Developing conceptual models that link multiple ecosystem services to ecological research to aid management and policy, the UK marine example

Our understanding of ecological processes that lead to ecosystem services is still evolving but ecological research aims to understand the linkages between the ecosystem and services. These linkages can affect trade-offs between different ecosystem services. Understanding these linkages, by considering multiple ecosystem services simultaneously supports management of the environment and sustainable use of resources. The UK marine environment is relatively data rich, yet the links between ecosystem and several ecosystem services and linkages between services are poorly described. A workshop with 35 marine scientists was used to create a conceptual model that links ecosystem components and key processes to four services they provide and to highlight trade-offs between them. The model was subsequently further developed to include pressures and mitigating management measures. The models are discussed in terms of their application to marine data to facilitate evidence-based marine management and their usefulness to communicate management measures with managers and stakeholders

Impacts of Climate Change on the Ascension Island Marine Protected Area and Its Ecosystem Services

This is the first projection of marine circulation and biogeochemistry for the Ascension Island Marine Protected Area (AIMPA). Marine Protected Areas are a key management tool used to safeguard biodiversity, but their efficacy is increasingly threatened by climate change. To assess an MPA's vulnerability to climate change and predict biological responses, we must first project how the local marine environment will change. We present the projections of an ensemble from the Sixth Coupled Model Intercomparision Project. Relative to the recent past (2000–2010), the multi‐model means of the mid‐century (2040–2050) project that the AIMPA will become warmer (+0.9 to +1.2°C), more saline (+0.01 to +0.10), with a shallower mixed layer depth (− 1.3 to − 0.8 m), a weaker Atlantic Equatorial Undercurrent (AEU) (− 1.5 to − 0.4 Sv), more acidic (− 0.10 to − 0.07), with lower surface nutrient concentrations (− 0.023 to − 0.0141 mmol N m− 3 and − 0.013 to − 0.009 mmol P m− 3), less chlorophyll (− 6 to − 3 µg m− 3 ) and less primary production (− 0.31 to − 0.20 mol m− 2 yr− 1 ). These changes are often more extreme in the scenarios with higher greenhouse gases emissions and more significant climate change. Using the multi‐model mean for two scenarios in the years 2090–2100, we assessed how five key ecosystem servicesin both the shallow subtidal and the pelagic zone were likely to be impacted by climate change. Both low and high emission scenarios project significant changes to the AIMPA, and it is likely that the provision of several ecosystem services will be negatively impacted. Ascension Island is a small remote volcanic island in the equatorial Atlantic Ocean. The seas around Ascension Island have been protected from commercial fishing since 2019. We used the marine component of computer simulations of the Earth's climate to try to understand the future of the Ascension Island Marine Protected Area (AIMPA). Over the next century, the AIMPA region will become warmer, more saline, more acidic, less productive, and with lower nutrient and chlorophyll concentrations in the surface waters. The most important current of the region, the Atlantic Equatorial Current, is also projected to weaken in all scenarios. These changes are likely to negatively impact the ability of the AIMPA to provide ecosystem services such as healthy ecosystems, fish stocks, the removal of carbon dioxide from the air, and attract tourism. This work is important because it is the first projection of the climate around the AIMPA since it was created, and it has allowed local policymakers to understand how the changing climate is likely to affect their environment and ecosystem service

Ecosystem service provision by marine habitats in Southeast Asia

Southeast Asia is an area of rich marine biodiversity providing a host of ecosystem services that contribute to the well-being of coastal communities and beyond. Sustainable management of ecosystems and the services they provide requires a good understanding of their underlying ecological functions and processes. This understanding can be gained through the rigorous assessment of studies identifying and quantifying ecological functions and ecosystem services. The aims of this study were to review the ecosystem services provided by marine and coastal habitats in Southeast Asia. The ecosystem service potential was scored for each habitat. The review was focused on nine key marine and coastal habitats, identified across four case study sites in Southeast Asia, contributing 18 marine relevant ecosystem services. The approach comprised a literature review supplemented with observations from experts from the case study areas. The four case study sites consist of three Man and Biosphere Reserves in Southeast Asia: Palawan in the Philippines, Cu Lao Cham- Hoi An in Viet Nam, Take-Bonerate Kepulauan Selayar in Indonesia, and a recently gazetted marine protected area, the Tun Mustapha Marine Park in Malaysia (Figure 1). The nine key habitats (eight benthic and one pelagic) covered in this review, identified as highly relevant for most case study sites, were mangrove forests, coral reefs, seagrass meadows, sand, mud, rock, coarse substratum, pelagic and modified habitats. Further division of these habitats into sub-habitats on the basis of biological type and substrate type was used to capture data on differential provision of ecosystem services within the broad habitat types. To ensure relevance in the four case study sites, firstly an ecosystem services typology was created tailored to these sites. After exploring several ecosystem service typologies, our final classification was adapted from the Common International Classification of Ecosystem services (CICES) V4.3 because it was considered to be most relevant to the objectives of this task. Provisioning, regulation and maintenance, and cultural services were assessed. Provisioning services focused on food for consumption by humans from plants, pelagic animals, demersal fish and invertebrates; energy from harvested plants; other materials from plants and animals, such as fibres, building and housing materials, medicines, decoration, handicrafts and souvenirs; and genetic material from plants and animals (including seeds, spat, spores, whole plants or animals, individual genes), for example seed or brood-stock collection for aquaculture and mangrove replanting and new plantations. Regulation and maintenance services assessed were treatment and assimilation of wastes or toxic substances; coastal erosion control; water flow regulation contributing to dampening the intensity of storm, floods, tsunamis, and hurricanes and the maintenance of localized water flows such as coastal current structures; maintenance of nursery,reproduction and feeding habitats; maintenance of critical habitats for charismatic species such as turtles, dugongs, cetaceans, sharks, seahorses, bats, fireflies, birds, monkeys, orchids and other epiphytes; and climate regulation through impacts on the hydrological cycle, temperature regulation, and the contribution to regulation of climate-influencing gases in the atmosphere, for example through carbon sequestration and long-term, decadal storage. Cultural services examined included uses of habitats as places for active and passive recreation; ceremonial activities; creative activities; and knowledge-based activities, such as educational activities, and citizen science or community environmental activities. The comprehensive literature review included peer-reviewed scientific research literature as well as grey literature such as government and other reports. To ensure a wide breadth of coverage, the research focused on studies from Southeast Asia. When no evidence was found in the literature, evidence was sought from experts, and where useful, was accompanied by observations from the authors in their respective case study sites. The evidence gathered was used to assess the potential of each habitat to provide an ecosystem service, rather than to assess the actual provision of ecosystem services from each case study site. This important distinction allows the differentiation between services provided by the ecosystem (i.e. the potential supply of ecosystem services that a habitat could deliver) and (achieved or used) benefits (i.e. the demand for ecosystem services). The knowledge gained from the literature, local and regional reports, together with observations from the study team and experts, was critically assessed using a robust methodology that captured different types of information together with a confidence score for the supporting evidence. The contribution of each habitat to each ecosystem service was then scored relative to other habitats. Our objective was to provide baseline information to enable better understanding of the ecosystem services arising from marine and coastal habitats in SE Asia. This provides a foundation for future assessments of natural capital and ecosystem services which may be used to inform sustainable management. The report will serve as a useful reference to many different readers. Regulators, managers of marine sites and policy makers might use this report to inform their management choices. This should enable more sustainable use of the marine environment and maximise the ecosystem service provision of all types of services addressed in this study. Stakeholders of the marine environment such as fisherfolk or residents might use this report to help them engage in management processes, to gain deeper understanding of the marine environment or confirm their observations of the marine environment. Academics can use it as a reference source or a base for further studies, in particular for valuation studies or when considering the trade-offs between ecosystem services in marine and coastal habitats. Finally, it is hoped that this report may bring a new appreciation and understanding of the marine environment and the life support it provides to society and inspire readers to improve management of the marine environment. This report is one of the outputs of the UK Research and Innovation’s Global Challenges Research Fund (UKRI GCRF) Blue Communities Programme (GCRF Blue Communities Global Challenges Research Fund via the United Kingdom Research and Innovation (UKRI) under grant agreement reference NE/P021107/1, www.blue-communities.org), which aims to “build capacity for sustainable interactions with marine ecosystems for the benefit of the health, well-being, food security and livelihoods of coastal communities in SE Asia”. GCRF Blue Communities is developing interdisciplinary research capability and lasting collaborations that can facilitate innovative application of integrated planning in the marine environment and respond to the UN Sustainable Development Goals of ‘no poverty’, ‘zero hunger’, ‘good health and well-being’ for coastal communities as well as ‘conserve and sustainably use the oceans, seas and marine resources for sustainable development’ through the sustainable use of marine resources

Evolution of Marine Organisms under Climate Change at Different Levels of Biological Organisation

Research to date has suggested that both individual marine species and ecological processes are expected to exhibit diverse responses to the environmental effects of climate change. Evolutionary responses can occur on rapid (ecological) timescales, and yet studies typically do not consider the role that adaptive evolution will play in modulating biological responses to climate change. Investigations into such responses have typically been focused at particular biological levels (e.g., cellular, population, community), often lacking interactions among levels. Since all levels of biological organisation are sensitive to global climate change, there is a need to elucidate how different processes and hierarchical interactions will influence species fitness. Therefore, predicting the responses of communities and populations to global change will require multidisciplinary efforts across multiple levels of hierarchy, from the genetic and cellular to communities and ecosystems. Eventually, this may allow us to establish the role that acclimatisation and adaptation will play in determining marine community structures in future scenarios

Boosting Blue Growth in a Mild Sea: Analysis of the Synergies Produced by a Multi-Purpose Offshore Installation in the Northern Adriatic, Italy

In the near future, the oceans will be subjected to a massive development of marine infrastructures, including offshore wind, tidal and wave energy farms and constructions for marine aquaculture. The development of these facilities will unavoidably exert environmental pressures on marine ecosystems. It is therefore crucial that the economic costs, the use of marine space and the environmental impacts of these activities remain within acceptable limits. Moreover, the installation of arrays of wave energy devices is still far from being economically feasible due to many combined aspects, such as immature technologies for energy conversion, local energy storage and moorings. Therefore, multi-purpose solutions combining renewable energy from the sea (wind, wave, tide), aquaculture and transportation facilities can be considered as a challenging, yet advantageous, way to boost blue growth. This would be due to the sharing of the costs of installation and using the produced energy locally to feed the different functionalities and optimizing marine spatial planning. This paper focuses on the synergies that may be produced by a multi-purpose offshore installation in a relatively calm sea, i.e., the Northern Adriatic Sea, Italy, and specifically offshore Venice. It analyzes the combination of aquaculture, energy production from wind and waves, and energy storage or transfer. Alternative solutions are evaluated based on specific criteria, including the maturity of the technology, the environmental impact, the induced risks and the costs. Based on expert judgment, the alternatives are ranked and a preliminary layout of the selected multi-purpose installation for the case study is proposed, to further allow the exploitation of the synergies among different functionalities

A matrix approach to tropical marine ecosystem service assessments in South east Asia

Ecosystem service assessments are increasingly used to support natural resource management, but there is a bias in their application towards terrestrial systems and higher income countries. Tropical marine applications are particularly scarce, especially in SE Asia. Given the growing coastal population and expansion in blue economy sectors in SE Asia, evidence to support effective marine planning, such as ecosystem service assessments, is urgently needed. Data deficiencies for marine systems, especially (but not only) in lower income countries is a significant obstacle for ecosystem service assessments. To overcome this, we develop an ecosystem service potential matrix which combines evidence taken from an extensive literature review together with expert opinion. The matrix includes both natural and modified habitats as the service providing units. The ecosystem service potential for habitats are scored at the macro level (e.g. mangrove) due to insufficient evidence to score micro-habitats (e.g. fringe, basin or riverine mangroves). The majority of evidence is available for biogenic habitats (mangroves, coral reefs and seagrass meadows) with comparatively little for sedimentary habitats. While provisioning, regulating and cultural services are scored, published evidence is more readily available for provisioning and regulating services. Confidence scores, indicating the uncertainty in the ecosystem service potential scores are included in the matrix. To our knowledge this is the first attempt to systematically capture the provision of ecosystem services from tropical marine habitats. Although initially developed for four marine biosphere reserves and protected areas in SE Asia, the generic nature of the evidence included suggests that the matrix constitutes a valuable baseline for marine ecosystem service assessments within SE Asia and provides a robust foundation for development in future work

Uses and management of saltmarshes: A global survey

Saltmarshes are important coastal fringe ecosystems supporting a myriad of coastal uses and users. However, saltmarshes have undergone a significant period of global decline, losing 25%–50% of their coverage due to a range of drivers, but mainly as a result of anthropogenic pressures and land-use change. While the value of these coastal systems to society is recognised, global data are fragmented, patchy, and often restricted to local case studies. There is currently no comprehensive understanding of the global variation of ecosystem services, benefits and management practices available. This pioneering study addresses this by investigating the socio-ecological dimension of global variation in ecosystem service provision, and how this is being managed by and for different saltmarsh users. Through a global online questionnaire survey (n = 438) targeting professional saltmarsh researchers and practitioners representing 40 countries across 5 continents, this paper presents an overview of saltmarsh ecosystem services, key drivers influencing management and the variation in factors that influence them. Analysis indicates considerable variation, with geographical location (‘continent’) being the most common moderator, influencing perceptions of saltmarshes, the prioritisation of ecosystem services and management perceptions. Finally, the paper presents a series of recommendations, including the development of an interdisciplinary, international research programme to support restoration and conservation of saltmarshes worldwide

Characterisation of the inshore marine sectors of Da Nang, Vietnam

Da Nang is a pioneer site in Southeast Asia for the implementation of Integrated Coastal Management and the first city in Vietnam to become an Environmental City in 2020. At the same time, the city of Da Nang in Vietnam is experiencing substantial changes in its urban landscape due to socioeconomic growth in line with three primary pillars: tourism, high-tech industry, and marine economy. These pillars are likely to bring negative environmental consequences, of which marine water quality is a key concern. Thus, this study carried out a characterisation of the inshore marine sectors and developed understanding of the impacts of poor water quality and Covid-19, with the aim of informing marine-coastal management. The sectors of artisanal inshore fisheries, aquaculture and marine tourism were assessed through surveys; blue carbon and policy mapping via desk-based research; and resilience of fishers and aquaculture farmers to Covid-19, and other major shocks, was studied via in-depth interviews and focus groups. The results provide a wealth of information, highlighting strengths and weaknesses in each sector, and areas for further research and management-policy advancement. The estimated monetary values for Blue Carbon in Da Nang are quite low, but it is important to remember that marine habitats provide a host of other services. Aquaculture farming are the most disadvantaged marine sector in Da Nang in several aspects, but they would mainly benefit from policies that legalise aquaculture and support training in sustainable practices. Inshore artisanal fishers evidence overall good conditions, but the marine environment would benefit from greater monitoring and enforcement of fishing policies. Son Tra Peninsula is a key location in Da Nang, as it supports a large proportion of marine tourism and artisanal fishing. Thus, the area needs special attention for conservation to ensure protection of the marine environment in the face of expected expansion of marine tourism. In all three marine sectors there is an almost total dependence on these activities for household livelihood, thus households would benefit from income diversification or support, especially in times of stress, and more equitable support system from the government. All marine sectors showed a trend towards not expecting future change in their respective sectors. However, aquaculture stands out for a tendency to expect an increase of demand for the sector despite its current unrecognised status. While fishers tend to have conflicting views on expected changes which seems to reflect uncertainty or lack of knowledge. All three sectors mentioned natural disasters as a main threat to their livelihood; marine tourism operators and aquaculture farmers also highlighted water pollution; and fishers emphasised the threat from destructive fishing. These threats evidence key areas to develop in Da Nang city: adaptation and preparedness for natural disasters, updating and implementing water quality monitoring, enforcing water quality policies, and enforcing fisheries policies including patrolling. The three sectors had an overall positive view on the water quality status for Da Nang Bay, as well as thinking that their activities did not have much impact on water quality. However, there was evidence of misinformation and conflicting views regarding their effect on water quality and other sources. Thus, there is a need for environmental education and awareness raising regarding different sources of pollution, impacts of pollution and impacts of their livelihoods on water quality and how to reduce them. There was a dominant view across sectors that sewage and industrial waste were two of the main causes of marine water pollution in Da Nang Bay. This highlights the need to take enhanced action for water quality improvement by improving sewage treatment. Impact of Covid-19 on fishers and aquaculture farmers were mainly felt on income, which was due to a lowering of price received for stock/catch and no access to buyers. Fishers’ food security and social networking were also affected. Aquaculture farmers were able to maintain good food security through their own stock and perceived increased environmental security from reduced industrial effluents during lockdowns. However, the pandemic was perceived to be less impactful than natural disasters. Finally, a detailed content analysis of Integrated Coastal Zone Management-related policies is recommended as it would provide a deeper understanding of the extent to which policy makers and deliverers in Vietnam, and Da Nang specifically, have included tourism, fisheries, aquaculture, and blue carbon within their coastal management policies, and how (un-) successfully the policies interact and complement one another in order to facilitate sustainable coastal management