1), tandis que le cortex calcarin, les gyri temporaux supérieur, moyen et transverse sont préférentiellement altérés par la délétion (Cohen’s d>1), les noyaux caudés et l’hippocampe sont préférentiellement altérés par la duplication (0.5<Cohen’s d<1). Les résultats sont généralisables à travers les differents sites d’IRM, les méthodes d’analyse computationnelle, les âges, les sexes et les divers diagnostiques psychiatriques des patients. Les résultats chevauchent partiellement ceux d’une méta-analyse sur plusieurs diagnostiques psychiatriques. Dans un second temps, je caractérise la trajectoire développementale de ces différences cérébrales. J’adapte un pipeline longitunal et une méthode de normalisation déjà publiés, construits à partir de 339 participants contrôles de 4.5 à 20 ans. Je calcule des Z-scores pour nos données transversales et montre que les différences cérébrales liées aux CNVs sont déjà présentes à 4.5 ans, avec les mêmes tailles d’effet et une trajectoire parallèle aux contrôles. En résumé, mes résultats suggèrent que les différences cérébrales, présentes dans la jeune enfance et stables à l’adolescence et l’âge adulte, sont liées au risque conféré par les CNVs en 16p11.2, quelque soient les symptômes. Des facteurs additionnels sont probablement nécessaires pour le développement de maladies psychiatriques. Je montre la pertinence d’étudier les facteurs de risque génétiques en complément des groupes de patients définis sur des critères comportementaux. Des études comparant diverses conditions génétiques, dès la naissance, sont nécessaires pour comprendre le début et le chevauchement des différences neuro-anatomiques observées pour différents facteurs de risque génétiques

Effects of copy number variations on brain structure and risk for psychiatric illness: Large-scale studies from the ENIGMA working groups on CNVs

The Enhancing NeuroImaging Genetics through Meta-Analysis copy number variant (ENIGMA-CNV) and 22q11.2 Deletion Syndrome Working Groups (22q-ENIGMA WGs) were created to gain insight into the involvement of genetic factors in human brain development and related cognitive, psychiatric and behavioral manifestations. To that end, the ENIGMA-CNV WG has collated CNV and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) data from ~49,000 individuals across 38 global research sites, yielding one of the largest studies to date on the effects of CNVs on brain structures in the general population. The 22q-ENIGMA WG includes 12 international research centers that assessed over 533 individuals with a confirmed 22q11.2 deletion syndrome, 40 with 22q11.2 duplications, and 333 typically developing controls, creating the largest-ever 22q11.2 CNV neuroimaging data set. In this review, we outline the ENIGMA infrastructure and procedures for multi-site analysis of CNVs and MRI data. So far, ENIGMA has identified effects of the 22q11.2, 16p11.2 distal, 15q11.2, and 1q21.1 distal CNVs on subcortical and cortical brain structures. Each CNV is associated with differences in cognitive, neurodevelopmental and neuropsychiatric traits, with characteristic patterns of brain structural abnormalities. Evidence of gene-dosage effects on distinct brain regions also emerged, providing further insight into genotype–phenotype relationships. Taken together, these results offer a more comprehensive picture of molecular mechanisms involved in typical and atypical brain development. This “genotype-first” approach also contributes to our understanding of the etiopathogenesis of brain disorders. Finally, we outline future directions to better understand effects of CNVs on brain structure and behavior

Dose response of the 16p11.2 distal copy number variant on intracranial volume and basal ganglia.

Carriers of large recurrent copy number variants (CNVs) have a higher risk of developing neurodevelopmental disorders. The 16p11.2 distal CNV predisposes carriers to e.g., autism spectrum disorder and schizophrenia. We compared subcortical brain volumes of 12 16p11.2 distal deletion and 12 duplication carriers to 6882 non-carriers from the large-scale brain Magnetic Resonance Imaging collaboration, ENIGMA-CNV. After stringent CNV calling procedures, and standardized FreeSurfer image analysis, we found negative dose-response associations with copy number on intracranial volume and on regional caudate, pallidum and putamen volumes (β = -0.71 to -1.37; P < 0.0005). In an independent sample, consistent results were obtained, with significant effects in the pallidum (β = -0.95, P = 0.0042). The two data sets combined showed significant negative dose-response for the accumbens, caudate, pallidum, putamen and ICV (P = 0.0032, 8.9 × 10-6, 1.7 × 10-9, 3.5 × 10-12 and 1.0 × 10-4, respectively). Full scale IQ was lower in both deletion and duplication carriers compared to non-carriers. This is the first brain MRI study of the impact of the 16p11.2 distal CNV, and we demonstrate a specific effect on subcortical brain structures, suggesting a neuropathological pattern underlying the neurodevelopmental syndromes

Multi-level analysis of the gut-brain axis shows autism spectrum disorder-associated molecular and microbial profiles

Autism spectrum disorder (ASD) is a neurodevelopmental disorder characterized by heterogeneous cognitive, behavioral and communication impairments. Disruption of the gut-brain axis (GBA) has been implicated in ASD although with limited reproducibility across studies. In this study, we developed a Bayesian differential ranking algorithm to identify ASD-associated molecular and taxa profiles across 10 cross-sectional microbiome datasets and 15 other datasets, including dietary patterns, metabolomics, cytokine profiles and human brain gene expression profiles. We found a functional architecture along the GBA that correlates with heterogeneity of ASD phenotypes, and it is characterized by ASD-associated amino acid, carbohydrate and lipid profiles predominantly encoded by microbial species in the genera Prevotella, Bifidobacterium, Desulfovibrio and Bacteroides and correlates with brain gene expression changes, restrictive dietary patterns and pro-inflammatory cytokine profiles. The functional architecture revealed in age-matched and sex-matched cohorts is not present in sibling-matched cohorts. We also show a strong association between temporal changes in microbiome composition and ASD phenotypes. In summary, we propose a framework to leverage multi-omic datasets from well-defined cohorts and investigate how the GBA influences ASD

Defining the Effect of the 16p11.2 Duplication on Cognition, Behavior, and Medical Comorbidities

IMPORTANCE The 16p11.2 BP4-BP5 duplication is the copy number variant most frequently associated with autism spectrum disorder (ASD), schizophrenia, and comorbidities such as decreased body mass index (BMI). OBJECTIVES To characterize the effects of the 16p11.2 duplication on cognitive, behavioral, medical, and anthropometric traits and to understand the specificity of these effects by systematically comparing results in duplication carriers and reciprocal deletion carriers, who are also at risk for ASD. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS This international cohort study of 1006 study participants compared 270 duplication carriers with their 102 intrafamilial control individuals, 390 reciprocal deletion carriers, and 244 deletion controls from European and North American cohorts. Data were collected from August 1, 2010, to May 31, 2015 and analyzed from January 1 to August 14, 2015. Linear mixed models were used to estimate the effect of the duplication and deletion on clinical traits by comparison with noncarrier relatives. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES Findings on the Full-Scale IQ (FSIQ), Nonverbal IQ, and Verbal IQ; the presence of ASD or other DSM-IV diagnoses; BMI; head circumference; and medical data. RESULTS Among the 1006 study participants, the duplication was associated with a mean FSIQ score that was lower by 26.3 points between proband carriers and noncarrier relatives and a lower mean FSIQ score (16.2-11.4 points) in nonproband carriers. The mean overall effect of the deletion was similar (-22.1 points; P 100) compared with the deletion group (P < .001). Parental FSIQ predicted part of this variation (approximately 36.0% in hereditary probands). Although the frequency of ASD was similar in deletion and duplication proband carriers (16.0% and 20.0%, respectively), the FSIQ was significantly lower (by 26.3 points) in the duplication probands with ASD. There also were lower head circumference and BMI measurements among duplication carriers, which is consistent with the findings of previous studies. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE The mean effect of the duplication on cognition is similar to that of the reciprocal deletion, but the variance in the duplication is significantly higher, with severe and mild subgroups not observed with the deletion. These results suggest that additional genetic and familial factors contribute to this variability. Additional studies will be necessary to characterize the predictors of cognitive deficits

Effects of eight neuropsychiatric copy number variants on human brain structure

Many copy number variants (CNVs) confer risk for the same range of neurodevelopmental symptoms and psychiatric conditions including autism and schizophrenia. Yet, to date neuroimaging studies have typically been carried out one mutation at a time, showing that CNVs have large effects on brain anatomy. Here, we aimed to characterize and quantify the distinct brain morphometry effects and latent dimensions across 8 neuropsychiatric CNVs. We analyzed T1-weighted MRI data from clinically and non-clinically ascertained CNV carriers (deletion/duplication) at the 1q21.1 (n = 39/28), 16p11.2 (n = 87/78), 22q11.2 (n = 75/30), and 15q11.2 (n = 72/76) loci as well as 1296 non-carriers (controls). Case-control contrasts of all examined genomic loci demonstrated effects on brain anatomy, with deletions and duplications showing mirror effects at the global and regional levels. Although CNVs mainly showed distinct brain patterns, principal component analysis (PCA) loaded subsets of CNVs on two latent brain dimensions, which explained 32 and 29% of the variance of the 8 Cohen’s d maps. The cingulate gyrus, insula, supplementary motor cortex, and cerebellum were identified by PCA and multi-view pattern learning as top regions contributing to latent dimension shared across subsets of CNVs. The large proportion of distinct CNV effects on brain morphology may explain the small neuroimaging effect sizes reported in polygenic psychiatric conditions. Nevertheless, latent gene brain morphology dimensions will help subgroup the rapidly expanding landscape of neuropsychiatric variants and dissect the heterogeneity of idiopathic conditions

Schema of the iBox (A), and experimental set-up (B).

<p>Schema of the iBox (A), and experimental set-up (B).</p

Examples of swing tasks.

<p>A: Internal Swing (pretending to drink). B: External Swing (pretending to read). Same legend as <a href="http://www.plosone.org/article/info:doi/10.1371/journal.pone.0178185#pone.0178185.g007" target="_blank">Fig 7</a>.</p

Examples of spinning tasks.

<p>A: Unimanual. B: Bimanual. Each figure represents the evolution of the time forces on the faces of the object. Phases and vertical stippled lines: same legend as <a href="http://www.plosone.org/article/info:doi/10.1371/journal.pone.0178185#pone.0178185.g004" target="_blank">Fig 4</a>.</p